Ranking Every Xbox One Exclusive From Worst To Best

Rocky start. VERY respectable end.

Forza Horizon 4
Playground Games

It's not up for debate: Sony has unequivocally provided members of the PlayStation family more reasons to choose its hardware over Microsoft's.

But the latter hasn't gone out without a fight. It would have been so easy to give up, given that - in lieu of the total humiliation that followed the Xbox One's disastrous reveal - Microsoft's goose appeared cooked in 2013, but here we are, half a decade later, celebrating a comeback for the beleaguered console.

In fact, more so than its competitor, Microsoft has provided ample variety across its modest selection of system sellers, with the usual heavy-hitters - Halo, Gears, Forza - joined by fresher, less established ideas thanks to the work of Remedy and Insomniac with Quantum Break and Sunset Overdrive respectively. There have been missteps along the way, of course, with titles like ReCore and Sea of Thieves failing to achieve their potential, but unlike Sony, Microsoft's momentum seems only to be building as of late.

If Microsoft can keep the ball rolling into 2019 with new releases comparable in quality to Cuphead, Ori or Playground Games' terrific recent addition to the Forza Horizon franchise, it'll be nipping at Sony's heels in no time.

17. Crimson Dragon

Crimson Dragon
Grounding Inc

Two critical mistakes doomed Crimson Dragon, spiritual successor to Sega's lauded Panzer Dragoon series, to commercial failure before it even launched alongside Microsoft's then shiny new Xbox One.

Not only was the on-rails shooter meant, as all launch titles are, to showcase the power of Microsoft's new hardware, but also prove Kinect's continued worth as a device fit for anything other than gimmicky, casual interactions.

Originally primed as an Xbox 360 title and repurposed as a One launch exclusive, Crimson Dragon's visuals failed to deliver - a fault only exacerbated by Crytek's gloriously detailed Ryse: Son of Rome - and its Kinect-only control scheme scrapped in favour of traditional gamepad controls.

The latter was functional at best and, coupled with its bland, repetitive mission structure, saw to Crimson Dragon's swift death.


16. Ryse: Son Of Rome

ryse son of rome
Crytek

Ryse: Son of Rome was supposed to be a surefire early success for the Xbox One, lord knows it had all the necessary ingredients. Visceral combat, a medieval setting, gorgeous visuals and a renowned studio to tie them all together, this was the type of launch title that would singlehandedly push hardware sales. Or so Microsoft thought.

In reality, Ryse, besides the undisputed next-gen sheen, bore none of the features expected from a next-gen jump in technical opportunity. The context-sensitive combat promoting severance of limbs from Marius' enemies was a short-lived indulgence that dulled faster than his blade and the campaign, Ryse's only major component, was over in less than a solid afternoon of play.

Alternatively, you could have gone out and picked up a copy of Ridley Scott's Gladiator for a fraction of Ryse's asking price and been entertained for longer.


15. ReCore

Recore 2016
Microsoft Studios

So much promise accompanied ReCore's reveal on-stage at Microsoft's 2015 E3 opener. Boasting collaboration between Comcept and Armature Studio, the former headed by Mega Man creator Keiji Inafune and the latter by designers with Metroid Prime on their portfolio, the pairing promised to be a match made in heaven.

A game featuring precision platforming, meaningful exploration and deftly designed characters is what was expected of Joule's struggle for survival in a post-apocalyptic world and, to some degree, that's what was received. Conceptually, ReCore ticked every box but in practice, the division of labour and development prevented each of its individual elements from meshing well.

That, coupled with horrendous technical difficulties and an inexperienced approach to combat sullied ReCore's reputation before it was ever given the chance to impress.


14. Super Lucky's Tale

Super Lucky S Tale
Playful

As a throwback to the golden age of 3D platformers, Super Lucky's Tale ticks all of the boxes that Banjo, Crash, Mario and Croc managed many moons ago, and that's the problem.

