FIFA 18: 10 Things EA Need To Steal From PES
FIFA's wealth of licenses mean little without the Champions League...
Every year sees the same battle between FIFA's license-heavy approach and the more quaint appeal of PES. EA Sports have undoubtedly become kings of the football video game world, but there are still a few hidden gems in the Konami playbook that FIFA could benefit from stealing.
No, PES 2017 still doesn't have a fully-fleshed out Premier League, official kits or even team names, yet there's still something charming about the title. In terms of pure football, Pro Evolution Soccer plays like a dream and holds an edge over FIFA that series fans eager to start pre-ordering FIFA 18 won't want to admit.
It's not all gameplay either, PES does possess a number of presentation tweaks that EA could be doing with introducing to FIFA. Perhaps then we'd finally get that perfect football game, instead of having to choose between the franchises each year...
10. International Football's Unique Atmosphere
Play an international fixture in FIFA 17 and it just feels like every other game. There's nothing special there, and that's a crying shame. Surely taking charge of a country in Career Mode and leading them to World Cup success should feel unique, unlike anything else gamers can do with their created manager.
Outside of Career Mode, the same problems are evident. Even with the addition of women's national teams, FIFA 17 still struggles when it comes to international football. Thankfully, PES is there to pick up the slack and Konami have a great grasp on what makes the national stage different from the club game.
Stadiums just feel grander. Playing international fixtures in PES 2017 feels like watching the World Cup or European Championships. This is made all the worse when realising that EA Sports could have the FIFA license for the former if they wanted. Sort it out, EA, 'World Cup' games in FIFA shouldn't feel the same as Barnsley vs. Fulham.
9. Lionel Messi As A Cover Star
There was a time when Barcelona's jinking genius Lionel Messi could grace both FIFA and PES box art without any hint of an argument. Those days are over, and Messi is very much Konami's property now. This means that EA can't use Messi's likeness on the cover of their own games.
As one of football's most instantly-recognisable stars, it sucks that FIFA can't have one of the world's greatest players front and centre. This suggests to hardcore football fans that PES is the product to get. After all, if it has the planet's best player (sorry, Ronaldo) on the box, then it must cater to those who favour on-the-pitch action over anything else.
The insinuation is that PES plays like Messi does, whereas FIFA is a throwback to the brand-heavy 'Galáctico' Real Madrid teams of a decade ago. All style, no substance.
8. Exclusivity Over The Camp Nou
Whether playing offline Exhibition matches, as part of Career Mode or on Ultimate Team, nobody wants to pick Barcelona only to play in some faceless stadium. Part of the appeal of FIFA has always been that authenticity, certainly for the bigger clubs.
The fact Barcelona's infamous Camp Nou is completely missing from FIFA 17 is a glaring negative that really harms the game's overall atmosphere. Curse you, Konami, we want Barca's ground in both our major footy titles this year.
Sadly, that's just not going to happen so long as PES and Barcelona continue their strong working relationship that ensures the Camp Nou can only appear in Konami's game. Meanwhile, fans of the Spanish giants who prefer FIFA over PES have to make do with the sight of a generic bowl stadium that doesn't reflect watching Barcelona on television.
All those licenses and one stadium makes a difference. Created a rod for your own back there, EA.
7. Those Little Cutscenes
FIFA fans agree that Career Mode needs a bit more love come FIFA 18. A few additions here and there could really make a huge difference, just look at the Master League in PES for proof of that. It's the subtle things that go a long way with fans, especially when EA tout presentation over anything else as most important.
Sign a star player for your side in Master League and prepare to be treated with a short, sweet cutscene that proudly displays your multi-million pound man wearing the team kit and being flaunted for the media. This may seem inconsequential, but it helps that immersion modern footy games strive for.
It's the same for awards ceremonies and when you switch clubs as a manager too. FIFA could be doing with some of these scenes to help beef out Career Mode, rather than relying on dry text that feels like a copy and paste effort every time.
6. Master League Team Roles
Admittedly, FIFA 17 does attempt to display uniqueness by telling players that some members of their squad are "showing great potential" or are a "leader of men". This isn't enough though, and even when EA have attempted to include player-specific skills such as 'Speedster', they rarely have much impact.
