Star Wars Battlefront 2: 9 Reasons It's A Massive Disappointment

"The best Star Wars game of all time", to 2017's biggest disaster.

star wars Battlefront 2 Iden Versio
EA

It goes without saying that Battlefront 2 is fast-becoming 2017's biggest gaming disaster.

From a sheer "hype-translated-into-launch-day-reactions" metric, you'll actively struggle to find anyone saying anything positive, with the general reception focusing on the egregious and predatory loot system, or laggy servers stopping even those who have no problem with it having any fun.

Indeed, the reaction to a property like Star Wars being riddled with what is genuinely a free-to-play mobile framework inside a full price retail game has tipped the scales. We've seen everyone from Belgium's own Gaming Commission investigate the game for child gambling, to Hawaii's representatives also label Battlefront a "Star Wars-themed online casino".

Latest developments include a straight-up boycott of the game despite Black Friday discounts, and EA's comments on Reddit being the most downvoted of all time have only given way to a mob mentality ripping the game to shreds.

It's a mess of 'Han shot first' proportions, but the question remains: What is Battlefront 2 like, day to day, now that EA are attempting to make regular fixes?

Is the campaign worthwhile? Does the loot grind really get in the way? Fundamentally, is Star Wars Battlefront 2 as bad as they say?

Well... erm, yes.


9. The Campaign Marketing Was A Lie

Battlefront Iden Del
EA

How to Squander Your Biggest Selling Point, by EA & DICE

Regardless of your political leanings, nothing is ever gained by removing the idea of conversation and empathy. The notion that there is one fundamental "right way to be" is always flawed, and though Star Wars is of course aimed at a younger demographic, the fact writers Mitch Dyer and Walt Williams wanted to explore the Empire/Imperialistic side of the galaxy was extremely interesting, to say the least.

Would we glean a greater understanding for the common stormtrooper, brainwashed or otherwise convinced that stampeding across the galaxy was for the greater good? How about paralleling into just how fractured the west is right now, what with left vs. right ideologies forever refusing to cooperate?

Could "just a Star Wars video game campaign" fundamentally make us more empathetic of the "enemy", retroactively enhancing the mythology by building on the conversations Rogue One started as to how the Rebel Alliance aren't as "pure" as we once thought?

Nope. Iden Versio decides the Empire are abjectly evil after only a couple missions, slaughtering all her fellow friends, officers and companions in a blaze of AT-AT-hijacked glory, becoming a trusted rebel fighter immediately after.

What a monumental wasted opportunity, and one that directly contradicts the entire reason this campaign looked so unique.


8. General Movement & Feel Is Nerfed To Incentivise The Loot Grind

Star wars battlefront 2
EA

2015's Battlefront wasn't the most lightning-fast thing - its movement not competing with the highs of Titanfall 2, the snappiness of COD or the eye-meltingly sublime speed of DOOM. However, it was responsive - your characters moved when you pushed the analogue stick, for example.

In BF2, to assumedly manufacture a sense of progression, starting characters/players feel awful to control on the battlefield. Movement is sluggish, with your avatar taking just that split second too long to get off the blocks - a start contrast to how DICE's other shooters operate, where you're usually able to leap into the fray in seconds.

This extends to ship combat too, where until you've unlocked and upgraded "+2% turning circle" on an X-Wing or TIE Fighter (both real cards, by the way), the basics of movement are flawed and off-putting.

Ultimately this results in encounters where - on a fundamental level - it's no fun to engage the enemy. On foot you're piloting a sluggish, half-asleep soldiers into encounters where even then, your tactical options are limited to a dodge roll or holding the triggers to fire.

It's supremely limited, and all of the above is compounded by the fact that...


7. Multiplayer Feels Incredibly Unbalanced

star wars battlefront 2
EA

Again, on a fundamental level, if you're playing a game where players are going to be fighting one another - i.e. there's a competitive element - you cannot, I repeat cannot have a system where progression is routed to blind boxes.

Removing the microtransaction model and reducing prices doesn't get around the fact that 1. Many players already bought their way to the top before these were removed, and 2. Every time you're taken out, the game shows you which mods the enemy killed you with.

It's supposed to incentivise getting lost in the loot system, but said system is literally just pulling a slot machine lever - there's no way to spec towards an individual card outside of obtaining enough crafting components to buy one. And of course, crafting components are themselves doled out randomly.

Your best bet is to focus on "Kill 50 enemy"-style goals to unlock better weapons, but again, when you have a multiplayer that at its core, features players fighting with a completely scattershot set of mods and add-ons, the takeaway feeling is one big crapshoot.

Oh, and that's not to mention...


6. Skill Literally Doesn't Matter Online

Star wars battlefront 2
EA

Almost like some existential desert island comment on "why we game", Battlefront II's doling out of crystals happens regardless of your position on the leaderboard - as if DICE are asking "Are a game's mechanics fundamentally enough? Do you need that biscuit or is a pat on the head enough?!"

I can get behind the discussion for sure - and Rocket League proves that mechanics alone can carry you to the revenue heavens - but here's the thing: Players have already broken BF2's progression.

Literally by tying a couple of elastic bands to the analogue sticks (ensuring you don't get kicked for being idle), many are racking up the points. The game automatically puts you in another match, and as you get a fraction of a percent more crystals based on leaderboard placement, there's no incentive - or reason - to, well, play the game.

I love the idea that gamers are essentially saying to EA, "Oh, so all that matters is the loot grind? Fine then, we'll break the experience and dwindle your player base through sheer annoyance as no one plays the objective."

Childish, yes, but this also forces EA and DICE to acknowledge that yet again, they've released something completely broken.

Last thing about the loot grind...


