10 Artists That Hate Their Own Albums

Falling Out of Love.

Nirvana smells like teen spirit
DGC

No one going into making an album is aiming to do a bad job. You’re always going to want to put your heart and soul into every single project you do, but there are always going to be those few that miss the mark compared to others. You can still stand by your work, but there are also some artists who want to distance themselves from it as well.

The passage of time can really change a person, and every one of these musicians despise what their records have become in the past few years, not really putting them up on the same pedestal as the rest of their albums. Even though it would be easy just to put god awful albums on a list like this, there are bands that see some of their greatest work as failures as well, chalking them up to either bad production or just a nasty experience that they had when making the project.

You also have to pay attention to what the public thinks of the record, which has had a heavy hand in shaping the artist’s opinion going forward. You may have thought that these songs were great at the time, but when you release them out into the wild, it becomes a bit of a different story when you see what they stand for. The magic might still be there on the studio version, but the real heart and soul behind these albums were ditched a long time ago.

10. Relationship of Command - At the Drive In

Any fairweather rock fan about to listen to At the Drive In really needs to know what they're getting themselves into. Being fed up with the same genre clashes that they had seen when they were kids, the work of Omar Rodriguez Lopez and Cedric Bixler-Zavala remains some of the most chaotic rock and roll that had ever been put to tape since the turn of the century. And on their watershed moment Relationship of Command, the band never felt like they were able to reach their true potential.

During the actual recording, Omar had mentioned that the entire operation was going great, thinking they were capturing something a lot more primal than what was going on in radio at the time. By the time we got to hear tracks like One Armed Scissor on the airwaves though, Omar was not really happy about the final mix of the record, saying that it was much too glossy for his taste. Although he was quick to praise engineer Andy Wallace (who will come up later in this list), he says that what you hear now is some of the most lifeless performances that he's ever heard of himself on a record.

Which is really saying something considering what we got, with tracks like Cosmonaut and One Armed Scissor sounding like they're on the verge of anarchy by the time they really kick into high gear. For Omar, this could have been something much more primal that what it became, but I guess we'll all just have to settle with this post hardcore masterpiece instead.


9. All Hope is Gone - Slipknot

Every great Slipknot record has thrived off of some sort of tension within the group. We saw it happen when they were on the verge of killing each other back in the days of Iowa and Vol. III saw them really take it up a notch by toying with new sounds that they were just getting used to on tracks like Vermilion. 2008 was a fairly happy time to be in Slipknot, and that makes for absolute disaster if you ask the rest of the band.

After years of being at their wit's end in the studio, All Hope is Gone was described as one of the more laid back experiences in the studio for Corey Taylor, who would often go home to see his son every night after work. In fact, things might have been a little too laid back for the rest of the band, with Jim Root saying that he couldn't remember jamming as a band and fleshing out the ideas together before they went into the studio. Once they were there, they couldn't even get on the same page, with Joey Jordison laying down his drum tracks without the rest of the band around.

That didn't stop this record from being one of the more commercially successful records that the band ever had though, with more pop friendly cuts like Dead Memories put alongside some actual heavy material like Gematria and the title track. It's every band's dream to have a #1 record, but it stings just a little when you can't really leave your stamp on it.


8. Let Me Up (I've Had Enough) - Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers

For most of the '80s, there was nothing that would stand in between Tom Petty and his need to make rock and roll songs. After already going through a massive lawsuit to get control of his publishing, he had kept on delivering just the right kind of heartland rock to merge into the '80s, from the synthesizers of You Got Lucky to the soundscapes in Don't Come Around Here No More. Once the tour for Southern Accents came to a close though, Tom felt much more adrift for his next record.

Going through his main discography, Tom had talked about how he was going through a frustrating time getting this record together, and you can really hear it when you see these songs paired together with different synthesizer parts that feel a touch dated. For all of the more forgettable aspects of the record, some of Tom's best songs of the '80s turn up on here as well like the folksy It'll All Work Out or when he gets more introspective about a relationship falling apart on Runaway Trains.

