10 Most Surprising Deaths in Horror Movies

You'd be lying if you said these deaths didn't blindside you!

The Invisible Man Emily Kass Harriet Dyer
Sony

When watching a horror movie, you'd really be a fool to assume that you're going to make it through without seeing someone bite the bullet. Death is as common in horror as jokes are in comedy movies, as kisses are in romance stories, as unfunny quips are in superhero flicks. The genre is designed to make audiences feel unsafe and scared, which is why most viewers go in expecting to see some gruesome kills. 

The hardest job any spooky filmmaker has is to take the audience by surprise with death, since very few characters are safe in a horror picture. However, just because it's difficult doesn't mean it's impossible. In fact, there are some examples of horror movie deaths so surprising, shocking, and unexpected that you'll be left wondering how the hell they managed to get you. 

The following ten films are the finest examples of this, as each of them features a character death that completely pulls the rug out from under you and leaves you speechless. 

--

This list will contain major spoilers for every movie discussed, the most recent being Bring Her Back and Obsession. 

10. Helen Holloway - Cube

Cube Dr. Helen Holloway
Trimark Pictures

It's always fun when a horror movie can bait and switch you, and the character arc of Quentin in the delightful '90s sci-fi horror Cube is a fine example. This movie, which follows a collection of strangers stuck in a high-concept, trap-filled, cube-shaped prison, lures you into seeing this character as the typical de facto leader. He's a macho cop who makes an effort to protect the other characters and seems dead-set on getting everyone out - of course, he's the hero. 

However, as the film progresses, it becomes clear that Quentin isn't as kind as he seems. He still leads the group, but tensions between him and the others, especially Dr. Helen Holloway, begin to rise. Then, that tension snaps, as while holding Holloway outside of the cube, Quentin unexpectedly drops her to her death, convincing the others that her fall was an accident. 

This surprise death served as a powerful stepping stone in the collapse of Quentin's heroism and slide into pure villainy, and you'd be lying if you claimed you saw it coming. 


9. Andy - Bring Her Back

Bring Her Back
Sony

Bring Her Back, the second movie from Danny and Michael Philippou, is a truly worthy follow-up to their smash-hit debut, Talk to Me. It's an arresting, haunting, and downright brutal film that follows a pair of siblings, Andy and Piper, as they're adopted by a grieving mother, Laura, who draws them into a sick supernatural ritual. 

Things are never easy for Andy, who has to protect his sister as Laura drives a wedge between them. However, after getting their social worker, Wendy, on his side, it finally feels like momentum is about to swing his way. Sadly, just as he and Wendy are running to get help, Laura blindsides them with her car. It comes out of nowhere, really pulling the rug out from under you. To make this moment even worse, Andy actually survives the crash, albeit barely, only for Laura to then drown him in a puddle. 

This shocking death is a testament to how unrelenting Bring Her Back is. It's a movie that explores the pain of grief and loss, but shows no mercy to its characters. 


8. Michael Tucker - Death Warmed Up

Death Warmed Up Michael
Tucker Production Company

Death Warmed Up is a delightfully disturbing, horribly grotesque, charmingly low-budget sci-fi horror from the '80s. This New Zealand cult classic tells the story of a very unfortunate man, Michael, who seeks revenge against the mad scientist who tested mind-control drugs on him that forced him to kill his parents. Oh, and this scientist is making zombies; there really is a lot going on. 

Michael and three friends storm the mad scientist's island clinic to neutralise the threat, battling the mind-controlled zombies and eventually taking the villain down. After going through all of that, Michael returns home, minus only two companions. 

While it's clear that something still isn't right and that the evil persists, you can rest easy in the knowledge that at least two of the characters survived the movie. Then, boom, their place is on fire, and Michael is electrocuted to death by a fallen electrical wire. 

This absolutely unexpected death, positioned right at the end of the movie, is a testament to how unforgiving this flick really is. 


7. Keith - Barbarian

Keith Barbarian
Fox Searchlight

So, you cast Bill Skarsgård, the scariest of the whole Skarsgård family, as a mysterious stranger in a horror movie, and he's not the villain? Not only that, he actually gets murked at the movie's midway point? Oh, Zach Cregger, you really are a lunatic.

Barbarian's opening act is a naturally tense setup. It follows our protagonist Tess as she learns she'll be sharing an Airbnb with a stranger, Keith, leading you to think the worst. Who is this man? Will Tess be safe here? What might this guy do? 

Then, the movie flips on its axis as Keith's head is suddenly splattered against a wall by a giant, naked, monstrous woman in a hidden underground bunker. 

To call this moment surprising is an understatement, as it's more akin to whiplash. Keith's shocking, completely out-of-the-blue death perfectly sets up the real horror of Barbarian, moving away from simple, domestic tension to an over-the-top nightmare. Sadly for Keith, it seems that he had to die to make that transition smooth. 


6. Sarah Harper - Obsession

Obsession
Focus Features

The only excuse anyone has for not knowing Curry Barker's instant horror classic, Obsession, is that they used a One Wish Willow to erase it from their mind, purely so they can watch it again. This ground-breaking supernatural flick has taken the world by storm, and rightly so. It's a psychological horror masterpiece, and the horrible, completely sudden demise of one of its main characters is a fine example of why it has made such a splash. 

Sarah is one of the protagonist Bear's closest friends, and a potential love rival for the titularly obsessed Nikki. Given Nikki's delve into possessive insanity, it's easy to see how another girl with feelings for her boyfriend might be in danger. That said, no one was prepared for this kill. 

