FIFA 19: 8 Surprises From The Top 100 Players
Messi and Ronaldo are the same, and Mo Salah isn't one of the world's elite?
EA drip-fed their announcement of the Top 100 players in FIFA 19 this year. That was a smart strategy, one that allowed them to steadily spin out hype for the game's 28 September release more than usual and coincide with the demo's launch on PC, Xbox One and PS4 this past Thursday.
Armed with new gameplay mechanics to muck around with, gamers can clearly see the key differences between 19's top-ranked player Cristiano Ronaldo and someone like Borussia Dortmund's Marco Reus just by playing as them. Both the demo's unveiling and that Top 100 reveal have become celebrated moments for the annual series.
Celebrated and riddled with surprises.
There are bags of them on this year's list. Yes, CR7 is the number one man (again), and sure, the Top 10 collection are supposed to be the game's must-buy players, but something feels a bit off in other places. Throughout, old favourites have slid down the ladder in EA's estimations, and others are absurdly high.
Ronaldo's management might not be happy that the new Juventus star isn't out on his own at the head of the pack too...
8. Buffon Has Fallen Out Of Favour
Spare a thought for the legendary Gianluigi Buffon.
Not only are the press reporting that the iconic Italian stopper will be dropped by PSG, now EA are browbeating the ex-Juventus hero in their FIFA 19 Top 100. This year, Gigi has fallen from the heady heights of #13 to mingling with the chasing pack as #35.
His overall stats have taken a hit too. Diving, Reflexes and Handling are all down on point from FIFA 18, and even Buffon's charming smile seems to exist solely to mock the fact that hey, one of football's greatest ever goalkeepers is on the slide. Poor, dapper Gigi.
According to EA, Buffon is now the seventh best keeper in world footy. He's behind Hugo Lloris, Marc-André Ter Stegen, Jan Oblak, Thibaut Courtois, Manuel Neuer and David De Gea on the list, and his overall rating is three points behind the Man Utd goalie.
7. So Has Gareth Bale
Gianluigi Buffon is coming to the end of his natural shelf-life as a top-level goalkeeper and, though EA do seem to be jumping the gun, his decreased position in the Top 100 is arguable. What the hell is going on with Real Madrid's grinning Welshman Gareth Bale though? He's another to hit the skids.
This year, Bale has dropped from #17 in FIFA 18 (which seemed low even then) to #31 on the FIFA 19 pecking order. His cheeky smile from last year's Ultimate Team card has been replaced by the stoic face of a man who knows he's not having a great time of it and might end up signing for José Mourinho's Man Utd.
Hey, it could happen, and probably will if FIFA's Career Mode is anything to go by.
Bale's stats don't reflect his fall from grace. Some of them are actually upped by a point, so it doesn't make sense that his overall has gone from 89 to 88. Pace and Shooting, notably, have been improved, and it's only Dribbling and Defending that drop. The latter isn't exactly paramount for a speedy, goal-getting wing man, so why has it affected his rating?
6. Handanovic?
Then, there's the confusing case of Inter Milan keeper Samir Handanovic.
Someone at EA must be a huge fan of the Nerazzurri. That's the only reasonable explanation for why Inter's 6'4" stopper has risen from #46 to #39 in FIFA 19. It's not like Handanovic is in a side flying high at the moment either; Inter have had a poor start to the campaign, winning only one of their opening three Serie A fixtures.
Here's a shortlist of players EA believe Samir is better than: Liverpool's Sadio Mané, Real Madrid's Keylor Navas, bloody Andrés Iniesta, Man Utd's Romelu Lukaku and French World Cup winning teenager Kylian Mbappé. Figure that one out.
It's not that Handanovic is a bad player (he's not), but he's strangely high on this year's Top 100, and there's no real reason for it. His stats barely compare to the aforementioned Gianluigi Buffon, yet they both share the same 88 overall rating.
5. Dele Alli Has Slipped Out Of The Rankings
"The English midfielder is one of the world's most exciting young talents".
Those were EA's very words in last year's FIFA 18 Top 100. When describing one of Spurs' main men Dele Alli, the dev team hinted there was more to come from the young powerhouse. There is, albeit not in this year's game. Alli, shockingly, isn't in 19's elite club full stop.