5. The Loot Grind Isn't Remotely Rewarding

Star Wars Battlefront 2 Loot
EA

Here's the elephant in the room comment: Loot grinds aren't fundamentally flawed as a 'thing' in video games.

Diablo III certainly built a reputation for having a phenomenal one, and although Overwatch is getting a lot of flak for "popularising" the idea (with the reality being that it originated in the 2000s), the old "let's take a spin and see what you get!" mentality is a satisfying one.

Though, it hinges entirely on the rewards being worthwhile.

Like some spin-the-wheel gameshow where all the prizes are take-home paperweights, Battlefront 2's array of items, taunts, victory poses and incremental mechanical tweaks are just... lame. The various victory poses are but the most minor differentiation in arm movement or perhaps a more slack posture, and then you've got increased explosion radius' for grenades, damage boosts, turning circle enhancements for vehicles.

It's tragic.

If you're going to do a loot grind, players most likely won't argue it's fun on some level, but you have to nail the rewards on the other end. This is part n' parcel of why Battlefront 2 is kicking up a stink - even those who've stuck with it are getting shafted.


4. Not All Faces Are Created Equal...

Star Wars Battlefront 2 Luke Han
EA

Yes, that's Han Solo on the right.

I know.

That's also Luke on the left, despite him looking like a WWE game's create-a-wrestler version of Mark Hamill, rather than the real deal.

Now, I've heard conspiracies regarding the idea that if DICE rendered the main cast with just a slightly "left of centre" (let's say) appearance, they wouldn't have to shell out the requisite funds to the estates of Hamill, Han Solo etc. However, characters like Leia, Lando and Rey look spot on (Billie Dee Williams and Daisy Ridley even reprise their roles for the latter two), leading me to believe that it's more just a mistake on DICE's part.

Thankfully, the heroes' appearances across the campaign are saved by better writing. There's a great "May the Force be with you" moment for Luke that has greater ramifications for the wider mythos once you connect the dots between Inferno Squad member Del's meeting with Skywalker and the Battle of Jakku, it's just a shame they couldn't nail everyone across the board.


3. Lightsaber Combat Feels Terrible

Star Wars Battlefront 2
EA

Less Rogue One's corridor massacre and more 2006's Star Wars Kid, wielding a lightsaber in any Star Wars game should feel like wielding cinema history. The Kyber crystal-powered blades of pure, crackling energy are meant to turn the tide of battle with every slice - their hum encapsulating the feeling of untapped potential waiting to explode.

Sometimes this comes through online as you manage to drop into a bout as a Hero or Villain and can set about carving your name through enemy forces - but the majority of the time you're left aimlessly flailing and reorienting the camera as an attack positions you in the worst possible place for a followup strike.

Overshooting enemies, not having any sense of impact or contact - piloting Yoda around is about as fun as precision-attacking people with a bouncing ball, as even the steely death-stare of Darth Maul is offset by lunges breaking up otherwise satisfying chain-killing.

In many ways, retaining the same FPS control scheme makes sense when you switch over, but the reality of play is that your own love of these characters has to paper over what otherwise feels like a far too sporadic animation system.


2. Campaign Doesn't Remotely Make Use Of Some Furtive Plot Territory

Battlefront 2 First Order
EA

"It's set between Episode VI and VII!" they cried, showing us highlight reels of Endor right next to Starkiller Base.

"And we've got this new character, Iden Versio!", the perfect addition to a 30 year gap in the chronology that many additional comics and novels have already began to fill up.

The assumption was that we'd get a character whose life spanned that substantial period, exploring what it's like to lose a leader and an icon in Emperor Palpatine, before exploring the true nature of the Empire vs. the Rebellion - perhaps delving into the nature of the Force, Jediism and oh, I dunno, Kylo Ren's birth, along the way.

Sadly, Battlefront takes the easiest possible way through this "time period", having 99% of its levels set directly after Return of the Jedi, before an almost hilarious, "Many Decades Later" pops up and we resume action just before The Force Awakens.

We completely skip over the formation of the First Order and the dissolution of the Rebel Alliance, Luke deciding to become a teacher or Han cutting himself off from fatherhood, instead going from the Battle of Jakku, right through to Kylo in full on Force Awakens garb, mind-reading people for information in relation to Lord San Tekka.

Needless to say, Disney are most likely saving all these years to fill in with movies for the rest of time, but all the same - the campaign was marketed as being in this time period, yet it only creates bookends with mostly forgettable information.

Even worse...


1. Story Is Incredibly Short, But Won't Conclude Until The Last Jedi Releases

Star Wars battlefront 2
EA

Of course, being Battlefront 2 is all about the online multiplayer and loot grind, its campaign is incredibly short - designed more as an elaborate tutorial with some awesome fan service, rather than a standalone, recommendable experience.

However, even with that rationale, a paltry 4-6 hours is over before you know it. All the heroes only appear for one mission a piece, and then you have the "Decades Later..." jump, and a cliffhanger ending tells everyone to wait until December 13th for the actual resolution.

Now, in theory this could be because Iden's story relates to something in The Last Jedi and Disney don't want that information getting out too early. We know Inferno Squad chap Del and Luke Skywalker are friends, after all, so it's possible that a disillusioned Luke finds the time to help him and Iden out before leaving for Ahch-To.

Buuut, I doubt it.

And why? Because Battlefront 2's story climax is dropping two days before the movie. If the mandate is to keep all spoilers contained until one of the most anticipated movies of all time is out, EA wouldn't be given the green light to spill the beans beforehand.

No, I'm calling this needless, manufactured "hype building" designed to lock-step Battlefront 2's ongoing conversations with that of The Last Jedi, creating one big maelstrom of Star Wars goodness.

It would've worked too, if not for the greed of the EAmpire ruining everything...


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.