20 Upcoming Horror Movies That Made PERFECT Casting Choices
These horror movies certainly cast the right actor for the role.
It's often said that 90% of directing is casting, because if you hire the right people to play the central roles, everything else becomes a whole lot easier, and it's simply way harder to produce a bad movie at the end of it.
Many movies make good or even great casting choices, of course, but what about those films that seemed to nail it on the most fundamental level, to the point where you might not even be able to imagine another actor in the part?
That sure seems to be the case with the following 20 upcoming movies, which, from what we've seen and heard so far, have absolutely knocked their most crucial casting right out of the park.
From directors reuniting with fruitful collaborators to actors being cast intriguingly against-type and incredible character actors getting their time to shine, these casting choices all seem like absolute slam-dunks on paper.
As ever, we'll have to see how the entire movie pans out, but in the very least, no matter the end result, the casting department absolutely cooked in each case...
20. Austin Abrams - Resident Evil
Zach Cregger's adaptation of hit video game franchise Resident Evil will star Austin Abrams, and while many initially assumed he might be playing series icon Leon Kennedy, he's actually set to portray an entirely original character - an embattled organ courier by the name of Bryan.
Now, Abrams' performance in Cregger's previous film, Weapons, was a perfect showcase for how brilliantly he can portray someone who is hopelessly, at times hilariously in over their head. So, it's easy to see why Cregger wanted to reunite with him for this role, with Bryan being a Totally Regular Dude who finds himself suddenly fighting to survive an undead apocalypse against all odds.
From the trailer, it's clear that Abrams will bring a whole ton of relatable humanity to the character, which already puts this loose adaptation leagues ahead of every other Resident Evil movie to date, even if some fans are miffed that Cregger isn't hewing closer to the source material.
19. Aaron Taylor-Johnson - Werwulf
Werwulf is the new film from the great Robert Eggers and will star Aaron Taylor-Johnson as the central character afflicted with lycanthropy and who spends his time prowling the countryside in 13th-century England.
For starters, Johnson and Eggers made for spirited collaborators on the director's previous film Nosferatu, and as Johnson will be sliding into a lead role here, he's presumably going to get even more to do. Eggers has proven himself extremely adept at casting in all of his previous films, and with Johnson's own anxiously intense energy, it's easy to see him delivering one of cinema's greatest screen werewolves.
A teaser trailer for the film did recently screen at CinemaCon, reportedly showing Johnson's partial transformation in front of the moon, and though it hasn't yet made its way online, attendees had nothing but praise for Johnson in the part.
If Johnson makes the most of it, hopefully this is just the second of many collaborations between him and Eggers.
18. Maika Monroe - Victorian Psycho
Few actors from the past decade-plus have made more of a splash in horror than the brilliant Maika Monroe, typified by her especially brilliant work in the likes of The Guest, It Follows, Villains, and Longlegs. And next up, we'll see her in Victorian Psycho, a darkly amusing horror romp where she stars as an "eccentric" governess, Winifred Notty, who struggles to contain her murderous urges while working at a gothic manor in the mid-19th century.
If you don't think this is a perfect part for Monroe, just check out the trailer, which shows her demonstrating the full force of her underappreciated, totally deranged comedic chops.
Margaret Qualley was actually originally cast in the role, but it's frankly tough to picture anyone but Monroe in the part after seeing the trailer - especially with her rocking one hell of a convincing British RP accent.
Even mixed reviews from the film's Cannes premiere have widely praised Monroe's work here, so it's certainly one to look forward to.
17. Neil Patrick Harris - The Last Temptation Of Becky
The Becky franchise has banked on quite a brilliant gimmick for each of its antagonists: cast a successful comedy actor who rarely plays a truly despicable bastard, and then have them play said despicable bastard.
The first Becky saw Kevin James play a vile neo-Nazi; The Wrath of Becky drafted in Seann William Scott to play the leader of an alt-right hate group; and now for threequel, The Last Temptation of Becky, we've got Neil Patrick Harris in the mix.
Harris will play Wilhelm Reuss, an aspiring Nazi who intends to launch the Fourth Reich, all while Becky (Lulu Wilson) rocks up in Poland to stop him and his family of hatemongers.
Granted, the against-type casting is a little less jarring considering that Harris did portray an intensely Nazi-coded character in Starship Troopers, but it'll still be an absolute trip to see him play an irredeemable scumbag who'll surely get his delicious, well-earned comeuppance at Becky's hand.
16. Margot Robbie - Attack Of The 50 Foot Woman
In early 2024, it was reported that the great Tim Burton and Gone Girl writer Gillian Flynn were teaming up to develop a remake of the classic 1958 sci-fi horror film Attack of the 50 Foot Woman, and the title role was later announced to be played by Margot Robbie.
