10 Bands Who Had Terrible Names Before They Were Successful
Limp Bizkit might not seem like the best name in the world, but it could have been much, much worse.
How important is a band's name?
"It sound like a first band name, doesn’t it? It’s so bad that the tribute bands don’t sound worse."
That quote is from the vocalist of a band who, let's say, aren't doing too badly - Alex Turner of Arctic Monkeys, speaking with Q Magazine back in 2011.
Now, we're undoubtedly way too far down the line for an Arctic Monkeys rebrand, and you'd likely argue that either the name of Arctic Monkeys doesn't matter, or that it's been beneficial by differentiating them in a crowded market - but what about bands who have changed their names?
To make things clear, that's not just Panic! At The Disco becoming Panic At The Disco - although Brendan Urie's previous band name of "Pet Salamander" may have been a contender for this list had there not been ten other terrible, silly and sometimes downright offensive titles to present.
Following the recent renaming of Slaves to Soft Play, complete with an apology and calling their previous name "an issue", let's look at some bands who managed to make the decision early enough to change their names for the better.
It'll be left to you to ponder over the importance of a band name and whether the previous monikers may have been a hindrance to their success had they not made the switch...
10. Def Leppard
Well, where better to start than with the notoriously misspelt Def Leppard?
Don't worry, we're not suggesting the name "Deaf Leopard". Despite that being a suggestion at one point, the band was actually previously called Atomic Mass.
Atomic Mass formed in Tapton School, Sheffield in 1976 with Pete Doubleday on guitar, Rick Savage on bass and Tony Kenning on drums, with Pete Willis also joining on guitar, Andy Nicholas on bass and Nick Mackley on lead vocals.
A handful of other members came and went, before an 18-year-old Joe Elliott auditioned to become a guitarist following a chance meeting with Pete Willis after missing his bus. It was decided Elliott would become the band's vocalist instead, and he proposed a name change to Deaf Leopard - which he'd thought of when drawing band posters in art class.
Drummer Tony Kenning suggested a modification to Def Leppard so as to not be confused for a punk band, however he left the group abruptly before the recording of 'The Def Leppard E.P'.
A 15-year-old Rick Allen joined shortly thereafter and the band's big break came from 'Getcha Rocks Off' getting major airplay before debut album On Through the Night saw the outfit become one of the most polarising in rock.
Of course, what followed was more line-up changes as Phil Collen entered the fray, and seminal albums 'Pyromania' and 'Hysteria' sky-rocketed the band to success. Almost 40 years after their breakthrough, those spots haven't changed with Def Leppard remaining one of the biggest bands in rock!
9. Pink Floyd
"Pink Floyd" may not scream amazing band name, but it's hard to imagine the world's most-renowned and coveted psychedelic and progressive rock band being known as anything else.
If you came across an album called "Dark Side of the Moo", you'd be certain someone had made a typo. However, if you then spotted that the album had a cow on the front, ala Atom Heart Mother, and had been released by "The Screaming Abdabs", well, you'd probably chalk it up to a joke, put the vinyl down and walk away.
However, you'd have just discarded an unofficial bootleg released in 1986 by Pink Floyd. The album was released on an anonymous label known as Trixie Recorded under the name "The Screaming Abdabs" in order to fly under the radar, the name was actually a nod to one of the band's previous monikers.
'Dark Side of the Moo' wasn't the only "release" by The Screaming Abdabs, though, with the band seemingly feeling fondness towards the name, using it for several unofficial releases as opposed to any of their earlier names - Sigma 6, the Spectrum 5, The Meggadeaths, The Adbabs, and The Tea Set.
Pink Floyd, of course, are known to be one of the most aesthetically and aurally pleasing bands - being huge merch-shifters to this day - but it's so hard to imagine all of those wonderfully iconic Storm Thorgerson artworks on t-shirts and prints being adorned around the globe with "Screaming Abdabs" written on them.
8. Lamb Of God
Lamb of God may already be viewed as a blasphemous band name by some, even getting them banned from performing at venues, but it could have been so much worse.
At the band's inception in 1994, Josh Campbell, Chris Adler, Matt Conner and Mark Morton chose to be called 'Burn the Priest' - initially performing as an instrumental quartet before adding vocalist Randy Blythe.
Not only did Burn the Priest release several demos and EPs, they were signed to Legion Records and released a full-length, self-titled album under the moniker. However, a line-up change seemed to usher in a new era for the metal legends and the band would christen themselves 'Lamb of God' shortly before the turn of the millennium.
