Red Dead Redemption 2: 15 Disturbing Secrets & Locations You Totally Missed

3. Arthur's Lost Night

Okay, so this is probably the most devastating secret in this entire list. Continuing to prove that going into random shacks is a recipe for disaster, you can find one in Lemoyne that manages to be incredibly disturbing without actually showing anything.

Initially it looks completely rundown, but there'll be a man sitting outside who invites you in for some food. If you follow him in, he'll knock you out, and as you lose consciousness you can hear him throw you onto the bed, with the sound effects and sinister overtones all pointing towards the stranger sexually assaulting Arthur while he's out cold. After being dumped back out in the wild, the character lets out a bewildered "oh my lord."

Now, you don't actually see anything happen, and if you accidentally stumbled into the shack you might want to pretend nothing actually did, but it's heavily implied that's not the case. My advice? Head straight back and throw him to the 'gators.