Modern revolutionaries like Super Mario Odyssey and Fez have pushed the envelope of expectations for the once-modest platformer, so much so that Playful Corp's sequel looks to have time-travelled from antiquity by comparison.

From start to finish, Lucky's adventure amounts to an afternoon of solid entertainment, but it's a vapid one with a narrow appeal that Microsoft should never have primed as a launch exclusive to promote the One X.


13. Sea Of Thieves

sea of thieves
Rare

Had Rare been fortunate enough to develop Sea of Thieves in a climate where Xbox One owners were bracing a tidal wave of exclusives, perhaps it would have had more time to populate its open world privateering adventure with more things to see and do, but sadly, it didn't have that luxury.

The result of its obviously hurried launch was a game that felt severely malnourished after the first few novelty-filled hours wore off and it's truly a crying shame because what Rare managed to finalise for launch was fantastic.

Piloting your own vessel with a crew of mates, plundering islands and sunken wrecks of their riches, fighting off competing crews: Rare proved it still had the chops to pull off a triple-A experience but couldn't quite manage to capitalize on Sea of Thieves' potential.

Free post-launch content has packed more meat on the game's bones, but it's still a long ways out from feeling like a finished product.


12. State Of Decay 2

State Of Decay 2
Microsoft

Another exclusive indirectly affected by Microsoft's inability to maintain pace with Sony on the exclusives front, Undead Labs' return visit to zombie survivor series State of Decay delivered on its promise of a more complete, refined version of the original, but that wasn't enough.

Unfairly so, Microsoft primed the sequel as a must-have first-party title to sit alongside the Xbox One's modest library of triple-A exclusives, a misconception that gave rise to unreachable expectations.

State of Decay 2, like its predecessor, struggled to stamp out technical hitches and bugs, but for genre enthusiasts able to look past its issues, the much-requested addition of multiplayer and a satisfying if simplistic combat system provided hours upon hours of undead-slaying entertainment.

There's no excusing technical issues, but State of Decay 2 isn't and never was meant to be a multi-million dollar budget game. At heart, it's an indie title and a mighty fine one at that.


11. Quantum Break

quantum break
Remedy

Continuing its partnership with Microsoft off the back of oft-overlooked action-adventure thriller Alan Wake, Remedy, tasked with cooking up a new intellectual property for the Xbox One rather than a sequel to its Stephen King homage, settled on another third-person affair, this time with a twist.

By no means did it reinvent the wheel of its respective genre, but what Quantum Break did do, was deliver a well-made exclusive with a palatable story and excellent gunplay complimented by impactful time-manipulating abilities and mechanics.

As for the tie-in live-action TV series, it was a commendable effort on Lifeboat Productions' behalf, but an ultimately unnecessary component that would have far better served Jack Joyce's story as a standalone series, rather than sandwiched between game time.


10. Dead Rising 3

Dead Rising 3
Capcom

Dead Rising 3 is exactly the type of game a platform holder wants to have available on New Console Launch Day. Accessible to casual and hardcore audiences alike, a (semi) open world packed with pop culture's favourite monster and an endless number of wacky tools with which to slay them, what else could anyone ask for?

Without a doubt, Nick's story made little more than a lick of sense and was a monumental mess of ideas from start to finish, but mucking through the streets of the fictional Californian town of Los Perdidos on motorbike-powered steam rollers while wearing a lightning-spewing mask themed after Street Fighter's Blanka is all the indication anyone needed that seriousness was the last item of importance on Dead Rising 3's agenda.

That, coupled with the least-restrictive multiplayer mode the series has enjoyed to date made questing for and subsequently building the next weapon of surreal destruction together with a friend an absolute blast.

More Dead Rising 3; less 4 for any potential future sequels please, Capcom.


9. Halo Wars 2

halo wars 2 atriox
Microsoft

Real-time strategy will never feel as intuitive to play on console as on PC, but Halo Wars 2 comes closest to making the formula work without falt, thanks in no small part to the efforts of Creative Assembly.

