The Best Xbox Game Every Year 2001 - 2024

14. 2011 - Gears of War 3

Gears of War 3
Epic

With the time that development now takes in today's age, getting a complete trilogy released on a system is a pretty unlikely affair. However, if one franchise were to perfectly embody the lifespan of the Xbox 360, from every possible perspective, it would be Gears of War. As such it's fitting that Gears 3 was the best Xbox game released in 2011.

Whilst the campaign of Gears of War 2 tends to be the overall fan favourite, the crescendo of the Marcus Fenix trilogy had some of the most of gut-wrenching and air-punching moments in the series, all set to some stunning visuals and cinematography. 

Like it's predecessor, Gears 3 was no slouch on the multiplayer side of things. The potential of Horde mode was cracked wide open, building on what came before by giving players fortifications against the oncoming enemy waves and, for the first time, the campaign supported four player co-op.

Perhaps the most underrated element of Gears 3 though was its challenges and rewards. Sure, it asked players to put in some serious work to unlock its cosmetics but it tracked progress across every single mode, making sure that players who came for one thing at least tried out the wealth of content in the conclusion of the original trilogy.


13. 2012 - Forza Horizon

forza horizon 2012
Microsoft Game Studios

With every Xbox Showcase that rolls around, players not engaged in driving games will inevitably roll their eyes at the amount of time given to the Forza franchise. But with the franchise crossing the $1 billion revenue mark in 2017, it's no surprise that Microsoft has leaned so heavily on it over the years.

Forza Horizon was a big part of the franchise's continued success, crafting a series in its own right by taking drivers off the speedway and out into the hills of Colorado. Whilst open-world driving wasn't new, it hadn't been approached with the same degree of attention that the Forza brand demanded. Allowing racers to navigate mountain paths, winding foothills and the open road made for a totally different experience, which was all the sweeter thanks to Forza's trademark tightness in controls and depth of content.

This total shake-up of style,with finish lines for races now being randomly generated, and new game types like Cat and Mouse, was particularly welcomed by the online community. Horizon's more open-ended vibe allowed an entry point to those who were daunted by the intensity of motorsport and simply wanted to bomb around a beautiful rendering of the American countryside in over 200 potential vehicles.


12. 2013 - Dead Rising 3

Dead Rising 3
Capcom

The Xbox One era was a truly troubling time for Microsoft. The following entries may well reflect that, as Xbox started to move away from exclusive releases and try to bill itself as the hub of entertainment in the home. Did nobody tell them they could do both?!

That's not to say that some games don't deserve their praise - and there is a lot to like about Capcom's Dead Rising 3 - but if a solid 7/10 is your best exclusive game of the year then that's very telling.

And whilst Dead Rising 3 was far from the prettiest princess at the next-gen ball, it found appropriately familiar ways to impress. The seamless, significantly bigger map than the first two games was populated with hordes of the undead and was the perfect staging area for mayhem. The refinement of the controls therefore goes a long way to making exploration (and zombie-killing sprees) a breeze, be that on foot or in one of the game's many new combo vehicles. Dead Rising is all about massive, mindless destruction and this was multiplied tenfold for every additional player added to the same map via the game's riotous co-op.

Hampered by lacklustre writing and tonal whiplash, Dead Rising 3 was at least a solid start to the Xbox One, but not the system-seller that a new console desperately needs. 


11. 2014 - Sunset Overdrive

Sunset Overdrive
Insomniac Games

With the number of exclusives in its first year being so painfully low, and Microsoft fumbling the launch in other ways (such as the DRM controversy), it meant that the hidden gems were truly hidden. That is to say, Sunset Overdrive is an overlooked cult classic that deserved so much better.

Whereas post-apocalyptic was already in danger of becoming a tired phrase, Insomniac Games christened Sunset Overdrive an “awesomepocalypse” - a bombastic, frenetic, stylish affair where players glide, grind and skate around a colourful city, blasting robots and energy drink fuelled zombies with weapons such as guitars, firework guns and bowling ball launchers.

It felt like a Saturday morning cartoon, in the best possible way.

