10 Artists Who Released Their Best Album First

Greatness doesn't always take time.

Arctic monkeys
Domino

We've all heard of the sophomore slump as well as the lofty reputation of the difficult third album. A debut record means nothing to lose and everything to gain, but the very task of creating, mastering and releasing a handful of tunes for mass consumption is never an easy feat, especially if it's your first time doing so.

Expectations are always tempered with an artists first album, and despite some finding astronomic success with the singles heard prior to said release, the consensus is that the songs that hit digital stores before the album release are never necessarily indicative of a great record.

Artists like Olivia Rodrigo and KSI have found success with their first foray into music composition, and in doing so have carved a niche that each subsequent album will look to improve upon.

Often the heights of album one are never reached again, as artists climb down from the meteoric critical or commercial success that they enjoyed with their debut.

That's not to say that the quality of their work plummeted, however, but these artists soon found out that recapturing the magic is a tough task to undertake.

10. Illmatic - Nas

A rare occasion where music critics knew better than audiences, Illmatic is now widely considered to be one of the greatest hip-hop albums of all time. Nas got it right out of the gate as his seminal first album, Illmatic, released at the height of hip hop's heyday and still receives praise to this day.

Illmatic is as quintessentially 'New York' as Derek Jeter or cream cheese bagels, and though it often paints the city in a less than desired light, it's an honest indicator of the big apple itself, and indeed the man who grew up there. A young Nas is plastered on the cover with an urban city block providing the backdrop, perfectly capturing the essence of the 1994 release.

There's a simplicity in the production value that, with the vast majority of releases would have been seen as a rookie error and a learning curve to be navigated with future releases, yet the way the melodies unfold on Illmatic only places emphasis on Nas' immense vocal ability.

All subsequent Nas offerings were, predictably, compared to Illmatic. Though there are pockets of brilliance dotted along the rapper's decades-long career, none lived up to the bold, authentic and immensely honest first release.

A true classic.


9. What Are You So Scared Of? - Tonight Alive

Although a couple of EP's showcased their talents before the first album hit shelves, Tonight Alive popped onto the pop-punk scene with their first album, What Are You So Scared Of? and with it came 14 top-tier pop punk anthems.

The Australian band, much like every other female fronted outfit, immediately drew comparisons to Paramore, and while both exist in a similar realm of music, Tonight Alive were packed with so much more energy from the get-go. The band have never quite reached the power of the first album, but it's evident that they've come mighty close as time has passed.

Tracks like Reason to Sing will have you screech the high notes with reckless abandon and just a mere two tracks later the album transitions to heartfelt and honest offerings like Amelia. All before departing with the titular track that only leaves you wanting more.

2013's The Other Side is also deserving of unrelenting praise, and refines their sound beautifully. Limitless saw the band take a new direction and fell victim to the 'difficult third album' trope before the band returned to form with 2018's Underworld, and while all were enjoyable, the pleasant surprise of the first simply makes it a cut above.


8. August and Everything After - Counting Crows

Firmly in the mix of great 90's alt-rock bands, Counting Crows found fans with their enjoyable melodies and Adam Duritz' desperate, beautiful vocal ability.

August And Everything After was one of the finest releases of the mid-90's, which is praise enough for the Berkeley-born band. Though their catalogue spans far past the 1993 debut (including new music in 2021), their first outing is easily as beloved as the band itself.

With uplifting plucky tunes like Rain King wonderfully juxtaposed by the tranquil, troubadour-ish notes of Omaha, August and Everything After is a fantastic introduction to a band that is loved by casual audiences and popular musicians alike. In a time and place where artists like The Offspring, No Doubt, Goldfinger and Faith No More were finding their footing with more angsty, youthful post punk-inspired sounds, Counting Crows leaned into something entirely different, with critical and commercial success never far behind.

Before Shrek fell Accidentally in Love in 2004, Counting Crows had already achieved the impossible of creating a truly great first impression, which is a feat that few have been able to replicate.

