The Best Nintendo Game Every Year 1983 - 2024
2. 2023 - Super Mario Wonder
We all take it for granted now but, when Mario debuted, it was weird. A little plumber man smashes bricks, eats mushrooms and grows, stomps on turtles, travels through pipes and beats up a king turtle. But when something becomes franchisable, it’s easy for it to be pushed into a box.
This is part one of what Super Mario Wonder does so well: change up the formula and surprise long-time players. The other, however, is that most of these inclusions feel so much like they belong that if you were told they’d have been a part of Mario canon since the Super Nintendo you’d believe it.
The stages across the Flower Kingdom contain a mix of enemies both classic and new in equal measure, and the debuting power-ups (like elephant, and bubble) feel so naturally Mario.
Of course, the central element is the Wonder Flowers, which warp reality around the player in whatever way the stage needs them to. This means that Mario Wonder can repeatedly throw curveballs on a stage-by-stage basis. One level you’ll be riding a line of bulls, another might make all the pipes in the stage start moving, another you’ll be playing as a Goomba… and it looks gorgeous every second.
2D Mario had been stale for a long time, but Wonder takes it to strange, new places and we thank it for it.
1. 2024 - The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom
All told, 2024 wasn’t the best year for Nintendo, with the biggest first-party releases mostly being classic titles repackaged to keep the Switch’s lights on in its final full year. Still, 2024 was at least a win for Princesses with both Peach and Zelda getting rare leading roles.
With the franchise already heavily toying with physics-based tomfoolery, it’s no surprise that Echoes of Wisdom does something in the same realm, yet pleasantly different. A sort-of pseudo-sequel to the Link’s Awakening remake - with the same lush, toybox charm - Echoes of Wisdom sees Zelda fighting less with sword and bow and more outfoxing her predicaments by cloning parts of her environment: sick enemies on each other or drop rocks on their head, and scale the cliff-sides with whatever you can find and reproduce.
This, of course, meant the game is completely breakable and unbalanced, with players falling back on a handful of super useful items over the 127 available. But, in a sense, that’s the beauty of it. It’s your adventure, and you can absolutely fill Hyrule with beds.
Echoes of Wisdom might not be in the upper echelon of the Switch’s astounding library, but a game that champions freedom of choice is the perfect way to close out the era where Nintendo coalesced its home console and handheld market.