10 Amazing Rock Bands That Almost Had The Wrong Members

Signs of What Could Have Been.

Krist Novoselic, left, and Dave Grohl, center, former members of the band Nirvana, pose with Butch Vig, producer of their landmark 1991 album
Chris Pizzello/AP

As much as some might like to think it, there are very few bands that are dominated by one person. Even though some might like to play the diva onstage, it takes one piece from every band member to make the magic happen in the best of bands. And when one person feels off, it's going to need to be dealt with fairly quickly.

That's not to say any of the people on this list are bad players by any stretch. Quite the contrary in fact, since most of these musicians have gone down as legendary performers on their own merits. If they were to have made it work with these bands though, the entire history of rock may have gone down very differently, with the entire rock scene having to change on a dime.

Though we might have bits and pieces as to what these hybrid bands might have sounded like, it's probably for the best that rock and roll managed to take its course like it did, with these acts finding their calling with much better musicians in tow. Still, if you want a peak into what could have been, these are some good options as to what your favorite bands could have sounded like. Hell, there's probably an alternate universe where each of these bands actually exist.

10. Anton Fig - KISS

As KISS ventured further into the '70s, the circus atmosphere of their live show really started to creep into their personal lives. With Ace Frehley and Peter Criss really starting to burn the candle at both ends, things got out of hand to the point that the Catman was asked to leave the group. While the band ultimately made the right choice by bringing Eric Carr into the mix, they almost put in a call to the future late night crowd.

Before holding auditions for drummers, Frehley had suggested getting Anton Fig to be the next drummer of the band. It only made sense, since he was the drummer on some of the previous KISS albums when Peter's performances weren't quite cutting it anymore. At first, Paul Stanley and Gene Simmons agreed, only for him to be turned down a few hours later after thinking that they should get a full member rather than just a hired gun.

There was no hard feelings between the members though, with Frehley eventually working with Anton on some of his solo material later down the road. It's not like Anton was necessarily hurting in terms of finding gigs either, getting the gig to be the resident drummer in David Letterman's house band just a few years after his fallout with the glam rockers. Then again, since most fans didn't recognize him drumming behind the scenes in the studio, maybe he could have made a nice Catman decoy if they needed one.


9. Kurt Cobain - The Melvins

Most of the '90s nostalgia has been very kind to almost everything that Kurt Cobain touched. From the moment that he got famous, it seemed like every band that he loved somehow found their way to the major labels, with the Butthole Surfers and the Meat Puppets getting the call from the higher ups when Kurt talked about them in interviews. For a split second though, it looked like even Kurt's band might not have happened if he hadn't failed an audition.

When Kurt was first starting off in the grunge scene, he was absolutely obsessed with the Melvins, going to many of their shows and picking up their albums. Once the word came out that they needed a guitarist though, Kurt was in line with a bunch of other Seattle hopefuls trying to snag a spot alongside Buzz Osbourne. And while Buzz did take a liking to Kurt at first, the kind of guitar playing he used just didn't gel with the more dissonant sounds of what the band was known for.

Time seemed to work out just how it should though, with Kurt becoming one of the most iconic frontmen of the '90s after Nevermind broke through. He never forgot where he came from though, and Kurt made a point to produce some of the Melvins' later material once he hit it big. Hell, if he didn't like the sound of Nevermind, he could at least express himself by helping out his favorite band.


8. Corey Taylor - Velvet Revolver

When Velvet Revolver were first getting started in the '00s, there were probably tons of names floating around to work with. Since these were members of one of the biggest rock bands of the past 20 years, they could have found a singer in a lot of icons, with Ian Astbury of the Cult being in consideration before Scott Weiland joined. Before even Weiland though, Velvet Revolver was originally going to be a lot darker than most people realized.

In the slews of auditions that were happening at the time, Corey Taylor of Slipknot actually came down for a handful of rehearsals, where they started to finetune a few ideas and turn them into songs. Keep in mind, this is also at a time when most fans didn't know what the guys in Slipknot looked like behind their masks, which would be a pretty jarring experience had this version of the band actually gotten some dates to play live.

