10 Best Alternative Rock Bands Of All Time

When the alternative is the best option, featuring Nirvana, blink-182, and more...

Crawling Linkin Park
Warner Bros

The term alternative rock, in its modern incarnation, is laden with contradiction.

Alternative rock at its emergence was a category used to group the underground music of the '70s. It celebrated and uplifted independent music over the output of commercial record labels. This took power from the big money mainstream record men, and through outside exposure, it allowed fans to be arbiters of their own taste. Musicians were boosted through the dynamic energy that allowed experimentation and sincerity to thrive uncompromised.

From the '70s DIY punk rock ethos to the experimentation and diversification of the '80s, alternative rock grew and prospered through independent publications and zines, independent radio stations, and the word of mouth of music lovers who embraced the experimentation of the genre.

However, the '90s saw the alternative scene break through into the mainstream as an immensely popular genre of its own. While it is open for debate whether this benefitted or detracted from the music, it certainly aided its bands and musicians in becoming both financially and creatively successful. After all, art has no chance of shaping society should nobody see it.

Alternative rock has spawned a movement around some of the greatest acts in musical history...

10. Linkin Park

Quintessential Lyric: (From 'Crawling')

"There's something inside me that pulls beneath the surface / Consuming (confusing what is real) / This lack of self control I fear is never ending / Controlling (confusing what is real)"

Anthem: Faint

Though Linkin Park have a plethora of hits, Faint is a track which best encapsulates the band's energy. The lyrics are introspective and personal yet widely relatable. Loneliness gives way to fighting back and refusing to be ignored.

Musically, the instruments and Chester Bennington's vocals come into their own on Meteora (2003). Though the track is driven by Rob Bourdon's drumming, this takes little to nothing away from the rest of the instruments (as lots of the lesser nu metal of the time did). Mike Shinoda’s strings arrangement, along with the violins, violas, and cellos only add to the impact.

Defining Album: [REAИIMATIOИ] (2002)

Linkin Park were stars in their own genre, pushing nu metal and rap rock to the forefront of mainstream rock. However it was with their remix album [REAИIMATIOИ] that the band showed not only their willingness to experiment with their sound, but also their talent for it. The album is the start of Linkin Park's rise out of the nu metal to become the band they would.


9. The Killers

Quintessential Lyric: (From 'Read My Mind')

The good old days, the honest man / The restless heart, the Promised Land / A subtle kiss that no one sees / A broken wrist and a big trapeze"

Anthem: Smile Like You Mean It

The Killer's career is dominated by their classic Mr. Brightside, which is not only an anthem for the band, but an anthem for music, indie rock, and '00s (the decade itself). However, Smile Like You Mean It (the track that follows Mr. Brightside on Hot Fuss) sees the band in its purest representation. The lyrics are left ambiguous yet driven by a potent sense of longing. The instrumental is pure '00s indie rock guitar, managing to maintain up-beat and down tempo concurrently.

Defining Album: Hot Fuss (2004)

While The Killer's following album Sam's Town (2006) saw the band blossom into full blown rockstars, Hot Fuss is simply a great album for singles, with the first five tracks (Jenny Was A Friend Of Mine, Mr. Brightside, Smile Like You Mean It, Somebody Told Me, and All These Things That I've Done) becoming bonafide hits. As the foundation of a solid career, Hot Fuss holds the test of time.


8. The Jesus And Mary Chain

Quintessential Lyric: (From 'Happy When It Rains')

"Talking fast couldn't tell me something / I would shed my skin for you / Talking fast on the edge of nothing / I would break my back for you"

Anthem: Head On

The 1989 track is a post-punk classic, that found further popularity after being covered by the Pixies (more on them later). As with the majority of Jesus and Mary Chain tracks, the creative force behind the writing was brothers Jim and William Reid. Lyrically the song is a testament to the band's tempered joy that embraces the darker aspects of life. However it keeps the audience's hooked with layered guitar feedback, synth bass, and drum machine.

