10 Albums That Will Make You Love Prog Rock

Opening Your Mind's Eye.

Rush Moving Pictures
Anthem

Progressive music isn't really known to be the most user friendly of genres. Since this is supposed to be building on the foundation of what modern music can do, you can't really blame people for not getting into something that doesn't fit inside the normal confines of pop or rock music. If an artist has that certain spice though, they can manage to find their way into your heart regardless.

As prog has made different twists and turns over time, there have been artists that are willing to bend the genre into something that can be a lot more accessible for what your average rock fan might be listening to. In lieu of your traditional time signature changes left and right and songs that go on and on for minutes on end, these are the kind of prog records that appeal to the mainstream, with songs that work just as well being played on the radio as they do for the seasoned prog head that's looking to dissect the inner workings of the tune.

Granted, these records are not necessarily a walk in the park for the fairweather rock fans either. These are the kind of records that might require a bit of homework before you really let everything sink in. If school taught us anything though, it's that doing your homework does help you grow as a person.

10. Black Holes and Revelations - Muse

The biggest hurdle that comes with prog rock is how much you have to take in at one time. When you have something that's really meticulous from one note to the next, it's going to become a bunch of mush when you try to take that into stadiums around the world. If you want to play prog in arenas though, you make music that sounds good playing out of arenas.

Granted, it's not like Muse is necessarily the most prog centric band of the bunch these days. Going further down the rabbit hole with different pieces of arena rock and electronic rock, they have certainly carved out their own niche. Upon their first arrival on the scene in the '00s though, Black Holes and Revelations is where everything came together, making for songs that Queen would have made if they somehow went into an even more art rock direction than they were before.

From one song to the next, it's almost like you're getting a completely different experience every time, like the power ballad Starlight put right next to the dance funk of Supermassive Black Hole. Muse definitely had the stadium crowd in mind here too, and songs like Assassin and Invincible have riffs that seemed designed to be played only through the massive speakers that you see in the likes of Wembley Stadium. Compared to the other garage rock acts out at the time, this was more than just another rock album. This was a full blown rock opera coming from space.


9. Hounds of Love - Kate Bush

Most of the greatest prog rock out there is normally indebted to classical music in one form or another. Those musicians always loved their orchestras, and it would make sense for bands that write complicated songs to make something that would sound well against a full symphony. And while Hounds of Love is very much on the baroque side of things, the character behind this project feels more rock than anything else Kate Bush would ever make.

From the sheer size of the production, Kate was definitely going for something a lot more lofty this time around, with grand orchestral pieces that make you feel like you're floating on air when you're listening to them. While the individual songs like Cloudbusting could rank among the absolute best that the genre has to offer, this isn't just any old baroque pop album. Kate's got a story to tell, and the back half of this project is an experience unto itself.

Bearing a different title of The Ninth Wave, the entire second side of this record opens up like a full sonic opera, as Kate imagines herself being lost at sea and eventually finding some sort of refuge she can towards the end of the album's run. While most prog bands are used to making albums that take you on a journey, this is one of the few albums that makes you feel like you're watching a theatre production without actually paying for a ticket.


8. Hot Rats - Frank Zappa

If you're making a prog rock album that crosses over, you're going to need some sort of X-factor. Since this is not meant to be a traditional style for the 'normies' to get into, you'll have to win them over through something a little bit more than just a great 9 minute song. Some bring on the hooks, others tell a story, and Frank Zappa does it by just being really freaking weird.

Granted, for Zappa fans, the kind of weirdness on this album is just par for the course, with someone like Captain Beefhart yucking it up on Willie the Pimp to glorious effect. When you peel back the funny asides that you're listening to though, most of Hot Rats is just a nice collection of jazz leaning rock and roll that seems to have a few different movements depending on which song you're listening to.

As you delve further into the songs though, Frank isn't just being progressive in the traditional sense. Anyone can just write a song with movements, but Frank has a lot more under his belt, whether it's putting in a few complex chords here and there or just creating a grand wall of noise with his guitar that disorients you just as you're starting to click with the song. It might not be the most tasteful from one minute to the next (I mean, look who you're talking about here), but you're going to have one hell of a time whenever you throw this record on.


