10 Best Sequels To Incredible Albums
When musicians go all Electric Boogaloo.
Sequels are commonly associated with movies above everything else. But musicians too have returned to their best albums and songs and tried to recreate the magic (and money) they originally spawned.
Sometimes the stories in the records warrant and deserve continuing and sometimes they’re just giant cash-grabs (do not, under any circumstances, listen to Bat Out of Hell 2 or 3). There have been the sequelized album equivalents of Basic Instinct 2, Grease 2 and The Hangover Part II - garbage.
But on the other side there have been similarly sequelized album equivalents of Aliens, The Empire Strikes Back and The Dark Knight - gold. There has been a glut of sequels in music over the years, especially in the rap genre. Nicki Minaj has revisited her Pink Friday album, Jay Z’s went back to the well with The Blueprint series and Lil Wayne’s again and again returned to his Tha Carter series.
Most fans would clamour at the idea that there’s a ‘Part 2’ of their adored favourite album, after all. That’s why modern albums getting re-issued by record companies has been a popular and familiar practice in the last decade or so, where albums get re-released with several new songs, like Ellie Goulding’s ‘Bright Lights’ or Florence and the Machine’s ‘Between Two Lungs’.
Here, we’ll look at the 10 best sequels to incredible albums, where artists have come up trumps with follow-up records.
10. Logic - No Pressure
‘No Pressure’ is Logic’s 2020 return to his debut album released back in 2014, ‘Under Pressure’. Perfectly fitting given it’s his retirement record to,, with him quitting the rap game at the exceptionally young age of 30 years old to concentrate more on raising his new born son.
It’s a passionately wise record that conveys Logic has found peace with the last decade of his career over six albums and six mixtapes. The same computer program, Thalia, welcomes you to the album on the Intro, as Logic meditates in verses on going from underground rapper (he funded his own tours in the beginning) to becoming the cult-like rap figure he evolved into.
Everything from the artwork to the themes on the LP are similar and comparable to Under Pressure. Logic perfectly bows out on final outro track ‘Obediently Yours’, that samples Orson Welles calling for action on putting an end to race hate in the 1940s. It’s as honest an album the Maryland native could put out in the world right now.
As Logic rapped on the ‘No Pressure Freestyle’ that teased the album: “Industry rule number 4081, your new sh*t ain't good as your old sh*t. 'Til your new sh*t is your old sh*t, son.” Know that Logic never strays from rule 4081 on No Pressure.
9. Metallica – Reload
Metallica’s ‘Reload’ is the follow-up to ‘Load’ that was released the year prior, in 1996. Load and Reload were originally intended to be released conjointly as a double album but the band had issues recording all the songs in time for release and wanted fans to have the time to properly absorb each song, believing this was better accomplished by releasing them separately.
Load and Reload set-up newfound relevance for Metallica throughout the difficult ‘90s period where post-grunge and alternative metal reigned supreme and so many of their contemporaries faded into obscurity. In the beginning many claimed Lars and company sold out with these two albums but in hindsight they progressed. Imagine if they had just made The Black Album 2; they would have gotten much more flack and accusations of selling out.
Reload is noteworthy for being the last original Metallica LP to feature bassist of 15 years Jason Newsted. Reload’s sound is more experimental than Load, featuring more stringed instruments in songs. Still, the guitars are prominent throughout. ‘Fuel’ is an adrenalin classic, ‘Devil’s Dance’ features some of James Hetfield's strongest lyrics aimed at The Devil and ‘The Unforgiven 2’ itself is a worthy sequel to The Unforgiven (featured on ‘The Black Album’). Metallica took the blues heavy metal found on Reload and expanded it further on their most recent release in 2016, ‘Hardwired... to Self-Destruct’.
8. Ryan Adams - Love Is Hell Pt. 2
Alternative country crooner Ryan Adams wanted to release ‘Love Is Hell’ as his fifth studio album until his record company Lost Highway didn’t think the album would be a commercial hit. As a result, Ryan, to his dismay and disillusionment, initially had to release the album in parts - a music equivalent of Quentin Tarantino being told by Miramax that he could only cinematically release Kill Bill in two installments.
