10 Best Performances From 2024 Horror Movies

The horror movie performances from this past year that stuck with us all.

Smile 2 Naomi Scott
Paramount

2024 has been quite the banner year for horror, again proving itself to be one of cinema's healthiest and most adventurous genres, with one hell of an enthusiastic fanbase to boot.

Whether you were in the mood for glossy, big-budget studio horror or a more low-key indie surprise, the past year has served up a ton of excellent horror flicks. But more than that, it's also given innumerable actors the floor to deliver some of their finest acting work to date. 

It's fair to say that horror films are continually underestimated on the acting front, evidenced by the tendency for awards bodies to near-totally ignore them, despite the unique opportunity they provide actors to let loose. And over the past 12 months, the following were the best and most memorable performances from the genre to grace screens both big and small. 

From savage antagonist roles to barnstorming heroes, these parts were all made totally unforgettable by the extremely talented actors who gave it their all throughout. For those misguided few who still think horror can't be a fertile ground for incredible acting, these fantastic performances categorically proved otherwise.

10. James McAvoy - Speak No Evil

Speak No Evil
Universal Pictures

Even those who decried the very existence of the Hollywood remake of Dutch-Danish psychological horror film Speak No Evil couldn't deny that the entire enterprise was held firmly together, even in its most sanitised moments, by James McAcoy's utterly electrifying performance.

McAvoy plays the central antagonist, serial killer Paddy, and brings an unnerving intensity to the part far above that of his counterpart, Fedja van HuĂȘt, in the original film.

Beyond cutting one hell of an imposing physique, McAvoy does a marvellous job bouncing chaotically between simmering calm and explosive psychopathy. It is a performance that balances on a razor's edge, boasting just enough psychological plausibility while being a whole ton of terrifying fun to watch.

Needless to say, McAvoy's swinging-for-the-fences performance ensures you'll never think of the songs "Cotton Eye Joe" or "Eternal Flame" the same way ever again. His work here is so good it basically solely justifies the remake's existence.


9. Melissa Barrera - Your Monster

Melissa Barrera Your Monster
Vertical

Your Monster proved beyond any doubt that Melissa Barrera is so much better suited to dorky horror-comedy roles than more straight-up horror flicks like Scream and Abigail.

Barrera gives an extremely charming performance as Laura Franco, a troubled young woman who attempts to piece her life back together with the help of a monster (Tommy Dewey) she discovers living in her house. The actress' work here is so expertly calibrated to the film's quirky, darkly comedic tone, transforming from a meek young woman into a confident, righteously angry badass, capped off by one of the most intense "freakout" scenes from any movie released this past year.

Her adorable chemistry opposite co-star Tommy Dewey seals the deal, and while not all of the film's twists and turns will work for everyone, it's without question career-best work from Barrera, demonstrating the full range of her acting chops.

Sadly, Your Monster was largely ignored on theatrical release, though it'll hopefully endure as a cult classic now it's available on streaming.


8. Lauren LaVera & David Howard Thornton - Terrifier 3

Terrifier 3
Iconic Events Releasing

Terrifier 3 is a film that's just jam-packed full of surprises. Not content to be the highest-grossing unrated film of all time, the slasher threequel also boasts not merely one excellent performance, but two.

First up, we have David Howard Thornton, who once again reprises the role of iconic antagonist Art the Clown, bringing a level of physicality and expressiveness to the part that's easy to underestimate. Given that Art is an entirely mute character, Thornton needs to do a lot of the storytelling with his eyes, facial expressions, and body language - and he absolutely knocks it out of the park!

But David Howard Thornton is perfectly matched by Lauren LaVera, who also returns as the previous film's heroine, Sienna Shaw. As fundamentally ridiculous as this movie might be, LaVera's performance as a young woman traumatised by Art's rampage grounds the film emotionally, no matter how absurd its grisly death scenes might be.

LaVera commits to the part like she's gunning for an Oscar, and the end product is all the better for it.


7. Nell Tiger Free - The First Omen

The First Omen
20th Century Studios

Even though there was much pre-release hand-wringing about the "necessity" of a prequel to The Omen, there was never any doubt about lead actress Nell Tiger Free's ability to give a barnstorming central performance.

The Servant actress is perfectly cast here as American novice nun Margaret, who uncovers a disturbing conspiracy after being sent to work at a Catholic orphanage in Rome. Free nails Margaret's naivete and increasing terror as she becomes ensnared in the scheme to bring about the birth of the Antichrist. It's a tremendously physical role that requires Free to put herself through the wringer, culminating in one of the most unforgettably unnerving breakdown sequences in recent horror history.

Inspired though Free's turn obviously is by Isabelle Adjani's work in classic horror film Possession, it nevertheless stands tall as a towering acting accomplishment in its own right, and confirms beyond any doubt that she's one of the most talented Scream Queens working today.


6. Hugh Grant - Heretic

Heretic Hugh Grant
A24

Hugh Grant has been enjoying one hell of a career renaissance in recent years, and so it was merely a natural next step that he'd eventually turn his talents towards the horror genre. And what a perfect vehicle Heretic was for him, casting the former rom-rom star as Mr. Reed, a reclusive man who ensnares two young Mormon women (Sophie Thatcher, Chloe East) in a disturbing cat-and-mouse game.