The studio, most known for its long-running Total War franchise, took time out of its busy schedule to work in tandem with Halo vanguard 343 Industries to craft a sequel to the series' first RTS outing, the former handling gameplay, the latter all things story and sheen.

The result, while far from perfect, is a well-built, feature-packed and welcome addition to the Halo mythos, despite the campaigns muddled, anticlimactic ending. If nothing else, the entire package proves that, with the right experience and pedigree, that real-time strategy can work when piloted with a gamepad.


8. Sunset Overdrive

Sunset Overdrive
Insomniac Games

Earning recognition for genuinely funny writing (especially in video games) is a rarity. That Insomniac managed to pull off just that with its contemporary satire on gaming culture is no mean feat in itself, but that, coupled with its terrific art design and gameplay make Sunset Overdrive an oft-overlooked Xbox exclusive worth the time investment.

Inspired in no small part by Sega's cult classic Jet Set Radio and other street sports a la Tony Hawk's Pro Skater series, there's simply too much to love in Sunset Overdrive's fluid, fast-paced gameplay to let its throwaway story and uninspired quest design ruin the fun.

Based on its strongest assets alone, it's clear as day, why Sony opted to hand the Spider-Man gig to Insomniac and in lieu of that game's release, it unequivocally made the right choice.


7. Halo 5: Guardians & Master Chief Collection

Halo 5 guardians
343 Industries

Master Chief has had a rocky relationship with the Xbox One. The Master Chief Collection, meant as a commemorative pre-meal appetizer for the upcoming Halo 5, united all of the Spartan's past triumphs under one banner with the aim of providing the ultimate suite of multiplayer options past and present.

343 Industries achieved exactly that on launch in 2014, though the celebrations quickly turned to protest when it emerged that the compendium's matchmaking system was borderline broken. 343 later fixed the issues, apologised profusely for the upset and doubled down on ensuring Halo 5's launch went off without a hitch.

As luck would have it, Guardians was lauded as a technical achievement upon release a year later, catapulting Master Chief into true next-gen with stunning visuals and solid performance, though garnered almost universal derision for its poorly written, regressive story.

As for multiplayer, it was and remains to be one of the most feature-rich online shooters of this generation, filled to the brim with modes, weapons, maps and (earnable in-game) cosmetics.


6. Gears Of War 4 & Ultimate Edition

Gears Of War 4
Microsoft

Mimicking the uncertainty that befell Halo when Bungie retired its relationship with Microsoft, Epic Games, too, desired to move out of the publisher's shadow and begin anew.

Gears of Wars' fate looked grim in light of the split until Microsoft acquired the series' rights from Epic, rebranded Black Tusk Studio as The Coalition to lead Gears of War 4's development and placed Rod Fergusson, former Epic employee and lead designer of past Gears titles, at its head.

The promising setup inevitably resulted in a sequel worthy of its title, featuring a new threat and generation of characters to carry the torch as humanity's protectors. Yes, The Coalition could absolutely have taken more risks with its soft reboot, but as the first entry in a new trilogy, nobody can blame the studio for playing it safe for the initial transition.

Gears 4 provided a perfect balance of old vs. new, but the sequel will need to shift in favour of the latter if its to continue that strong initial momentum.


5. Killer Instinct

Killer instinct
Microsoft

Eyebrows were prompted to raise in scepticism when Microsoft announced Killer Instinct and its unorthodox content delivery model. The fear was, given its free-to-play core and intended delivery of paid seasonal DLC, that getting the reboot of Rare's brawler into a 'finished state' could take years or, due to unforeseeable circumstances, not achieve that milestone at all.

What was present in-game from day one was fantastic. Jago, Sabrewulf, Orchid and others had been christened in three-dimensional glory, combos were crazy but accessible in tandem and a deep-voiced announcer screamed his head off whenever anything remotely impressive unfolded on-screen.