So ‘Love Is Hell pt. 1’ was released as an EP in November 2003 (which includes his astonishing cover of ‘Wonderwall’ that’s racked up more than 75 million listens on Spotify) and ‘Love Is Hell pt. 2’ was released a month later in December. Love Is Hell pt. 2 is particularly emotionally gorgeous, with Ryan chewing over his emotions and fears on tracks ‘My Blue Manhattan’ and ‘I See Monsters’. It’s a gut-wrenching record about broken hearts and battling your own bleak despair. It’s such a departure from the generic rock sound that was found on his ‘Demolition’ and ‘Rock n Roll’ albums that came before his Love Is Hell EPs. The album’s dark turn was partially inspired by The Cure’s classic ‘Disintegration’.
Thankfully, when the EPs sold much better than expected, Lost Highway released Love Is Hell in full the following year to enjoy as it was intended.
7. Kid Cudi - Man On The Moon II: The Legend Of Mr. Rager
Kid Cudi re-emerged on his second studio album with the same reflectively-charged emo rap he developed on his first, ‘Man on the Moon: The End of Day’. Once again he comes up against dark subject matter in lyrics like depression, anxiety and loneliness, battling good and evil throughout - topics that weren’t commonly rapped about in 2010.
‘Man on the Moon II: The Legend of Mr. Rager’ is sonically deeper than its predecessor, with Cudi able to score major collaborations with CeeLo Green, Mary J. Blige, St. Vincent and Kanye West. Standout tracks include ‘Erase Me’, in which Cudi reflects on unrequited love, ‘Maniac’, where he raps about embracing the darker parts of his personality, ‘Revofev’, where he tells his younger fans not to stress about the worries they face in day-to-day life, and ‘Ghost!’, on which he ruminates on how his ongoing depression can make him feel deserted in misery. The album was certified platinum and Complex would list it as ‘25 Rap Albums From the Past Decade That Deserve Classic Status’.
Cudi originally spoke of wanting to record ‘Man on the Moon III’ one day, only to change his mind believing the Man on the Moon series belonged to his youth. He held that belief until this year when he dropped a teaser video announcing, “The trilogy continues… soon.”
6. Guns N’ Roses – Use Your Illusion II
With ‘Use Your Illusion I’ and ‘Use Your Illusion II’ being released the same day on 17 September 1991, it’s easy to look past both records as giant cash-grabs, given Guns N’ Roses easily could have made their third studio album a double album and saved their fans the trouble of shelling out twice their money. But if you forget about that, both albums are absurdly good, particularly Illusion II.
There are ballads and anthems to be found throughout. Highlights include the Dylan cover ‘Knockin' on Heaven's Door’ (the album’s counterpart to the Wings cover ‘Live and Let Die’ on UYI1) and the lengthy epic ‘Estranged’ (in comparison to the 10 minute number ‘Coma’ on UYI1) and ‘You Could Be Mine’, which every Terminator fan in existence knows the words to.
GnR are much more political on Illusion II, with songs like ‘Civil War’ and ‘Get in the Ring’ that touch on topics like violence, fake news and government. It was the album that featured the last recording by the classic ‘Appetite for Destruction’ line-up, with Steven Adler playing drums on Civil War. Both albums were inspired by the band not wanting to be remembered as a one album wonder , with Axl Rose commenting, “I just want to bury Appetite. I like the album, but I'm sick of it… I don't want to live my life through that one album.”
5. Phoebe Bridgers – Punisher
‘Punisher’ is only modern folk-rock hero Phoebe Bridgers' second LP. Noteworthy given she was only 25 when it was released in June 2020. Rather than just a second studio album, Phoebe considers this record an extension to her tender classic ‘Stranger in the Alps’. She’s commented: “There’s bits on this record that do feel weirdly like a sequel.”
It’s been labelled as a confessional emo-folk album in comparison to the melancholic feel of Stranger In The Alps. She recorded most of it on the road in-between soundchecks. She address death and purpose in the lyrics throughout, evolving the themes she perfected on her first album. The acoustic harmonies permeate like some eerie dream on Punisher. It’s less catchy but far more reflective with lyrics like, “The doctor put her hands over my liver, and she told me my resentments getting smaller.”
Within Punisher’s track listing, there are even singular sequels to songs, with ‘Savior Complex’ continuing on from previous song ‘Moon Song’. Phoebe expressed, “Songs like Moon Song and Savior Complex, when I wrote them, they felt like different versions of each other. I was like, ‘Oh, sh*t, Savior Complex is the sequel to that song’, so it should be right after.” Bridgers believes ‘Garden Song’ too is a "sequel" of sorts to her acclaimed ‘Smoke Signals’ single.
