Final Fantasy XV: 10 Major Risks That Could Go Either Way

Almost a decade in development is LOT of hype to live up too.

To say Final Fantasy XV has been a long time coming is an understatement. Originally announced as Versus XIII alongside Final Fantasy XIII, the project has gone through what may be one of the roughest development cycles ever. At least, the roughest cycle that didn€™t end in cancellation. But after years of bouncing between development teams struggling to juggle the ludicrous number of projects Square Enix has going at any given time, a change in director and even a totally different name, FFXV is finally on the horizon, with the release date set to be announced on March 30th. However, after such a long time fluxing in and out of limbo, there€™s a lot about the game's various elements that could go either way. The game has a lot going for it in terms of mechanics and sheer ambition, but every one of the game's potential highlights could just as easily end up being its undoing, such as...

10. Having An All-Male Party

Let€™s get this one out of the way first. For the first time in the franchise since the very first game, FFXV will feature an entirely male main cast. There€™s nothing wrong with this on its own, if it serves the story and its themes of brotherhood and male friendship, then an all male party is the way to go. Games are art, and if the developers want the game as a boy€™s club then that€™s their decision, and there€™s nothing wrong with that. The only problem is that this decision may end up alienating a big chunk of the fanbase. Part of Final Fantasy€™s appeal has always been their large, diverse cast of characters; guys, girls, weird animal people, you know how it goes. All have been staples of the major Final Fantasy instalments so far, meaning the sudden exclusion of anyone without a Y chromosome from the core cast, could be really off-putting to a lot of fans. Art can never fill everyone's desires, after all. The artist has the right to choose what they want, the consumer has just as much right to be disappointed after the fact. If executed properly, this could mean a fantastic if not terribly original story about a band of close male friends battling monsters and bonding, Lord of the Rings-style. If done poorly, however, it would mean that women were excluded from the party for the sake of narrative elements that just didn€™t work.

9. Open-World Elements

From what we€™ve seen so far and played in the demo episode, FFXV has a HUGE map to explore. Apparently Square Enix have taken fans complaints about XXIII€™s linearity to heart, and have brought back the overworld of classic entries. However, it needs to be noted that a lot about game design, especially open-world game design, has changed since the PS1 era. The overworlds of FF VII, VIII and IX were basically just the connective tissue between the game's various cities and dungeons. There were secrets to find and monsters to encounter, but nothing that resembled the side quest-filled, 3D landscapes we€™ve become accustomed to. Last year we were spoiled by The Witcher 3, which showed that you can have a massive open world without resorting to Ubisoft-style busywork. Hopefully, FFXV can give an interesting world to explore filled with interesting stories and characters, instead of pointless filler for the sake of it.

8. The Car

One of the most publicised features of the game is the party€™s fancy car that will be used to traverse the map. As FFXV is basically a JRPG version of a road trip movie, a sweet ride is obviously necessary. Amazing as it sounds to drive a convertible alongside a herd of Chocobo and burn rubber fleeing from a pursuing dinosaur, depending on how the car is implemented it could either be a fantastic new edition or a vestigial feature holding back the open world aspects of the game. It all comes down to how it functions in gameplay. If it€™s just a method of navigating the roadways, basically a glorified fast travel system/taxi service, then that sounds incredibly boring. However, if the car ends up having more functionality, like being able to drive it freely in the field or even use it in combat situations, then it could be one of the coolest parts of the game. Can I use it to chase down the elusive black Chocobo? Can I use it to ram skyscraper sized monsters in the face? I certainly hope so.

7. 'Realism'

€œThis is a fantasy based on reality.€ This has been the games tagline since very early on, and it€™s a reflection of the kind of story Tetsuya Nomura was trying to create. FFXV would make a conscious effort to be a realistic reflection of reality, both in terms of its world and the presentation the characters therein. This is why, despite the inclusion of Chocobos, magic powers and other Final Fantasy staples, the game takes place in what otherwise looks like modern day Japan, with cars, architecture and technology to match. As a realistic Final Fantasy hasn€™t really been attempted before, this could be really interesting, but the problem that comes with this approach is immersion-breaking juxtaposition. If a realistic setting is the goal, suddenly introducing wacky, eccentric elements could be really jarring. For example, if the rest of the game has shown a dedication to realistic combat wear for enemy soldiers, suddenly introducing a character with the outrageously stupid (yet awesome looking) costumes indicative of the series starts to feel really out of place. Think about it; if Cindy makes her living welding futuristic space cars and Gladio is a bodyguard to a guy who spends most of his time getting shot at, then why do they both wear clothing that exposes most of the torso? Why is the recently revealed Aranea wearing a cage on her head? Trying to be realistic is a valid design approach, but you have to stick to it. So, fun as cheesecake designs can be, they may just end up detracting from the characters overall.

