Shantae: All Games & DLC Ranked Worst To Best
Which is the best Shantae game?
Shantae is in this weird limbo of being popular yet not quite a household name. She got into Smash as a spirit and a Mii costume, but not as a fighter because she's well known, just not that well known.
Opinions on the series are divided as well. Some view the games as masterful Metroidvanias with great writing and even better gameplay; others view them as those weird titles where nobody wears much clothes. It makes sense that not everybody is a fan of the series, everything is a bit over-sexualised and not all of the entries are exactly masterpieces.
Now, no Shantae game is downright bad, you could probably pick up any entry and find something to enjoy but there is definitely a huge quality difference between the best games in the series and the worst.
So let's rank the games and DLC so those new to Shantae know where to start, and those who have played them can get mad at me for being wrong.
Oh, and if you want to get into the series then it's actually pretty easy as most of them are on every modern console, especially on the Switch where all five titles are available.
9. Shantae: Half-Genie Hero - Jammies Mode
The DLC for Shantae: Half-Genie Hero in general is very hit-or-miss. They're all somewhat let down by the fact that they all tread the same ground as the base game yet at least some of them are fun alternative ways to experience it again.
Unfortunately, the free Jammies Mode DLC for Shantae: Half-Genie Hero isn't that. Jammies Mode is just playing the main game again but now it's boring.
You take more damage which you think would lead to this being a harder alternative to the main game but you also have the ability to fly over enemies right from the start so a lot of the campaign is a breeze, a really boring breeze. But then there will be a giant difficulty spike like the chase section with Wilbur which I swear is impossible in this.
At least the campaign is free. It's one of two free campaigns that have been added to the game since launch with the other being Hardcore Mode which won't be covered as it's just a difficulty option.
8. Shantae: Half-Genie Hero - Friends To The End
The Friends to the End DLC for Shantae: Half-Genie Hero has promise. You get to play as Sky, Bolo, and Rottytops, three of the best characters in the series. You also get to know what happened during that weird out of place moment in the base game where Shantae turns evil for two seconds. It turns out that she was cured when her friends entered her mind to tell her to be good again.
It does what any good midquel should do by exploring a different perspective of the previous story. It's the gameplay that really lets Friends to the End down.
You can switch between the three characters whenever you want and they all essentially have one ability of interest. Rottytops can throw her head, wherever it lands she will appear, Sky can create platforms, and Bolo can use a grappling hook.
The game lacks any flow because of this. Instead of chaining interesting moves together, you're doing one uninteresting move before switching characters to do another uninteresting move, all really slowly.
7. Shantae And The Seven Sirens
The latest entry in the series as of writing, Shantae and the Seven Sirens is the definition of mediocrity. It doesn't feel like anybody wanted to make this, it looks like the developers over at WayForward just decided to make another Shantae game because they sell well enough nowadays.
Shantae And The Seven Sirens is functional but almost every environment looks the same, nothing interesting happens, and the game is way too easy. Also, any good ideas that are here are really underdeveloped.
The introduction to a ton of new half-genies could have been cool if we spent any time with them.
The instant transformations are a really cool idea. It manages to mesh the wacky forms of most Shantae games with the fast-paced gameplay that doesn't require stopping to dance from Shantae and the Pirate's Curse yet there are so few of them. Also, two of the five forms feel nearly identical with the Sea Frog and the Gastro Drill basically doing the same thing.
The ability to gain skills from enemies is really cool but most of the powers are so inconsequential that the novelty wears off quickly.
The game has some underutilised albeit good ideas and some really well-made cutscenes, that's about all the praise you can give to this entry.
6. Shantae: Half-Genie Hero - Costume Pack
In the Costume Pack DLC for Shantae: Half-Genie Hero you play through three different campaigns each with their own stories and gameplay styles. The thing is, these campaigns weren't created equally.
Ninja Mode tasks Shantae with becoming a master ninja. The gameplay here is a lot of fun as you're dashing around, wall jumping and throwing shurikens at foes.
If Beach Mode was sold as its own DLC then the title would be at the bottom of this list. You have to play through the levels of the main game in search of the perfect place to tan, the problem is the sun is constantly burning you so unless you're frequently collecting sunscreen you're going to die pretty quickly. This is alright until you get to boss fights where it becomes nearly impossible. It's like Jammies Mode but your health is always at risk of depleting. Beach Mode sucks.
Officer Mode is a crossover with another WayForward property Mighty Switch Force! and is easily the best of the three campaigns included here. You get a gun but also the ability to switch which blocks are pushed in and therefore can be walked on and which ones are simply in the background. This leads to a lot of fun platforming and puzzles.
