The Best Nintendo Game Every Year 1983 - 2024

12. 2013 - Super Mario 3D World

Super Mario 3D World
Nintendo

Nintendo posited 2013 as the Year of Luigi so it’s some kind of hilarious irony that even still he got overshadowed. 

This year saw the release of the Wii U’s highest-rated, second-best-selling game (behind Mario Kart 8) and one that - despite launching on a console with a limited audience - smashed Mario’s previous sales records. 

Super Mario 3D World was the follow-up to 2011’s 3DS title and whilst it didn’t make great use of the Wii U’s gimmicks, it certainly felt like the full-fat version of what 3D Land had offered on handheld. Now, players could race through the Mushroom Kingdom in teams of up to four. This was the big appeal - something akin to classic Mario that was playable with friends, simultaneously, for the first time. 

This made for cooperative but, more importantly, competitive chaos as Nintendo knew all too well how players get when the chance to outperform friends presents itself. The game’s “crown” mechanic of giving the highest-scoring player visible bragging rights drove groups to put more and more time into the game.

Super Mario 3D World also gave us the introduction of Captain Toad and his isometric adventures and Cat Mario - a costume so popular it showed up in the 2022 Mario movie. With great stages and plenty of content, it was the perfect blend of new and old and one of Mario’s greatest outings.


11. 2014 - Shovel Knight

Shovel Knight
Yacht Club

Most people forget that in terms of exclusives, Shovel Knight dropped onto the Wii U the same day that it made its PC debut - 10 months ahead of any other console.

Very rarely do indie games blow up to the point of consideration for Game of the Year but Shovel Knight was such a moreish package. What made Shovel Knight so brilliant was that it wasn’t ripping a specific 80s classic off wholesale. Instead, it was an amalgamation of several of the games at the top of this list and their contemporaries: Mega Man, Castlevania, Zelda II, Ninja Gaiden and Super Mario Bros 3. 

This attracted older fans who connected with familiar elements but found something fresh, which was also something that appealed to younger gamers. They might not have the touchstones of the NES games, but certainly recognised the level of challenge and the mechanic of dropping currency and having to reclaim it or risk losing it forever from the likes of Dark Souls.

The final part of this ingenious recipe was wholly unique mechanics, such as being able to smash your own checkpoints for treasure at the risk of replaying more of a stage. 

Whilst many were beginning to stumble on the slippery slope of microtransactions, long installs and bloated open worlds; Shovel Knight was a reminder that video games are just supposed to feel good to play.


10. 2015 - Splatoon

splatoon game
Nintendo

You can never tell what Nintendo are going to do with new IP yet nearly a decade later it’s hard to parse if Splatoon was a wild surprise or a surprisingly tame addition to Ninty’s catalogue, at least from a genre perspective. With dwindling third-party support, the company tried their own spin on a team-based online shooter.

And whilst this made all the sense in the world, it's unlikely anybody had “squids that are also kids shooting coloured ink all over oil rigs to mark their territory” on their bingo card. However, it's zany approach really made Splatoon a feature title of the Wii U. The chaotic team-based fun of fighting for control by painting the scenery more than trying to snipe your foes was delightful.

It also made simple but effective use of the GamePad, showing players a top-down map of the arena to see where their presence (and ink) was needed, as well as allowing them to quickly super-jump from place to place with a touch of the screen.

One of the best things about Splatoon was that it was a great representation of Nintendo’s ability to support a game after release, something that they hadn’t been asked to do a lot of in the past. Like many games, Splatoon only got better with time, tweaks and more content.


9. 2016 - Pokkén Tournament

pokken tournament
Nintendo

It was clear early on that the Wii U was going to be a rough generation for the company to turn around but 2016 was a dud across both of Nintendo’s consoles; giving us a bad Paper Mario, a disappointing Star Fox and a divisive Pokémon generation in Sun and Moon.

Thank goodness for the anticipated home console release of Pokkén Tournament, the fighting game that pit the likes of Mewtwo and Lucario against Pikachu in a mask and a sentient chandelier. 

