FIFA 15: 12 Leaked Ratings That Are Already Wrong

FIFA 15 has already seen player ratings leaks, and already EA have got it all wrong.

Player ratings for EA Sport's upcoming football simulation game FIFA 15 are some of computer gaming's worst-kept secrets with a series of leaks finding their way through the many porous cracks of the internet a good month before the game's official UK release on September 26th. Already we've seen alleged leaked player ratings for the stars of Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool and Manchester United while yesterday we unearthed a list purporting to show Barcelona and Real Madrid's scores. Some of these ratings were as you might expect, while others, others were well off the mark. Long-term fans of the FIFA franchise will tell you player ratings are a pretty big deal. Scored out of 100, publishers EA assign a score value to each and every single player on the game based on their real-life counterpart's performances in 2013-14, which dictates how the digital version of the footballer fares on computers and consoles. These ratings are often a bone of contention among the game's fanbase with even the most marginal of changes to a player's score - be it up or down - enough to send gamers into a fury. And some may not be happy by what they've seen so far based on the purported leaks, with a number of stars either under or overvalued in FIFA 15. Here, we take a look at 12 leaked ratings EA have already gotten wrong.

12. Luke Shaw, 76

Luke Shaw has exploded onto the football scene over the course of the last 12 months, excelling for Southampton at left-back last season before completing his move to Manchester United this summer, becoming the world's fourth-most expensive defender and one of the planet's costliest teenagers following his £27 million switch. And that all makes his paltry rating of 72 in predecessor FIFA 14 look somewhat ridiculous. According to the leaks, EA have revised Shaw's score by handing him an increase up to 76 but we still feel this is too low. The 19-year-old is one of the game's fastest-rising stars at present and his recent performances - which saw him earn a place on England manager Roy Hodgson's 23-man World Cup squad - should have seen him score closer to 80. His new teammate Rafael has apparently been handed a ratings increase to 79, and that's despite the fact the Brazilian only made 19 Premier League appearances last season due to injury. Why then is Shaw considered inferior to the right-back? It really is perplexing giving the duo's varying campaigns in 2013-14.

11. Mesut Ozil, 87

If Luke Shaw is underrated, Mesut Ozil is overrated. Here we come to the opposite end of the spectrum as we take a look at the Arsenal midfielder's somewhat generous points score. Ozil may have been worthy of his reported score of 87 two seasons ago, back when he was playing for Real Madrid, but since joining Arsenal last summer he has flopped. Ozil excelled for Madrid in 2012-13, providing 13 assists and scoring nine La Liga goals. It was enough to seal a £42.5 million move to Emirates Stadium a year ago, but the German international has found life difficult in England since. The 25-year-old only scored five times during his maiden spell in the Premier League while he set up four fewer goals than he managed at the Bernabeu, while he appears to lack fitness. The ex-Madrid man only played 14 full games in 2013-14, according to Squawka stats, and appears to have found it difficult adjusting to the physicality of the English game, where he is not afforded the luxury of a winter break he was used to when he played in Germany and Spain. As such, he looks tired, and it really is remarkable that EA have still given him a lofty score of 87 in spite of all this.

10. Didier Drogba, 83

While a score of 83 would have been more appropriate during his first spell at Chelsea two years ago, it seems somewhat ludicrous now. Didier Drogba returned to west London earlier this summer following a spell away playing for Chinese side Shanghai Shenhua and Turkish outfit Galatasaray and his career appeared to be fizzling out until Blues boss Jose Mourinho made the remarkable decision to bring him back to England for a second spell at the club. But rather than playing the role of the club's main man in front of goal as he was once used to, Drogba is now a squad player at the age of 36 and will have to settle for a place on the substitutes' bench. The Ivorian's two appearances in the Premier League so far this season have both come from the bench and he is simply no longer an important first team player. So why EA have decided to slap a reported score of 83 on his head in FIFA 15 is beyond us, quite frankly, because he's nowhere near that good anymore. This rating, astonishingly, puts him one point behind Liverpool striker Daniel Sturridge and three behind Real Madrid's James Rodriguez, according to the leaks, which really is mad.

