10 Most Disappointing Villains From Recent Horror Movies

Which recent horror villains failed to hit the Devil’s Mark?

Winnie The Pooh Blood and Honey
Altitude Film Distribution

We recently covered a sinister selection of the vilest villains from recent horror films, but what about the recent horror villains that made us go "Oh, bother," like Winnie-the-Pooh, in disappointment?

Some villains have become so iconic and embedded in our psyche that we expect their petrifying presence to permeate every scene in the sequels that follow. But instead, they're minimised, to the detriment of these follow-ups. Others may have set such a high horror benchmark in previous films that we're then left feeling a sense of dissatisfaction with the next outing of these supposedly chilling characters.

There have been mortal monsters brought back from the dead, but imbuing them with immortality somehow lessens their overall effectiveness. And some rogues start off with understated scariness, but then fail to stick the landing come their show-stopping reveal.

Then there are those other horror villains who have been hyped up, but leave us feeling frustratingly shortchanged, or those characters who literally live long enough to become the villain, only for the one-eighty turn to leave a lot to be desired.

So, let's take aim at these recent disappointing horror antagonists. Hey, you may even get a shot at some Razzie winners…

10. The Grabber - Black Phone 2

Black Phone 2
Universal

Ethan Hawke gave us an unnerving performance as a child serial killer, the Grabber, in Scott Derrickson's 2021 supernatural horror The Black Phone. 

In that first movie, the Grabber wasn't enhanced with the supernatural side of things. He could be your next-door neighbour. Your brother. The man in a black van pulling up alongside you at the traffic lights. The man you would help when he dropped his groceries on the ground. The everyman visiting a hardware store. He's someone who defines our absolute worst thoughts when we wonder what goes on behind other people's closed doors. He was a human who died at the hands of survivor Finney Blake (Mason Thames). 

Until 2025's Black Phone 2, that is.

Here, the sequel takes the Nightmare on Elm Street route, with the Grabber now a supernatural spectre seeking vengeance against an older Finn and his younger sister Gwen (Madeleine McGraw). And with the supernatural, anything goes.

Set within a Christian winter youth camp, the Grabber turns his ferocious focus on Gwen by distorting her dreams with terrifying and traumatising images of the killer's first victims. Seeing the Grabber invade Gwen's haunting dreamscape and pull her towards a fiery doom, while others look on in suspended terror, does give us the requisite heebie-jeebies.

However, in amongst the multiple rabbit hole mysteries, the one that should have been further explored is the Grabber's genesis. This was briefly touched upon and is something that Hawke himself has expressed interest in. What made the youth camp maintenance man nicknamed "Wild Bill" turn to a life of black balloons, amongst other things?


9. Ray Bronson - I Know What You Did Last Summer (2025)

I Know What You Did Last Summer 2025 Ray Bronson
Sony Pictures Releasing

I Know What You Did Last Summer (1997), from director Jim Gillespie, introduced us to Julie James (Jennifer Love Hewitt), Helen Shivers (Sarah Michelle Gellar), Barry Cox (Ryan Phillippe), and Ray Bronson (Freddy Prinze Jr.).

Beauty queen Helen and hothead Barry were, amongst others, brutally fish-hooked to death by Ben Willis (Muse Watson). Julie briefly suspected that Ray was responsible for the savage Southport murders, but he ends up saving her, and it seems as though they go off to live happily ever after having survived another round of fishhook massacres in 1998's I Still Know What You Did Last Summer.

Alas, no.

I Know What You Did Last Summer (2025), written and directed by Jennifer Kaytin Robinson, introduces us to Danica Richards (Madelyne Cline), Ava Brucks (Chase Sui Wonders), Milo Griffin (Jonah Hauer-King), Teddy Spencer (Tyriq Withers), and Stevie Ward (Sarah Pidgeon) - with Julie and Ray also returning, but now divorced.

The film is essentially a carbon copy of the original. This time, Teddy and Milo, amongst others, are the unfortunate victims of the hook-wielding killer. The person underneath the hat and slicker? Stevie. Her motivation was revenge against the group for causing the accident a year earlier that led to the death of her close friend, Sam Cooper, whom she formed a close bond with in rehab. Fortunately, it looks as though Ray has, once again, saved the day by seemingly shooting Stevie dead. Hooray!

Nope.

In an about-turn that Daenerys Targaryen would be proud of, we discover that Ray assisted Stevie's bloody revenge spree. With his unresolved trauma from 1997, Ray wasn't a fan of the gentrification of Southport, believing it was erasing the town's ruinous past reputation. 

Urgh. Changing a likeable character for cheap shock value leaves a fishy stench in the air.