Defining Album: Darklands (1987)

Following the phenomenal debut Psychocandy, Darklands saw the band become masters of post-punk and pioneers of the increasingly popular alternative rock movement. From the opening chords of the album's first track (the titular song) the album pulls listeners in, with its solid melody and muted but self-assured lead vocals from William rather than Jim. Musically Darklands harks back to classic rock, while maintaining fresh and innovative. It keeps a toe in the contemporary, but forges its own path. Plus it gave us two of the band's most enduring staples Happy When It Rains and April Skies.


7. Blink-182

Quintessential Lyric: (From 'First Date')

"Please, don't look at me with those eyes / Please, don't hint that your capable of lies / I dread the thought of our very first kiss / A target that I'm probably gonna miss"

Anthem: What's My Age Again?

With the release of Enema of the State (1999), blink-182 brought their brand of pop-punk perfection along with some admittedly sophomoric, but undeniably fun, humour. Both All the Small Things and What's My Age Again? were the album's biggest hits, as party songs with a heart. The latter holds up better due to it's duality between tentative love and growing up. Instrumentally, WMAA? exhibits the energy of the rock triad of guitar, bass, and drums.

Defining Album: blink-182/untitled (2003)

As much love as blink-182 fans have for the Enema era, the band's 2003 effort spurred on a maturity without losing their unique take. Always is perhaps the most typical Enema track, though it too lands a gut punch. I Miss You and Feeling This show the band at their pinnacle. In addition to this, All of This allowed the band to collaborate with one of their idols The Cure frontman Robert Smith, the appreciation of who can be seen all over this album.


6. My Chemical Romance

Quintessential Lyric: (From 'Thank You For The Venom')

"So give me all your poison / And give me all your pills / And give me all your hopeless hearts / And make me ill / You're running after something / That you'll never kill / If this is what you want / Then fire at will"

Anthem: Famous Last Words

The Black Parade (2006) proved My Chemical Romance could rise from the pack of emo rockers fighting to define alternative rock in the '00s. The band's rock opera is enjoyable as ever, however, with most cultural milestones it can come across as a little dated. In regards to the album's singles, Teenagers holds up the best. Yet, Famous Last Words captures the raw rock of Teenagers with just enough operatic pomp to keep things on-brand.

Defining Album: Three Cheers For Sweet Revenge (2004)

The album that elevated MCR to the mainstream. I'm Not Okay (I Promise) alone is the emo equivalent to a national anthem. Though, that doesn't take away from it being a solid alt. rock masterpiece, that retains the fervent fury of 2002's I Brought You My Bullets... while tailoring their sound to the wider rock community.


5. R.E.M.

Quintessential Lyric: (From 'The One I Love')

“This one goes out to the one I love / This one goes out to the one I've left behind / A simple prop to occupy my time / This one goes out to the one I love"

Anthem: Nightswimming

Nightswimming is somewhat of an outlier in the band's catalogue, featuring bassist Mike Mills on piano, strings arranged by John Paul Jones (former Led Zeppelin bassist), and Deborah Workman underpinning the latter section of the song on oboe. These all combine to create a poignant atmosphere. While the band wouldn't see this arrangement again, it shows the blueprints for their future success. Experimentation was the key.

Stipe's vocals here are a prime example of his evocative delivery and the power and beauty of his voice as he comes to terms with lyrics that attempt to grasp at an idealistic, care-free sense of nostalgia.

Defining Album: Out of Time (1991)

Michael Stipe is one of often overlooked architects in propelling alternative rock out of the underground. It was with Out of Time that the band expanded from cult appreciation to garnering a worldwide strong fandom. It was a great album with a solid theme that distilled the band's essence, backed-up with mega-singles Losing My Religion and Shiny Happy People.


4. The Cure

Quintessential Lyric: (From 'Just Like Heaven')

"Daylight licked me into shape / I must have been asleep for days / And moving lips to breathe her name / I opened up my eyes / And found myself alone, alone / Alone above a raging sea / That stole the only girl I loved / And drowned her deep inside of me"

Anthem: Lullaby

Lullaby combines the gothic grandeur that Robert Smith is adored for with an instrumental dominated by the six-string bass, along with the typical four string variety, giving the track melodic yet misplaced funk. The track allows listeners to dip into either the toe-tapping melody or the dark and elegiac lyrics. The Cure are at their best when they summon and tether disparate inspirations in a way that forms dualities.

