FIFA 13: 7 Things That Would Have Guaranteed Perfection
It's now been a few days since FIFA 13 landed on retail shelves, picking up a five star review from this website in the process, and now that the dust has settled it's time to reflect a little more deeply on what is arguably the finest footballing video game to ever be released to the market. Overall in fact, this year's marketplace for footballing games was a particularly strong one, thanks to the resurgence of Pro Evo 2013, and the annual uplift in quality from EA Sports' own addition to the genre - but there was still room for improvement for both games. This year Konami made some serious strides to catch FIFA, rebuilding the gameplay engine with admirable success, but they were forced to make some compromises in presentation quality, and there is a distinct lack of gloss about this year's release. That isn't quite as fatal a problem as some might have you believe - and neither are the licensing issues that have dogged the property since day one - but Konami will see even more success next year by fine-tuning what they have already achieved this year. Bringing a little more fluidity to the AI will help, and EA Sports will no doubt be looking over their shoulders with a little more urgency after this year's round of releases. So what do EA Sports need to do to make their own game better? How do you improve on a game that scored impressive reviews almost across the board, with five stars liberally given out by the most impressed reviewers, like myself? Well, despite the inference of that "perfect" score, I fully recognise that FIFA 13 could have been better, and since we're in the business of fantasy, I've looked back at FIFA 13 with a more cynical eye and identified what extra features and developments would have made the game a perfect release. Read on to see my picks for what would have guaranteed perfection for EA Sports and FIFA 13...
1.Be The Ref Mode
Something that FIFA fans have been calling for almost as long as they have for the return of the now infamous Indoor Arena (more of which later), the Be The Ref Mode has been rumoured for inclusion in FIFA for some years now, and no doubt FIFA 14 will see a fresh round of speculation. But why is the Man In Black Mode so sought after? The idea of playing 6 minute matches without the ability to touch the ball legally or actually get into the action might not appeal to most die-hard fans of football gaming, but there are definitely those who want to flex their carding arm muscles and decide on the key instances in the game. And both interpreting the rules and keeping up with, and out of the way of play would definitely represent a challenge - whether you would consider that as a more entertaining challenge than actually scoring goals probably says a lot about how dedicated you are to the football sim side of FIFA. It's a difficult prospect of course, given how easy it might be for players to exploit the situation - especially if it was introduced into player-on-player matches with a third player taking control of the refereeing. The opportunity for bias would have to be all but eradicated, unless EA Sports choose to believe that no-one will repeat the tendency of certain referees to make a name for themselves with over-zealous officiating (Uriah Renee for instance). But it would be great fun to spend a few games seeing how well you can interpret the rules of the game, with some sort of rating system ensuring that repeat offenders are relegated to the very bottom rungs of the league system, and only those who ref fairly and appropriately likely to get to the big tournaments. That might sound like celebrating jobsworthism to some, and tantamount to suggesting someone releases a Traffic Warden Manager sim to others, but there is certainly enough appeal among the FIFA communities that EA Sports should seriously consider it.
2. Licensed Referees
And following on from that last point - it seems a strange oversight that EA Sports didn't include something as simple as licensed referees in FIFA 13, especially considering how much depth the developer ritualistically goes into with the rest of the game's licenses. Think about it: as a fan of football in England I look out for which officials have been put in charge of my team's upcoming match, because each referee has their own behaviour type, and their own idiosyncracies. This one will let the first few robust tackles get through without punishment, that one will look to book any and every tackle deemed over-zealous, and that one likes to make himself centre-stage, breaking up play and flamboyantly stamping his authority on the match to keep the cameras on him. That sort of individualism in match refereeing could make all the difference to the way a player approaches a game, and would make preparing for matches a different experience depending on who the man in the middle is. It would also go some way to advancing the completist objectives of those in charge of the game's licenses.
3. Five-A-Side
Something that has been a much-lamented missing feature of FIFA for more years now than it actually appeared in the game is the Indoor Arena, which has now seen more online petitions for its return than any other lost gaming feature I care to remember. Since 1999, FIFA has been cruelly without an indoor arena, and indeed the ability to play small-sided matches against the CPU or friends, and it's something that many fans expected EA Sports to have rectified by now. The opportunity to play small-sided games would introduce an entirely new gameplay dynamic, and would fundamentally change how players played matches, not only entertaining in themselves, but also allowing the player to hone the skills necessary to play well in limited space and in a pacier match, as it does in real life. This would encourage players to learn more skills, and integrate them into their style of play more successfully, rather than always looking for a defence-splitting pass or a burst of speed to beat their man. Considering how EA Sports took the new dribbling system from FIFA Street, you might have thought they would have included small-sided games into FIFA 13 as a way of showing off those skills, and making the step off of that style of play a more fluid transition for those players who didn't usually go for skillful play. And it would have been a very welcome inclusion, judging by the continued clamour for EA Sports to relent on the Indoor Arena issue.