So, it turns out Julie was right about Ray all along... eventually.


8. Mirror Demon - The Conjuring: Last Rites

The Conjuring: Last Rites Judy Warren Mia Tomlinson
Warner Bros.

The Conjuring films have given us some of the most iconic and truly terrifying horror villains. You will never see the top of a wardrobe in the same way again thanks to Bathsheba Sherman, and you'll think twice about looking at a portrait painting of a nun because of Valak.

Both are clearly S-tier, so it would take someone or something sinisterly special to join those demonic delights. In terms of an incredibly powerful entity of pure evil, the Mirror Demon from 2025's The Conjuring: Last Rites is at least a close second to Valak.

This is shockingly demonstrated when the Mirror Demon malevolently manipulates Father Gordon's (Steve Coulter) reality when he seeks further assistance from the church to help the troubled Smurl family.

Whilst waiting to see Bishop McKenna, we see a vacuum cable forebodingly move across the floor in the adjacent hallway. Father Gordon then notices the secretary has suddenly disappeared and picks up a ringing telephone, with the voice on the other end telling him: "You can go now". He sees a doorknob engraved with a crucifix slowly turned upside down. Thereafter, the closed doors violently burst open, leaving the entire room completely enveloped in disheartening darkness. The Mirror Demon growls at Father Gordon and sets alight his wooden crucifix, before the kindly priest proceeds to hang himself with the cable. To think, all within the confines of the most sacred and seemingly safest of places.

Apart from that standout scene, Last Rites plays rather safe. Yes, we get the standard jump scares with the Old Crone Ghost (Gabrielle Downey) and obligatory chilling chases with the ferocious axeman Abner (Leigh Jones), but given the Mirror Demon's extraordinary reality-bending powers, the filmmakers could - and should - have gone full-on Mirror Dimension, with a film of torturous trippiness. Still, you'll think twice about purchasing a massive antique mirror.


7. The Murderous Mascots - Five Nights At Freddy's

five nights at freddy's
blumhouse

Tense, terrifying, atmospheric, and sweaty-palm-inducing are just some of the words to describe the thoughts and feelings when playing the first two Five Nights at Freddy's games by Scott Cawthon from 2014. Disappointing, frustrating, plodding, and sleep-inducing are just some of the words to describe the thoughts and feelings when watching the first two Five Nights at Freddy's films from 2023 and 2025. 

The games' immersive survival horror premise is dreadfully diluted in the first instalment. Instead of focusing our heightened anxieties around the animatronic antagonists - Freddy, Bonnie, Chica, and Foxy, etc. - the film favours exploring the laborious backstory surrounding security guard Mike Schmidt (Josh Hutcherson). Instead of mainly hearing Freddy et al. moving around sinisterly in the pizzeria shadows, then jump-scaring you out of your seat, we see cuddly-looking mascots plodding about and building a bloody fort!

Thankfully, the overall horror is wound up come the second film, especially the Marionette possessions of Lisa (Mckenna Grace) and Mike's sister Abby (Piper Rubio). And it does elicit an oddly juxtaposed cheer when Mike is sat at the computer desk figuring out how to disable the escaped Toy animatronics, whilst covering his face with a Freddy Fazbear mask to stop himself from being killed by the monstrously mangled Prototypes.

Unfortunately, these are the only horrifying highlights across both films. Far too much time is spent on the human melodrama and beyond the chilling confines of the pizzerias. Therefore, we'll forego our cheque for $120 and be on our way, because these shifts simply weren't scary enough.


6. Monster Sarah - Cobweb

Cobweb Sarah
Lionsgate

A classic case of a horror villain better left to our own insidious imaginations.

Cobweb (2023) builds the requisite suspense right from the off, as troubled child Peter (Woody Norman) starts hearing bumps in the night and scratching behind one of his bedroom walls. He then proceeds to knock on the wall, which is returned in kind. Soon after, a young girl's voice whispers beyond the wall and begins talking to Peter, eventually revealing to him that she's... his sister, Sarah.

At this point, we're signposted into believing Peter's parents Carol (Lizzi Caplan) and Mark (Antony Starr) are the monsters of this piece for imprisoning their daughter. Especially Mark, who channels his inner Homelander by forcing his son to stay in the cobweb-covered basement following a violent transgression with a nasty school bully.

So far, so sinisterly good. And the only glimpse we've had of sweet-sounding Sarah is a creepy moment of seeing an eye through a hole in the wall. However, when Peter poisons his parents to death on Sarah's manipulative instructions and lets her out, Cobweb suddenly descends into hammy horror, as Monster Sarah releases all her pent-up, bloodlusting rage on, admittedly, a bunch of d**kheads.

