How The Death Of E3 Changes Gaming Forever

A giant stumbles and falls.

e3 2020
ESA

With news of both Sony and Geoff Keighley backing out of E3 2020, it’s clear the influence once held by ESA’s convention is waning.

Based at the Los Angeles Convention Centre, it was gaming’s first dedicated trade show, first appearing in 1995 as a result of publishers needing an event to show off their products, finding themselves given little acknowledgement at events like the Consumer Electronics Show.

It quickly established itself as a gaming institution and became the go-to place for new announcements. To this day, publishers still choose it as the place for their biggest yearly reveals, be it games or the next generation of hardware. But E3 has suffered an identity crisis these last few years and what worked so well in 1995 doesn’t necessarily work anymore in 2020.

ESA's aimed to make it a show fit for industry officials and the public, but their strategy has brought the benefits of neither, contributing to former attendees exiting the event.

E3 is clearly in trouble, and its slow death creates a larger impact on the industry than first assumed.

8. Sony's Nail In The Coffin

Ps5 sony
Sony

In hindsight, Sony's withdrawal from E3 shouldn’t be as surprising as we first thought.

Whilst it wasn't widely noted until they backed out, Shawn Layden, former SIE Worldwide Studios chairman and the face of Sony’s conferences, made his concerns apparent. Talking about E3’s focus several times, he described it in 2017 as “stuck in the middle of the highway about to get hit by cars on both sides”, later saying "the trade show became a trade show without a lot of trade activity”.

Layden stepped down last year amidst internal company politics, but it’s a view still held within Sony’s leadership, considering E3 2020 is not in their plans either.

It seems odd to skip such a large trade show in PlayStation 5's launch year, and to many, this leaves Microsoft with an open goal when they’re planning to launch their next major hardware upgrade.

Still, this confirms that Sony no longer see E3 as an essential event for their business, focusing on other trade fares like the recent Taipei Game Show.

This presents wider ramifications for the industry, but there are more options available to Sony that didn't exist in 1995, the decision speaking volumes for how the event has changed, as well as its failure to adapt to a modern audience.


7. Changing Their Focus

Bethesda E3 2018 Andrew WK
Bethesda

Historically, E3 was an industry exclusive event, and the only outside access provided was for journalists.

Realising there was increasing demand for public access, ESA opened the convention doors to the public in 2017 with general-admittance passes but the conference hasn’t truly adapted with it and the modernisation attempt has so far backfired. It's become unclear what they believe E3 should be, an industry-focused affair or a public convention.

Last September, it became news that they were planning to rebrand it as a “fan, media and influencer festival”, an idea met with widespread derision from pretty much everyone.

They've faced wide criticism for lack of clear vision and now Geoff Keighley has expressed similar concerns, saying “Given what has been publicly communicated about plans for E3 2020, I just don’t feel comfortable participating in the show at this time”.

Whilst Keighley's E3 Coliseum only started in 2017, he's attended in differing capacities since 1995 and this position holds a bigger impact as a result. Regardless of what you think of the man, it’s clear that losing a long-standing figure like himself is another big blow for ESA and it's more likely that we'll continue to see the VGAs develop further instead.

He hasn’t ruled out returning though, believing E3 still has a future if its approach changes and this is more than what can be said for Sony right now.


6. Nintendo Ditching The Conference Stage

Nintendo games decade
Nintendo

Nintendo was arguably the start of E3's problems, long before Sony's withdrawal. Having been a major player at E3 since it began, 2012 was their last conference within the Expo and each year since has seen them move to online, pre-recorded broadcasts instead for their main announcements.

Presented as an E3 edition of their “Nintendo Direct” format, where the company provides updates for their upcoming plans, it was first adopted in 2011 by Nintendo under Satoru Iwata and soon extended this to E3.

It gave Nintendo a level of presentation freedom not possible within the LA Convention Centre, and this approach became widely adopted by other companies ever since, including Sony with their “State of Play” broadcasts.

Despite this, Nintendo continue to maintain a floor presence, providing demos of upcoming games and broadcasting their “Treehouse Live” events from the show floor to offer a more in-depth look at their new titles for online viewers.

They may not have left E3 in full, but the impact of their approach laid out the foundations for what followed in recent years.


5. Companies Moving To Online Formats

state of play playstation
Sony

Just as Nintendo Directs became a thing, the rise of streaming services across the internet has seen publishers embrace platforms and social media for new announcements.

Each major conference has provided an online stream for public viewing for many years, be it through Twitch, Youtube or their own websites and others have also replaced the live conference stage for a pre-recorded format.

It's a method utilised by companies of all sizes, but unlike Nintendo, a lot of publishers have prepared these broadcasts to match up with the convention, instead of directly attending. Google and Bungie utilised this approach last year for Stadia and Destiny 2 reveals, respectively.