9. Raheem Sterling, 80

Apparently worse than Didier Drogba is Liverpool's Raheem Sterling. This, despite the fact the young winger has just enjoyed a breakthrough season with the Reds, putting on a series of exciting performances to earn himself a spot on England manager Roy Hodgson's World Cup squad. Sterling was on fire last season, scoring nine Premier League goals to help fire his side to the brink of title glory, only to lose out on the final day. With his breakneck speed, agility and attacking mindset, the 19-year-old was a breath of fresh air in 2013-14 and won Liverpool's Young Player of the Year Award. And while his rating has gone up in the FIFA series from the dismal 76 he was afforded a year ago, 80 is still far too low a score for the England international, who has already scored one league goal from two appearances so far this term. Given his recent performances, a score of between 81-83 would have been more reasonable, but as it is, gamers are going to have to make do with an underrated Sterling once more in EA's footy games.

8. James Rodriguez, 86

Another player who has exploded onto the world scene over the past 12 months is James Rodriguez. A Golden Boot-winning string of performances at this summer's World Cup have ensured the 23-year-old has taken centre stage recently but you could make the case that Real Madrid's new signing is somewhat overrated. Yes, Rodriguez enjoyed a fantastic World Cup. He averaged a goal once every 67 minutes at the finals in Brazil, finishing as the tournament€™s leading marksman with six goals and two assists. As such, Real paid a reported ‚80 million for his services when they signed him from Monaco this summer. However, at Monaco, Rodriguez was something of a disappointment during his one and only season in France in 2013-14, failing to hit double figures in Ligue 1 after mustering up just nine goals. And it's only because of his unexpected performances at the World Cup, along with the inflated fee Madrid have just signed him for that have prompted EA to reportedly boost his score in FIFA 15 to 86 from 83 in last year€™s iteration, which we feel is a knee-jerk reaction considering the South American has only recently started to turn it on at the highest levels of the game.

7. Alexis Sanchez, 84

Alexis Sanchez is quite often mistreated by EA. In last year's iteration of the FIFA franchise, the former Barcelona man was downgraded by three points from his FIFA 13 rating of 85, while this time he has only risen two points from his score of 82 in predecessor '14. That's despite the fact the forward put on a series of dazzling performances last season, providing 10 assists and scoring 19 La Liga goals for Barca. Sanchez's performances last term prompted Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger to shell out £35 million to bring the Chilean to England this summer, and though he has yet to fully settle in the Premier League, FIFA 15's rating system is designed to reflect the player's performances from last season, not this. As such, we feel the Gunner's latest recruit is undervalued. We feel Sanchez is far more deserving of his previous aforementioned rating of 85 from FIFA 13, for the South America has surely not depreciated in form over the course of the last two seasons. Though it may appear pernickety to argue for a one-point increase for the 25-year-old, we are fully prepared to champion his cause considering EA's historic penchant for overlooking the star. Enough is enough.

6. Per Mertesacker, 82

Another Arsenal player who has been underrated by EA in their ratings system for the upcoming FIFA 15 is Per Mertesacker. The centre-half has allegedly only retained last year's score of 82 in '15, which we find just a little bit odd. The Germany international enjoyed a terrific season with the Gunners in 2013-14, and his side had never lost a match when he partnered Laurent Koscielny at the heart of defence prior to the defeat to Liverpool on 8 February 2014. Before that defeat, it was pointed out that when the Arsenal pair played 90 minutes together, the Gunners never lost a single match, which stretched to 28 games and took in 16 clean sheets out of 28, averaging 0.5 goals conceded-per-game. It's a phenomenal record, and makes his score on '15 seem all he more harsh. Worse still is his current overall speed rating of 35 on the game, which makes him a liability when playing as Arsenal on FIFA and not worth having in your team. The German might not be the next Usain Bolt but he hardly wades through quicksand on a weekly basis either, and we feel as though EA have overlooked his abilities.

5. Aaron Ramsey, 83

One final Arsenal player who we feel has been handed the short end of the stick by EA is Aaron Ramsey. The midfielder was also overlooked in last year's game, being handed a derisive score of 77 at one point in FIFA 14 before being upgraded to a still-too-low 81. And though Ramsey has seen another rise to 83, we still feel this isn't entirely accurate. The Welshman is rapidly becoming one of Arsenal's most important players and scored 10 Premier League goals in 23 appearances last term, being named Arsenal Player of the Season as a result. He was also named London Player of the Year for 2014 and was Arsenal's Player of the Month for four consecutive months in the back-end of 2013, scooping the honour between August and November. His biggest accomplishment last season however was scoring the extra-time winner against Hull City back in May to fire his side to FA Cup glory and put to an end their near decade-long trophy drought, being named as the FA Cup Final Man of the Match for his performance. Ramsey has come an awful long way since last year's game and we strongly believe he's worthy of a rating closer to the 85 mark.

