Madden 16: 10 Overrated Players Who Need Downgrading

3. Peyton Manning - 98

Peyton Manning is one of the greatest quarterbacks of his generation, there's no doubt about it, but is he still the joint best in the league as things stand? Unfortunately, no. Aaron Rodgers is the standout 98 at the top of the pack, with Drew Brees perched in third at 96. That should be similar to Manning as he begins his descent towards retirement. He'll still claw his team into the playoffs, but his post-season record doesn't look great recently, with the young pretenders coming to steal his crown.