'Lamb of God' is taken from the Gospel of John, where John the Baptist proclaims Jesus Christ as "the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world" - and not merely a reference to the meaning of Agnes Skinner's forename.
Shortly thereafter, Randy Blythe mentioned the name change would, for people hearing it for the first time, be "a little less of a sledgehammer to the face" and help the Virginia rockers avoid being mistaken for a satanic metal band.
"You're automatically stamped with 'Evil' on your forehead with a name like Burn the Priest."
Ironically, folklore suggests the name change was a result of the band being banned from venues, but those bans actually came thereafter - as bassist John Campbell confirmed to Metalship in 2012.
7. KISS
Well, this might feel like a drop in pace after the last entrant, and KISS may not be the greatest name on the planet, but could you imagine if the band whose bass player chops his own tongue off every night on stage were called... Wicked Lester?
Originally formed by Gene Klein - aka Gene Simmons - Brooke Ostrander and Stephen Coronel in 1970, the band were soon joined by Stanley Eisen - aka Paul Stanley - who had previously failed an audition.
After recruiting drummer Joe Davidson, the band formed as Rainbow. No, not that one.
To avoid confusion, the outfit soon became Wicked Lester, which sounds like a vegan alternative to a famous British cheese. Their brief existence saw the band only perform as Wicked Lester twice before disbanding in 1972 due to a lack of direction and vision. Although, just months later, Klein and Eisen - now known as Simmons and Stanley - revived the group with a new drummer and guitarist to form KISS.
KISS were named when new drummer Peter Criss mentioned he'd been in a band called Lips, which prompted Paul Stanley to suggest KISS.
While Wicked Lester may not be the worst name on the planet, it's hard to imagine KISS being called anything else - maybe, in part, due to how monumental the band have become, both in terms of their live shows and their image making them one of the biggest bands in rock over the past 50 years.
6. Black Sabbath
When you think of Black Sabbath, you instantly think of the Prince of Darkness himself, Ozzy Osbourne, and a band who have staked their claim as pioneers of metal music, but there's nothing too metal sounding about 'The Polka Tulk Blues Band'.
While the name in itself is pretty bad, its origins are reportedly even worse, with suggestions it was either taken from a brand of talcum powder or a traditional Asian clothing shop. While Ozzy, Tony Iommi, Geezer Butler and Bill Ward called themselves 'The Polka Tulk Blues Band' upon their formation in 1968, there's no doubt they'd have sounded slightly different due to having a slide guitarist and a saxophonist in their midst at that time, too.
Following the departure of those two members, the band changed its name to 'Earth'. However, as another English group had that moniker, they decided to switch it out. As luck would have it, the cinema across from their rehearsal room was showing the 1963 movie Black Sabbath, that name changed again, and the group were set on their path to metal infamy.
Oh, how different life could have been though if Ozzy Osbourne had been fronting The Polka Tulk Blues Band, although the possibilities are endless if that cinema had been showing another 1963 movie at that time...
That said, The Haunting and Billy Liar don't sound too bad, but you may not be so enthusiastic about seeing a band called Jason and The Argonauts or The Sword in the Stone!
5. Creed
Now, imagine hearing a band live and asking, "Who is that?", then hearing a name that there's absolutely no chance anyone of sound mind could Google... or go into a record shop to ask for... or request from a DJ... or just say out loud.
That's what you have here, as Creed were originally named 'Naked Toddler'.
Founding member, vocalist - and the only member of the band not to join Alter Bridge - Scott Stapp wrote in his 2012 book Sinner's Creed that the band first performed as 'Naked Toddler' at Yianni's in Tallahassee, which was a name picked up by guitar virtuoso Tremonti from a headline in that day's newspaper.
The reaction that night to the name was, rather predictably, a negative one, and a name change was decided. Brian Marshall said he had been in a band called Mattox Creed. Stapp latched onto the Creed part, and the group agreed.
Thankfully that name change came before debut album 'My Own Prison' and the band's rise to fame, although arguably that second part may never have arrived had the outfit stuck with their original title.
Creed disbanded in 2004 before reuniting in 2009, which was followed by another hiatus in 2013. Ten years on and the band have confirmed another reunion for 2023, although Tremonti, Philips and Marshall have been a constant in Alter Bridge for the entirety of that time since 2004.
4. The Goo Goo Dolls
The Goo Goo Dolls are best-known for heartfelt, poignant ballad Iris, but would that song have the same effect and success if it were by a band called 'Sex Maggot'?
