10 Bands That Really Need To Call It A Day

When you've aged out your appeal and are playing the same single from 20 years ago, it might be better to take some time off.

Whether it be the result of lingering egotism from their distant heyday or complete ignorance of any sentiment with which to ground them in reality, the musical landscape is littered with bands clawing onto past successes and yearning after halcyon days where their popularity was referred to in the present tense. Just imagine if music's most luminary figures - your Cobain's, your Morrison's and your Joplin's - were conducting their umpteenth greatest hits tour which sees them reeling off the big songs night after night, year after year rather than bowing out by getting their 27 Club membership card. Would the world remember them with such fondness and reverence? I think not. The acts gathered here should take a leaf out of Keane's book and realise when their tenure at the helm of pop culture is exhausted. Slipping into the integrity-eroding position of the nostalgia act - existing purely to bask in past glories to ever dwindling crowds - is all too freely practiced much to the detriment of a band's legacy. It's a long, slow descent back toward obscurity that could be offset by displaying even a minuscule sense of self-awareness. Each band mentioned in this list are long past their respective cultural sell-by dates and should have taken heed with Neil Young when he sang that immortal line on "Hey Hey, My My (Into The Black)"; "It's better to burn out than to fade away".

10. Blink-182

Let's face it, Blink-182 helped define the era of American Pie films and commercialised pop-punk. 'Take Off Your Pants And Jacket' and 'Enema Of The State' are juvenile yet infinitely enjoyable masterstrokes. 2011's 'Neighborhoods' on the other hand, well, the less said about that the better. Whilst "All The Small Things" and "Miss You" remain surefire crowd pleasers, the novelty of three dudes fast approaching their forties playing songs that spurt the lyrical maturity of a twelve year-old with a comprehensive knowledge of toilet humour, is wearing rather thin. After all, these were guys writing songs about the tribulations of high school well into their twenties; a fact which doesn't bode well for anyone hoping the trio will down the instruments and simply enjoy the fruit of their labours, living the easy life of regular royalty checks after 35 million records sold. Rather, Tom DeLonge and co. seem content in gradually grinding away at their legacy with a continual output of mediocre records that sees the trio joining the likes of Metallica and Iron Maiden in the cyclical nature of predictably recurring festival appearances and upside-down drum solos.

9. Bon Jovi

The masters of overblown pop-rock, Bon Jovi have been churning out blue collar anthems for thirty years in a never-ending cycle of gigantic stadium shows that gross enough to largely diminish the severity of the global poverty crisis. New Jersey native Jon Bon and his denim-clad bandmates present no shame in playing "Livin' On A Prayer" on a nightly basis to tens of thousands of middle-aged mothers who assemble on an annual basis to witness the once poodle-haired arena rockers reel off the classics for the millionth time. New records are released in uniform succession, their songs constituting the live filler placed as a formality between the hits. The well-oiled and impeccably slick live show specialises in the overwrought. It's chock full of generic rockstar poses, the playing of extended solos with eyes closed and plenty of biting lower lips in an intense demonstration of feeling, despite Richie Sambora reeling off his solos from muscle memory alone. But with the Rolling Stones still stubbornly touring, despite their onstage presence as rickety geriatrics, Bon Jovi will unfortunately be rather content in belting out "You Give Love A Bad Name" another few thousands times.

8. Green Day

It's a familiar story: A bunch of snot-nosed youths get together and unleash a tirade of angst-laden vitriol that is a huge hit with a disaffected youth, eventually landing them a major label deal. As the pay checks get fatter so does the band's propensity for pretentiousness. The music loses its edge or 'matures', as the band themselves would say. Before they know it, said band are attempting feats of self-indulgence that would have even the master of self-indulgence Sting grimacing at the sheer pompous audacity of it. Such is the story of Green Day (apart from the Sting bit). As one time bonafide punk heroes, they were adept at inciting havoc and notorious for playing riotous shows that once saw the band survive being pelted with mud for entirety of their set. Gradually, the band has succumbed to the attraction of the rockstar stereotype; frontman Billy Joel Armstrong, once a prime usurper of the socio-political zeitgeist, can now not only be found firing t-shirts out of a canon in stadiums the world over, he has also re-worked his songs from the rock opera and commercial opus 'American Idiot' to the medium of a Broadway musical.