Filmmakers Scott Beck and Bryan Woods do a masterful job of taking Grant's charming persona and weaponising it in a totally unique way, his initially disarming demeanour luring his victims into a false sense of security before the other shoe drops.

It's obvious that Grant is having an absolute blast throughout Heretic, chewing through Reed's verbose dialogues with scarcely veiled glee, and in turn delivering one of his finest performances to date - one which even unexpectedly nabbed him a Golden Globe nomination for Best Actor (Musical or Comedy).


5. Willa Fitzgerald - Strange Darling

strange darling willa fitzgerald
Magenta Light Studios

It's tough to talk about JT Mollner's delicious horror-thriller Strange Darling without giving away its most impactful surprises, but it's no spoiler to say that lead actress Willa Fitzgerald gives one of the year's most unforgettable performances as its imperiled lead character.

Fitzgerald, who was a standout in Mike Flanagan's miniseries The Fall of the House of Usher last year, is fantastic as an unnamed woman who finds herself pursued by a violent man credited only as The Demon (Kyle Gallner).

There's so much more to the story than this, as is gradually unfurled throughout the runtime, and without Fitzgerald's assured, intense performance, some of its more ambitious turns of plot probably wouldn't work.

Her chemistry with genre vet Gallner is fantastic, and she instantly establishes herself here as a deeply compelling new Scream Queen with a clear aptitude for portraying femme fatale-type characters. Hopefully, she's just getting started.


4. Lupita Nyong'o - A Quiet Place: Day One

A Quiet Place: Day One
Paramount

Though it's no surprise that Lupita Nyong'o gave it her all in A Quiet Place: Day One, it was surprising that Michael Sarnoski's film proved to be such an intimate and character-driven piece of work, enough that some were even left underwhelmed by how little it functioned as a true prequel to A Quiet Place.

Sarnoski was clearly far more interested in examining protagonist Sam in forensic detail - a terminally ill woman who simply wants to make it through one more day just as the alien creatures invade Earth.

Nyong'o gives one of her best performances - and that's really saying something - as an innately sympathetic character with a clear-eyed goal she wants to accomplish before her limited remaining time alive is over.

She brings enormous soul and gravitas to Sam's tragic journey, and plays wonderfully off co-star Joseph Quinn as fellow survivor Eric. In a film that many assumed wouldn't offer too much for its actors, Nyong'o gave a genuinely Oscar-worthy portrayal.


3. Nicolas Cage - Longlegs

Longlegs Nicolas Cage
Neon

Nicolas Cage's streak of fascinating genre film roles continues with his utterly mesmerising performance in Osgood Perkins' horror-thriller Longlegs, where he portrays the titular serial killer.

Though Cage's role in the film is smaller than many expected, he makes every single second count. Aided by a ton of facial prosthetics, Cage absolutely disappears into the antagonist role, giving a terrifyingly unhinged, unpredictable performance quite like nothing else he's ever given us before. It feels like a part tailor-made for Cage's off-the-wall instincts as a performer - at times unexpectedly hilarious and always incredibly unsettling.

For anyone who felt that Nic Cage was too much of a meme today to be genuinely terrifying, Longlegs offered up persuasive evidence to the contrary, the actor immersing himself fully in the role, enough that co-star Maika Monroe reported being legitimately scared the first time she saw him in makeup on set.


2. Naomi Scott - Smile 2

Smile 2
Paramount Pictures

Smile 2 proved that filmmaker Parker Finn is no one-trick pony, offering up an arguably even better sequel that has one major ace up its sleeve: Naomi Scott.

Scott portrays troubled protagonist Skye Riley, a pop star who finds herself preyed upon by the focal trauma demon. And to call the film one hell of a calling card for her acting chops is quite the understatement indeed. She doesn't merely do a serviceable job for a mainstream horror movie - she commits fully to the script's intense demands and delivers a performance that, in a just world, would be courting awards buzz tight now. 

But alas, we all know what the Academy thinks about most of the horror genre.

All the same, Naomi Scott gives herself over entirely to Finn's script, delivering one of cinema's most evocative recent portrayals of sanity slippage, regardless of genre. One can only imagine how emotionally draining Smile 2 must've been for Scott to shoot, but the result is one of the most memorable performances from any mainstream horror film of the past decade.


1. Demi Moore - The Substance

The Substance Demi Moore
Mubi

And finally, this list appropriately ends with the only performance here that might actually land an Oscar nomination: Demi Moore's career-best performance in The Substance.

Did anyone expect Moore, at this seemingly comfortable, unadventurous point in her career, to star in a face-melting body-horror film? Nobody could've seen it coming, or that she'd end up giving one of the year's best performances of any kind.

As fading, middle-aged movie star Elisabeth Sparkle, Moore gives a jaw-droppingly vanity-free performance - one that commands a lot of her physically, the gross-out particulars of which shouldn't even be discussed here.

But Demi takes the assignment dead seriously, treating it like any purely straight drama she's ever starred in, and in turn wrings every last possible drop of pathos out of Elisabeth's tragic journey. Enormous credit should also go to Moore's co-star Margaret Qualley, who as Elisabeth's younger self Sue, provides the perfect mirror image for Moore to play off.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.