10 Awesome Rock Bands With One Terrible Album

We all have our off days...

I Give It Away - Red Hot Chili Peppers
Warner Bros.

There are few bands who have successfully maintained a winning-streak throughout their career. Some have pulled it off... , Nirvana gave us three unique and brilliant records in their short lifespan. The Beatles had a few less than stellar releases, but nothing that could be considered terrible. And The Talking Heads have never put out an album that wasn't at the very least interesting.

But sometimes it's the case that the greater the rise the harder they fall. When acts are on the road to glory, there's always the fear that somewhere along the way, they're going to hit a pot hole. The success of a really great album can often be a double-edged sword. The pressure to follow it up, can lead to bands delivering absolute duds. Look at what happened to The Stone Roses... Sometimes a group's 'worst' album is only considered so, due to the prowess of records that have pre and proceeded it. Fleetwood Mac's, Tusk, was no Rumours but it was harshly treated by critics for not following the same themes...

These examples, however, are records that have little, to no saving graces.

10. Cut The Crap - The Clash (1985)

Cut The Crap marked the end of The Clash as a musical force to be reckoned with. The recording process was marked by creative differences and internal squabbles - resulting in the firing of co-lead vocalist, Mick Jones.

The title has come to symbolise, both, Joe Strummer's frustration, and the record's reception. The overriding consensus from critics and fans was that it wasn't worth their time. Dirty Punk, delivered on its name but not on quality: It was reminiscent of the group's early sound, but it felt cheap; the mix was a mess, and Strummer's vocals were muddied by all the thrashing guitars.

The album contained all the anger of the group's early days, but rather than it being directed at societal injustices or political policy, it seemed only to reflect the mood of reminiscent felt by the remaining members. We Are The Clash, was a desperate attempt to convince the audience, that the new line up still embodied the brilliance of the original. Instead of leaning on decent melodies and lyrics, however, the group relied on a Sex Pistols-esque chants, which begged for legitimacy rather than proving it.

Cut The Crap, served as a sad goodbye from the pioneers of punk.


9. Sonic Youth - Sonic Youth (1982)

Sonic Youth's unique form of noise-rock, puts them in the category of 'acquired taste'. They had a penchant for creating sounds outside the usual realms of enjoyment. Inspired by the avant-garde experimentation of groups like The Velvet Underground, but adopting the ferocity of acts like the MC5 - who's guitarist Fred "Sonic" Smith, inspired the group's name - they engineered a sound of unique intrigue.

This was a group who took the DIY mentality of punk and post-punk and ran with it. They originally formed in New York, during the early '80s, with a line up cobbled together from a number of club acts. For a bunch of '80s creative-types living in the Big Apple, it's unsurprising they didn't have a huge amount of money. They were forced to use the cheapest instruments they could find. The low grade, tacky guitars already sounded like sh*t, motivating the group to mess around with alternative tunings.

This resulted in an assortment of noise, that although captivating wasn't all that enjoyable. Experimenting for the sake of it doesn't necessarily lead to a good sound... Although, their first record caught the eye of several labels, it's not one you can sit through for long.

The experience, is unique in the sense that it's far from pleasant, but you can recognise the very early hints of the sound that would push these guys to greatness.


8. Anthems For Doomed Youth - The Libertines (2015)

It's rare that a group like The Libertines ever make a triumphant return to glory.

In the 2000s, these guys captured the imagination of the youth; lighting a fire under the British rock scene, with brash, poetic lyrics; sloppy but exciting guitar jangles and a romanticised notion of traditional England. They boasted the confident bravado of youth and a hard living attitude to life. The nervous and frantic excitement, their music elicited, was all the more poignant because you had a feeling, that nothing that burned that fast, could possibly last.

Sure enough, after two great albums the group disbanded. Pete Doherty shambled around with a new band for a while, before disappearing into drug addiction. Carl Barât had slightly more success with Dirty Pretty Things, but nothing came close to The Libertines.

In 2014 they announced they were officially getting back together to release a new record. Pete was clean and everyone was excited. But the album just fell flat. Critics were encouraging, but the reality was, it was just a jumble of old concepts and tired anachronisms. This was a bunch of middle-aged rockers, attempting to relive their salad days.


7. The Spaghetti Incident? - Guns N' Roses (1993)

Wait, hold on a moment, The Spaghetti Incident? was worse than Chinese Democracy? Look, does anyone really consider Chinese Democracy a real Guns N' Roses album? It was a solo record in all but name. And Chinese Democracy is kind of enjoyable; it's weird and silly and reeks of Axl Rose's inflated ego, but it serves as a fascinating insight into the guy's mind.

This album, however, still had the original Guns line up, - minus Izzy Stradlin. For all the wealth of talent, however, it sucked harder than an elephant eating spaghetti. Cover albums are rarely good, and this was no exception. Many of the tracks had been recorded at the same time as Use Your Illusion. The a whole album was cobbled together from whatever unused material was lying around. The band slapped on a few over dubs, and pushed out a record, as a money grabber.

The Stooges, T-Rex and Soundgarden all got a nod, but the compositions were so uninspired, that listening to the renditions, becomes an exercise in trying to stay awake. It signposted the end of the band's creativity. Guns N' Roses fast become the Axl Rose show. Which became more evident, after the release of the aforementioned, Chinese Democracy.


6. One Hot Minute - The Red Hot Chili Peppers (1995)

Some folks might not be surprised at the inclusion of this album. Then again, others might consider some very early Chili Peppers records, more worthy of ridicule. It's true the group's first few albums were by no means perfect... But they exemplified the raw and energised talent of the band. Those early records suffered from poor production, and too many line up changes, but they captured the impassioned charm of a group finding their sound.

