5. Iker Casillas Being Rated As Good As Neuer
Another rating that had us scratching our heads was the decision to rate Real Madrid's Iker Casillas at the same value as Bayern Munich's Manuel Neuer on 86. This decision really doesn't stand up in the face of logic, particularly when you consider Casillas isn't even getting in the Madrid team right now. The Spain No.1 has been displaced at the Bernabeu by Diego Lopez and has yet to play a single La Liga game for the Spanish giants this season. He was also dropped last season by former Madrid boss Jose Mourinho in favour of Lopez, and only made 19 league appearances. Meanwhile, Neuer won the Bundesliga, DFB-Pokal, DFL-Supercup, UEFA Champions League and UEFA Super Cup with Bayern, yet still isn't worthy of edging out Casillas in the rankings, apparently. That's despite the fact Casillas won nothing with Madrid last season.