Seeing how Tom was a few months away from recording his first solo album Full Moon Fever, you can tell that he wanted to break free from the confines of the band on this project. If you listen past the internal drama though, this is the sound of a gritty rock and roll band just cutting loose in the studio.


7. The Trilogy - Green Day

Every single album that Green Day had released in the '00s seemed to be going for a more ambitious sound. By the time they had reached American Idiot, they were looking to make their next few albums big enough endeavors to equal that, with 21st Century Breakdown bringing classic rock into the mix. The only place left to go after that was a three record experience, but Billie Joe Armstrong did have a few regrets along the way.

Looking to go much more ambitious than before, this felt like one big Green Day album cycle, with Uno Dos and Tre all going for a unique vibe on every single project. Once you start listening to these records back to back though, the guys seem to go for quantity over quality, making for some of the most lackluster Green Day songs ever put to tape. When Billie looks back at this though, he doesn't see himself in the most positive light all of the time.

Though this era is defined by this man only asking for a few more minutes at the iHeartRadio festival, Billie called most of these records completely pointless, being much more motivated by his addiction to pills during this time than actually writing quality Green Day material. There's definitely a decent record to be made out of all these tracks, but it's going to take fans a little while to actually slog through them.


6. Be Here Now - Oasis

After What's the Story Morning Glory, Oasis really had lived up to every single title that they had set up for themselves. Noel Gallagher had always wanted to be a part of the greatest band in the world, and by the time they played their massive shows at Knebworth, there was no one else who could touch them. When you're as big as that, you're really tempting fate when you decide that you want to go even bigger.

Then again, time has been far kinder to Be Here Now than it was just a few years ago. While some of the press have called this one of the most misguided fumbles of the '90s, most Oasis diehards see this as the band cementing themselves as one of the most legendary bands of their era, with songs that feel like pop rock odysseys from start to finish. The critics can say all they want to about this record, but it appears that Noel Gallagher actually agrees with the press this time around.

As far back as the early '00s, Noel already had some pretty nasty things to say about his last album, saying that it was way too long for its own good and that most of the songs that he had from around this time were not up to his usual standard. To be fair, he also said that he was out of his mind on drugs during this time as well, so this might have been one of the greatest albums ever made if you were stoned.


5. Ten - Pearl Jam

When Pearl Jam were just starting to make some noise in Seattle, Eddie Vedder wasn't really thinking that he was going to be in one of the biggest bands in the world. Here was just a group of guys playing from the heart and trying to recover from the loss of Mother Love Bone singer Andy Wood, and Eddie would have been content to just play clubs for the rest of his life. A funny thing happened once the grunge wave started to kick into high gear though.

In a matter of a few months, Pearl Jam turned into one of the most beloved bands of their era, with Ten spawning some of their greatest hits they would ever have like Jeremy as well as fan favorites like Black. Though Eddie has been known to stand by his work, he had a particular distaste for the reverb that was used during these sessions, which gives the record the arena rock style bombast that it has.

Not looking to be a part of the corporate rock machine, Eddie used the rest of Pearl Jam's albums in the '90s to deliberately move away from the sound of Ten, like going in a much more heavy direction on Vs. and rarely doing promotional material for any of the records after this. You can have some insecurities about the way that your record was handled, but if you take the arena rock away from this record, it loses 90% of its power.


4. ReLoad - Metallica

Most of Metallica's heavy metal fan base is probably hoping that they can purge the Load era from their catalog. Even though the Black Album was the first sign of fans getting upset of the metal titans' radio appeal, the one two punch of Load and ReLoad made fans really start to question their intentions of trying to remain a metal band. Fans may have been upset at the time, but it only took a few more years for some of the band to feel the same way.

If you go back and listen to interviews that Metallica have given since these records, half the time they seem to refer to it as the 'haircut' album, where the band was given a lot of flak for cutting their hair during this era of the group. Once you've distanced yourself from the experience, you also get to see how tired some of the songs sound, and James Hetfield made no secret about how he was spinning his wheels.