Whilst talking with Bear in a car, quietly expressing her concerns, Sarah is suddenly interrupted by a crazed Nikki who breaks through the window and barbarically smashes her face into smithereens. This death is so quick and sudden that it feels like it happens at lightspeed, catching every viewer off guard. 

Sarah deserved better, Nikki deserved better, and Bear did everything wrong. 


5. Emily Kass - The Invisible Man

The Invisible Man Emily Kass Harriet Dyer
Sony

The horror of Leigh Whannell's The Invisible Man isn't in the onslaught of a famous monster; it's far more nuanced than that. It preys on the fear of an abuser convincing the world that you are crazy. While the titular villain plays plenty of tricks to make this happen, this totally unexpected death is perhaps the most intense one of all. 

The movie follows a woman named Celia whose life slowly unravels as her abusive ex-partner uses a high-tech invisibility suit to stalk and harass her. 

Convincing anyone about the truth feels like an uphill battle. That is, at least, until she finally starts to get through to someone, her sister Emily, who seems finally ready to take her seriously. Then a knife suddenly appears, floating in the background, before slashing Emily's throat and flying into Celia's hand. It all happens so quickly that it takes a few moments even to register what has happened. But by that point, the damage is done, Emily is dead, and Celia looks like a murderer. 

This movie isn't particularly violent, which makes this quick splash of blood all the more shocking. 


4. Ben - Night of the Living Dead

Night of the Living Dead
Continental Distributing

George A. Romero's iconic Night of the Living Dead may never refer to its hellspawn monsters as zombies - instead calling them "ghouls" - nevertheless, it is the granddaddy of the modern zombie, having created the blueprint for the flesh-eating beasties that horror fans know and love. But besides the walking corpses, another major staple this movie created was the bleak tone of this subgenre. This surprise death right at the end of the movie is a fine example of that. 

Throughout the film, a group of strangers attempts to survive the onslaught of the titular living dead, with one particular survivor, Ben, becoming a natural hero. This character does his best to keep everyone alive, and while it doesn't all go his way, he at least makes it through the night. Sadly, once the cavalry arrives at the end of the movie to eradicate the remaining ghouls, they mistake Ben for one and shoot him in the head. It's unfair, unceremonious, and entirely unnecessary.

In the end, it wasn't the monsters that killed him, just a misunderstanding. 


3. Charlie Graham - Hereditary

Hereditary Charlie
A24

Ari Aster's Hereditary is an uncompromising nightmare of a film, and the fact that it's willing to get its hands bloodied with the death of a kid within the first 30 minutes says that better than any tagline ever could. 

Charlie is a strange but sympathetic youngster caught up in a horrifying supernatural conspiracy. Unlike the typical creepy child archetype in horror, you can feel yourself pitying Charlie, even when she behaves in unsettling ways. 

Sadly, the movie's slow build is kicked up to 100 after Charlie accidentally eats walnuts, triggering her severe nut allergy. Her brother, Peter, drives her to a hospital at breakneck speed, but in the process of getting her there, she sticks her head out of the window and is brutally decapitated by a telephone pole. 

This moment is so out of left field, as Hereditary lures you into thinking that Charlie's anaphylactic shock is the biggest problem she's facing, before switching gears. Aster then makes the moment even worse by showing you Charlie's head lying by the side of the road. 


2. Mademoiselle - Martyrs

Martyrs Whisper
TWC

If you've seen the infamous yet iconic French horror Martyrs, then you already know why it's on this list. This unexpected death is more than a simple piece of shock value; it's the key to one of the most tantalising questions in cinematic history. Sadly, it's one that you'll never know the answer to. 

To explore this death, the entire plot of Martyrs will need to be spoiled, so here's an additional warning. 

Martyrs is a gruesome film that slowly unveils a grand conspiracy led by the mysterious Mademoiselle to uncover the secrets of the afterlife. After doing some heinous things, this vile woman finally learns the truth after the protagonist, Anna, whispers it to her. How does she respond to finally learning the secrets she's spent years torturing people to learn? Well, by gathering up all of her rich compatriots and then suddenly shooting herself just before the credits roll. 

This abrupt demise leaves so many lingering questions. What did she learn? Why did she do it? Why were her last words "keep doubting"? Unfortunately, this antagonist takes those answers to the grave with her. 


1. Terry Chaney - Final Destination

Final Destination Terry
New Line Cinema

Oh, Terry, this character really has one of the most bizarre fates in the Final Destination franchise, because in this series' high-calibre résumé of over-the-top deaths, she was taken out in the simplest way possible: a sudden traffic accident. Yet, despite its simplicity, the sheer surprise of this demise makes it one of the most iconic in horror history.

You're likely familiar with the classic Final Destination set-up by now. Someone has a premonition of an incoming catastrophe, prevents it, and saves a selection of characters, all of whom are slowly reclaimed by Death in convoluted yet entertaining ways. 

Terry's one of the original victims of the Reaper's grip, having been the second main character to die in the first film. Her shocking death comes directly after lecturing all the other characters on how the fear of death won't dictate the rest of her life. After doing so, she steps into the road and is unexpectedly blindsided by a speeding bus, splattering viscera across the shocked ensemble. How ironic. 

Not to put the blame on Terry, but you really should look before crossing the street. 


Contributor

Michael is my name, overanalysing comedy is my game! Anime, wrestling, TV, movies and video games all live in my head rent free!