10 Bands That Everyone Loves To Hate
Music's biggest headaches.
There are plenty of bands that represent the gold standard of their respective genre. From rock to pop to country, certain artists are such experts at their craft that pretty much everything they've done could be heralded as some degree of awesome. Some people thrive at the top of the totem pole, but there are always those musical speedbags we love to take a few jabs at.
For as hated as some of these bands are though, do they really deserve all the hate that they get?
Well...it depends.
Rather than showering something with praise, hate is typically something that comes with the passage of time and can only hold up if it remains consistently bad throughout the years. If something is just boring or just sounds gross to listen to, you can typically get over that, but 'hated' is something that has to stick with you.
Some of these acts even have some genuine talent behind them, but there is that one turd in the punchbowl that everyone just can't get around. Whether they've survived through memes, scars, or just the refusal to go away, these are just a handful of artists that we love taking to court. No artist can be all bad, but given the slogging some circles have given these bands, they can only go up from here.
10. Eagles
On first glance, there's hard to find much to complain about when it comes to the Eagles. Not only were they able to cross the boundaries of rock, country, and soul across their career, but they've also created some of the most classic tunes of the '70s from "Hotel California" to "Peaceful Easy Feeling." Things may seem peachy on the surface, but the real venom comes when you dig a bit deeper.
Ever since the band's first demise in the '80s, there have been many rock fans who cannot stand the attitude behind lead singer Don Henley. While the first part of the breakup was triggered when guitarist Don Felder got into a sparring match with Glenn Frey, Henley has had his name dragged through the mud over the years for not standing up for the everyman in the rock world.
Granted, he puts in a lot of effort to make you think he's a down-to-earth guy, but his stance on the music business and industry at large makes him sound like a grandpa that's too old to deal with these new kids coming up the ranks.
Look no further than the fact that nearly all of the Eagles songs are only limited to Spotify, with Henley making a point to take down any cover or song coverage if he isn't paid for it.
The '70s may have been a blast, but not even the wild fun of Joe Walsh can save the Eagles from Henley's nasty reputation.
9. Dave Matthews Band
If there's one word that's typically used to describe the Dave Matthews Band, it's harmless. While there has been plenty to hate about the man's music, he is still a perfectly fine musician who puts on a stellar live show whenever he comes through town. There's nothing wrong with being harmless, but to hear it from one record to the next starts to grade on you after a while.
Though the band has at least one amazing album in their catalog with Crash, the rest of the group's body of work tends to get pushed to the side as too mellow for most to stomach.
Along with their more soft sounds on record, it's almost like night and day when you eventually go to see the band perform live. Known primarily as a jam band, every single person on stage shoots from the hip with licks that almost feel like second nature to them.
In this case, it's not so much about Dave Matthews himself, but rather with the endless amount of wasted potential at play every time another lukewarm record sees release. You might want to catch that live show at least once in your life, but as far as the albums go, you might want to stick with the classics until further notice.
8. John Mayer
John Mayer has really had a tremendous journey from being pop rock's posterboy. For as hooky and infectious as some of his earlier material was, Mayer has proven himself to be a modern guitar legend, even nabbing himself a spot jamming with members of the Grateful Dead. On the other hand, it's kind of hard to see the talent when you have the foul aroma of douche.
Pretty much since day one, Mayer has always had a wicked tongue when it comes to discussing his love affairs, which didn't really earn him any favors with the rock faithful.
Aside from his romantic woes, the demeanour that radiates off of Mayer tends to be in line more with frat boy attitudes than the rootsy rock he typically gives us. No matter what situation he finds himself in, Mayer always comes off as that one dude in the college dorm trying to use his guitar to meet girls.
While this particular college frat boy can play circles around most other guitar players, that didn't stop many wannabes from trying to follow in Mayer's footsteps, leading to some of the most milquetoast music of the past decade. Mayer has certainly moved on from his usual sound, but his huge hits back in the day may have created a monster.
7. Metallica
Metallica have fought tooth and nail to become one of the biggest metal bands in the world. Say what you want to about their more artificial tactics, but this gang of punks have come a long way from a tiny garage to some of the biggest stadiums in the world. Even though they have reached living legend status at this point, you don't get that big without some type of hate coming at you.
Then again, it's not like everything Metallica has done is necessarily perfect either. The band's material of the '80s is excellent almost without question, but from the '90s onward, it was anyone's guess whether a Metallica record would be amazing or devastating.
They may have won tons of fans with the mainstream crossover the Black Album, but the "sellout" years of Load and Reload left many fans feeling burned. Even when the band was on the brink of destruction, Lars Ulrich's decision to go after file-sharing service Napster earned him no favors with your average metalhead.
It also probably didn't help matters that the record that followed this debacle, St. Anger, is commonly referred to as one of the worst albums in metal history. Since then, Metallica have seemed to be much more in tune with their metal roots, but it's been a crazy journey to say the least.
For a band that reached the upper echelons of the music business, Metallica may have the distinction of being the most beloved and most hated band in the metal world at the same time.
6. Coldplay
When Coldplay were first coming into their own, they had a lot of potential going for them. From Chris Martin's soaring vocals to the Radiohead-influenced guitar squeals from Jonny Buckland, the band's material in the early '00s saw them coming up the ranks as rock's greatest crossover act. After Viva la Vida though, things started to go a little bit sideways.