Since the documentary Some Kind of Monster was all about the band opening up to each other about their creative process, James had talked about the ability they used to have for whipping some bad ideas into shape, and pointed to ReLoad specifically as one of the few times they actually did that. For all of its strong moments like Fuel, you can kind of see where he's coming from, with some tracks feeling like blatant rip offs of themselves. There's still some quality material here...you just have to sift through some duds here and there.


3. Their Satanic Majesties Request - The Rolling Stones

There's an old quote from John Lennon where he mentioned how much the Rolling Stones were able to take from the Beatles at the worst of times. Even though the Stones were born and bred in the blues, the songwriting partnership of Lennon and McCartney definitely had an influence on Mick Jagger and Keith Richards, who made some of their best stuff almost to compete with their friends from Liverpool. You can only play catch up for so long though, and Mick felt that the band was starting to lose their identity during their psychedelic period.

Though singles from this time like We Love You feature some guest appearances by some of the Beatles, the accompanying album Their Satanic Majesties Request was a bit too much for Mick Jagger to look back on in hindsight, calling most of the songs that they made around this time absolute rubbish. For a band that was known for their rock and roll swagger, you can sort of see where he's coming from, with the album cover itself looking like a blatant copy of what the Beatles had done just a few months before on Sgt. Peppers.

Mick wasn't the only one leaving these sessions with a sour taste either, as string arranger (and soon to be Led Zeppelin bassist) John Paul Jones calling these sessions unprofessional and boring. After something like this, we almost needed the Stones to make Beggars Banquet, if only to show us they still had that bluesy sound in there somewhere.


2. Nevermind - Nirvana

There's a case to be made that Nirvana's Nevermind is one of the most important records in the history of rock and roll. Since the hair metal scene of the '80s was starting to wear out its welcome for a while, Kurt Cobain created an entire new subgenre beneath his feet, bringing together alternative kids and casual rock fans under one roof to create what we now know as grunge. And if Kurt had it his way, the record would probably not exist like this at all.

That's not to say that Kurt hates the songs by any stretch. During the recording of the record, most of the band and producer Butch Vig talked about how proud Kurt was of these songs and thinking that he was hitting on something a lot more potent than he did on Bleach. When it came time to mix though, Kurt was horrified by what engineer Andy Wallace had done. He had hired him because of his work with Slayer, but Andy's fine tuned approach turned this record into a masterpiece, and KURT WAS PISSED!

For the next few months of promotion for the record, Kurt grew more and more cynical because of how well the record was taking off, saying it sounded closer to a Motley Crue record than the punk rock approach that he was looking for. Since his fans had switched over to jocks on this album, you can see why Kurt went for something much different on In Utero. When you have that much success that quick, you're going to want to run away from it as fast as possible.


1. Let It Be - The Beatles

Once the Beatles broke up, none of them had any intention for the album Let It Be to ever reach the public. Though the band was proud of their famous rooftop concert and some of the lead singles from the project like Get Back and Don't Let Me Down, they figured it would be better to shelve these sessions and work on something even better with Abbey Road. After calling it quits though, their label demanded one more album, and Phil Spector either wrecked or saved the album depending on who you ask.

Known for his traditional Wall of Sound approach, Phil worked his magic on what was mostly a few jams and ballads that they had lying around, to mixed results. While John Lennon thought that the original demos sounded terrible, he was surprised to find out how well Phil put it together. Paul McCartney was not a fan of this record by any stretch, and even sent a personal note to Abbey Road Studios saying that everything should be put back to the way it was and to never have anyone tamper with one of his songs again without his permission.

Even decades after the fact, Paul still felt uncomfortable with the swan song of his old band, releasing Let It Be Naked in the '00s with a completely different song order and mixes that were closer to what he had in mind for some of the songs. There may have been a lot of potential with all of these songs, but it's a shame that the Beatles' final statement will always have some harsh feelings connected to it.


In this post: 
nirvana
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97