7. Puddle Of Mudd

Post-grunge is a sub-genre that has produced absolutely nothing of any lasting merit. From the horrendous Cobain-aping whine of Nickelback, to the paltry, watered down angst of Seether and the embarrassing mightier-than-thou disposition of Nickelback, it seems to be consumed exclusively by fans of WWE. Every band assembled under the post-grunge moniker lined up to offer their best Eddie Vedder impression whilst representing everything that grunge had so vehemently defined itself against. Puddle of Mudd, a band who are interchangeable with the likes of Creed, Seether, Staind or Everclear, continue to hold onto every last morsel of fame by breaking into 'She Hates Me' at any given opportunity. Once prodigies of Fred Durst, another has-been who should seriously consider hanging up his trademark red baseball cap for good, the group sit on a stylistic plateau of pure beige. The only thing imbuing the band with any cultural relevancy is the fact that whatever bland, characterless rock the band produce, by default it will become that year's WWE theme song.

6. Johnny Borrell/Razorlight

Yet another mid-noughties megastar who has fallen by the wayside into the indignity of a forced return to UK toilet venues. Once upon a time Johnny Borrell had it all: headliner of Reading Festival, supporter of Queen and The Rolling Stones as well as holder of two four-times platinum records. For a time, Borrell even got away with wearing white skinny jeans until people began suspecting they were the manifestation of a kind of indie Messiah complex. Borrell, now the sole original members after his bandmates sensibly fled in quick succession, faced an identity crisis as the world began to grow tired of guitar-based indie that was perhaps a direct result of the dulcet tones of his voice emanating on an hourly basis from every regional radio station in the country. Like most indie bands of the noughties, the band's initial run of unstoppable success was perturbed by a difficult third album; 2008's 'Slipway Fires', which bombed with a veritable aplomb. Yet, Borrell has commendably squeezed another six years of life out of the band, deviating briefly to work on a universally-hounded solo project that saw him shift a whopping 594 copies of his debut album in the first week of release. Understandably, he has returned with his tail between his legs to the good ship Razorlight, who will bless a host of 2014 festivals with their unwanted presence.

5. Liam Gallagher/Beady Eye

Ah Liam Gallagher, Britpop's most fervent advocator of the tambourine and a man who sees no shame in charging fans nearer £100 for a t-shirt that consists solely of an image of his own face. As the helmsman of Oasis, once the face of British music, Liam and brother Noel ended the latter years of the band's career with a succession of decidedly average and uninspired albums. Unlike the equally tempestuous Noel, Liam seems devoid of any inkling of self-awareness, once declaring himself to be possessed by the spirit of John Lennon. With his new band Beady Eye, whose new record 'Be' was described by the man himself as "F**king mega", Liam is content in peddling an insipid pub rock drivel that only goes to justify his penning of one half-decent tune in his Oasis tenure. Somewhat embarrassingly, the new songs are peppered with thinly veiled lyrical assaults on his brother. It comes across as mere bitter jealousy, Liam remaining perpetually incensed as Noel's High Flying Birds project enjoys greater critical and commercial successes. In the meantime, Liam seems perfectly satisfied waddling around in his omnipresent parka and chewing on that same piece of gum that has been stuck in his mouth since 1994. As past-their-peek rock stars with grand delusions go, Liam is up there with the best of them, his extensive entourage dragging behind them an ego whose expansion show no signs of abating.