Even ignoring the fact that Robbie literally played a giantess in the iconic opening sequence of Barbie, she's certainly got the winning combination of glamour and genuine screen presence to have an absolute ball with the role of a wealthy heiress who gets turned giant by aliens.
It'll certainly be interesting to see how Burton and Flynn reinvent the original story for modern audiences, but with Robbie also set to produce under her own LuckyChap banner, it's fair to say she'll have a decent level of input.
No matter how it all turns out, especially with late-career Burton being rather uneven, in the very least Robbie's casting is absolutely beyond reproach.
15. Sebastian Stan - Frankenstein In Romania
Sebastian Stan has proven himself to be an extraordinarily adventurous performer in recent years, and he seems set to continue that trend with Frankenstein in Romania, a collaboration with singular Romanian filmmaker Radu Jude (Bad Luck Banging or Loony Porn).
Stan, himself a Romanian-born actor, will star as both Victor Frankenstein and Frankenstein's monster, while the story will combine a loose adaptation of Mary Shelley's iconic text with the true story of a secret CIA prison which once existed in the country.
That certainly sounds off-kilter in a very on-brand way for Jude, and considering the impressive range Stan has recently demonstrated in roles such as Fresh, A Different Man, and The Apprentice, the prospect of him playing both the creature and his creator is filled with basically endless potential.
Frankenstein in Romania naturally won't be one of Stan's bigger hits, but it'll surely only further his arthouse cred while establishing a working relationship with one of the pre-eminent filmmakers from his native land.
14. Kristen Stewart & Wagner Moura - Flesh Of The Gods
Flesh of the Gods is the long-awaited new film from the brilliant Panos Cosmatos, best known for his kaleidoscopic horror films Beyond the Black Rainbow and Mandy.
Described as a gothic supernatural horror-thriller, the film takes place in 1980s Los Angeles as a married couple crosses paths with a mysterious vampire and are seduced into his surreal ways.
The central couple, Alex and Raoul, will be played by Kristen Stewart and Wagner Moura, and that alone is enough to pique plenty of interest in this one. For starters, Stewart and Moura are, of course, both fantastic, Oscar-nominated actors, and it's not much of a stretch to picture them having great chemistry on-screen.
More to the point, though, Stewart's casting here is especially fun considering her history in the vampire subgenre per her tenure in the Twilight franchise, and one can imagine there's a certain self-aware element to her landing a part in this decidedly more left-field horror offering.
13. Crispin Glover - The Third Parent
The Third Parent is a new horror film based on the infamous creepypasta of the same name, revolving around an unsuspecting family who are targeted by a disturbing, doll-like figure, Tommy Taffy, who swiftly exerts control over said family.
Considering the popularity of the original creepypasta and iconic nature of Tommy Taffy online, it's certainly one hell of a tough part to cast, but the filmmakers struck gold by securing the great Crispin Glover for the role.
Glover's entire career is basically defined by playing oddballs, weirdos, creeps, and unnerving individuals, so he seems like an incredibly snug fit for Tommy - assuming he's supported by a striking makeup job, of course.
Regardless of how the film turns out overall, there's absolutely no way that Glover doesn't give a totally captivating performance, and one which brings the mythologised character to life in more tangible terms than we've ever seen before.
12. Nicole Kidman - The Young People
Longlegs filmmaker Osgood Perkins is certainly an actors' director, his films having delivered some of the most distinctive work from performers such as Kiernan Shipka, Nicolas Cage, Theo James, and Tatiana Maslany.
Though we don't know too much about Perkins' new film The Young People, we do know that it boasts quite the diverse supporting cast, including among its ensemble Tatiana Maslany, Johnny Knoxville, Heather Graham, and most surprising of all, Nicole Kidman.
Kidman is nothing if not a tenacious performer willing to fully embrace challenging roles, and from what little we know so far about this film, she may well be playing an older cult member who wishes to exploit Lola Tung and Nico Parker's younger protagonists for her own ends.
Perkins is playing his cards pretty close to the chest right now, so we don't know for sure precisely who Kidman is playing, but she's presumably not going to rock up for a disposable, throwaway supporting role; she's almost certainly here as a prominent antagonist.
11. The Entire Cast - Mike Flanagan's The Exorcist
Easy though it is to be skeptical about the "necessity" of Mike Flanagan's new Exorcist film, it's incredibly difficult to argue with how insanely stacked the massive ensemble cast is.
Scarlett Johansson will star as our rookie detective protagonist, but the wider cast includes the stupendous likes of Diane Lane, Jacobi Jupe, Chiwetel Ejiofor, Laurence Fishburne, Sasha Calle, and John Leguizamo.