And truly, Sunset Overdrive might be Insomniac’s secret magnum opus. The ridiculous arsenal was akin to their Ratchet and Clank series combined with the real sense of momentum that the studio’s eventual PlayStation Spider-Man series would be acclaimed for, but all contained within a wonderfully cartoonish setting (complete with comic book-like text appearing alongside some of your actions). 

Insomniac Games might be one of the most reliable development studios of the modern era, which is precisely why they’ve been given the keys to the Marvel kingdom under the ownership of Sony. That said, Sunset Overdrive accomplishes perhaps that little bit more by being so brash, charmingly stupid and refreshingly original.


10. 2015 - Rare Replay

Rare Replay
Rare

Several years before the launch of Game Pass, 2015’s Rare Replay - intentionally or otherwise - made for a strong rebuttal against the talk that Xbox didn’t have a solid portfolio. Or, moreover, Microsoft's acquisition of Rare gave them a solid portfolio by proxy.

Celebrating 30 years of the company with 30 of their best titles, the quality and artistry on display was inarguable. The package featured Viva Piñata, Blast Corps, as well as the remastered versions of Perfect Dark and the Banjo-Kazooie games, and a slew of early ZX Spectrum outings. 

It’s arguably cheating to feature a collection of classics, but Rare Replay was so much more than that. Everything was tied together with the attention to detail that one expects from Rare, with a charming UI and unlockable documentary pieces on the company’s history.

And whilst Rare Replay wasn’t a brand-new game, it did feature the console debut of the Battletoads arcade sequel. This was the extra cherry on top of the video game preservation sundae. When many classic games are getting harder to get a hold of, Rare put 30 of their best in one place for a mere $30.

Despite criticisms that it wasn’t totally comprehensive thanks to various copyright issues from Nintendo, Rare Replay was still well worth its below average asking price (and even moreso in later years when Goldeneye was eventually gifted to owners for free).


9. 2016 - Quantum Break

quantum break
Remedy

There’s some irony perhaps in that Xbox One’s infamous E3 unveiling and it’s obsession with “TV, TV, TV(!)” did coincide with one of the better exclusives of 2016 being a hybrid piece of media. Quantum Break was Remedy Entertainment’s first console game since 2010’s Alan Wake and is perhaps even more of a cult classic than that had been.

Between missions of Quantum Break players were invited to sit back and enjoy an episode of a serialised live-action drama that took place alongside their own actions. Even if the reception to the show itself was varied, the concept was intriguing. Performances from lead actors such as Aiden Gillan and the late, great Lance Reddick were the glue between the two halves.

From a gameplay standpoint, where Quantum Break perhaps didn’t always land as a shooter was more than made up by the player’s time-based powers - freezing enemies, dashing to and from cover and using time itself as a shield, all of which can be combo’d into each other for some rewarding (and incredible looking) combat sequences. Where it truly excelled was its environmental design and the way players used those powers to navigate and solve puzzles. 

Whilst Quantum Break never became the huge IP Microsoft had perhaps hoped for, it exceeded sales expectations and became the console’s best-seller up to that point.


8. 2017 - Cuphead

cuphead game
Studio MDHR

Few new IPs get quite as strong a reaction as Cuphead did in 2014 when it was shown - very briefly - at E3 that year as part of a sizzle reel. Over time, the run-and-gunner inspired by the golden age of animation grew a significant level of interest because there was nothing out there on the market like it.

As such, it made a splash when it landed (and in fact delivered), becoming the most enviable Xbox game that year and perhaps across the life-span of the Xbox One. In a time where hunger for challenging games was rising, Cuphead offered something different from the dark and brooding Soulsborne games (and their many copy-cats) by harkening back to games of the past. And, best of all, it did so in a beautiful, bizarre and consistent art style that only the current generation could handle.

Even when Cuphead was smashing players from pillar to post (which was all the time), it was a delight for the eyes. 

Cuphead fever was truly massive, spawning a Netflix show, a table-top game and even getting some unexpected representation in the video game historical encyclopaedia that was Nintendo's Super Smash Brothers Ultimate.


