EA Sports UFC: 10 Fighters Who Must Be Downgraded

Before they enter the virtual Octagon, we need to take the chip off the shoulder.

So EA Sports UFC is finally available to the public and MMA fans the world over will at last be able to immerse themselves in the incredible graphics, create the fantasy match-ups they never got to see in real life and attempt to put the beating on Jon Jones that we all want to see. EA Sports have confirmed that some of the notable omissions from the roster of 99 fighters available at launch (most of which we discussed here) will be provided in a free DLC pack shortly. This is most welcome news to all the potential customers who had feared that their brand-spanking new MMA game would be without its bantamweight champion, T.J Dillashaw, and it is an appreciated show of goodwill from EA that they won€™t be trying to squeeze extra money out of us for this additional content. However, despite the solved issue of the glaring roster omissions, there are still several conspicuous problems with the fighters featured on the game which have become apparent with its launch. Many of the fighter ratings feel inaccurate with the performances they have displayed in the Octagon in recent years. The main issue is that many fighters feel vastly overrated. Unlike in game€™s like EA Sport€™s FIFA franchise whose highest rated player is Lionel Messi (94), the new UFC game feels like it has been overly generous in its ratings. A huge portion of the fighters are rated over 90 while many occupy the high 80s. It doesn€™t make the sport€™s best fighters feel potent enough when so many athletes have been given a 90+ rating. With this in mind, we believe many are deserving of a downgrade.

10. Conor McGregor

Overall: 90Striking: 89Ground : 86Submissions: 90 As we are a UK-based website, the observation that Conor McGregor €“ the best MMA fighter to have ever come out of Ireland €“ has been completely overrated on the new UFC game may be an unpopular one. However, the fact of the matter is that the Dubliner is too unproven in the top tier promotion of MMA to warrant an overall rating in the 90s. It is his combination of a flashy, exciting striking style with his undeniable charisma which has generated so much hype around the 25-year-old prospect. However, all this excitement has blinded us from the fact that he has fought only twice in the UFC against mid-to-low level opponents. How an earth can such a high rating be justified to a man who is yet so unproven? McGregor is set to have the biggest fight of his career this time next month as he faces the fearsome Diego Brandao in the main event of the Dublin card. Even if he is victorious against this tougher opponent, it would be hard to say that Conor€™s rating isn€™t a little generous. What is particularly galling about McGregor€™s rating is that the strongest area of his skills has been judged to be his submissions. Not only has the Irishman picked up but a single submission victory in his 16-fight career, but both his loses have come via submission so you can€™t even argue that he deserves this rating from a defensive standpoint. They literally seem to have picked this submission stat out of a hat. Suggested Overall Rating: 85

9. Ronaldo Souza

Overall: 93Striking: 91Ground: 97Submissions: 100 Ronaldo €˜Jacare€™ Souza is on a win streak of 6 fights right now. A lot of people are saying he should be near the front of the queue of people waiting to challenge Chris Weidman for his belt. While Jacare has been impressive in his Octagon outings there is one very irksome stat we can€™t get over: his 100 rating in submissions. Souza has had a lot of success in the submission department with 14 of his 20 wins coming by submission, but rating him a perfect 100 seems a little generous. Surely 100 should just be reserved for those souls who have only won fights by submission. Arguably, Souza isn€™t even the best submission artist in the UFC. Guys who are renowned for having really astounding jiu-jitsu are rated below him such as Frank Mir (97), Demian Maia (97) and €“ perhaps most shockingly of all €“ Ronda Rousey (98). Giving Souza a 100 rating in submissions makes it seem like he will literally be indestructible and will be the sort of character annoying players online will use and attempt to spam submission attempts with. Perhaps what is the most striking about this is that no other fighter on the game holds a 100 rating in any category so for Souza to have been given perfect submissions is all a little bit strange. Indeed in his last fight he spent the best part of all three rounds on the mat with Francis Carmont €“ a man who has been submitted several times before €“ and was unable to force him to tap out. Suggested Overall Rating: 88

8. Anthony Pettis

Overall: 95Striking: 93Ground: 93Submissions: 96 It might seem like a peculiar angle to accuse the undisputed champion of the most talent-rich division in the UFC of being overrated, but the fact of the matter is that we haven€™t really seen Pettis do enough in the UFC to warrant this incredibly high rating. His UFC wins over Donald Cerrone and former champion Benson Henderson were extremely impressive, but it is hard to justify rating a fighter just 5 points shy of perfection based on two wins. Indeed you could argue that Josh Thomson and Gilbert Melendez have both beaten the former champion Benson Henderson as well (though they both actually lost in highly controversial decisions) yet they haven€™t been rated this highly. Since obtaining the belt, a recurring knee injury has meant that Pettis is yet to make a single title defence €“ perhaps once he defends the belt a few times against the sharks which occupy the 155-lb waters, his rating would be deserved. Pettis€™ rating of 93 striking is completely justifiable €“ the lightweight champion is easily one of the best pure strikers in the UFC. However, that 96 submissions stat is completely off the mark. It feels like EA Sports are so blinded by the slick submission victory which won him the belt that they forget that Pettis is not a submission fighter. Yes, he has had submission victories in his career but 96 makes him one of the best grapplers in the game. Suggested Overall Rating: 92