At this point, she reveals herself in all her silliness glory by scurrying around in questionable CGI, with exceedingly long hair dangling down that's less scary Samara Morgan and more risible Rapunzel - plus a farcical face that shows she's clearly one of Jumba's Experiments gone catastrophically wrong.

So, even though Carol and Mark weren't exactly role model parents towards either of their children, you can understand their rationale for keeping their firstborn hidden from society. That and the fact that she was a murderous monster, admittedly.


5. AMELIA - M3GAN 2.0

M3GAN 2.0 AMELIA
Universal

M3GAN was one of the surprise critical and commercial hits of 2022, with the Gerald Johnstone-helmed horror/sci-fi blending gross-out kills with laugh-out-loud moments. And so, naturally, Universal Pictures greenlit a sequel shortly afterwards. 

However, whereas Aliens perfectly infuses Ridley Scott's 1979 horror with James Cameron's action-packed spectacle, 2025's M3GAN 2.0 is a disappointing downgrade.

The follow-up traipses the Terminator 2: Judgment Day template by having M3GAN (Amie Donald and Jenna Davis) assisting her creator Gemma (Allison Williams) in stopping the rogue Autonomous Military Engagement Logistics and Infiltration Android, aka AMELIA (Ivanna Sakhno).

Sakhno does embody the physicality of the AI android antagonist with deadeye aplomb, but without any wicked wisecracking quips accompanying her murderous moments, AMELIA has all the charm of an interview with AI actress Tilly Norwood. Perhaps it was concealed within the black hole of her core directive.

At one point, M3GAN remarks, "This might actually get interesting". It's just a shame it never really does, and that's because of the serious lack of humorous horror that made the first film so memorable. Whilst M3GAN gave us a feeling of suspense and anticipation - "You need to learn some manners, Brandon" - AMELIA dishes out more of a crash, bang, wallop brand of punishment - although props to her for sneaking up on tech titan turncoat Christian (Aristotle Athari), then coolly emerging with his severed arm moments later.

Even the final showdown between AMELIA and M3GAN fails to generate any electricity, despite them being spectacularly surrounded by the stuff.


4. Lipstick-Face Demon - Insidious: The Red Door

universal orlando resort hhn halloween horror nights insidious
Universal Orlando Resort

We all know the comparison between Darth Maul and the Lipstick-Face Demon, with their devilish red and black face markings and yellow eyes giving them an instantaneously iconic look and plenty of nightmare fuel for children and adults alike. The latter is simply one of the most iconic horror villains of the 21st century and gave us one of the most iconic jump scares in horror history.

Portrayed by Joseph Bishara since 2010's Insidious from director James Wan, the first instalment sees the Demon appropriately insidiously finding his way from a dark realm of tortured souls called the Further to briefly possessing the body of young Dalton Lambert (Ty Simpkins). Bishara also provides the series' heart-stopping, horrifying music scores. The man sure does love this genre.

Following some minor cameo appearances in the franchise's various sequels and prequels, the marionette-loving evil entity returned as the headline antagonist in 2023's Insidious: The Red Door, serving as a culmination of the Lambert family saga.

Unfortunately, it's essentially an underwhelming facsimile of the original film.

Dalton is again possessed by the Demon and chained up in his ostentatious lair, being tortured by the sound of Tiptoe Through the Tulips by Tiny Tim. The Man With Fire On His Face pops up for a standout jump scare when strangling Dalton's college roommate, Chris (Sinclair Daniel), there's a bloody handprint on a bedsheet, and Dalton is again saved by his father Josh (Patrick Wilson, who also directed the film). 

There's no exhibition of violent power from the Demon, à la the séance scene from 2010, that you'd expect from a final showdown. The only hint of frightening ferociousness we get is when he smashes through the Red Door, only to be promptly stopped by Dalton, who paints over his painting of said door in the real world. Honestly, watching it dry may well be more thrilling. 


3. The Falconer Family - Fear Street: Prom Queen

Fear Street: Prom Queen
Netflix

Following a brilliantly bingeable trilogy of Fear Street films, 2025's fourth instalment, Fear Street: Prom Queen, represents after the Lord Mayor's show. This entry is particularly disappointing considering it was helmed by Matt Palmer, who wrote and directed the critically acclaimed Highlands horror, Calibre, from 2018.

We've seen some great horror villains wasted in terrible films, but that redeeming distinction can't be extended to Prom Queen's one-dimensional antagonists: the forgettable Falconer family, whose motivations are as weak as the prom punch before it was spiked.

Nancy (a wasted Katherine Waterston) is the malicious matriarch, demonstrating a ruthless love towards daughter Tiffany (Fina Strazza) by telling her before prom, "I just want you to know, whatever happens tonight, I am proud of you. Now, don't f**k it up".