PES gets this right by introducing titles for different players. The descriptions for these bleed passion too, and that's what football enthusiasts want. They need to know that a 'Hero' (for example) will drag the team kicking and screaming to a win like his life depends on it.
Better yet, Master League dishes out nicknames gifted by fans as it progresses. This gives bonuses to your team should they pick that player, and they can be the difference between nicking a late win or settling for a 1-1 draw.
FIFA must put more focus on this individuality.
5. Individual Player Attributes Make A Difference
Speaking of which, why is it so bloody difficult to sprint past even the oldest of defenders with speed merchants like Cristiano Ronaldo in FIFA 17? Worse, it seems like the CPU has been programmed to ensure nobody has a clear advantage in a foot race. That's just not like real football.
EA should be commended for attempting to eliminate unrealistic dribbles that beat 10 players, but in doing so they have stripped away one of the game's best features. In other words, it's not realistic that Ronaldo couldn't outrun Per Mertesacker and skip past the Arsenal CB with lightning quickness before bearing down on goal.
In PES, those individual player attributes make a real difference to how each game plays out. Facing Real Madrid as Swansea shouldn't see the Welsh club's defence matching CR7 move for move like they're reading his mind. PES gets that distinctiveness right, whereas FIFA's apparent fear of speed requires a rethink.
4. Tactical Depth
FIFA is a much more scripted experience all-round compared to PES, and this becomes more obvious when analysing how tactics work across both games. In EA's world, almost every team plays the same kind of style, driving up the middle to exploit through balls and playing intricate passes around the box to find space for a shot.
PES adopts a different approach, and it's shockingly open to player interpretation. Make no mistake about it, you can get thumped by even the weakest of teams in Konami land if you don't set the team up correctly and play to the strengths of key players.
Tactical nouse isn't essential to playing PES, but it does open the game up and lend itself to the idea of actual management. The sheer number of options can be overwhelming, yet they trod all over FIFA's more modest 'attack full force or park the bus' outlook. FIFA 18 needs to let tactics change whether player-controlled teams have the ball or don't, instead of merely offering up one play style.
3. Switching Teams Fluidly In Career Mode
A real pet peeve of any Career Mode lover in recent FIFA titles has been the inability to change clubs easily. The system in place is just so awkward, and PES proves this by going in a different direction that rewards success and patience in equal measures.
Take charge of a lower-league club in FIFA and you're doomed to struggle for new jobs unless snatching any that come along around October/November of the first season. That doesn't make sense, because surely winning trophies counts, and PES gets this balance right.
Offers come in from teams who are actually interested, instead of forcing players to apply without much hope to the giants of the game. EA need to stop making Career Mode a chore that punishes those who want to pump countless hours into the single player mode. Master League in PES features a more natural career progression for created managers.
2. The Ability To Import Kits & Teams
One big selling point of FIFA is the knowledge that all official club kits and logos will be available from the off. PES remedied their own lack of licences by releasing data packs that feature real-life strips and logos players can then (somewhat straightforwardly) copy into the game.
EA Sports don't necessarily need to outright lift this idea, but FIFA could do with some more customisation. Imagine being able to edit your chosen team's strip each season, debuting a new kit that could then be sold to fans for additional income. That's a tantalising prospect for FIFA players forced to see Chelsea pull on the 2016-2017 kit a decade later in Career Mode.
Being able to create full teams and stadiums would also be wonderful. PES has always been a more customisable experience generally, but there's no reason why EA Sports can't make FIFA a creator's paradise too. Simply being able to import images so teams don't have the same sponsor every season would be a start.
1. The Champions League License
Suffering from the same problems that plague international tournaments, the 'Champions Cup' in FIFA 17 feels lifeless next to the genuine article over in PES 2017. Konami's title features a proper Champions League mode, one that can be played individually or as part of Master League each year.
The biggest club competition in the world is a must for FIFA at some point. EA badly need to get their grubby mitts on UEFA's cherished tournament by hook or by crook. Playing an unlicensed European Cup competition just doesn't feel right these days.
We'd even settle for the lack of a Europa League license, because that Champions League branding is way more important to feeding the authenticity EA yearn to present annually. Seeing your team lift a cheap knock-off in FIFA is becoming tiresome. Get the wallet out, EA Sports!
What else do you think EA must nab from PES in the future? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!