10 Best Rock Comeback Albums
Metallica's trajectory from St Anger to Death Magnetic was something else.
As Ann Perkins says in Parks and Rec, "everyone loves a good comeback story".
It's not like she's wrong either.
Even though we've seen people fall time and time again on the charts, it's always best when they're able to pick themselves up and move on and become stronger because of it. This isn't just your standard comeback though. These people had to overcome the impossible.
Outside of the usual game played with the charts, artists have found themselves having to weather some of the biggest storms that anyone would ever have to deal with. Compared to just slipping behind on the album before, these are the records that came from bands who should have been dead in the water, and yet became the reason why we're still talking about them today.
While some of them are grand spectacles that show new sides of what these bands were capable of, there are also bands just reaching to a higher level of quality that many had forgotten they could pull off.
Sure, some of them have faded since then, but it's still nice to be able to leave your genre on your own terms. You being a badass never went anywhere, but sometimes you just need albums like these to remind the public of what you can do.
10. Diamond Eyes - Deftones
For any band looking to build themselves back up, it's always that much harder when you're down one of your members. Since no one is operating at full capacity any more, you're going to need to dig a little bit deeper to come up with goods.
Even with Chi Cheng's untimely passing though, Deftones made their return look damn near easy on Diamond Eyes.
Coming off of the contentious sounds of Saturday Night Wrist, this is the return to form that most of us had been waiting for since the days of White Pony. While stuff like the self titled record were experimental for what they were and played with what Deftones could really do, this is where we start to see the real fruits of their labor pay off in spades.
As opposed to just spending 40 minutes tearing our heads off with one banger after another, there are a few more nods to genres like shoegaze and even post rock in places. This is still a metal record at the end of the day though, and songs like You've Seen the Butcher are still some of the crunchiest things that the band would ever make.
Compared to the dark atmosphere that we normally get from Deftones, this is the closest they've come to actually making a picture in your mind with sound.
9. The System Has Failed - Megadeth
So what if someone thinks that you can't play up to your usual standard anymore? Whereas most bands fade into obscurity, it takes the true legends to actually come back from the break bigger than they ever were. It gets more complicated when you have a doctor sticking his opinion in the proceedings though.
When Dave Mustaine was entering rehab, he had fallen asleep on an armchair and had circulation completely cut off in his left hand. This wasn't just a case of his arm falling asleep...this was enough for doctors to say that he would never play the guitar again. Even after Dave turned over the Megadeth name to Dave Ellefson, he managed to go through countless hours of treatment and get his playing back to its classic level on The System Has Failed.
Bringing in Chris Poland from the glory days to drop in solos here and there, Dave felt like a new man after going through the whole ordeal, almost like he was trying to prove to the world that he still had something to say.
To put it in perspective, this is the equivalent of a runner cutting their hamstring and told that they'd never run again. Then again, when you've put your life's work into something like this, you weren't going to go down without a fight.
8. Achtung Baby - U2
Sometimes it's not the comeback album that you really have to worry about...it's about measuring to what you already did. After the Joshua Tree left them looking like the almighty gods of rock, how the hell was U2 going to transition into the age of alt-rock without falling flat on their faces? Instead of just donning flannel shirts themselves, they leaned even further into the excessive image, and it actually worked.
For as much as Bono was portraying himself like a god among men in songs like The Fly, it was clear that the entire thing was becoming a satire of what rock stars should be. At the same time, Achtung Baby isn't just about taking the piss out of yourself for daring to be a rock star. No, this album has the potential to take your heart out of your chest and stomp it into pieces.
Outside of the usual U2 soundscapes, songs like Who's Gonna Ride Your Wild Horses and One are some of the most raw-nerved songs in their catalog, which sound both depressed and a little bit jaded about the years of heartache that each of these men have gone through. It's not going to be easy moving to the next stage of your career, but we should all be thankful that U2 made it over the hump.
7. Death Magnetic - Metallica
If there was any album that should have been a career killer, chances are that it would have been St. Anger by Metallica. Though people were already a bit skeptical of what they were up to during the Load era, the flimsy snare sound and the therapeutic lyrics of their 2003 disaster left most fans wondering if the thrash band that they knew and loved were gone for good. Like all professional musicians though, Metallica managed to pick themselves up and start walking in the right direction again with Death Magnetic.
Aside from the production issues from the loudness wars, these are the kind of songs that St. Anger should have been. Although there are some blatant retreads of past glory, a little bit of nostalgia is exactly what the fans needed to make sure that the thrash band thy loved wasn't completely tapped out. There are even some songs that hold up as some of the best in their catalog, like the Day That Never Comes being up there with some of the greatest Metallica ballads.
There are also some songs like All Nightmare Long and Suicide and Redemption that offer a few more surprises that people even wanted, like James Hetfield taking solos and a singalong chorus that we hadn't seen since Enter Sandman. Metallica may have been dormant for a while, but the resurrection begins the minute you hit play on this record.
6. Blackstar - David Bowie
The entire career of David Bowie after the turn of the millennium was a bit scattered to say the least. From his original album Toy being shelved by him to sustaining a heart attack onstage in the middle of the tour for Reality, many people were wondering whether the Thin White Duke had the potential to wow us like he did back in the day. Even though he did, that final comeback came at a very high price.
While Bowie's album the Next Day had established him back in full force, Blackstar was the eerie blending of genres that we had known Bowie for back in his Berlin period. Accompanied by jazz titans, Bowie makes epic tracks that reflect on his own mortality and what he thinks about leaving this Earth one day.
