10 Amazing Noughties Albums No One Ever Talks About

The most underrated, neglected, under-talked-about albums of the 2000s.

Franz Ferdinand1 I never see my favourite albums on 'Best of' or 'Top X' lists. Never. Okay, that's a slight exaggeration. I love Nirvana and their albums appear on those things quite a lot. Oh, and I kind of like David Bowie, too, and his work gets around. But generally speaking, the albums I (and I'm sure many others) adore and listen to frequently never even get even a trace of a mention. And that - quite frankly - makes me sad. So, starting with a decade that spawned some truly wonderful but highly under-loved artists, bands and albums - the noughties - I'm taking something of a stand. Many of these albums haven't faded away because they had no success. More than a few did fairly well, commercially as well as critically. Others simply live in the shadow of more well-received or popular releases. And inevitably there are some which critics just weren't ready for. But all are, quite simply, underrated, and in some cases, appear to have been entirely forgotten by the majority. The following works are all special in their own way, and I'm not just saying that because I'm biased. Here are what I believe to be the best of those who made few or no best of-lists: the most underrated, neglected, under-talked-about noughties albums...

10. The Von Bondies - Pawn Shoppe Heart

The Von Bondies never quite found the level of popularity they deserved. All of their releases were well-received critically and they even had a taste of commercial success with Pawn Shoppe Heart, and its lead single, C'mon C'mon, which received regular airplay and charted around the world. But sadly, their only major label release has not been remembered well. Driven by self-indulgent blues and dirty, jarring riffs, Pawn Shoppe Heart is an underrated masterpiece of the so called garage rock revival. A particular highlight is an electrifying cover of Try a Little Tenderness as a hidden track (seriously, the album is worth it for this alone). The follow-up single to C'mon C'mon, Tell Me What You See, didn't quite have the same success (although it did have a great video), and unfortunately no further songs from Pawn Shoppe Heart were released. After a number of line up changes, The Von Bondies released an EP and one final album before disbanding in 2011. Best Tracks: Been Swank, The Fever, Tell Me What You See

9. Polly Scattergood - Self Titled

Whilst Polly Scattergood's ethereal debut received mixed reviews, many critics praised her for the honesty of her lyrics and her unique vocal style. However, they all agreed on one thing: that Polly hadn't quite grown into herself musically yet. And if her most recent album Arrows, released earlier this year, is anything to go by, they were right. Her songwriting has matured beyond what anybody was expecting. But just because many of the songs on Polly Scattergood's first offering were written when she was a teenager does not mean that this album should be dismissed simply as juvenilia. It's the sheer rawness that makes it so compelling: the unapologetic emotional exhibitionism, the moments where her voice escalates into an unrestrained wail, the semblance of a real and unique sound despite the obvious room for improvement. It's sincere; and the strong points of the album fair outweigh the weak. Best Tracks: Nitrogen Pink, The Poem Song, Please Don't Touch

8. Nine Black Alps - Everything Is

The Nirvana comparisons attached themselves to this group from the very beginning, and perhaps that has led some people to dismiss Nine Black Alps as merely another rip off band. But if you look very closely, the only real similarity to Nirvana is that they look a bit miserable and use a lot of distortion... This is actually a very strong debut album. It's well balanced, angsty without being self-indulgent, roaringly loud yet accessible. It spawned the hits Shot Down and the brilliant, brooding Unsatisfied, both of which gained regular airplay on MTV. The album has its softer moments too, with the sweet acoustic melodies of Behind Your Eyes and the gentle, poignant Intermission. Everything Is was a moderate success, but it's possible that it just came out at the wrong time to achieve the popularity it deserved. In a period where arty, upbeat indie pop reigned, it's not surprising that Nine Black Alps, in all their grungy glory, were just a little out of place. The band released their fourth album, Sirens, earlier this year, and maintain a solid fanbase. Best Tracks: Everybody Is, Unsatisfied, Southern Cross

7. Be Your Own Pet - Self-Titled

With an average age of just 18 when their self-titled debut was released, Nashville's Be Your Own Pet certainly weren't short of attention, with famous fans including Thurston Moore and The Kills. But their career was short lived; they disbanded after just five years. Out of the two albums they released, this and 2008's Get Awkward, this one was significantly better, but has been somewhat eclipsed by the controversy of the second release. Get Awkward made headlines when three tracks were deemed too violent for American audiences and subsequently banned from the album. Be Your Own Pet is a refreshing piece of work. It's unpretentious, perfectly under-produced and Jemina Pearl's unique howl is somehow charming. If you're a fan of gentle, poetic indie, give this one a miss. But if you like fun, childish punk and enjoy songs about adventures and zombies, there are few albums (or bands, for that matter) that do it better than this lot. Best Tracks: Bunk Trunk Skunk, Adventure, Bog