Tiffany does her mum proud as the narcissistic high school mean girl we all love to hate, who constantly torments Lori Granger (India Fowler) about how the latter's mother, Rose (Joanne Boland), "killed" her father. She commands a callous version of a Wolfpack we'd rather not enjoy misadventures with.

As for the wasted Chris Klein as the father, Dan? Well, he certainly takes utter devotion to his wicked wife and devilish daughter to heinous heights of absurdity. Alongside Nancy, he savagely murders all the other prom queen candidates (barring Lori), amongst others, so that Tiffany would take the crown.

A mid-credits scene shows a dying Nancy's blood pool into the symbol of the Witch's Mark, therefore hinting that the Falconers were possibly influenced by the Shadyside Curse. So, guillotining someone's hands with a paper cutter and sawing another's face to death all for a tacky tiara? Gotcha.


2. The Nasmaranian - Lee Cronin's The Mummy

Lee Cronin's The Mummy
Warner Bros.

The man who helmed the excellent Evil Dead Rise is directing a Mummy movie? Surefire hit, right? Sadly, it's a crushingly disappointing no. 

Lee Cronin's Mummy is in all but name only. The film undertakes the possession playbook with Katie Cannon (Emily Mitchell and Natalie Grace), a young girl with self-inflicted scratches on her seriously sun-malnourished face, who has painful-looking contorted limbs, and who emits raspy breaths. Yep, we've all seen Repossessed from 1990.

Seriously though, The Exorcist checklist goes on. For Regan projectile vomiting, Katie spews green bile after gorging on a scorpion. For the wild dogs fighting ferociously at the start of the iconic 1973 supernatural horror, a pack of coyotes snarls sinisterly at Katie's father Charlie (Jack Reynor), her older brother Sebastián (Shylo Molina), and younger sister Maud (Billie Roy), thus indicating the terrible portents to come. For the demon Pazuzu, see Egyptian demon, the Nasmaranian.

Don't put away your checklist just yet. For when Regan exclaims: "F**k me! F**k me!" to a couple of doctors, a possessed Maud calls her teacher a rat-faced C-word. When Regan does, err, a certain thing with a crucifix, Katie uses the sacred holy symbol to strangle the family's kindly devout grandmother (Veronica Falcón), thereafter launching her out through a window, where she's then mauled to death by those coyotes.

We even get an Evil Dead Rise tick when Charlie visits Professor Bixler (Mark Mitchinson) and plays a recording of an international lecture on Egyptian Demonology alongside a book depicting the Nasmaranian's decidedly devilish deeds. So, that's a Control C on Danny playing a recording about the Book of the Dead, with said book nearby depicting decidedly devilish deeds.


1. Pooh Bear & Piglet - Winnie-The-Pooh: Blood And Honey

Winnie The Pooh Blood And Honey 10
ITN Studios

It was all up for grabs when the cute characters from A.A. Milne's beloved books became public domain in the United States - and boy, did filmmaker Rhys Frake-Waterfield run with it in the most alternative way possible in 2023.

There was a lot going for it ahead of Winnie-the-Pooh: Blood and Honey's release, and seeing images of Pooh and Piglet depicted as horror characters generated massive viral momentum for the low-budget slasher. The premise of Christopher Robin leaving his woodland friends to go to college, resulting in Pooh Bear et al. becoming feral creatures (R.I.P. Eeyore), set it up for something frighteningly fun. Unfortunately, no amount of honey could salve, or indeed salvage, this 3% Rotten Tomatoes-rated mess.

What we're served up with is basically two burly blokes in painfully obvious Temu-priced Pooh Bear (Craig David Dowsett) and Piglet (Chris Cordell) latex masks, causing macabre mayhem. The mute serial killer is a highly effective horror trope, as we've seen with Art the Clown, but their expressionless faces make the acting as wooden as the trees in Hundred Acre Wood. So, the animation scene where Pooh and Piglet burn Christopher's wife's body was a welcome, albeit too brief, changeup.

Remove the masks, and you're left with any one of many eye-rollingly awful slashers found on Tubi. Furthermore, what the blood-thirsty anthropomorphics really needed was a decent dose of dark humour to balance their monotonous murder spree. 

Naturally, the only way was up from such an abominable low, with the subsequent 2024 sequel and other films in the gloriously named Twisted Childhood Universe fairing markedly better thanks to bigger budgets and better effects, with no latex masks in sight! But hey, we all remember our firsts, however forgettable.


Contributor

The name's Colbourn, James - yeah, doesn't quite have the same ring to it.