7. Tarec Saffiedine

Overall: 90Striking: 90Ground: 88Submissions: 86 Firstly, how a combination of 90, 88 and 86 manages to give an overall rating of 90 is completely beyond us. To save you working it out, the average comes to 88. It seems like the hype surrounding Saffiedine must have been particularly high when EA Sports and Dana came together to decide the ratings. While Saffiedine is on a win streak, his record is distinctly lacking in notable names. Though he holds wins over Roger Bowling and Nate Marquardt, the rest of his wins leave you mostly saying, €˜who?€™ (six of them don€™t even have a wikipedia page €“ that€™s when you really know it€™s bad). The decision to rate Saffiedine€™s striking at a lofty 90 is a little strange as only one of his wins has come by way of TKO or KO. Saffiedine may be a very good technical striker but he has demonstrated a lack of power in his UFC fights. Interestingly, he actually has 5 wins by submission but is rated a mere 86 €“ this rating would normally be fine, but the overall generosity of the stats makes it seem a little stingy. There is no doubt Saffiedine has a lot of potential to progress in the sport but this rating at his current level is very befuddling and his inclusion over the likes of more established welterweights like Tyron Woodley, Dong Hyun Kim and Matt Brown is baffling. Suggested Overall Rating:87

6. Roy Nelson

Overall: 90Striking: 91Ground: 90Submissions: 90 Though he is coming off a first round knockout win over Pride legend Antônio Rodrigo Nogueira, rating Roy Nelson as being both this high and this balanced is overly generous. Prior to his fight with Stipe Miocic, Big Country wanted to squeeze the UFC for every penny they were worth by waiting till after the fight to sign his new contract. He assumed that he would win and that on a four fight winning streak he would be in the perfect position to negotiate a particularly generous new deal. However, Stipe €“ who is not featured in EA€™s new game €“ would demonstrate the schematics of how to outclass Roy Nelson en route to a clear-cut unanimous decision victory: it is based on performances like this that Nelson should not be so highly rated by EA Sports. Roy€™s overhand right may be one of the most lethal weapons in all of MMA but we saw in his back-to-back loses to Stipe and Daniel Cormier that it was realistically only potent for one round. Even if Roy€™s heavy right remained dangerous for the whole fight, this shouldn€™t warrant a striking score of 91. His overall striking game is too lacking in other areas to warrant such a lofty score. Big Country may have scored 13 of his 20 wins via KO/TKO, but these have all come from that ridiculously powerful right €“ all of Nelson€™s other striking techniques are a ploy to create an opening for his finisher. Nelson€™s atypical image makes him a fan favourite so there can be no denying that his place in the new MMA game is justified. However, his stats describe a fighter who is incredibly well rounded which Roy Nelson most certainly isn€™t. Suggested Overall Rating: 85

5. Cat Zingano

Overall: 93Striking: 91Ground: 92Submissions: 93 The sad but unfortunate truth surrounding Women€™s MMA is that the talent pool is currently too shallow. While the UFC€™s addition of the strawweight division gives us hope for the future, the bantamweight division is currently all we have. With key talents like Cris Cyborg being a weight class above and many of the women in the division moving up from 125lbs, there seems to be a lack of threat to Rousey's throne. Cat Zingano is an exciting prospect in WMMA. Her undefeated record speaks for itself but unfortunately there just isn€™t that much (bar a fight with Ronda Rousey) that could test her. Couple that with the fact she has only fought once in the UFC, and it makes her rating seem a little absurd. There is absolutely no doubt that Zingano is a true talent in the making and can eventually really achieve the rating she has been given but for now her rating should be made to be a little more realistic Suggested Overall Rating: 87