This has mostly benefitted smaller companies and E3 2019 featured separate broadcasts from UploadVR, Devolver Digital and Limited Run Games.

This opened up the field, providing a platform alongside big publishers and giving them greater precedence, with Devolver receiving wide acclaim for their unique, comedic approach. It brought a creative aspect to press conferences that simply can't be achieved on a convention stage, one that can only continue evolving.


4. Publishers Creating Their Own Events

xbox xo19 show
Microsoft

That’s not to say gaming trade shows aren’t as popular anymore. Far from it.

Dedicated shows were rare in the 1990s but the industry has evolved considerably since then, and its global popularity has risen. Whilst events like the EB Games Expo and EGX host a variety of publishers, some companies instead create events focused only on their products.

It’s not a new idea by any means, as ZeniMax and Blizzard Entertainment’s have hosted QuakeCon and BlizzCon since 1996 and 2005 respectively. But recent years have seen Microsoft and Sony also held their own events, such as XO19 and the Playstation Experience, and this doesn’t even factor in publishers like EA, who’ve hosted their own EA Play event since 2014 in the week event before E3, as opposed to attending the conference.

The conference experience is becoming more fragmented as publishers seek greater control over promoting new games and hardware, both on the show floor and with online media and this changes marketing in a big way.

There's no longer the same guarantee that publishers will hold back until E3 to reveal new details now, providing a more even spread of announcements across the year.


3. Competitor Shows And The Video Game Awards

The Game Awards Spider Man God Of War
The Game Awards, Insomniac & Sony

This doesn't stop with publishers however and smaller shows are now taking greater precedence than they previously achieved. Events like Tokyo Game Show and PAX may be more established but the last decade has seen a number of new events establish themselves successfully like Gamescom and EGX, built with a stronger public focus that's proven more successful manner than E3's current attempts.

It's not just trade shows which expanded upon E3's premise and one of the biggest events founded in the last decade is Geoff Keighley’s Video Game Awards.

A successor to Spike TV's Video Game Awards, they first appeared in 2014 as a continued effort by Keighley to create gaming's equivalent of the Academy Awards, having previously worked with Spike TV's program before leaving in 2013.

Knowing that gamers would seek more than just an awards presentation, he’s aimed to balance the VGAs by co-operating with game developers to bring new announcements, proving highly successful.

It certainly doesn't aim to replace E3, but what it provides is a more modern outlet for new announcements, whilst recognising developers for their hard work.


2. Effect On Game Development

WWE 2K20 Glitch
2K Sports

The reduced prominence of E3 isn’t purely marketing based, as it also presents a tangible change to game development.

Each year, we would see Microsoft, Nintendo, Sega, Square Enix, Bethesda, Sony, Ubisoft and many more rush to finalise new trailers and gameplay demos in preparation for the event.

It would cause delays by taking away development time from the rest of a game, focusing on finishing up trailers or specific gameplay segments for demo purposes.

It cannot be understated how much a first impression brings to players and it's understandable they'd want to ensure it's as polished as realistically possible. But this approach creates strict deadlines, often resulting in large scale overtime (Otherwise known as crunch) to meet these goals with the aim of being presentation ready and imposes a lot of stress on developers.

It's an issue that's gained increasing attention in recent years, where more developers such as Rockstar and CD Projekt Red have come under fire for imposing this overtime on staff members.

Whilst the situation is likely to remain the same under other publishers, Sony's decision to back out means this E3 deadline is no longer a factor for them, but whether this leads to any tangible change or if this just means deadlines for other events is yet to be seen.


1. The Event's Legacy Lives On

There’s still life in the event, with Limited Run Games confirming just a few days ago that they’ll be present for E3, noting their broadcast time and a commitment to saving the conference.

It's clear that Microsoft have no intention of abandoning the stage either and Sony's withdrawal from the expo gives them a strong advantage, having slowly regained their position after the disastrous Xbox One reveal left them on the back foot this generation.

They won't be alone in this either, as the ESA have also confirmed that "Several leading video game companies have already committed to participating in E3 2020, including Xbox, Nintendo, Ubisoft, Bethesda Softworks, SEGA, Capcom, Square Enix, Take-Two Interactive Software, BANDAI NAMCO Entertainment America Inc., and Warner Bros. Games, among others."

Plus, there's always Microsoft's stage acting as the perfect place to go to for major third-party reveals.

It may seem an odd sentiment for what is just a trade show, but E3 showed just how important it was for gaming to have its own, exclusive event, helping it forge an identity when it was often pushed to the side. This has long ensured it a place in the heart of the gaming community.

No one wants to see it fall, but as the ESA struggle to adapt it for modern purposes, E3's demise has crept in step by step.

Even if the conference manages to recover, it's already impacted the industry in multiple ways, and this is not likely to change anytime soon.


In this post: 
E3 2020
 
Posted On: 
Contributor