Like traditional Pokémon gameplay, Pokkén was on the surface a game of rock/paper/scissors whilst also being deceptively complex. More than just trying to outfox your opponent's choice of attack style; there was making use of the two different phases of battle, a diverse move pool and a choice of support Pokémon. Battles looked good as they felt and it was cool to see classic monsters actually getting into a proper scrap.

Whilst Nintendo’s slow embrace of online play was where Pokkén tended to live best, it was unfortunately lacking content elsewhere. Despite a Switch rerelease, Pokkén feels all but forgotten, which is a shame because it added something unique to a franchise that is often very sweet and twee.

And that something was beating Pikachu into a fine, yellow paste.


8. 2017 - The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild

Breath of the Wild Open World
Nintendo

The darkest days of the Wii U were finally behind us. A new dawn had begun. In 2017, the Nintendo Switch arrived and put Nintendo back front and centre. With the console dropping in March, it had plenty of time to bolster its catalogue and make it a must-buy for the Christmas period with Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, Mario Odyssey and its industry-shaking Zelda launch title.

In many ways, Breath of the Wild was a perfect way to introduce the Switch as you could play Link’s new console adventure at home and then take it with you on your own adventure (to work, to the shops, to a different room… endless possibilities). But obviously, what made the game truly great was the boldness to throw out tradition.

Zelda’s formula had gotten more tired than tired and Breath of the Wild’s laser focus on a feeling of discovery was key. Hyrule was now a wide open expanse and players were left to their own devices to conquer its enemies, environments and secrets. Landmarks and shrines in the horizon drove players forward, and physics-based puzzles made them stop and think.

The freedom of not just exploration but the approach to it would eventually be bettered by the sequel Tears of the Kingdom, but Breath of the Wild was an event that stopped gaming in its tracks.


7. 2018 - Super Smash Bros. Ultimate

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate
Nintendo

When it comes to the Most Hype Video Game Trailers Of All Time, few reach the bar that Super Smash Bros Ultimate’s reveal hit. With previous games including DLC and often guest characters from non-Nintendo property, there was always the question about whether Nintendo had secured contracts for more than one appearance. As such, when Solid Snake landed (who missing from 2014’s Smash games) and the trailer announced “everyone is here”... well, heads rolled.

And they carried on rolling for the next three years as Nintendo released more and more incredible DLC offerings like Minecraft’s Steve, Kazuya and Sora.

Super Smash Bros Ultimate deserves its flowers as a celebration of the medium we love, through the eyes of the company that has been through the most. With 89 playable characters, 115 versus stages, over 1000 pieces of music… Masahiro Sakurai’s magnum opus is a museum in game form.

It also helps that it’s also the most complete version of the gameplay with fast yet crunchy, rewarding feedback and a great escalation from casual party play to something deep and challenging for diehards. With the best campaign of the series on top of it, and the Spirit system making for an endless stream of unique battle set-ups, it wasn’t shocking that Nintendo said that the game was still one of the Switch’s most played five years later in 2023.


6. 2019 - Fire Emblem: Three Houses

Fire Emblem Three Houses
Intelligent Systems

Famously, Fire Emblem Awakening was the game that really caused the long-running strategy sim to blow up in the West and also - by extension - saved its neck from the chopping block. Ergo, its debut on the Switch needed to maintain the momentum.

And Three Houses met expectations by totally refreshing itself for the new age. Swapping out tired mechanics for something much deeper, the stakes of battles are now far greater as each unit has so much more individuality based on how you train them.

Training is part of the monastery, which houses the expanded social side of the game. This allows for greater control of the pace of the experience for both developers and players, who are rewarded for checking in with classmates rather than just bouncing from one battle to the next. This is made all the sweeter by incredible writing and voice performance, which is consistent across its gigantic cast.

With four possible major story paths and a seemingly endless amount of customisation, Three Houses is one of those perfect Switch games as it gets better the more you play. 

Fire Emblem Awakening lit a fire under the series and Three Houses cemented it as one of Nintendo’s most worthwhile properties, making sure that it’s here to stay.


5. 2020 - Animal Crossing: New Horizons

Animal Crossing Tom Nook
Nintendo

In a case of incredible timing, when the world was collectively told to stay at home and avoid human contact, Nintendo just so happened to drop their new social simulation game.