One Hot Minute, on the other hand, was an all time low. After guitarist John Frusciante departed, Anthony Keidis resumed his drug habits, and Flea became despondent. Although replacement guitarist, Dave Navarro, is talented musician, his sound didn't jive with the group.

The album represented the personal struggle each member was going through at the time. Many songs were melancholic and jarring. The more upbeat numbers were even worse. The combination of Navarro's heavy grunge sound, with Flea's funked out bass, just made everything sound like Faith No Moor trying to mimic Soundgarden - but not in a good way.


5. The Weirdness - The Stooges (2007)

It's always a risky business when a much revered band, decides to reunite after decades of inactivity. Between 1969 and 1973, The Stooges released three albums before going their separate ways. Although the group didn't achieve mainstream success - during their heyday - their albums had a monumental effect on the punk and alternative rock groups that followed. Those albums, although shabbily recorded, captured the essence of rebellious rock n' roll.

Iggy Pop went on to have a successful solo career, which turned even more people onto The Stooges - making them something of a cult band. When The Stooges got together decades later, there was a huge buzz. But, as is usual when ancient bands reunite, it didn't really hit the same way. One would expect the sound to have progressed, but without the years to develop together, Iggy and The Stooges sounded like a bunch of old dudes trying to relive their youth.

Having said all that, the group gave it one last effort in 2013 with the album Ready To Die, which was nothing, if not a return to form.


4. The Final Cut - Pink Floyd (1983)

The Final Cut could not have been more aptly named: It was the final Floyd album to feature Roger Waters; and half the tracks could have used a trim. During the early '80s the band was falling apart. Waters and David Gilmour no longer had a working relationship.

Waters was keen to push another concept album, but kept changing his mind about the direction. Originally, the record was meant to expand on the story of The Wall. Instead, Waters changed tack, hoping to use the album to berate Margaret Thatchers policies, both at home and abroad. David Gilmour wasn't convinced by the whole idea, which was reflected by his lack of input. The result was an album of confused ideas and concepts, unceremoniously dovetailed together. The record attempted to capture they grandiosity of The Wall but only came-off as a pale imitation. Indeed, many of the tracks used recycled material, deemed not good enough to be included on The Wall.

It was saturated with preachy Jesus-talk, and on-the-nose political sentiment. Instead of coming across as insightful, the lyrics felt like the half-baked notions of a student who has just discovered marijuana.


3. Calling All Stations - Genesis (1997)

It's not just, that this was a terrible Genesis album, it's that this is a terrible album, that used the name of Genesis to sell units.

After the departure of Peter Gabriel in 1975, Phill Collins took the reins, moving the group into a more pop-centric rock act. Prog rock was out and pop-rock was in. When Collins left in '96, however, the remaining members were left without a frontman. Eventually they recruited Ray Wilson to contribute vocals and lyrics. Tony Banks can write a mean synth melody, and Mike Rutherford is a proficient guitar player, but neither have the songwriter chops of Gabriel or Collins.

Musically this album had some interesting ideas, the title track in particular, exhibited qualities of the group's earlier prog sound. But at the same time, it felt like a rip-off of Queen's, The Show Must Go On. Congo hinted at the Phill Collins era, but only for a moment. And, If That's What You Need, sounded like a band trying to bring back the '80s synth ballad, well after it was out of fashion. Ultimately, the album floundered without strong creative guidance.


2. Relaxer - Alt-J (2017)

So remember what I was saying about a band being hamstrung by their own brilliance? This is the ultimate example of that sentiment. This is a band who played with musical texture and subverted the idea of music in such a way as to reinvent the game.

Now, let's be clear, there are some great songs on this record, 3WW and Dead Crush, are both numbers as good as anything the band has ever written. But the true brilliance of alt-J - at least on their first two records - was their ability to perfectly structure an album around seemingly contradicting musical styles and textures.

An Awesome Wave, saw the fusing of traditional folk music; dubstep style drops, and indie guitar patterns- all interlaced with chorale melodies. Somehow they managed to tie in heavy folktronica beats, with tunes played on a child's recorder. It was a marvel. This Is All Yours, proved they weren't a one hit wonder, either. They expanded their sound by imbuing their songs with a triumphant cinematic resonance. Both of these records had an intrinsic cohesion to them.

Their third album, however, was a sloppy mixture of tracks - ranging, from great, to sub pair - all tied together with interludes of half-baked ideas. This all might sound overly harsh, but alt-J can do far better.


1. Squeeze - The Velvet Underground (1973)

This record really has no business barring the name The Velvet Underground. By this time, the driving creative forces of John Cale and Lou Reed, were off doing their own thing. Doug Yule was the last remaining member from the band's heyday, but rather than calling it quits, he attempted to pick up the reins himself.

Yule all but castrated the ballsy sound of the Underground. There was non of he avant-garde experimentation, and no risqué lyrics about sexuality, drug taking or New York's underbelly. Although, Loaded, had seen the band adopt a more poppy sound, the songs were well crafted and memorable. Squeeze, however, was a record of unimaginative drivel.

At best it serves to put you in a slightly better head space, after a particularly potent hangover... On the other hand, all the upbeat melodies and Beach Boy style backing vocals, become irritating fast.

If this record didn't have the audacity to attribute itself to The Velvet Underground, it might be better received. It is in essence a solo record. But the songs fade from memory almost as soon as they've ended. For an Underground album this is offensively inoffensive, lacking any of the challenging edge or charm of the band's earlier work.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Before engrossing myself in the written word, I spent several years in the TV and film industry. During this time I became proficient at picking things up, moving things and putting things down again.