5. Shantae: Risky's Revenge
In Shantae: Risky's Revenge you must explore Sequin Land to find the three magic seals which contain the power of a lamp that Risky Boots stole at the beginning of the game. After acquiring the lamps magic you fight Risky and the game just ends with Shantae losing her powers.
Risky's Revenge just doesn't feel complete. There are only three dungeons here and one is an enemy gauntlet. Who sets out to just put two and a half dungeons in their game?
That's not saying short games are bad, most Shantae titles are short, it's just that this is the only entry to actually feel unfinished, being a complete downgrade from its predecessor in everything but the art, most sequels try to add more.
The title's release is much more interesting than the game itself as it was released as DSiWare and is widely regarded as the best title on the service although there isn't much competition. Of course, this isn't the only place where you can experience this game as the director's cut was made and ported to basically everything.
The director's cut adds a magic mode that allows you to play with more magic but take more damage as a consequence.
4. Shantae: Half-Genie Hero - Pirate Queen's Quest
Pirate Queen's Quest is easily the best piece of DLC for Shantae: Half-Genie Hero. It's a return to the excellent pirate gear gameplay from Shantae and the Pirate's Curse, what's not to love?
Well, the fact that some of the level design from Half-Genie Hero hasn't been altered enough to fit with the much most fast-paced gameplay that the pirate gear offers you.
When you get to a bit of level that you know has been truly modified enough to fit the gameplay of this DLC then it's the most fun you can have in the entirety of Half-Genie Hero. The problem is there are just enough moments where the gameplay doesn't feel like it belongs, to make the base game feel like a slightly better experience.
It is cool playing as Risky Boots whilst she navigates Sequin Land to find what she needs to upgrade the Dynamo machine, the DLC just could have been better. What this really highlights is the fact that a spin-off Risky Boots title would probably work really well. Come on WayForward, make it happen.
3. Shantae: Half-Genie Hero
If you want to know what Shantae is all about then Shantae: Half-Genie Hero is a great option. Every level in it essentially tells a short story that helps you understand Shantae and her rogue's gallery, with someone new from a previous game being the antagonist in almost every level.
And the levels that house these stories are mostly great.
Scuttle Town is a good enough starting location which is slightly underwhelming due to the fact that almost every Shantae game starts off there. Mermaid Falls is a fun albeit slightly disturbing location. Tassel Town is one of the more detailed levels in the game. Cape Crustacean is a fun chapter where you must platform during the middle of a magic carpet race. Finally, Hypno Baron's Castle is a cool final area.
The gameplay here is good as well, it makes the transformation dancing that the series is famous for almost instantaneous, it's still not perfect as there's still a small delay which stops the gameplay from feeling as smooth as it could.
2. Shantae
Most of the time a video game franchises first entry is the weakest. It's normally the game where the developers are still working out the identity of the series and there's not an initial entry to build off of yet. Despite this, the first Shantae manages to be one of the best in the entire franchise.
For a start the game has one of the best worlds in the entire series, it's much bigger than most of the subsequent entries and has a focus on exploration that the likes of Seven Sirens and Risky's Revenge can only dream of.
The story is simple yet the characters are all here out of the gate just as charming as they are in every subsequent game. More importantly, the gameplay here is really fun, yeah it's built upon in later entries but it's still a good time here.
That's not even to mention the fact that this is one of, if not the best looking Game Boy Colour game ever made. Tell somebody who hasn't heard of the series that this is a Game Boy Advance title and they wouldn't question it.
1. Shantae And The Pirate's Curse
Whilst the likes of the original Shantae and Half-Genie Hero are great games they're nothing in comparison to Shantae and the Pirate's Curse. Pirate's Curse isn't just the best Shantae game, it's one of the best 2D platformers in general.
The first two entries had the problem of Shantae's animal dances. Because of this, you would often have to stop to do a little dance to progress, completely killing the pace. However, in Pirate's Curse, Shantae must move around with the new pirate gear which is just infinitely better.
Chaining together the pirate gear is just so much fun and you don't need to stop at all. For example, you get the likes of the Pirate Hat which lets you glide across long distances and the Cannon which allows you to shoot a projectile below you, pushing you into the air. You can chain these two moves together to stay in the air for a long time. It's a lot of fun and one of the many ways the pirate gear works together.
It's also got the best pixel-art of the entire series, the best levels, and the best soundtrack. The only reason you might not want to start here is because it makes every other entry slightly disappointing in comparison.