7. In the Court of the Crimson King - King Crimson

In the early '60s, most of the prog rock that we know didn't really have a name. If it wasn't the traditional pop rock and roll or taking cues from the psychedelic movement, most of this felt like it was just put under the label of 'art rock' and was reserved for the ultra hipster record stores. Though King Crimson certainly were artsy for their time, they made the entire world pay attention by knocking you over the head every time you heard them.

While it might not seem as forceful now, this was a pretty abrasive listen when fans first heard it back in the day, especially on songs like 21st Century Schizoid Man, which makes you feel like the world's coming to an end through the sheer blast of music. This wasn't just noise for the sake of noise though, and Robert Fripp knew that all too well, taking the bombastic parts of the band's sound and pushing it as far as he could on every track, whether it was lulling you into a daze or bringing down fiery Armageddon.

Granted, you can still sort of tell where this album fits in history, having the same cosmic lyric sheet that you would see from a lot of the more psychedelic acts around this time. If you're even considering to start with prog and leave this record out though, there are going to be chunks missing from your musical diet.


6. A New World Record - Electric Light Orchestra

Most of the best prog rock that has ever come out is indebted to the classical tradition. Even when people like Yes and King Crimson were climbing the charts, you still had people like Emerson, Lake, and Palmer releasing songs that were straight up covers of old classical pieces that they had decided to expand upon. While they accomplished all of this with rock instruments, there had to come a time where someone cut out the middle man and added a full orchestra.

Taking place almost solely in the mind of Jeff Lynne, A New World Record by Electric Light Orchestra feels like pop with a prog mindset. Across its runtime, you can tell that Jeff's heroes are as much Tchaikovsky as they are Lennon and McCartney, like when he practically reinterprets opera on Rockaria! and brings a lot more soul to Telephone Line with the amount of strings blaring in the background.

This isn't exactly a subtle change either, especially when the opening song Tightrope starts like a grand overture before exploding into a catchy as hell guitar melody. While rock and classical music have always made for polar opposites, there is that middle ground somewhere, where violinists play riffs that would work just as well under the fingers of Jimi Hendrix. Even if Jeff would eventually vanish down the studio rabbit hole as a producer, this is the kind of grand statement that painted him as rock and roll's almighty conductor.


5. A Trick of the Tail - Genesis

For the OG Genesis fans, there are probably some funny looks coming this way right now. Especially with all of the great prog albums that the band made with Peter Gabriel, putting Phil Collins behind the mic is the moment where everything started to go off the rails and go full blown pop, right? Well, yes, but those prog rock chops don't just go away overnight on A Trick of the Tail.

As Gabriel left to pursue a solo career and spend time with his family, Phil's vocals are definitely a lot more user friendly, especially when he didn't have to wear the strange outfits every night. When you listen to the kind of music that they're making here, it's not that dissimilar from what they had on their hands earlier, only given an extra sonic sheen this time around.

Since the band had become a four piece at this point, there's also a lot more room for every member of the band to experiment, with Steve Hackatt putting some amazing guitar fills into the mix. If you also want a reference for how well a keyboard can work in a prog context, Tony Banks delivered a master class on this album, like Dance on a Volcano where it's practically the lead instrument. This was the one moment where Genesis could have sank like a stone, but they managed to actually win their old fans over without Gabriel. The pop years weren't too far away, but the complexity was still firmly in place.


4. Aenema - Tool

Even for being one of the more high profile bands of their kind, Tool is normally the point where most of the uninitiated prog fans have to admit defeat. They might be able to jam to a few of the riffs, but having songs that are tied into the Fibonacci sequence and go on past the 10 minute mark is a bit much sometimes. When you look at something like Aenema though, this is probably one of the funniest prog metal albums that you'll ever listen to.