Following developer Double Helix's departure, Killer Instinct's future was left in jeopardy, but fears were promptly calmed when Microsoft brought Iron Galaxy on board to keep the ball rolling with new characters, modes and the like

Today, boasting a healthy roster, tournament scene and a devoted fan base, Killer Instinct has flourished from humble beginnings to a cornerstone of the Xbox family.


4. Forza Motorsport (Series)

Forza Motorsport 7
Microsoft

Turn 10 made some poor choices for the latest entry in its semi-sim racing series, but it'd be unfair to let that mar an otherwise important member of the Xbox family.

Where Driveclub, Gran Turismo and The Crew have only damaged the appeal of the genre in recent years, Forza Motorsport has been its saviour, supplying wish-fulfilment to the masses who want nothing more than to whittle away the early hours tweaking a multi-million dollar supercar to their liking and then taking it to the track to blaze a trail.

Clinical and devoid of personality have been persistent criticisms of Turn 10's obvious passion, one that it answered with the christening of Playground Games' spin-off, arcadey Horizon series.

Between them both, Forza has the market cornered, and deservedly so. It'll be a long time yet, until another competitor has even a chance of dethroning Forza from its throne.


3. Cuphead

the devil cuphead
Studio MDHR

Developers trumpeting difficulty as a core component of their game is a surefire way to attract hardcore attention but without proper integration, that challenge is frivolous and frustrating, not rewarding. This generation, but a handful of creators have achieved the oft-sought after goal of 'tough but fair.'

From Software's lauded Dark Souls series is one; Cuphead is another. Balls of steel are required to guide Studio MDHR's titular hero to a face-off against Satan to earn his soul back, a process that rewards persistence through trial and error and muscle memory. Never does death in Cuphead feel cheap or unwarranted, but a result of the player's own inadequacies. When victory arrives (and it will), the dopamine rush is palpable.

Replaying that one fight you've been stuck on for hours on end can, of course, start to grate, but the frustration is near-to non-existent in Cuphead thanks to its sensational hand-drawn aesthetic homage to 1930s cartoons.

Truly wonderful.


2. Ori & The Blind Forest

Ori and the Blind Forest
Microsoft

In a mechanical sense, Ori & The Blind Forest does little that hasn't been seen before in hundreds of other 'Metroidvania' style games: what makes Moon Studios' own entry in the genre a perfect specimen is the components wholly attributable to its talented team of artists, writers and composers.

Gameplay does have its own little unique nuances, of course, in the form of the simple yet brilliant 'Soul Links' checkpoint system, but it's Ori's orchestral score, impossibly beautiful environments and coming-of-age story that leave the strongest lasting impressions.

If not already, Xbox owners new and old owe it to themselves to experience Moon Studio's labour of love. Especially so, now that a sequel is on course to land in 2019.


1. Forza Horizon (Series)

Forza Horizon 4
Playground Games

Just when we thought Playground Games couldn't better itself following 2016's open-world road trip Down Under, Turn 10's sister studio has pulled another win out the bag with the fourth entry in Forza's spin-off series, although at this point, that label is a little disingenuous.

Motorsport and Horizon now stand toe-to-toe in terms of popularity and success, but it's the latter series that appears to have the edge now, what with Forza Horizon 4 now confirmed to be the fastest-selling entry in the series to date, and rightfully so.

Joining the Horizon Festival in its move from Australia to the UK is a seamless multiplayer system, more cars than you'll find in a billionaire's garage and the headliner: dynamic seasons (good luck attempting to plough through winter snowdrifts with your shiny new supercar) that rotate on a weekly in-game basis that drastically change the way you play.

The real British countryside may be devoid of anything but fields and cattle, but you'll never go wanting for things to see and do in Playground Games' version.


Contributor
Contributor

Joe is a freelance games journalist who, while not spending every waking minute selling himself to websites around the world, spends his free time writing. Most of it makes no sense, but when it does, he treats each article as if it were his Magnum Opus - with varying results.