The group do come from punk origins and have a song called Sex Maggot, having been forced to change their moniker from that when a club owner refused to promote them under the name.
While it's hard to come across any evidence of the band's previous moniker aside from decade-old interviews - many of which proclaim the name would have been The Sex Maggots - some old material has found its way onto YouTube, including original versions of the songs Sex Maggot and Humble Me.
A name change came after the band flicked through a copy of True Detective magazine and saw an advertisement for a Goo Goo Doll. Still, bassist and vocalist Robby Takac wasn't sold on the new name either, as he stated in an interview back in 1999.
"The first name was bad, so we moved on to another bad name, got 15,000 fans, and were afraid to change it … At the time, we thought [the name] was just really inappropriate for what we were doing in that post-punk era that we were sort of wallowing around in.”
Ironically, one of the band's breakthrough singles was actually called 'Name', with with guitarist and vocalist John Rzeznic later saying in 2022 that he doesn't actually recall how they came up with the 'Goo Goo Dolls' and regrets the current iteration.
3. Green Day
After the earlier entry on the list of Creed previously being known as 'Naked Toddler', Green Day's former name seems much more innocent and palatable.
Pre-1989, and pre-Tre Cool, Billie Joe Armstrong and Mike Dirnt's band that would go on to become Green Day were simply called 'Sweet Children'. Of course, the iconic drummer's addition - and name change - would come shortly after, filling in for the band in 1990 when he was then drumming for The Lookouts.
The name was only changed to avoid confusion with another local band named Sweet Baby, and the band's penchant for cannabis meant they adopted the name Green Day; a slang term in the bay area for a day spent doing two things: smoking marijuana and procrastinating. Although, even Billie Joe Armstrong later professed that he would later think the name was "the worst band name in the world."
Green Day may be one of the key arguments in a conversation around why a band name isn't too important when you look into the concoction of what makes any musical group or artist successful.
The name 'Sweet Children' would go on to be used for an EP released by the band in 1990 shortly after the release of debut album 39/Smooth, but has all been forgotten 30 years later. That said, of all the entrants on this list, Sweet Children may be the least unlikely to have been a hindrance had the band not gone on to become Green Day.
2. Red Hot Chili Peppers
If there was an award for the least catchy name ever, Red Hot Chili Peppers would win it for their previous moniker: 'Tony Flow and the Miraculously Majestic Masters of Mayhem'!
Just rolls off the tongue, doesn't it?
While Red Hot Chili Peppers may be one of the longest names in rock music, any journalist trying to fill their word count would be delighted to come across RHCP's moniker between 1982 and '83, which we'll just call 'Tony Flow' for now.
The band - made of up Anthony Kiedis, Flea, Hillel Slovak and Jack Irons - first performed at the Rhythm Lounge to a modest crowd of 30, which saw them open for Gary and Neighbor's Voices with a largely improvised set that included a poem from Kiedis called 'Out in LA'.
Thankfully, their name change came in 1984 with the release of debut album The Red Hot Chili Peppers, and the group have undergone a few line-up changes with John Frusciante and Chad Smith ultimately joining Kiedis and Flea.
The funk rock legends have never looked back and have gone on to become one of the biggest rock bands on the planet; although you do wonder just how posters and t-shirts may look had the band stuck with the moniker of Tony Flow and the Miraculously Majestic Masters of Mayhem!
1. Limp Bizkit
You may wonder how one possibly tops names like Tony Flow and the Miraculously Majestic Masters of Mayhem, and Naked Toddler. Well, ladies and gentlemen, please get on your feet and give a round of applause for...
Blood Fart.
Yep, as if Limp Bizkit wasn't one of the most bizarre names to ever grace the music industry, the band were almost named Blood Fart. Although it doesn't stop there, as more whacky suggestions were discarded in favour of Limp Bizkit.
Fred Durst and Co. had a list of not one, but four names that could easily have topped this list: Gimp Disco, Split D**kslit, B*tch Piglet, and Blood Fart. While the band pitched those names to record labels with the full intention of carrying on, each one that showed interest put pressure on the group to change their name.
According to Durst, "The name is there to turn people's heads away. A lot of people pick up the disc and go, 'Limp Bizkit. Oh, they must suck.' Those are the people that we don't even want listening to our music."
Despite Durst's seemingly best intentions to keep the band as niche as possible, they went on to be one of a select few that define the nu-metal genre and inspired a new generation of rap metal. Even then, who knows if they reached their full potential? You can only imagine the mainstream success a band called Split D**kslit might have.