4. Diego Costa, 86

Returning to Chelsea now with their new signing, Diego Costa, who has just joined the Blues from Atletico Madrid off the back of a fine season in Spain having netted 27 goals in 35 La Liga appearances last term to help fire his side to their first league title since 1996. You might argue then that that goal-scoring form warrants an alleged boost in rating from 83 in last year's game to 86 in successor FIFA 15, but as with James Rodriguez's score, we can't help but shake the feeling EA have made another knee-jerk reaction here. Yes, Costa was on form in 2013-14, but he has had ONE good season. He came from nowhere last season, emerging from the shadow cast by Radamel Falcao following his move to Monaco having previously been somewhat anonymous, with very few speaking his name. He only scored 10 goals in 2012-13 and just five years ago was plying his trade in Spain's Segunda División with minnows Albacete. We feel it is far too early to come to any real conclusion that Costa is worth anywhere near his lofty rating of 86, which puts him on a par with James Rodriguez and two ahead of Liverpool's Daniel Sturridge. The Chelsea man may yet go on to put in a series of performances that rubbish our concerns, but as of this moment, we think EA have jumped the gun.

3. Robin van Persie, 87

Robin van Persie endured a difficult season for Manchester United in 2013-14. A series of injury niggled meant the striker was limited to just 21 Premier League appearances last term, meaning he wasn't able to replicate the form that saw him win the Golden Boot award last year after netting 26 league goals in 38 appearances during his debut spell at the club in 2012-13. Instead he managed a return of just 12 goals from his scattering of appearances and has seen an apparent decrease in rating in FIFA 15, dipping two points from his score of 89 in predecessor FIFA 14. This is understandable, though you could argue it's also harsh. RVP is still one of the best strikers in the game and the fact he got injured doesn't mean he's any less of a player. At the World Cup for example he showed what he is capable of when fully fit by shining for the Netherlands, scoring a wonderful diving header against World and European champions Spain and firing his country to third place at the finals in Brazil with four goals, averaging a goal every 137 minutes. Personally, we'd have left his score as it was.

2. Daniel Sturridge, 84

Daniel Sturridge enjoyed a terrific season in 2013-14 but is still considered marginally better than Didier Drogba, two points worse off than Diego Costa and lags well behind van Persie - a player who was largely injured last season - according to EA's estimations. And that's simply ridiculous. Sturridge was the Premier League's second-highest goal-scorer last term with 21 goals in 29 appearances, falling just behind former teammate Luis Suarez, and was named in the PFA Team of the Year for 2014. His run of form took in four goals in three games after netting a brace against Notts County in the League Cup last August while he became the first Liverpool player in the Premier League era to score in seven consecutive league games when he found the net against Fulham back in February. How EA arrived at the conclusion to assign him a lowly rating of 84 quite frankly leaves us befuddled and, to take a leaf out of Wayne Rooney's book, angry and confused. Sturridge should be among the big-hitters in FIFA 15 with a score to match his performances and a rating of 86 really wouldn't look out of place considering the England man's recent form.

1. Andres Iniesta, 90

Andres Iniesta was not so long ago considered the third best player in world football by most pundits and so-called experts, falling just behind the €˜big two€™ of Cristiano Ronaldo and Barcelona teammate Lionel Messi. However, you could make a case that his apparently-leaked rating in FIFA 15 is overly generous. Iniesta has seemingly been afforded a score of 90 in EA Sport€™s upcoming football simulation game, which represents a glacial increase from the 89 he was assigned in last year€™s game. And we€™re trying to work out why EA thought the veteran midfielder deserved a boost. Barca endured a pretty dismal season last term, finishing the season without a trophy, while for Spain the 30-year-old was similarly ineffectual at this summer€™s World Cup, with La Roja crashing out of the group stages. If you had to name the third best footballer in the world today, would you still name Andres Iniesta? That€™s debatable. There are perhaps more worthy candidates in James Rodriguez, Luis Suarez and Gareth Bale for that particular mantle. We can€™t help shake the feeling that Iniesta is overrated in €™15, and personally, we€™d have left him at last year€™s rating of 89. Do you agree that these stars are either over or underrated in FIFA 15, or have EA actually got their ratings right? Share your thoughts in the comments thread, below.

Contributor
Contributor

Joseph is an accredited football journalist and has interviewed nearly all of the current 20 Barclay's Premier League managers. He is also a correspondent for Bleacher Report and has written for Caught Offside and Give Me Football.