Defining Album: Disintegration (1989)

The Cure's 1989 effort remains one of the all-time great albums of alternative rock, and a staple in the art and gothic rock genres. As well as a home for Lullaby, the band ran the gambit of their experimental influences. While the surface of Disintegration presents as a jarring spiral of creativity, some time spent with it sees the tracks become a unified masterpiece that doesn't dull after repeated listening.


3. The Smiths

Quintessential Lyric: (From 'Still Ill')

"And if you must go to work tomorrow / Well, if I were you I wouldn't bother / For there are brighter sides to life / And I should know because I've seen them / But not very often"

Anthem: How Soon Is Now?

The Smiths are predominantly known for two elements; the masterful misery of Morrissey and the guitar brilliance of Johnny Marr. Though originally a b-side for the single release of William, It Was Really Nothing, this offering sees The Smiths at their very best. Marr's guitar whines as the chords ring out rapidly. Morrissey's unique voice that has captured generations of admires (as well as detractors) heaps more feeling on top of the already evocative lyrics that depicts the inner struggle between one's crippling shyness and the longing for love.

Defining Album: The Queen Is Dead (1986)

Over it's ten tracks The Queen Is Dead shows all sides of The Smiths; the counter culture defiance, the at times over-the-top melancholy, the wry humour, and the ability of the often contentious Morrissey/Marr partnership to create anthemic masterpieces that hold the test of time. The album also boasts There Is a Light That Never Goes Out, considered an all time great in the indie and alt rock scenes.


2. Nirvana

Quintessential Lyric: (From 'Pennyroyal Tea')

"Give me a Leonard Cohen afterworld / So I can sigh eternally"

Anthem : Frances Farmer Will Have Her Revenge On Seattle

It is always difficult to pick a stand out track from such a successful band who burned too bright for a short time. Yet Frances Farmer Will Have Her Revenge on Seattle catches Nirvana at their best by stripping back without losing any of their signature sound. While Cobain's lyrics are rather muted in terms of his penchant for linguistic flourishes, the song's message is simple and effective, with the vocal delivery carrying the emotion. The repeated chorus line of "I miss the comfort in being sad" is haunting.

Defining Album: In Utero (1993)

The world unfortunately lost Kurt Cobain too soon for Nirvana to have an extensive back catalogue with just three studio albums and compilation album Incesticide (1992). While it was 1991's Nevermind that propelled Nirvana from Seattle's underground to the headphones of Gen-Xers world wide, In Utero is the album commonly considered to capture Nirvana's essence, the grittiness of Bleach (1989), the pop sensibility of Nevermind, and the growing greatness of Cobain's darkly poetic lyrics that pack universal appeal.


1. Pixies

Quintessential Lyric: (From 'Cactus')

"I miss your kissin' and I miss your head / And a letter in your writing doesn't mean you're not dead / Run outside in the desert heat / Make your dress all wet and send it to me"

Anthem: Monkey Gone To Heaven

A lyrical concoction that blends the Pixies themes of major world issues (i.e. environmentalism), personal struggles, and biblical imagery. 'Monkey' shows the band at the purest incarnation of their brilliance. The addition of guest cellists and violinists only adds to the anthemic force of the track.

Defining Album: Doolittle (1989)

The Pixies are alternative rock musician's favourite alt. rock band, who are yet to put out a dud album. This makes it a task to whittle down their back catalogue to a single album. However, their second studio offering holds the distinction of propelling the Pixies to superstardom. Showcasing tracks such as Debaser, Here Comes Your Man, and the aforementioned anthem, along with drawing upon an abundance of musical styles and influences, it is easy to see why 'Doolittle' hasn't left best album lists since the early '90s. It is an album which generation after generation of rock fans have, and will continue to, flock to.


Contributor

An English Lit. MA Grad trying to validate my student debt by writing literary fiction and alternative non-fiction.