While the quality of the band's music didn't drop off immediately, many of the rock crowd had had enough of the milquetoast sound they were hearing. The songs may work in a pop context nowadays, but fans of their earlier work have felt betrayed to hear one of their favorite acts become sonically neutered.
Just picture it: you just picked up a new Coldplay record and things start sounding promising on the first track. Then you wait for the interesting part to kick in, then you wait, and wait some more, and then the album's over.
Then again, it's not like the band are bad writers, with Chris Martin still having a firm grasp on melody even on the more forgettable cuts. But at the end of the day, listeners want to hear bands who will break the rules, and as of recently, Coldplay is about as safe as they come.
5. KISS
It's really hard to make a concept like KISS uninteresting. For as straight ahead as some of the band's party anthems can be, every single one of their shows is an absolute spectacle, from bombs going off to levitating drums to a Demon who breathes fire and spits blood for everyone to enjoy. That kind of delivery just screams excitement, but it gets a lot less fun when you see the people behind the makeup.
Ever since the band's inception in the '70s, Paul Stanley and Gene Simmons have each been known to indulge in more snobbish behavior over the years. Though Ace Frehley and Peter Criss weren't necessarily golden, the way that Stanley makes everyone not aligned with his ideas out to be an awful person just speaks to how insecure he is about his own ideas.
While Stanley may have a good heart at the end of the day, Simmons pulls absolutely no punches when making his assholery known, down to exclusively branding his content in interviews and feeling almost no human connection to anyone he comes in contact with.
The band may have written plenty of classic tunes in their time, but the KISS we know today just feels like a bunch of businessmen who happen to have guitars in their hand during important meetings.
4. Smash Mouth
From the start, Smash Mouth was never a band you had to take seriously. As soon as you heard cuts like "Walking on the Sun," the band definitely talent, but no real ambitions to be Radiohead or anything. However, Smash Mouth may have been the first ever victims of death by memes.
As soon as the online community picked up on the inherent silliness of "All Star," fans made it a point to ram it down people's throat for the foreseeable future. It's one thing to pair these down to SHREDS videos or just your typical bad song, but it's another thing entirely when you have "All Star" being linked to a Bach chorale or being mashed up with other great songs from our childhood.
On the other hand, it's not like the band are necessarily ashamed of their meme-y reputation. Ever since they have exploded, the memes have helped keep the Smash Mouth name alive, which you can't say for most of the other less-than-nostalgic acts like Sugar Ray.
While the masses might still know of "All Star," the afterglow of the meme has ended up squandering any goodwill the band's future material has, leading many people to just let it fall by the wayside. There are a lot of great bands who rose to prominence in the '00s, but this is the band we wish we could forget, except they won't go away.
3. U2
There's no denying that every member of U2 has talent. Throughout the '80s, the band made their way to the top of the rock world with albums like the Joshua Tree and Achtung Baby, showing Bono to be one of the best frontmen in rock and the Edge as the next mad scientist behind a guitar effects pedal. The band definitely have more than their share of classics, but it starts getting a little complicated once Bono stops singing.
Ever since they've reached the top, U2 have always used their platform to promote charity organizations and speak at length about the political discord of the times they live in. While it's anyone's right to say what they want when the mic's in their hand, Bono has come off less as an ambassador for a good cause and more like a preacher lecturing you about how you should live your life.
If you're looking for any indication where things go sour, check out Rattle and Hum, where Bono stops in the middle of the song to talk politics, after which he chastises the audience for not being as enthused about the cause as he is. The world at large may in fact be a better place because of U2, but in terms of their political leanings, the man in the sunglasses just needs to know when to tone it down.
2. Nickelback
Out of all the bands known for their mass hatred, Nickelback is pretty much everyone's first punching bag.
For over two decades, these guys have turned themselves into industry giants by catering to the most bottom-of-the-barrel rock riffs of the entire genre. Though they've definitely had a few stray good tunes here and there, the amount of crap they you have to crawl through to get there is much too big for most rockers to attempt.
Whether you're looking at songs like "Photograph" or "How You Remind Me," you can tell the band is trying their hand at blending the hard rock of Metallica with the angst of the grunge movement, alongside a taste of Southern rock and metal sprinkled in for good measure.
While the instrumentation might be serviceable at best, the fact that Chad Kroeger has not really made any progress from his butt rock snarl has left rockers disheartened for years. Along with the more streamlined songwriting approach, Kroeger has even admitted to taking influence from hit songs of the past strictly to get his music on the radio.
Any rocker can forgive a couple of lousy songs, but when you spend years writing songs just to get a profit, even the most seasoned rockers can smell the pretentiousness.
1. Creed
Creed has made quite the journey from being just a menial post grunge act in the mid '90s. For as much as people like to dunk on the band's classic material, albums like My Own Prison showed that there was a little glimmer of hope peeking through the cracks at one point. Once Human Clay came out though, it all went to hell with Scott Stapp's yarling.
It's not like the talent isn't there though, with the rest of the band's later work with Alter Bridge making for some of the greatest hard rock of the past decade. However, the overarching plight of Stapp has kneecapped pretty much every single song the band has ever put out.
Though there were a few shots taken at Stapp's Christian rock lyrics, but the real problems have less to do with the message and all to do with the macho affectation that Eddie Vedder already had trademarked.
It's alright to be open about positive themes in your music, but when your music is this lacklustre, you're left with a lot of great pieces that make for a grotesque whole. There are probably far less talented bands out there, but for as big as they were, Creed is the sound of rock from the perspective of someone who has never heard rock before.