"If I knew Picasso, I'd buy myself a grey guitar and play."


7. Damaged - Black Flag

Black Flag had existed a while before their first studio album hit store shelves, but with Henry Rollins fronting the Southern California outfit through much of the 80's, Damaged kicked off the band's best era.

Credit alone should be given to the band's first release for granting us a stark introduction to the unbridled energy of Rollins, but while Damaged was indeed a pleasant introduction to the frontman, it was also a phenomenal introduction to their sound. Such an offering was critical in kickstarting --and maintaining-- the hardcore punk movement until Bad Religion truly perfected it with 1988's Suffer.

The fuzzy riffs and raspy vocals are inkeeping with the time. Artists like Minor Threat and Bad Brains were producing similar tunes at a similar time, yet the intensity even of the cover matching the intensity of the tunes, as well as the topical themes of each track makes Damaged stand above the rest.

Damaged became a defining moment for hardcore music, and was a refuge for pissed off teens across the globe, much to the dismay of parents everywhere.

If you've got a six pack and nothing to do, reacquaint yourself with Black Flag's crowning achievement; you'll be glad you did.


6. Innerworld - Electric Youth

Only forming in 2011 but wielding one of the best bedroom/synth pop albums of the past century, Electric Youth have all the time in the world to expand on their already impressive catalogue of music.

The Toronto-based duo have dabbled in creating music for film (which is no wonder since their success was born largely from their song A Real Hero's inclusion in the 2011 film Drive) with albums like Breathing, as well as releasing a full, isolated studio album in 2019 titled Memory Emotion. The latter was fantastic, but their first release, simply named Innerworld, is as close to chill-pop perfection as it gets.

12 infinitely listenable tracks make up the album, which is wrapped in artwork that is immediately recognisable to those who find pleasure in the band's discography. While Innerworld is undoubtedly covered under the 'Synthwave' banner, it's not as abrasive (for better or worse) as Carpenter Brut or Perturbator, nor as nostalgia-inspired as artists like Kavinsky.

Yet, when the topic is raised amongst moustache-twirling music snobs, Electric Youth are always considered one of the best the genre can offer, which is due in large part to their maiden album's unrelenting quality.


5. Hybrid Theory - Linkin Park

Mere whispers of the west coast band's name immediately conjures an image of brash thrashings, oversized jeans and plentiful piercings, with Linkin Park's meteoric* success at the turn of the millennium wrapped in a cultural movement that most 80's and 90' babies would rather forget.

Linkin Park, much like Cindi Lauper, is synonymous with a time. The early 2000's is so frequently categorised by the video game you were wasting valuable homework time on and the band you had plastered all over your bedroom wall. The latter was surely occupied by Shinoda, Bennington and co, which is due in large part to the band's first outing, Hybrid Theory.

The sub-40 minute album was packed with quality, and granted us iconic tunes like Papercut and the utterly unforgettable In The End before ushering in a few more solid years of success before the band --and our hearts-- were shattered by the passing of Chester Bennington.

Hybrid Theory is still the best selling debut album of the 21st century. Sure, glancing back with a critical eye will reveal some drawbacks, but if you dust off your baggy jeans, reapply your guyliner and let yourself be immersed in the 2000's cheese, you'll be reminded of why it succeeded so greatly.

*- No pun intended.


4. Rage Against The Machine - Rage Against The Machine

Rage Against the Machine's stern political views and overtly confrontational approach to social change has always been an essential component of the band's limited discography. While they are known largely for such beliefs, their influence on music is not to be overlooked, however, especially with their first, self titled record.

Zack De La Rocha's piercing, evocative vocals fused wonderfully with the fuzzy, experimental and always catchy guitar riffs, which made even the most ardent of political or social messages that much more listenable. The self-titled Rage Against the Machine debut is the most enjoyable state of the union in American history, even if the message being delivered is near-apocalyptically glum.