Granted, it's not like the Tool that we love has gone anywhere, they just seemed to grow up as a band since Undertow, especially with Forty Six and Two getting a little more heady than normal. Outside of the more complex songs though, you also have some pretty juvenile subject matter in there, like Useful Idiot just being a bunch of static noise and A Message to Harry Manback just being some dude trolling you for a few minutes.

And the comedy bit is not even that much of a joke, like on Third Eye where they sample bits and pieces from comedian Bill Hicks and the Satanic sounding Die Eier Von Satan containing a loud German translation of a recipe for cookies. While most prog bands take themselves a little too seriously, you're half expecting the guys to go "ain't I a stinker?" halfway through things. In the case of Stinkfist though, you might want to tread lightly after listening.


3. Moving Pictures - Rush

One of the biggest stumbling blocks that comes with prog rock is that it's hard to really find a hook in many of the songs. Just when you try to grab onto something, the whole song will switch on a dime to something completely different, which makes for a bit of a mess for someone just wanting to hear a chorus. When you've been a prog rock band for the better part of a decade though, you start to swerve into poppier territory whether you know it or not.

As Rush were coming off of albums like Hemispheres, they were getting a little too burned out on the epic material they were writing and tried to scale things down on their next records. While Permanent Waves was definitely a step in the right direction, Moving Pictures was where they started to really pair down the formula and make something that could get played on stations without losing that prog mindset.

There's also a lot of heart between the songs on here, with Neil Peart getting a lot more introspective on songs like Limelight or painting the archetype for the modern rebel with Tom Sawyer, with one of the single greatest drum breaks in rock history. Even YYZ, a song that has absolutely no lyrics, is one of the most celebrated tracks on the album, with many fairweather rock fans being able to sing along to it without really trying too hard. Prog rock always had its fair share of competent musicians, but you're on another level when you're able to switch time signatures and your fans don't even realize it.


2. Dark Side of the Moon - Pink Floyd

For many of the prog snobs in the audience, an album like Dark Side of the Moon is almost a mandatory choice to get people into the genre. This has been a staple of rock in general for years, with a cover design that has donned many a college kid's dorm room in its day. Even with the overhyped factor that some fans give it, Pink Floyd is one of the few bands that actually deserve that kind of accolade for a record like this.

In just ten tracks, Floyd made one of the most surreal experiences that you can have while listening to a rock album, with every single song dissecting some part of your everyday life. While the context of Syd Barrett's absence was still there, you can hear them using that separation as fuel for this album, whether it be showing Syd's lunacy on the last few songs on the record or facing your own mortality in the beginning of the record.

Outside of the backstory though, there's a lot of heart behind some of these songs, using the fundamental parts of rock as a strength. While something like Money and Time might seem basic in themes, hearing them talk about making the most of what you have and calling out the greedy nature of humanity is a lot more nuanced than most people realize. Sure, it might seem basic for the general prog fans, but you sometimes need to have the building blocks so you know how to live your life later down the line.


1. So - Peter Gabriel

It probably wasn't easy for Peter Gabriel seeing his career go south after leaving Genesis. After originally being the star of the show in his strange outfits, he was now back underground while his band was just going from strength to strength with Phil Collins behind the mic. Little did we know that Peter was slowly chipping away at his sound before making some of the most progressive flavored pop of all time with So.

That's not an oxymoron either. Looking at the basic foundations of these songs, they all have the basic construction of your traditional pop tunes, but the devil is in the details here. Working with producer Daniel Lanois, every one of these songs is built with a much more progressive foundation, bringing in session players like Tony Levin to make outlandish sounds like breaking out the funk fingers on a track like Big Time or bringing in world musicians to flesh out something like In Your Eyes.

Even on the more cheesy sounds of the time like Don't Give Up, bringing in someone like Kate Bush to work alongside him is just the kind of idea that blends perfectly with Peter's voice. The subject matter might be a little bit much to take in all at once, but these songs aren't meant to just be throwaways by any stretch. These are the kind of pops songs that you listen to again and again and pick out something new that happens every single time you listen to it.


In this post: 
Muse
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97