Somewhere in the shuffle though, the schedules for each respective band started to clash, with Corey having to go back on the road with Slipknot and having to put his original Velvet Revolver tapes on the shelf. Though it's still up in the air as to whether we will ever hear those handful of demos, Taylor has said that it was worth it if only for him turning into a fanboy seeing Slash play 5 feet away from him.


7. Elizabeth Fraser - A Perfect Circle

In most fans' minds, the entire idea of A Perfect Circle doesn't exist without Maynard James Keenan in the fold. As much as Billy Howerdel might steer the ship for the band, not having Maynard behind the screams on a song like Judith just feels wrong to even contemplate for more than a few seconds. When Billy was first coming up with the idea though, the vocals were almost the polar opposite of Keenan's strengths.

As the songs started to take shape, Billy had originally thought of having a female voice above everything, almost to have a sort of haunting quality to the vocals. While there were never actual auditions had or anything, one of the names that Billy shuffled around was Elizabeth Fraser of the Cocteau Twins, who had already earned her credentials at making some more somber forms of rock music at the time.

That might sound like a bit of a stretch considering what we got, but it's not actually as far off as you'd probably imagine. Though something like the Outsider might not be anywhere near Fraser's style, hearing Maynard's voice on the more mellow cuts on APC records like Gravity or Blue is just the kind of intensity that she could have pulled off pretty well. We're a far way off from something like Amy Lee from around the same time, but this would have definitely been a change of pace from what we were used to.


6. Kerry King - Megadeth

When you bring up the millions of what-if's in music, you're more than likely going to get people talking about the possibility of Dave Mustaine staying in Metallica. Although everyone in the band had their demons when it comes to alcohol, Dave just seemed to take it that one step too far and managed to drink his way out of the band. The bounceback with Megadeth must have been sweet, but he could have had an equally iconic guitarist right by his side.

For as many proficient players that have come and gone in Megadeth's guitarist slot, the first one to occupy it was actually Kerry King of Slayer. This was around the time that Mustaine was first picking up the pieces, and Slayer was already making a name for themselves in the thrash scene at the time. As much as King said that he enjoyed playing Megadeth's first handful of shows, he never really had an intention of staying for too long, looking to go back to the balls to the wall energy of what he already had going on with Jeff Hanneman.

The split ultimately ended up contributing to an ongoing feud between Slayer and Megadeth, with Dave having to go through even more guitar heroes like Chris Poland through the '80s. Things may not have been on the best of terms by the end, but if that trade meant getting Marty Friedman in the band for a little while, it's not like Dave was losing sleep over it or anything.


5. Krist Novoselic - Foo Fighters

For a short few months, it didn't look like Dave Grohl was going to play any new music after Nirvana had ended. No one would really blame him either, having lost one of his best friends to suicide and having to come to terms with whether he even wanted to continue on. When Grohl decided to pick up where he left off, he did have a few casting choices to lay down first.

While he played the entire Foo Fighters record by himself for the most part, Dave was looking for a full band and drafted in Pat Smear from the Germs after serving as Nirvana's backup guitarist on tour. Before seeing the performance of Sunny Day Real Estate and getting Nate Mendel and William Goldsmith though, Dave was seriously considering bringing in his old bandmate Krist Novoselic to play bass in the band.

It may have looked like a logical next step at the time, but after a few days contemplating everything, both Dave and Krist figured that it wasn't a good idea, being too close to the chemistry that they originally had when they were in Nirvana. With Krist eventually going into politics, Dave soldiered on with the Foos, featuring a bit of a revolving lineup before finding himself on firmer ground around the turn of the '00s. This version of the band could have been cool, but could you imagine the amount of Nirvana comparisons that he would have had to deal with at the time?


4. Keith Moon - Led Zeppelin

It was going to take more than a little bit of sweet talking to get Keith Moon out of the Who. Since the man is commonly regarded as one of the greatest drummers to ever pick up two sticks, Pete Townshend definitely wasn't going to leave behind his animal behind the drum kit. When Moon ended up talking with John Paul Jones though, his smackdown led to something a lot more interesting.