But that's not all, as Flanagan will also reunite with a large number of his prior collaborators, including Rahul Kohli, Hamish Linklater, Carl Lumbly, John Gallagher Jr., Carla Gugino, Samantha Sloyan, and, of course, his wife, Kate Siegel.
That's quite the exciting team. To see these actors, many of whom have never worked together before, mix it up in a big, splashy studio horror film directed by one of the most celebrated genre auteurs working today, should be one hell of a trip.
Flanagan hasn't ever really put a foot wrong casting anyone before, so why doubt him here while in command of such mighty acting talent?
10. Linda Cardellini - They Know
Bill Hader is setting his sights on becoming the latest comedian to make a successful transition into horror, and considering the huge success he had with his black comedy crime series Barry, it's incredibly easy to have faith in him.
His feature debut, They Know, is centered around a divorced dad (played by Hader) who becomes suspicious that his ex-wife is dating a man capable of exerting a bizarre influence over their kids.
The ex-wife character will be played by Linda Cardellini, who has enjoyed quite the career resurgence in recent years with her terrific performances in TV shows Bloodline and Dead to Me. Cardellini may not have many horror films to her name, but from what we've seen of her recently, it's easy to see her as a note-perfect fit for this part while having great chemistry with Hader.
Hopefully it's a significant enough role that she becomes the next actress to pick up awards buzz for her involvement in a horror film - only to likely be ignored by the Academy, of course.
9. Melissa Leo - The Mannequin
Melissa Leo finally got her hard-earned Hollywood breakthrough with her phenomenal, Oscar-nominated performance in 2008's Frozen River, and followed it up with a 2011 Oscar win for her role in The Fighter.
This made Leo one of the most in-demand character actors of the 2010s, and though her profile has tapered off somewhat in recent years, she seems set to make quite the intriguing return with her new film The Mannequin.
The Mannequin is the latest effort from The Loved Ones and Dangerous Animals filmmaker Sean Byrne, and is said to be a horror-thriller revolving around a serial killer, with the lead roles played by Leo and Lili Reinhart.
Though we don't actually have an official plot synopsis, the film's press release suggests that Leo will be playing a grizzled elder who helps Reinhart's younger character bring down the serial killer. Byrne has singled out Leo's "fearless performance," which is, frankly, enough to be excited about her casting.
8. Margaret Qualley & Callum Turner - Possession
Though there are many, many horror fans who can't quite get behind the idea of remaking 1981's psych-horror masterpiece Possession, in the very least director Parker Finn (Smile) has nailed the casting right out of the gate.
The put-upon couple Anna and Mark, played so memorably by Isabelle Adjani and Sam Neill in the original, will this time be portrayed by Margaret Qualley and Callum Turner.
Qualley earned a whole ton of genre cred with her sublime, Oscar-worthy performance in The Substance alone, while Turner has been consistently putting out strong dramatic performances across film and TV in recent years.
Again, there's considerable skepticism about Possession getting a Hollywood remake at all, but at least Finn will be able to put his best foot forward by having two terrific performers attempting to live up to Adjani and Neill's prior work.
If the film isn't any good, it surely won't be because Finn cast it wrong.
7. Mikey Madison - The Masque of the Red Death
Last year, it was announced that A24 was developing a darkly comedic adaptation of Edgar Allen Poe's famed short story The Masque of the Red Death, which follows a prince who attempts to avoid a plague called the Red Death by hiding out in his abbey.
Though word on the precise plot is being kept tight-lipped, the film is said to be a gender-flipped revision of the original text, with Mikey Madison set to play twin sister protagonists caught up in a world of, and we quote, "orgies, opium, power schemes, revenge and decapitations."
In movies such as Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, Scream 2022, and, of course, Anora, Madison has proven herself a tremendously bold performer, and the eminent appeal of her playing opposite herself speaks for itself.
Curiously, the part was originally set to be played by Sydney Sweeney of all actors before scheduling conflicts got in the way, but from what we know of Poe's original story and this striking new take on it, Madison absolutely seems like the better choice.
6. Lauren LaVera - Man Or Bear
Lauren LaVera is best known for her star-making work as protagonist Sienna Shaw in the last two Terrifier movies, which alone have established her as one of the most iconic scream queens of the decade. But not one to rest on her laurels, in addition to the upcoming Terrifier 4, LaVera will also star in Man or Bear - a film inspired by the TikTok thought experiment which asked women whether they'd rather be alone in the forest with a man or a bear.
The result is a survival horror-thriller in which LaVera plays Alex, a solo backpacker who finds herself joined by a male hiker whose behaviour becomes increasingly erratic. And that's without getting into the bear which the duo apparently also find themselves facing off against.
