The Best Xbox Game Every Year 2001 - 2024

4. 2021 - Forza Horizon 5

Forza Horizon 5
Xbox Game Studios

Realistically speaking, Microsoft had two exclusives launch in 2021. One of these was Halo Infinite which, whilst it can be argued is a great total package now, wasn't exactly warmly received at the time. The other was Forza Horizon 5 which, in a series that regularly scores extremely well on MetaCritic, became one of the highest-praised entries in Xbox's most consistent franchise and opened up to 10 million players in its first week.

Forza Horizon 5 was all about refining an idea to its sharpest point. It was the (so far) logical endpoint for a side-series that took Forza's racing sim mechanics and put them in a more arcade-y setting. You couldn't drive more than a few minutes across the game's huge map without encountering some sort of objective, ranging from off-road races to finding rare cars in barns; from drift challenges to wreckage events that see players destroying piƱatas. 

Everything was optional and, brilliantly, all equally viable, as players consistently earned adventure points towards their completion and the rewards of new vehicles from the game's absurd collection of over 800 came thick and fast. Forza Horizon 5 was more about freedom than ever.

This also included the freedom to ignore it all and simply enjoy the game's refined driving mechanics whilst exploring one of the prettiest open worlds released this generation.


3. 2022 - Grounded

grounded wasps
Microsoft Game Studios

Grounded was exciting right from the off. Developed by reliable RPG hands Obsidian Entertainment, the game entered early access in 2020 with a campaign that was about 20% complete. In the two years between this and the full release, the company were praised for using feedback from their audience to shape the game which, at one stage whilst still in early access, got to a whopping player base of 5 million.

The result of this was the best Xbox game in 2022 - a "Honey, I Shrunk the Kids" inspired adventure where players are reduced to the size of an ant, dropped in a backyard which now feels like a jungle, and tasked with protecting themselves from terrifying insects, crafting themselves into a formidable survivalist and trying to escape.

Aside from its brilliantly realised setting, this was what made Grounded great: it was a rare survival game that had an end goal. Rather than just crafting more and more until you were unstoppable, players knew that their ultimate destination was to finish the story and leave the backyard for good. This really helped drive both solo players and groups forward rather than drop off early, all assisted by an addictive gameplay loop which was expertly paced, with meaty quests and satisfying character growth.

In a genre swimming with some pretty half-assed attempts to cash in on the survival craze, Grounded proved that good things can come in small packages.


2. 2023 - Hi-Fi Rush

Hi-Fi Rush
Bethesda Softworks

2023 wasn't without its issues for the green brand but it also had plenty of wins. For the company, their acquisition of Activision-Blizzard was finally a done deal. For gamers, Xbox delivered console exclusives like Cocoon, Lies of P and Starfield. Whilst the last of those was perhaps the biggest (and certainly most anticipated) launch of the year for the console, it was met with very mixed reactions.

On the other hand, Hi-Fi Rush was a unifying moment. The slick, stylish action game shadow-dropped in January, kicking off 2023 with smiles amongst GamePass owners who had immediate access to Tango Gameworks' latest accomplishment.

And an accomplishment it was, as Hi-Fi Rush's sense of humour, breezy pacing and chaotic gameplay cut through the usual modern gaming fare with aplomb. The rhythm-based combat was entirely addictive and paired wonderfully with the game's colourful world, which animated perfectly in time to the beat to create a setting that was simply satisfying to be in. Appropriately, Hi-Fi Rush's audio design and soundtrack went on to win awards at the end of the year, proving it left a mark through all of 2023.

With the sad closure of Tango in 2024, it's a sting in the narrative to know that Hi-Fi Rush will not get the sequel it no doubt deserves.


1. 2024 - Hellblade II: Senua's Sacrifice

Hellblade II
Ninja Theory

And thus we come to the current year, as of writing. Whilst 2024 is only half over, it's been a very bad year for Microsoft. Aside from the ill will associated with the heartless closures of smaller studios (such as the aforementioned Tango Gameworks), it's also just been a very quiet year for games. Hellblade II wins purely by default by being the only Xbox console exclusive to launch so far.

In its defence, Senua's Sacrifice did grab a strong MetaCritic of 81 on release, with the audience reaction sitting at a sturdy 7.1. 

The game has been praised for its gorgeous graphics, stunning location design and the continued immersive storytelling of Senua's psychosis from the first game, but was also criticised for not shaking things up enough. Whilst the devs clearly spent more time on combat-related animations (and they do look great), the game lacks depth in terms of approaching the combat itself.

One's perspective and expectation is everything with Hellblade II. Microsoft's marketing of the game implied it was closer to AAA fare than Ninja Theory perhaps intended. If the goal was to craft a solid, narrative-driven puzzle adventure, like the first game, then the developers have succeeded.

It's impossible to say where Hellblade II will find itself for Xbox when awards season rolls around, and seems a great example of the doubt and mistrust that the Xbox brand continues to unfortunately generate in 2024.


Contributor

Coming from a content creation background that now spans over two decades, Psy cut her teeth on personal video production and community radio. Originally joining the team as a writer and presenter, she added video editing duties to her responsibilities over time and became the longest-standing editor of the irreverent gaming show Tues Your Own Adventure. Psy has worked on many previews and reviews, long-form editorials (either her own, or supporting as an editor), as a frequent quizmaster and more. Praised for the two-pronged attack of her hard work ethic and light-hearted editing style, Psy is otherwise known as a font of retro video game knowledge which has caused her to rack up many gaming quiz wins. Outside of WhatCulture, Psy runs First Aid Spray Podcast - a long-running channel that focuses on Resident Evil in all of it's forms. You can follow her on BlueSky at http://psywhite.bsky.social and Instagram at http://instagram.com/therealpsywhite