Around the time that the Who were going down the experimental rabbit hole on albums like the Who Sell Out, Jonesy actually asked Moon if he would be interested in jumping ship to form a new band that he was starting with Jimmy Page. Considering the band were on the verge of dramatic rock operas like Tommy, Moon wasn't willing to let that go, saying that the idea of them playing together would have gone over like a lead balloon.

Without even knowing it, Moon had just given this new project its name, with Led Zeppelin rising to prominence soon afterward after going for a few months as the New Yardbirds. Zeppelin weren't necessarily hurting behind the kit either, drafting in John Bonham and having something even more thunderous behind some of their riffs. As it turns out, the main solution to not getting an animal behind the drum kit is to just find another animal.


3. David Ellefson - Metallica

A good portion of fans who witnessed Metallica's Some Kind of Monster documentary argued that we probably saw a little too much of the band around this time. Even though they were clearly going through a harsh time during the band's tenure, each of the members have stood by the documentary, showing the human side of them as well as the bass auditions that went by before eventually bringing in Robert Trujillo. Long before Metallica inherited Robert's funk chops, one potential standout was actually a lot closer to home.

If you look at the bonus features, it looks like the closest bassist to almost join Metallica was Pepper Keenan from Corrosion of Conformity, but the band had actually reached out to David Ellefson of Megadeth before everything got started. At this time, David was actually out of Megadeth after a legal falling out with Dave Mustaine, which left the void wide open for him to fill in Metallica.

Knowing the history behind each of the bands though, it made sense why Ellefson turned them down, being a little too close for comfort considering how much him and Dave had fallen out around the same time. While you did have some notable names in the mix like Twiggy Ramirez and Scott Reeder from Kyuss, it's clear that they made the right decision when you see the chemistry they have onstage these days.


2. Eric Clapton - The Beatles

Most diehard Beatles fans know that replacing anybody in the Fab Four is pretty much impossible. Even though a lot has been said about the dominance of Lennon and McCartney, every single member of the group made the Beatles what they were, along with the honorary Fifth Beatle George Martin bringing their songs to their fullest potential. For a brief period during the Let It Be sessions, things were dangerously close to turning a corner with George Harrison.

After being fed up with having to compete with the Lennon-McCartney songwriting machine, George quietly sauntered off in the middle of one of the sessions, telling the band that he wasn't intending on coming back any time soon. In the Get Back documentary, you can see the band not taking this well, with most of them getting more and more angry and unsettled until they break out into a discordant jam at the studio they were working in.

Offscreen though, Lennon had originally suggested that if George didn't turn up within the next few weeks, they would consider drafting in Eric Clapton, having already worked with him on the solo to George's While My Guitar Gently Weeps. Granted, Clapton has always balked at the opportunity, saying that he could have never filled the void that George made in the Beatles if he tried. Hired guns come and go in rock music, but what the Beatles had during their heyday truly is lightning in a bottle.


1. Daryl Hall - Van Halen

The announcement of David Lee Roth's departure from Van Halen should have been a proven death blow to the band. Even though Roth wasn't necessarily the greatest singer in the world, the kind of charisma that he brought to the stage was going to be difficult for anyone to beat, let alone a relatively unknown singer. While Eddie Van Halen finally got a helpful tip from his mechanic to bring in Sammy Hagar, the next phase of the group was dangerously close to being a lot more soulful.

Along with thoughts of working with Joe Cocker at the time, Eddie actually had his sights on Daryl Hall, who was already riding the momentum of working in Hall and Oates at the time. Before people start scratching their heads though, you can kind of see what Eddie was going for if you look at what was to come on 5150.

As much as some of the songs fit squarely in the category of rock, the guitar was starting to get replaced with keyboards on some of the songs, which had been Daryl's instrument of choice whenever he played in his main gig. Then again, this is probably one of the times where history worked itself out correctly. Otherwise, we would have had the next version of Van Halen that would have sounded like Led Zeppelin trying to be the Temptations.


In this post: 
Foo Fighters
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97