10 Horror Movie Final Girls Who Actually Weren't

These "final girls" were anything but.

Wrong Turn 2
20th Century Fox

There are few more hallowed institutions in the horror genre than that of the Final Girl. 

For the better part of a half-century, slasher films and the wider horror genre have typically foregrounded one female character who makes it to the end of the movie to confront the killer. Obviously, this isn't true of all horror films, and the final girl can indeed come in many forms, and then there are also times when it feels like filmmakers have deliberately gone out of their way to subvert the whole final girl trope. After all, the final girl is such a firmly cemented facet of the genre that it risks feeling a bit moldy and played out, as much as many horror fans still swear by it to this day. And in fairness, when it works, it works.

All the same, filmmakers can't be blamed for wanting to tinker around with the genre's more formulaic elements, and so one way or another, the following efforts all presented apparent final girls who actually turned out to be anything but, for one of a multitude of different reasons.

10. Angela Vidal - Quarantine

Quarantine Jennifer Carpenter
Screen Gems

Quarantine was a largely beat-for-beat English-language remake of hit Spanish found footage film [REC], with Jennifer Carpenter portraying Angela Vidal - a news reporter who ends up trapped inside an apartment building where a deadly strain of rabies is turning the inhabitants feral.

Angela is very clearly presented as the film's protagonist and our anticipated final girl, but much like [REC], the film ends with Angela being dragged off into the darkness by an infected individual.

Here's where it gets interesting, though. While [REC] had two sequels in which Angela returned, confirming her to be the series' badass heroine protagonist, remakes of these films were never actually produced, and so Quarantine was effectively a one-off that left Angela's fate hanging in the balance.

That is until 2011, when a direct-to-DVD sequel, Quarantine 2: Terminal, was released. Despite being largely standalone, the film offered up a few slivers of dialogue suggesting that nobody survived the apartment incident from the first film. And so, while the Spanish version of Angela was a card-carrying final girl all the way through her three movies, the American Angela was dragged away after a single one, never to be seen again. 


9. Dany Wilkins - The Belko Experiment

The Belko Experiment
MGM

James Gunn-penned The Belko Experiment does a masterful job of sidestepping audience expectations, by making viewers firmly believe that the final girl is going to be Belko's new employee Dany Wilkins (Melonie Diaz).

Given that it's Dany's first day on the job, she serves as a perfect audience surrogate and someone they can easily root for, especially as she's not remotely prepared for the Battle Royale-in-an-office situation that soon enough unfolds.

All the same, Dany smartly manages to avoid unnecessary conflict while proving herself capable of fighting back when needed, all of this suggesting she'll probably end up coming out on top. Dany makes it oh-so-close to the end, but alas, she's suddenly shot in the head by Belko COO Barry (Tony Goldwyn) when she exits an elevator barely five minutes before the end credits roll.

There's ultimately no final girl in The Belko Experiment, with the sole survivor instead being a male employee, Mike (John Gallagher Jr.), who while likeable enough in his own right, didn't feel quite as fleshed out as Dany.


8. Arlene - Death Proof

death proof arlene
Dimension Films

Trust Quentin Tarantino to thoroughly subvert our expectations with his single directorial foray into the horror genre. Though Death Proof is styled as an homage to exploitation slasher flicks, Q.T. has a few nifty rug-pulls up his sleeve.

In the film's opening moments, we're introduced to our apparent trio of leads - Arlene (Vanessa Ferlito), Shanna (Jordan Ladd), and Julia (Sydney Tamiia Poitier) - set to be preyed upon by the psychopathic serial killer Stuntman Mike (Kurt Russell).

Arlene is clearly earmarked as the central character in establishing scenes, cemented by the memorable sequence where she performs a lap dance for Mike in a bar. Though Arlene ticks most of the final girl boxes - including being suspicious of Mike's intentions early on - she's suddenly killed off halfway through the movie along with her two pals.

Mike murders the ladies by crashing his stunt-rigged "death proof" car into theirs at high speed, killing them all instantly. And Arlene arguably gets the worst of it, given that we see a tire from Mike's car collide with her face and shred it to mincemeat.

At this point, Tarantino cuts to 14 months later, where the rest of the movie follows an entirely new set of characters - Abernathy (Rosario Dawson), Kim (Zoe Bell), and Lee (Mary Elizabeth Winstead) - who manage to kill Mike at the film's end.


7. Kim Hammond - Prom Night (1980)

Prom Night 1980
Astral Films

The original Prom Night offers up a highly unique instance of the not-final-girl, because while she neither dies nor is revealed to be a secret villain, she was never actually being targeted by the killer at all.

Prom Night's female lead is Kim Hammond (Jamie Lee Curtis), with the film cleverly playing off Jamie Lee Curtis' newly-minted scream queen status from Halloween, which was released just two years prior. Though Kim is the main character and survives to the end, we eventually find out that she was never really in danger at all, because the killer is actually her twin brother Alex (Michael Tough), was was only hunting down those who caused their sister's death years prior.

It's certainly an interesting way to present the female lead in a slasher movie - on a superficial level, Kim appears to be the obvious final girl, but she's siloed away from the murder and mayhem for almost the entirety of the movie.

The best argument you can make is that Kim is the final girl by default, but if she wasn't ever in the game, can you really call her a player?


6. Sam - The Mortuary Collection

The Mortuary Collection
Shudder

2019's horror anthology The Mortuary Collection wasn't merely content to offer up a compendium of compelling horror stories - it also bamboozled viewers with one hell of a deranged wraparound.