6. The Mythology

Like FFXIII and Type-0 before it, FFXV falls under the Fabulla Nova Chrystallis banner, meaning that it utilises a lot of the same mythology and concepts. The mythos actually has a lot of cool ideas and thematic elements, inescapable fate, and humanity being used as pawns by a pantheon of enigmatic, often malicious deities. That could make for some really good stories if done well. However, in all four of the previous games centered around it, the Chrystallis mythology has been a poorly presented overly complicated mess. FFXIII threw out dozens of awkward-sounding, easy to confuse fantasy terms vital to the games story... and then proceeded to explain them through the riveting storytelling technique of handing the player an in-game dictionary and expecting them to read through to understand what€™s going on. To that end, we better get a better explanation for Noctis€™ superpowers beyond a simple €œThe goddess Etro did it€. FFXV needs to do a better job of explaining its lore and in-universe mechanics, simple as.

5. The Combat System

Ever since FFIX, Square Enix has tried to completely reinvent the franchises battle system with each major installment. FFXV is no exception, and instead of the traditional turned based paradigm that€™s defined much of the series, is instead going with a system that can only be called 'Kingdom Hearts on steroids'. The player exclusively takes control of Noctis, with the other party members taking the roles of support NPCs and as components of special group attacks in a similar fashion to how Donald and Goofy help Sora with Trinity Attacks. This approach worked rather well in the demo, even with most of the more extravagant features cut out, and when fully implemented it could be a fast, frantic, and wonderfully over-the-top combat experience. Really, this one comes down to personal taste. Kingdom Hearts fans will probably eat it up eagerly, but purists for the franchise's earlier instalments may find the new approach off-putting.

4. Noctis

To me, the biggest problem with FFXIII and its two sequels was Lightning, the principal protagonist. On paper, she sounds like a fantastic character. A former soldier who abandoned the fascist regime she served in order to protect the younger sister who she raised like a daughter, ultimately learning to move past her grief and suffering to become the world€™s savior. That sounds fantastic... and it could€™ve been, if the writers had remembered to give her an actual personality instead of just making her a female Cloud, minus the subtle humanity and character arc. At this point, it€™s up in the air whether Noctis will be a similarly boring, mopey protagonist as his predecessor, though from what we€™ve seen so far, it could honestly go either way. In the demo, Noctis barely spoke at all, with most of the dialogue coming from his friends, and him only responding with nods or one word answers. The full game will no doubt show a more fully formed personality complete with pathos and relationships to other characters, but for now, Noctis looks like he could turn out to be another Lightning.

3. Luna

Since the game started it€™s life as Versus XIII, main character Noctis has been set to have a female rival/love interest. Originally, she was called Stella and had the same power-set as Noctis, but despite caring about him and being compelled to fight him by the gods, didn't actually want to. Now, after revising the story to be a one and done narrative, the character has taken the form of Luna, an oracle princess who is also Noctis€™ childhood friend and fiancé.Though her exact role in the story is un-clear at this point, the trailers and interviews by the games director have indicated that she€™s one of the game€™s most important characters. I have two main concerns about this: Firstly, can her role feel cohesive with the rest of the story after being so heavily rewritten? Secondly, and most importantly, can the game manage to make us care about a character and their romance with the protagonist when they€™re not a party member? Writing a compelling romance is hard enough, without one half of it being off screen most of the time. This is why no one really cares about Sora and Kairi€™s romance in Kingdom Hearts. Kairi has had twenty minutes on screen over the course of seven games. Hopefully the writers will manage to balance this and make Luna a compelling, dynamic character. Who knows, maybe she'll end up in the party temporarily.

2. The Story

FFXV has gone through a lot of changes since its origin as Versus XIII. The art design has changed a bit, it€™s gone a graphical overhaul with the change of console generation, and the story has gone through a lot of significant revisions. The basic pieces are the same, it€™s a story about Noctis and his friends going on cross country road trip to save the world, but many of the details have shifted around over the course of development, and it€™s kind of up in the air whether the narrative will manage to balance all its various elements and still feel cohesive. The story at its core is supposed to be a bromance between the main crew, but along with that there€™s also the political situation between the world€™s various kingdoms, supernatural elements relating to various divinities, and Noctis€™ relationship with Luna, who€™s apparently the games second most important character despite not being a party member. Imagine FFX, if Yuna wasn€™t in the party. How would that work? That€™s a lot of plates to keep spinning. It done right, it could be glorious. If done wrong though, well, we all remember how XIII turned out...

1. The Wait

This one may seem like cheating, but I feel it needs addressing. FFXV has been a long time coming. It was announced nearly a decade ago, and that€™s a ludicrously long time to build up fan expectations. No matter how good the game ends up, it may not be able to live up to what many fans want it to be; the rebirth of a legendary franchise. That€™s a heavy burden to bare for any game, and knowing the ferocity of gamers, if it€™s anything other than spectacular, it€™ll get ripped to shreds. In fairness, it'll probably get ripped to shreds anyway, considering some hardcore fans can never be truly satisfied. They have their own vision for the game already established in their head, and if the real thing deviates, they won€™t show any mercy. Maybe when the game comes out, it€™ll be everything we want it to be. But it could just as easily be crushed under inflated expectations, thanks to a wait that was just far too long for the final product to be worth it. Where do you stand on Final Fantasy XV? Let us know in the comments if you're excited, cautiously optimistic or something else entirely!

Contributor

A creative writing student from Indianapolis, Joe loves games, fantasy novels and comics.