In the Terrifier franchise alone, LaVera has confirmed herself to be a ferocious and easy-to-root-for heroine, and so it takes virtually no imagination at all to picture her knocking this role way out of the park.
5. Michael Shannon - King Snake
King Snake is the latest movie from the brilliant Take Shelter and Mud filmmaker Jeff Nichols, and will mark the director's first foray into horror, with a Southern-fried supernatural horror romp centered around a young couple (Margaret Qualley and Drew Starkey) who encounter issues after inheriting a farm in rural Arkansas.
Michael Shannon has also been announced as part of the cast alongside Qualley and Starkey, and though we don't officially know who Shannon is playing yet, it seems incredibly likely that he's playing the film's central antagonist.
And considering Shannon's singular brand of intensity, why the heck wouldn't he be? His prior collaborations with Nichols - especially Take Shelter - have borne incredible fruit, so we'll expect much the same here.
Above all else, we don't see Shannon work enough in the horror genre, so it'll be an absolute treat for him to flex his ginormous acting muscles in a genre that plays so well to his sense of theatricality.
4. Gillian Anderson - Teenage Sex And Death At Camp Miasma
Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma is the hotly anticipated new film from the brilliant Jane Schoenbrun (I Saw the TV Glow), and follows Kris (Hannah Einbinder), a young queer filmmaker who is hired to reboot the slasher franchise Camp Miasma.
Kris soon enough becomes obsessed with the idea of casting Billy Preston (Gillian Anderson), the reclusive actress who played the Final Girl in the original Camp Miasma, leading the duo into a psychosexual odyssey.
Anderson has proven time and time again that she's one of the finest actors of her generation, but this film marks her first major foray into horror - and it sure is long overdue.
The trailer alone makes it clear that Anderson is an easy fit to play the middle-aged former starlet, while reviews from the film's recent Cannes premiere uniformly singled out her performance for praise, some even considering her worthy of an Oscar. Whether or not that pans out, it seems like Camp Miasma just might see Anderson enter her scream queen era once and for all.
3. Scarlett Johansson - Scapegoat
Now, in fairness, we don't really anything about Ari Aster's new film Scapegoat, but considering that each of his previous four features have been different twisted flavours of horror in one way or another, it's a fair assumption that he'll stay the course for this one.
And Aster has already roped in one hell of a talent for the lead role - none other than Scarlett Johansson.
Johansson is a terrific actress, albeit one who hasn't really stretched herself much in the last few years, so it'll be great to see her playing around in Aster's absolutely unhinged cinematic sandbox. She's proven in roles like Under the Skin, Marriage Story, and Jojo Rabbit that she's willing to totally give herself over to the right story and character, and whatever Aster's film ends up being, there's little doubt that she'll deliver some of the finest work of her career.
Aster being Aster, though, there's basically no chance the Academy gives it a second look, no matter how probably-amazing Johansson will be in it.
2. Rebecca Hall - A Head Full of Ghosts
Rebecca Hall is a phenomenal actress in any estimation, but in recent years she's delivered a number of top-tier performances in horror movies in particular, most notably The Night House and Resurrection.
Next, she'll co-star in A Head Full of Ghosts, the new film from Goodnight Mommy and The Lodge filmmakers Veronika Franz and Severin Fiala.
Based on Paul G. Tremblay's 2015 novel, the story follows a Massachusetts family whose daughter exhibits signs of mental illness, all while her parents come to believe she's possessed by a demon. And once the family appears on a reality TV show, this strange situation captures the general public's attention.
Hall will play the family's mother, Sarah, the most complex and conflicted character in the book, as she reckons with her guilt about exposing her daughter's strife to the wider world. The actress' knack for playing nuanced, layered, tortured characters is long-evident, so starring opposite David Harbour as her husband John, she'll surely have an absolute ball here.
1. Adria Arjona - Onslaught
Onslaught is the new movie from the great Adam Wingard, and after spending years working on franchises such as Blair Witch and Godzilla vs. Kong, it'll be great to see him back in the more confined, modest genre film arena.
In Onslaught, Adria Arjona stars as a mother living in a trailer park who is forced to defend her family after a dangerous threat escapes from a nearby military facility - said threat apparently being a deadly experimental super-soldier called The Butcher (Alex Pereira).
Adria Arjona has built up an enviable filmography in recent years, demonstrating her penchant for playing gutsy, complicated heroes - especially in Hit Man and Andor - and with Onslaught being described as a "gonzo action horror thriller," it should provide one hell of a platform for her to deliver a ferocious mama bear performance.
Wingard certainly knows how to ratchet up the intensity and get thunderously entertaining performances from his badass leading ladies - see Sharni Vinson in You're Next - so why expect any less here?