The frame narrative revolves around a young woman named Sam (Caitlin Custer) who applies for a job at Raven's End Mortuary, where she's regaled with three terrifying tales by mortician Montgomery Dark (a brilliant Clancy Brown).

In the third act, however, Sam decides to tell Dark her own story, revealing that she's far from the final girl material she clearly appears to be. Rather, she's a serial murderer known as the Tooth Fairy Killer who kills and eats children, and her real name is actually Charlotte Gibbons.

Charlotte certainly gets hers, though, as at the film's end she's torn apart by the spirits of her young victims, before Dark sews her back together and installs her as the mortuary's new undead mortician - a job which she's unable to leave.

Hands up if you saw any of this coming.


5. Lorraine Day - X

X Jenna Ortega
A24

Even though Mia Goth's Maxine Minx was the focus of the marketing for Ti West's slasher homage X, that didn't necessarily guarantee she would be the final girl, especially as the world had no idea that West was planning a trilogy of movies at that point.

It seemed highly probable that final girl honours might instead be bestowed upon Lorraine Day (Jenna Ortega) - the seemingly most demure member of the porn film crew, who nevertheless ends up participating in the shoot.

Given that Jenna Ortega's profile was blowing up around the time of X's release - in large part due to her lead role in the fifth Scream film a few months prior - it was wholly believable that she'd be the sole survivor, or at least make it out alive with Maxine. But that's not what happens at all. Late in the movie, Lorraine ends up taking a shotgun to the face from geriatric murderer Howard (Stephen Ure), leaving Maxine as the final girl and only survivor.

Ostensibly, X had already been filmed before Ortega shot to fame courtesy of Scream, but had the timing worked out a little differently, it's entirely possible West wouldn't have dispatched Lorraine quite so flippantly. 

As a genuinely surprising death scene, though, it absolutely benefits the movie.


4. Joan Leaven - Cube

Cube Leaven
Lionsgate

Up until the last 10 minutes of Cube, if you asked most viewers who they thought would be the sole survivor, the overwhelming majority would've surely picked Leaven (Nicole de Boer), a big-brained maths student who appears to be both the smartest and most sensible person in the room.

Every other character seems like an obvious victim one way or another, but Leaven feels like a natural leader, helping the group deduce which rooms are safe through her understanding of prime numbers. However, Cube ends with Leaven being mortally wounded by the crazed psychopath Quentin (Maurice Dean Wint), who is himself killed while trying to escape.

Ultimately, the only survivor is the most vulnerable member of the group - Kazan (Andrew Miller), an autistic young man who is seen exiting the cube to parts unknown in the film's final seconds.

While it was sad to see a character as resourceful as Leaven cut down at the final hurdle, the dramatic irony of Kazan being the only one to make it out alive was most certainly worth it.


3. Karen - Cabin Fever

Cabin Fever Karen
Lionsgate

As a horror fan himself, Eli Roth clearly relished toying with the audience in his gnarly directorial debut Cabin Fever.

Of the five college students we're introduced to at the start of the movie, Karen (Jordan Ladd) certainly seems to be the most probable survivor, largely through virtue of being the least bone-headed and most dignified member of the quintet, and also because actress Jordan Ladd is the film's top-billed female.

However, Karen ends up infected with the focal flesh-eating virus halfway through the movie, and spends the rest of her screen time confined to a shed as she slowly rots away. After seeing a dog feeding on her remains, Karen's boyfriend Paul (Rider Strong) decides to put her out of her misery by bashing her head in with a shovel. 

Quite the nasty end for someone who seemed like such an obvious final girl from the outset.


2. Mara Stone - Wrong Turn 2: Dead End

Wrong Turn 2
Lionsgate

Expectations were low enough for the first direct-to-video Wrong Turn sequel that it allowed the talented Joe Lynch to pull off a number of surprises - not least that the film was actually good.

Lynch spends a good deal of the movie's first half establishing reality TV show producer Mara Stone (Aleksa Palladino) as the neon-signposted final girl. She's smart and modest compared to most folk around her - two key traits of the prototypical final girl.

But at the mid-way point, Mara is chased through the woods by the inbred cannibals and suddenly catches an axe to the head, naturally killing her instantly. At this point, our perspective shifts to vegan artist goth Nina (Erica Leerhsen), the sort of character who might be typically ripe for killing in horror movies, and yet turns out to be the real final girl.

Nina manages to kill the inbred parents and eventually get out of dodge with fellow survivor Jake (Texas Battle).


1. Sister Barnes - Heretic

Heretic
A24

The recently released Heretic revolves around a pair of Mormon missionaries, Sister Barnes (Sophie Thatcher) and Sister Paxton (Chloe East), who attempt to convert a reclusive man, Mr. Reed (Hugh Grant), only to end up trapped inside his home.

Reed spends the movie tormenting the pair in order to prove his ultimate thesis, that control is at the root of all religions. While we as the audience are never in much doubt that at least one of the girls will escape in the end, it probably isn't the one you expected.

Sister Barnes is very clearly the more natural final girl of the pair, given that she's decidedly more worldly than the evidently naive Sister Paxton, and that she's being played by the more well-known actress of the two - Yellowjackets star Sophie Thatcher.

But in the end, Barnes is mortally wounded by Reed, yet she musters up just enough strength to kill Reed before she dies. This leaves Paxton, who has shown herself to be far more of a survivor than anticipated throughout the third act, free to escape captivity.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Wrong Turn 2
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.