Dele clocked in at a lowly #93 last time, and it was expected he'd kick on and crack into the top 60 at least. Not quite, and it appears one p*ssed off England fan wasn't impressed by the midfield maestro's performance in that World Cup Semi Final loss to Croatia over the summer. Alli, for his sins, has been ousted.
Given EA's love of making virtually every promising Premier League player look world class in-game, this comes as a huge surprise. Raheem Sterling, Dele's England teammate, just scrapes in at #97, and there's no place for Kyle Walker, who is roundly regarded as one of Europe's best wing backs.
4. Some Shocking Decisions Near The Bottom
Don't worry though, because there's still house room for some old battled-hardened veterans who nonsensically capture EA's attention in 2018.
Zlatan Ibrahimovic, who plies his trade in MLS for LA Galaxy these days, is still clinging on to his Top 100 bragging rights. He's in at #98, one place below Man City speedster Raheem Sterling. Also, FIFA 17 cover man Marco Reus, despite missing a hefty portion of last season through injury, makes the cut at #90.
The most surprising addition to the list is Man Utd's Nemanja Matic. Yes, the 30-year old hits the heights of #76, which is again above Premier League winner Sterling, Juventus and France midfielder monster Blaise Matuidi and Liverpool's new keeper Alisson.
It's also an absolute tragedy that Champions League winner Marco Asensio is forced to settle for #95 when a more limited player like Matic struts his stuff a full 19 places above him. Positions 100-60 seem like a randomised mishmash of players.
3. Lewandowski's Nonsensical Slide
Robert Lewandowski, as usual, romped home with the top scorer plaudits in last season's Bundesliga campaign. The Polish striker netted 29 league goals for champions Bayern Munich and he's already off the mark with two strikes from two matches in the new campaign.
Somehow despite that terrific form, he's dropped from #6 in FIFA 18's Top 100 players to #11.
In FIFA 19, Lewandowski will be the fourth-best full-blown attacker. He sits snugly behind Luis Suárez, Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo. Hardly bad company to be in, and yet Bayern's goal machine will be disappointed to fall short of players in other positions.
Munich teammate Toni Kroos is above him, as is Chelsea's Eden Hazard. Last season, Lewandowski netted 17 more goals than Hazard (who bagged 12) in league play. Although the Bundesliga is arguably an easier division than the Premier League, it's still harsh he's fallen so many places.
2. Mo Salah Isn't In The Top 10
In other inconsistent news, Liverpool's beaming 2017/18 success story Mohamed Salah hasn't made it into the Top 10. Stop the press, because that's simply unacceptable. Salah scored 32 Premier League goals last season, helped his side reach the Champions League final with his link-up play brilliance and was one of Europe's best players across the board.
What were EA thinking?
It might have been slightly less of a shock had Mo been named between positions 15-11, but he's way, way back in #27. Twenty seventh is not good enough for a right wing master who cut in so deftly time and time again to captivate both Anfield and neutral fans alike.
There has to be a rethink here. If FIFA's Top 100 is based on what players achieved the season before, then Salah should be in the upper echelons alongside Messi, Ronaldo and Neymar. He definitely shouldn't be toiling away down between 21-30.
1. Messi & Ronaldo Have The Same Rating
Last year, Cristiano Ronaldo regained the cover star crown from Dortmund's Marco Reus, and he was logically named the best player in FIFA 18. One full point above Lionel Messi (Ronaldo had 94 to the Barca man's 93), CR7 stood out on his own as the world's greatest.
This year, he's sharing the throne.
Messi has been elevated back into contention, and stats between he and Ron are remarkably tight. Both superstars have an overall rating of 94, and Messi actually has some better skills than his old La Liga rival. His Dribbling is six points better off, and his Passing seven. On the flip side, Ronaldo has the advantage when it comes to Pace, Shooting, Defending and Physical attributes.
Before the Top 10 was revealed, it was expected that Ronaldo would continue his march towards isolation at the top of the charts. Another (smaller) surprise comes from the fact that he and Messi are now two points ahead of PSG's main man Neymar. The little Brazilian won't like that one bit.
-
What other surprises did you spot in EA's Top 100 for FIFA 19? Let us know down in the comments section below!