Like all great debut albums should, the 1992 offering introduced us to a band that would go on to influence the nu-metal craze of the mid-late 1990's while also providing a frightfully high bar for the band themselves to hop over with each new release.

Tunes present on the album still hold up today, with Denzel Curry's earth-shattering take on festive* single being mighty close to the immense intensity of the original; and yet, it's the four-piece from Los Angeles that still reigns supreme, all these years later.

*X Factor's Joe McElderry won't thank them for that one.


3. Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not - Arctic Monkeys

The seminal debut album from Arctic Monkeys came at a time where British Indie music was seeing a revival with artists like The Libertines, Franz Ferdinand and Kaiser Chiefs were all finding success.

Though all would produce immensely catchy and always listenable tunes, it was the Sheffield-based outfit's 2006 offering Whatever People Say I am, That's What I'm Not that captured the most hearts thanks to its angsty vocals and rough-around-the-edges production.

Arctic Monkeys had a monumental start, and only got softer and more stodgy with age, relinquishing the youthful energy of tracks like Fake Tales of San Francisco or The View From The Afternoon in favour of higher emphasis on 'too-cool-for-school' psychedelic and hip hop influences of later albums.

Turner and Co's six total studio albums all have a deep sense of identity, and while all can be enjoyed if the mood is ripe for the likes of Humbug or Suck It And See, most casual fans will so often seek refuge in the first because of its timeless tunes.

Taking the band from the humble streets of Ecclesall, Sheffield to the bright lights of Los Angeles may have catapulted them to global fame, but in doing so they failed to reach the quality of their immense debut.


2. Traveller - Chris Stapleton

Released three years before Stapleton joined pop legend Justin Timberlake on the tune Say Something, Traveller was country music and beard-aficionado Chris Stapleton's emergence into the Nashville scene, and immediately stunned audiences with his dynamic, raspy and seductive vocal range.

The surprise of Stapleton's exceptional vocals were felt with Traveller, an album that he has yet to match, despite a valiant effort with 2020's Starting Over.

In 2015, Traveller scooped up the CMA for Album of the Year, routing the likes of Little Big Town and the incredible Pageant Material by country darling Kasey Musgraves. There was little surprise as Traveller, while shrouded in grief after the loss of Stapleton's father, was simply a cut above the rest.

Each track explores a new aspect of country music, but the album never lacks cohesion, and avoids the pitfall of branching into so many genre nuances that it lacks identity. Traveller is a glorious introduction to Stapleton, and a mesmerising addition to 21st century country music.

Stapleton boldly stepped away from the Nashville machine, as highlighted in the devastating tune Nashville, TN released in 2020, and though Traveller provided almighty shoes to fill, the Kentucky-raised county boy can only flourish now that the glitzy lights of music row are firmly in the rear view.


1. Sigh No More - Mumford and Sons

Boasting absolute bops such as Little Lion Man and The Cave, Sigh No More rocketed Mumford and Sons from relative obscurity to an Album of the Year award at the Brits.

The London-based outfit formed just two years prior to the pivotal debut album's release. Their subsequent offerings also provoking critical praise (the follow up Babel even won album of the year at its respective Grammys), yet the way in which Mumford and Sons made a name for themselves is a tough task to top.

Sigh No More is a beautiful compilation of tunes that wonderfully showcase who the band are and where they draw inspiration from. The titular singer Marcus Mumford's raspy vocals are on full display on tracks like The Cave and the criminally underrated Awake My Soul is a thoroughly delightful reminder of just how well the band have taken influence from the likes of Old Crow Medicine Show.

Sigh No More's meteoric success had a significant hand in paving the way for artists like The Lumineers and Frank Turner to seek --and achieve-- commercial success. British Folk music is back, and it's due in part to Sigh No More.


Contributor
Contributor

Fan of ducks, ice tea and escapism. Spends much of his time persistently saying 'I have so much studying to do' before watching Zoey 101 for the millionth time. Thinks Uncharted 3 is the best one.