7. 2018 - Sea of Thieves

Sea Of Thieves Athena Keg
Rare

With heads of the Xbox brand laser-focused on building the value of Game Pass as a one-stop shop since its release in June 2017, Xbox One’s roster of 2018 exclusives was almost non-existent. Crackdown 3, State of Decay 2 and even Sea of Thieves all launched to tepid results.

However, over time the clear winner of that trio has not only risen up as one of the best games of it's year across the but also done so as one of the best examples of live service done right.

Sea of Thieves’ biggest draws have always been its social aspects and freedom, allowing teams of players to board their custom ships and follow their hearts. There’s treasure to be found, other pirates to battle and monsters in the deep to flee from. Each moment of tension, panic and loss makes every shared success at discovery or victory that much sweeter.

It's Rare's commitment to quality that turned the game around, even going so far as to secure license deals with Secret of Monkey Island and Pirates of the Caribbean for beefy stories that fit so joyfully into the tapestry of the Devil's Shroud.

Sea of Thieves launched as a very pretty game with that distinctive Rare charm but nothing beyond the surface. In one of gaming’s greatest redemption arcs, it slowly became one of the most rewarding online games still active today, proving its worth to the 30,000 players it still retains six years later.


6. 2019 - Gears 5

Gears 5 Act 3
Microsoft

In 2016, The Coalition - a development studio handpicked by Microsoft to take the reigns from Epic Games - put out the first new story in the Gears of War saga. Even with a new cast of characters, a new threat and a significant time jump, Gears of War 4 was criticised as playing things too "safe".

Reacting to this is where Gears 5’s true strengths lay. New robotic companion Jack could be upgraded to change the flow of battle. The game featured optional larger open areas that (whilst poorly marketed as “open world”) made for a refreshing change of pace and allowed players to pause the flow of the story to explore the world a little more. Overall, the level and encounter design are up there as some of the best in the series, and the game was superbly well-written, offering an intriguingly more human drive to the Gears universe.

Unfortunately, the game was severely let down on launch by an extremely thin multiplayer portion. Gears 5's multiple awards of “Best Xbox Game” at the time felt more like the circumstances of it yet again being one of the very few exclusives released in 2019 for the green brand.

That said, like Sea of Thieves, time and updates were kind to Gears 5 in turning it around to something that felt more worthy.


5. 2020 - Ori and the Will of the Wisps

ori and the will of the wisps
Microsoft Game Studios

2020's long-awaited Ori and the Will of the Wisps was the perfect example of what a sequel can and should do. Instead of being a very pretty homage to the genre, like the first game was, Will of the Wisps expanded its influences to include more contemporary titles, unlocking the franchise's full potential.

With a larger map, there was adequate space for the studio to expand the scope of what an Ori game could be. A selection of well-realised NPCs fleshed out the new location of Niwen, almost all of whom served purposes like tracking stats or offering side quests. Boss battles entered the fray for the first time, giving the pace of the game a more precise flow. In turn, these gelled perfectly with Ori's new blade and projectile-based offence which overhauled the combat into something ultimately more satisfying.

It would be impossible not to talk about Ori without complimenting its art direction and Will of the Wisps was gorgeous in every regard - a brilliant soundtrack, jaw-dropping visuals and captivating animation. There was something indelibly warm and sincere about the game's presentation and touching story beats.

Both Ori titles are a testament to games as art, but it's easy to argue that Will of the Wisps remains the most complete feeling Metroidvania still today.


Contributor

Coming from a content creation background that now spans over two decades, Psy cut her teeth on personal video production and community radio. Originally joining the team as a writer and presenter, she added video editing duties to her responsibilities over time and became the longest-standing editor of the irreverent gaming show Tues Your Own Adventure. Psy has worked on many previews and reviews, long-form editorials (either her own, or supporting as an editor), as a frequent quizmaster and more. Praised for the two-pronged attack of her hard work ethic and light-hearted editing style, Psy is otherwise known as a font of retro video game knowledge which has caused her to rack up many gaming quiz wins. Outside of WhatCulture, Psy runs First Aid Spray Podcast - a long-running channel that focuses on Resident Evil in all of it's forms. You can follow her on BlueSky at http://psywhite.bsky.social and Instagram at http://instagram.com/therealpsywhite