4. Nate Diaz (at Lightweight)

Overall: 91Striking: 88Ground: 89Submissions: 95 The only person other than the team at EA Sports who would believe that Nate Diaz is deserving of this munificent rating would be Diaz himself. The vociferous lightweight€™s only win in the last two years was against a severely diminished Grey Maynard and before this fight he had been demolished by both Benson Henderson and Josh Thomson. Despite being all over Diaz before handing the TUF 5 winner the first TKO loss of his career, Thomson was inexplicably given an overall rating of 89 in EA Sports UFC. After beating Grey Maynard, Diaz made MMA news earlier this year as he refused to take a fight with rising young prospect Khabib Nurmagomedov. With his impressive Sambo and Judo credentials, Diaz joined the long list of fighters who had refused to fight the intimidating Russian. Despite his refusal to fight Khabib, Diaz has still been rated as his superior by EA Sports. Though it is hard to question that 95 submissions stat as Diaz €“ with his black belt in Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu €“ has shown himself to be a devastating finisher on the mat, there can be no doubting that the 29-year-old has been overrated. Suggested Overall Rating: 87

3. Phil Davis

Overall: 90Striking: 88Ground: 93Submissions: 90 Phil Davis probably still believes in his head that he deserves a title shot. Prior to his fight with Anthony Rumble Johnson, Davis was adamant that the next shot at Jones€™ belt shouldn€™t go the way of Alexander Gustafsson or Daniel Cormier but to himself. He was even calling Jones out at press conferences. Unfortunately for Davis€™ ego, he lost the fight to Johnson, who absolutely dominated him for no less than 3 rounds. While it€™s true that every fighter has a bad day where he just isn€™t all there, this is not the first time Davis has looked outclassed by an opponent. Despite his record (12-2) not portraying this, the majority of Davis€™ wins have been decisions. His most recent win against Lyoto Machida was also a controversial decision with most people scoring the fight in favour of the Brazilian. Of his twelve wins, only four have come by way of submission which makes the 90 rating in that category is a little confusing. The fact that he has been given an overall rating higher than Rashad Evans (89) who soundly beat him when they fought is even more inexplicable. Davis€™ striking rating may seem modest but anyone who has seen Phil fight knows how clunky, robotic and stiff his striking can be. He may have two KO/TKO wins to his name, but both of these occurred outside the UFC against easier opponents. Suggested Overall Rating: 84

2. Bruce Lee

Overall: 94Striking: 93Ground: 93Submissions: 89 We know, Bruce Lee is just a novelty character, included in the game to make up for the lack of Brock Lesnar. Though we're not sure how many people will see Bruce Lee's inclusion advertised and feel compelled to buy a copy, it€™s a nice incentive for those that have taken the time and money to preorder a copy. That being said, the statistics for Bruce Lee look somewhat ridiculous. While his striking rating is fair it€™s the others we have an issue with. When did Bruce Lee ever show us his greco-roman wrestling skills? Apparently he was talented enough to receive a higher ground rating than former state championship wrestler Ryan Bader (92). Bruce Lee also must have been pretty submission savvy to earn the same submission rating as former champion Frankie Edgar. In EA Sports UFC, Bruce Lee seems like one of those really over-powered guys in video games that are near impossible to beat and the made-up submission and ground skills make some of the other fighter ratings seem like a complete joke. You could make a fair case that he should be given a higher striking rating but make him less well-rounded, but ranking him as a better MMA fighter to those who fight in the Octagon for their profession is somewhat insulting. Suggested Overall Rating: 82

1. Renan Barao

Overall: 96Striking: 95Ground: 96Submissions: 99 Rated as being the fourth best fighter in the overall game, in light of his recent loss, the former-bantamweight champions is certainly no longer worthy of such a high rating. A 96 overall stat may have been justified before as the Brazilian had been riding an insane winning steak stretching all the way back to 2005, but it must be remembered that the vast majority of these fights were against opponents who were not UFC calibre fighters in other organisations. It was the loss of his title to T.J Dillashaw €“ a fighter not currently included in the game €“ that confirmed that the Baron had been overrated. We don€™t like to judge fighters based on one bad performance, but Dillashaw€™s victory over the former #1 pound-for-pound contender was so dominant that it is now impossible to say that the 27-year-old is the fourth best fighter in the UFC. After hurting him badly in the first round, the Team Alpha Male Fighter dominated the former-champion before finally putting him out of his misery in the fifth round with a masterful head kick. Barao€™s submission rating of 99 is particularly conspicuous €“ though he has several submission wins to his name, Barao€™s championship reign was primarily defined by his wild, dangerous striking. Rating his submission skills as being superior to the likes of Demian Maia, Ronda Rousey and Urijah Faber is ludicrous. Suggested Overall Rating: 90

Contributor
Contributor

Hailing from South East London, Sam Heard is an aspiring writer and recent graduate from the University of Warwick. Sam's favourite things include energy drinks, late nights spent watching the UFC with his girlfriend and annihilating his friends at FIFA.