4. Guns N' Roses

An extended residency at a Las Vegas casino and hotel is probably the most solid indicator that an act has shed itself of every morsel of cultural relevancy or usefulness other than providing evening entertainment for a few thousand tourists in-between extended bouts of otherwise uninterrupted gambling. Rose, who last made contact with reality somewhere around mid-1988, continues to throw his toys out of the pram at any given opportunity and in 2012 he even attempted to ban T-shirts depicting his ex-bandmate Slash from their live shows. His continual urination over the Guns n' Roses legacy means that to all but a few stalwart fans, W Axl Rose and his merry band of session musicians - whose loyalty extends as far as the next royalty cheque - are a laughing stock and nothing more than a pantomime act. The legendarily cantankerous frontman, who now resembles the aged offspring of Mick Hucknall and Mickey Rourke, has successfully elevated himself to the upper echelons of the ridiculous and it seems everyone but Rose himself is aware that he is the butt of the music world's most ludicrous and longest running joke.

3. U2

In the mid-80's, U2 produced some of the era's definitive albums in 'The Joshua Tree' and 'War'. The regularity with which they would mete out anthemic rock songs that bristled with a seething political discontent was rather laudable. But, like the Edge's hairline, the antagonism has continued to recede whilst the band's collective egos have bloated to such volumes that they are transported to every stadium show in individual trucks. Helmed by St. Bono of Nazereth, aka the second coming of Jesus in platform shoes, U2's periodical release of new albums are met by a collective sigh of relief by kids worldwide because, as everybody is aware, U2 albums are always among the most dependable Father's Day gift fodder. At present, U2 remain in a never-ending cycle of mediocre releases followed by tours whose production budgets and subsequent profit is barely fathomable. Meanwhile, the band's propensity for tax avoidance surpasses that of even the most notorious culprits in Amazon and Starbucks, revealing the true fallacy that lies at the heart of Bono and his cohorts oeuvre. Don't be fooled by the ever-present shades and endorsements by the likes of Bill Clinton and the Obama family, Bono and co. are corporate suits masquerading as musicians.

2. Scouting For Girls

Headed by perpetual ivory tinkler Roy Stride and his two other infinitely anonymous cohorts, Scouting For Girls specialise in a relentless scourge of irritating piano pop that resulted in every band's boyhood dream of a mutual promotional deal with the UK's second biggest chain of health and beauty stores. It left their single, the irksomely quirky "She's So Lovely", being piped into every chain of Superdrug in an eternal loop that led many staff to seek counselling. For several years, the band were a continuous presence on every corporate mega-festival, enthralling crowds with twenty minute versions of "Heartbeat" and generally being so inoffensive as to instil a genuine hope that James Morrison would come onstage to liven things up a bit. The band has thankfully bestowed upon the world a greatest hits package of fifteen songs, which is a pretty optimistic act for a band with just eight UK top 40's. Fans however, were collectively relieved that "Keep On Walking", which reached 198 in the UK charts, was included on the disc. Phew.

1. The Kooks

Eight years ago, teens sporting unkempt hair and dressed in tight-fitting Topman t-shirts, drainpipes and straw hats were a ubiquitous presence in high streets and festivals across the land. Now however, sightings of such v-necked and cardigan-sporting youths are as rare as rickets. Yet, small gaggles of mis-guided Luke Pritchard worshippers amass periodically at monthly indie nights in dreary clubs situated in the UK's dullest provincial towns to drink themselves back to 2007. Interest waned after second album 'Konk' mad a ham-fisted attempt at profundity and third album 'Junk of the Heart' disappeared without a trace after lead single "Is It Me" failed to crawl past 160 on the UK charts. Comeback single "Down" sees Pritchard taking his cues from Prince and the results of such an unnatural union are predictably cringeworthy and contrived, although the band have at least stopped trying to write songs as poetically clumpy as "Ooh La". Somehow, the band are still receiving festival offers, presumably as the interchangeable mid-afternoon nostalgia band with the accolade of warming up the crowd for the likes of Ed Sheeran. Should worst come to the worst, the lads could always make like Spinal Tap and decamp to Japan, where their last single "Is It Me" reached the heady heights of 49th in the chart.

Contributor
Contributor

Aspiring music journalist and cultural commentator. Connoisseur of all things noisy and weird as well as anything David Lynch has ever touched.