4. Two Player Career Mode
This one is something that I know frustrates certain FIFA Career Mode players every year the game comes out. Career Mode is clearly considered a solitary endeavour for EA Sports - who have taken the model established by popular management sims on-board in their own management mode, but that misses the fact that some FIFA players like to have their opponents in the same room as them, and to have a continued challenge to play with together. At the minute, if players want to play a two player Career, the only solution is for one to take on the role of the Manager, and the other to take on the role of Opponent, taking control of the manager's opponent team in every match of the season to thwart their attempts to win the league. That however means that the second player is never able to build their own dynasty, to try and create a duopoly at the top of the league, and establish their own legacy at a club of their choice, which would be far more preferable for those players who want to play Career Mode this way. There is no really adequate explanation why Career Mode is limited to single player - it simply is - and it is a shame once again that some fans aren't able to play as they wish. This might not be a majority of players by any means, but it can't be something that hasn't cropped up before.
5. A Little More Unpredictability
One of the only ways that Pro Evo 2013 outstripped FIFA 13 in terms of the gameplay was the issue of ball physics and unpredictability. EA Sports' attempts to create the ultimate football sim seem to have missed the point that you can't actually predict what a football will do 100% of the time - which is precisely why a beach ball scored a Premier League goal not so long ago. The Beautiful Game is occasionally unpredictable, and realistic ball physics actually require a loosening of the definition of realistic physics. Yes some might complain about a game in which the ball frustratingly does what it wants, despite the controlled intentions of the player, but that would be more realistic than what FIFA currently does. And while the new control system does mean that players are no longer all capable of superhuman acts of ball control, regardless of whether they play for Real Madrid or Tow Law, it isn't quite enough. The longer you play, the more you realise that the miscontrols aren't always as fatal as they should be - admittedly if you do it close to a touch- or by-line, chances are the other team are going to be awarded with a set-piece, but miscontrolling on the edge of the box is by no means fatal thanks to an improbable recovery rate for most players. Too many times now I've miscontrolled with a good player - not a Messi-level one - and then recovered with a shot that has arrowed into the goal past the usually impenetrable goalkeeper, and that just isn't as realistic as the control system initially intended. It's not really a problem with the system, but more with its integration into the game, and it seems EA Sports have reserved the punishment factor for miscontrols a little more than they should have.6. More Licenses
Considering how impressive EA Sports' work to put as many licensed teams and competitions into FIFA 13 clearly was, it's a shame that there's no space for the African Cup of Nations, or either the Champions League or Europa League competitions. The latter two are a little more understandable considering the cost that would presumably be required to make them part of any game, but the lack of an African Cup of Nations feels more like a simple oversight. With a lot more African players now plying their trade in the top divisions in Europe, their bi-annual trips back to Africa to play in the tournament represent a particularly pressing concern for top league bosses, and that should be reflected in the game's Career Mode. For two Januaries in a row, Alan Pardew has had to be without his starting strike-force duo, thanks to their international affiliation with Senegal, and top Premier League talents like John Obi Mikel, Cheick Tiote, Yaya Toure and Gervinho could all be taken away from their clubs at a crucial point in the domestic season, testing the team's resources and their managers' adaptability to pressure. To not have that reflected in as big a game as FIFA 13 feels like a missed opportunity for more realism. The next licensing step must surely be to bring in fully licensed major tournaments - like the World Cup and the Champions League, but as long as EA Sports recognise the potential to release those competitions as DLC Expansions as they did with the World Cup, I can't see it happening. I would however be willing to buy affordable expansions, so even that option is preferable to just not including the licenses at all. It's also a shame that there's still no place for the Argentinian league, which ranks among the best in the world and features some of the continents best talents.
7. Historical Mode
I may be in the minority here, but the idea of playing in historically significant matches in a retro FIFA mode really appeals. Not only would players be able to control some of the legends of the game in iconic matches, stamping their own identity to those matches and changing the results, but the Mode could also include specific challenges like emulating the Arsenal Invincibles with the same squad, or avoiding relegation for a doomed team with ten games to go. For me personally, the prospect of showing Alan Shearer how Newcastle United could and should have been saved from relegation in 2008/09 would be enough to make this Mode a massive draw, but there are an infinite number of huge historical moments in the game and subsequent challenges that EA Sports could include. For a game property so obviously invested in the present and the future of the sport, a reflective, retro mode would go down well, particularly among older players, and the added challenge of changing history would surely appeal to the more competitive players and their egos. Just imagine stopping Maradona from going down in history against England in '86 by beating Argentina (on the hardest difficulty obviously), or taking Blyth Spartans to the final of the FA Cup in 1978. That would be a great way of celebrating the history of the Beautiful Game. So what do you think FIFA fans? Would you like to see the features above brought in for FIFA 14? Share your thoughts below.