That day would end up coming a lot sooner than expected though, with Bowie passing away just a few days after the album was released after fighting a long battle with cancer. It's almost respectable how much Bowie was dedicated to his craft that he managed to give us everything he could up until his final days. The end may have been near, but you don't see fear in an album like this. This is a man in his final moments and is going to go out swinging no matter what the cost.
5. Band on the Run - Paul McCartney and Wings
If you were a Beatles die hard back in the day, you probably would have thought that Paul McCartney was losing his damn mind after the breakup.
Though his first few records had their fair share of bright spots, the more eccentric side of RAM and the beginnings of Wings on Wild Life was starting to scare many of the hardcore fans away with how ramshackle they were. Just when Paul was at his lowest, he stationed in Nigeria and came through with his finest post Beatles release.
That didn't come together that neatly though. With the rest of the band quitting before they went to Nigeria, most of what you hear on Band on the Run is just Paul, Linda, and Denny Laine making the tracks. When left to his own devices though, Paul still had his signature gift for melody, unearthing gems like the title track and Jet into legendary status.
Even when delving into newer territory, Paul still finds a way to put some of his rock and roll groove into things, like the strange swing of 1985 or the return to the acoustic guitar on the pseudo sequel to Blackbird with Bluebird. Though Paul was the poster child of someone falling from grace for a while, this was the record that may have made his former Fabs a little bit nervous.
4. American Idiot - Green Day
The fact that bands can even make a genre defining record is a miracle on its own. When you have something that's touches that many people though, you're going to have to live in the shadow of it for the rest of your days. Hell, even when you try to reinvent the wheel again, you're not safe from people trying to steal your tapes.
Around the time that Green Day were getting ready to make a return to roots record with Cigarettes and Valentines, all of the master tapes were stolen from their studio, leaving them back at square one again. Instead of just playing the same songs over again, producer Rob Cavallo encouraged them to dig down deep inside themselves to create something better.
Taking inspiration from the Iraq war that was about to kick into high gear, Billie Joe Armstrong crafted American Idiot into a scathing rock opera about the youth of America looking for something better than what they'd been given.
Compared to the rest of the pop punk scene at the time, this was now the new benchmark for how every band could grow up, taking the building blocks of classic rock and injecting them with a whole lot more attitude.
Green Day may have been considered fossils of the rock scene at this point, but acts like Fall Out Boy and Blink 182 only wished they could write a record like this.
3. Back In Black - AC/DC
For any band to lose their lead singer is normally a sign that the end is near. After all, when you lose the person who was the mouthpiece for the band, there's no real way to regroup and find someone who can deliver the same amount of charisma and intensity. Especially if the shoes you have to fill were that of AC/DC legend Bon Scott.
While trying to create the followup to their smash album Highway to Hell, Scott went on a drinking binge and was found the next day dead in a car, having choked on his own vomit during the night.
After burying their singer and musical brother, Malcolm Young made it clear that he wasn't going to spend the next year of his life eulogizing his friend. He was going to carry on making music, and he knew he had to deliver the goods.
Drafting in Brian Johnson from the band Geordie, the riffs on the next record were a stroke of genius, bringing the same attitude while also serving as a fitting tribute to their fallen friend. The bell on the opening track Hells Bells alone almost feels like a funeral dirge for Bon's memory.
With it becoming one of the best selling rock and roll albums of all time, the Young Brothers kept on trucking and turned into one of the few bands that could actually cheat death.
2. Black Gives Way to Blue - Alice In Chains
After Layne Staley passed away, there was no real reason for Alice in Chains to even be a band anymore.
Since their last record showed them at their most raw wounded and their MTV Unplugged performance showing just how bad things got, revisiting some of these songs again might have been just poking at an old wound. Once they came together for some tribute shows with William DuVall though, we were in for one of the biggest career resurrections in rock history.
It's not like the band themselves weren't aware of the fact either. On the opening track All Secrets Known, they lay things out plain and dry that there's no way they could replace Layne's presence in the band. Black Gives Way to Blue doesn't go that route though.
Instead of just resting on their laurels, Alice ends up mixing things up and leaning into the strengths of where the band are at now, from the warped riff of Check My Brain to DuVall actually flexing his vocal chops on Last of My Kind.
Compared to the usual comeback albums that seem like cash grabs, this feels like a labor of love and a thank you to the fans who have stuck by them all these years. Alice in Chains without Layne is a very different band, but it's one that Layne would no doubt be proud of.
1. Hysteria - Def Leppard
It's hard to really nail down what constitutes a band making a comeback. Sometimes you have to deal with manager troubles, and other times there's band members who just aren't gelling with the rest of the band at the time. In Def Leppard's case, it was if all the sh*t hit the fan at the exact same time when making Hysteria.
Already having to follow up the massive success of Pyromania, the band was dealt a heavy blow when superproducer Mutt Lange wasn't going to be available to produce the album.
What followed was every band's worst nightmare, with jam sessions going nowhere and a break that ended with drummer Rick Allen losing his left arm. Once they picked themselves up though, Lange returned and Def Leppard became a functioning unit again.
Working for the better part of three years, the result was one of the most airtight set of songs of the entire MTV era of heavy metal, bringing together one classic melody after the next on ballads like Love Bites and singalongs like Animal and Pour Some Sugar on Me.
Whereas most bands try to write a couple of good songs and pad the rest of the album out with filler material, this is the hard rock equivalent of an album like Michael Jackson's Thriller, with every single song having the potential to be a single cut.