6. Franz Ferdinand - You Could Have It So Much Better

You Could Have It So Much Better is, quite simply, a good album. But despite heavy praise from critics, like many sophomore albums, it lives in the shadow somewhat of the self-titled debut. Franz Ferdinand had set the bar very high for themselves with their first release, and although they didn't win a Mercury Award with their second effort, they certainly delivered. With You Could Have It So Much Better, Franz retain their unique art-pop sound (and idiosyncratic weirdness), and with the indie classic Do You Want To and the sinister and erratic Well That Was Easy as just two of the album's top moments, they prove that they were always capable of matching the quality of their debut album and then some. Best Tracks: Walk Away, Evil and a Heathen, Well That Was Easy

5. Giant Drag - Hearts and Unicorns

They're the masters of song titles that have nothing to do with the actual song (see: Kevin Is Gay). They're Daniel Radcliffe's favourite band. Vocalist and guitarist (and in later years sole band member) Annie Hardy has gained a lot of attention for her eccentric personality, and has been known to handle hecklers at live shows by threatening to defecate on their heads. Yet, despite a fair amount of attention and generally favourable reviews upon the release of this album, Giant Drag have remained fairly obscure. Hearts and Unicorns is an under-recognised album if there ever was one, but it's also hard to categorise. It combines multiple genres and influences, from the gentle, dream-like shoegaze of Cordial Invitation to the raw, self-deprecating grunge of My Dick Sux. There is also an excellent cover of Chris Isaak's Wicked Game as a hidden track which, quite honestly, tops the original. Giant Drag disbanded earlier this year after completing a farewell tour of the UK. Best Tracks: Smashing, Cordial Invitation, Wicked Game

4. Auf der Maur - Self Titled

Sometime in early 2004, you couldn't turn to any alternative music channel or radio station without seeing or hearing lead single 'Followed The Waves' from Auf Der Maur's self titled debut. Auf Der Maur is a hard rock record which was met with moderate commercial success, but many critics complained that the album was unoriginal and even dull. Some reviewers were sadly also more interested in the fact that former Hole bandmate Courtney Love was releasing her debut album, America's Sweetheart, around the same time. They never got their big chart battle showdown. Auf der Maur is not a startlingly original album by any stretch of imagination, but it doesn't deserve the labels 'cliche' or 'uninspired'. The quality is consistent throughout, with little filler or repetitiveness, and Auf der Maur's voice, sweet and sultry in equal measures, is a perfect contrast to the brutality of the music. The only real weakness of this album is its lyrics, but the songs' concepts are interesting, which more than makes up for it. Best Tracks: Followed The Waves, Would If I Could, Skin Receiver

3. The Long Blondes - Couples

The Long Blondes' first album, Someone To Drive You Home, was a success, receiving excellent reviews and finding a comfortable spot on many of 2006's best-of lists. But 2008's Couples was one of those notorious follow-ups that didn't quite garner the same success as the debut. It wasn't panned, exactly, other than the odd grumble here and there, but like with many Next Big Thing bands, the initial hype surrounding the group before and around the release of their first album had long since died down. Couples is a very different album to Someone To Drive You Home, in that it forgoes the cheery indie pop feel for a more dance-oriented sound, and the lyrics are far more personal; but the quality certainly doesn't wane because of the change. Some critics were alienated by this, and complained that the Long Blondes had somewhat lost their appeal. Perhaps the band on this album are not the same Long Blondes everyone fell in love with, but that does not make Couples a bad piece of work. Best Tracks: I'm Going To Hell, Guilt, Here Comes The Serious Bit

2. The Dresden Dolls - No, Virginia

The only album on this list to feature a song about stealing garden gnomes to get back at high school bullies, No, Virginia was largely dismissed by critics and some fans as nothing more than a collection of outtakes. While strictly speaking this is true - songs like Dear Jenny and Boston were played live for years but never made it onto the previous albums - No, Virginia is so much more than that, and stands up as a great album in its own right. It does not sound anything like a bundle of watery odds-and-sods, but rather a collection of strong, well-developed songs that never deserved to exist only in live bootleg form in the most devoted Dolls' fans' music library. Like any Dresden Dolls work, No, Virginia's sound is sinister, anomalous and sometimes oddly uplifting - and just as good as previous releases. Best Tracks: The Sheep Song, Night Reconnaissance, The Kill

1. The Donnas - Gold Medal

The Donnas' sixth album saw them taking an entirely new musical direction; and not everybody was best pleased. If I remember rightly, Metal Hammer even said something along the lines of 'who the f**k has kidnapped the Donnas and replaced them with The Bangles?' These people clearly can't handle change. Whilst this is certainly a much calmer and more serious album than the previous five, with the earnest acoustic pop of title track Gold Medal and It Takes One To Know One, a scathing assault on sexism with a riff that shows Allison Robertson's undeniable growth as a guitarist, the transition is smooth. They were neither trying too hard, nor had they lost their signature pop-punk sound - which suggests the maturity was not just The Donnas' attempts at being grown ups, but actually entirely natural. Those who criticised this album for its new direction didn't seem to be keeping in mind that The Donnas formed when they were still in high school. They were never going to make music about lusting after cute boys in skintight jeans and beating up their love rivals forever. Best Tracks: Fall Behind Me, Have You No Pride, Friends Like Mine Like this article? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Stephanie is a writer and free spirit who likes to pretend she's a Londoner, though strictly speaking she's from Watford. She likes books, music, elephants, and hairspray.