The Animal Crossing franchise is as iterative as it gets, with each game functioning largely the same as the last, and 2020’s New Horizons was no different. You shake trees, sell your fruit, buy furniture and welcome talking animals to your private island whilst paying off a non-negotiable loan with notorious tax dodger Tom Nook.

Of course, New Horizon’s most complete version of this makes for an endless drip feed of content and events, and enough variety so that when you go online to compare islands with your friends you’re guaranteed to have a good time. The relaxed, cosy pace makes it easy to lose hours every day.

We can talk about the importance of games for the industry's health until the anthropomorphic cows come home but Animal Crossing was crucial in a different way. As a sales juggernaut (especially in Japan, where it nabbed the silver for the country’s best-selling game behind the original Pokémon), you almost certainly know or, in fact, are someone who was positively affected by New Horizon’s release. 

In the face of the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Year, Animal Crossing was the perfect salve: whimsical, affable and warm.


4. 2021 - Monster Hunter Rise

Monster Hunter Rise
Capcom

Whilst Monster Hunter had been lowkey kicking ass for years, it wasn’t until 2018’s World that it truly exploded. The pressure to follow it up was immense, and the excitement among diehards for Monster Hunter returning to the Nintendo was palpable. 

The Switch had plenty of great titles, but it was missing the kind of action game that players could really sink their teeth into (or their axe, or sword, or lance, or bowgun, or glaive...)

It might seem daunting at first, but when Rise clicks it does so beautifully. The game has an incredibly gradual difficulty curve, meaning that newcomers to the series won’t even notice how far they’ve come until they look back. It also means it’s easier than ever to experiment and find your ideal weapon style, with each one intuitive to pick up and plenty of depth for those who stick with it.

Perhaps Rise’s biggest improvements come in the form of control and traversal. The Palamute mount makes everything speedy and the Wire Bug gadget offers verticality and the ability to ride enemy monsters into battle.

The Switch’s ability to go handheld might make some developers feel as though they should make their games piecemeal and easy to digest in chunks and, whilst Rise is certainly snappy, it has a mind-boggling amount of content and depth.


3. 2022 - Xenoblade Chronicles 3

Xenoblade Chronicles 3
Nintendo

If the Switch is a machine for a single franchise, it’s Xenoblade. With the announcement of X coming to the console in 2025, it’ll mean every single entry is playable in one place.

And whilst Xenoblade has remained consistently well-received, the end of the trilogy sees things out with a bang. Across the board, Chronicles 3 represents the pinnacle of Monolith Soft’s work; the stylised graphics are gorgeous, its gameplay is constantly evolving and narratively it manages to smash the worlds of the two previous games together in a satisfying way that rewards long-term fans.

Best of all is how these come together, as the story’s themes of freedom and crafting your own future absolutely apply to both the endless possibilities of the battle system and of Xenoblade going its own path. Watching the earnest first entry almost not make its way out of Japan and pave the way for a series that has become a pillar of the Switch and reach its thus-far conclusion is incredibly gratifying. Streamlined combat allows for more overall depth, and a stronger script means darker and more touching moments.

Xenoblade Chronicles is unashamedly a JRPG for fans of the genre. Both huge and meticulous, it rewards players who imbed themselves in all that it has to offer.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Coming from a content creation background that now spans over two decades, Psy cut her teeth on personal video production and community radio. Originally joining the team as a writer and presenter, she added video editing duties to her responsibilities over time and became the longest-standing editor of the irreverent gaming show Tues Your Own Adventure. Psy has worked on many previews and reviews, long-form editorials (either her own, or supporting as an editor), as a frequent quizmaster and more. Praised for the two-pronged attack of her hard work ethic and light-hearted editing style, Psy is otherwise known as a font of retro video game knowledge which has caused her to rack up many gaming quiz wins. Outside of WhatCulture, Psy runs First Aid Spray Podcast - a long-running channel that focuses on Resident Evil in all of it's forms. You can follow her on BlueSky at http://psywhite.bsky.social and Instagram at http://instagram.com/therealpsywhite