Punisher was released to critical acclaim, with The Daily Telegraph and NME both giving it five-star ratings. It deserved six.
4. Beck - Morning Phase
In a press release for the record it was stated that Morning Phase is the "companion piece" to Beck’s eighth studio album, ‘Sea Change’. With Sea Change being released in 2002 and Morning Phase in 2014 there was a 12-year gap in-between. So what made Beck want to return to the acoustic heartbreak sound found on Sea Change all those years later? Beck originally started demoing a follow-up to Sea Change in the mid-noughties, only for the tapes to be stolen whilst on tour (with no backups). Beck found this devastating and went in a completely different direction on albums that followed Sea Change.
But Beck had an acoustic itch to scratch and wanted to venture back to the melancholic melodies of old. He returned to his heavy heart folk sound, adding instruments like the mandolin, harp and piano to arrangements. Songs like ‘Blue Moon’ and ‘Heart Is a Drum’ conjure a tender Beck trying to find some calm in the world. He’s said his depression on the record comes not from a breakup (like it did on Sea Change) but rather a spinal injury that had Beck not being able to record music for a long period of time.
Mojo voted Morning Phase the ‘Best Album of 2014’ and it won ‘Album of the Year’ at the 2015 Grammy Awards, which irked Kanye West no end.
3. Queen - A Day At The Races
Queen considers ‘A Day at the Races’ a sequel to their beloved ‘A Night at the Opera’. Just look to the titles after all, with A Night at the Opera being named after the famous Marx Brothers film, just like A Day at the Races is named after the Marx Brothers follow-up film.
A Day at the Races cost roughly the same as its predecessor to make too, along with the artwork and themes running through the record being comparable. It includes the classics ‘Tie Your Mother Down’ and ‘Somebody to Love’ that produced mass singalongs in arenas and stadiums. Freddie Mercury’s love and inspiration from Aretha Franklin is evident on Somebody to Love with his liberated gospel-like vocals.
When it was released in 1976, A Day at the Races was regarded as a disappointment and underwhelming, given A Night at the Opera was so well-liked by the British public. With time though, it’s grown in appreciation as a companion piece. In a national 2006 BBC poll, A Day at the Races was voted the 67th greatest album of all time. It’s a complicated, grandiose album. While not as well regarded at A Night at the Opera (to be expected – it’s Queen’s best record), it still serves as a fantastic sequel.
2. Eminem – The Marshall Mathers LP2
When Eminem first released ‘The Marshall Mathers LP’, it catapulted him to mainstream success with iconic singles like ‘The Real Slim Shady’, ‘The Way I Am’ and ‘Stan’. So you can see the appeal of wanting to return to his roots and issue a second instalment. This wasn’t the first time Eminem (or any rapper) made sequel albums after all, like ‘Relapse’ and ‘Recovery’ (and later ‘Revival’).
‘The Marshall Mathers LP2’ is a critical/commercial return to form for Eminem, with standout tracks ‘Bad Guy’, ‘Survival’, ‘The Monster’ and ‘Headlights’. The cover includes a picture of Eminem’s childhood home, only it’s in a worse state than before compared to the TMMLP, which had Eminem sat on the porch. He’s persistently aggressive as he is nostalgic throughout. He raps as if he was competing/winning. You feel there’s a sense of purpose that was missing on the records that came before when Eminem was either battling or recently recovering from his prescription drug addiction. He raps on Berzerk: “I’m about to bloody this track up so everybody get back. That’s why my pen needs a pad because my rhymes on the rag. Just like I did with addiction I’m about to kick it.”
1. Mac Miller – Circles
Mac Miller tragically died from an accidental drug overdose in 2018, a month after his astonishing album ‘Swimming’ was released, where he truly evolved from rapper to technically great musician. Amazingly, Mac had already tirelessly worked on its follow-up in that time. So producer Jon Brion, who was working with Mac before he passed away, was tasked with completing the record at the appeal of Mac’s family, believing it was what Mac would have wanted out in the world.
In January 2020, ‘Circles’ was released, the record Mac was faithfully working on at the time of his untimely death. Circles was going to be an accompanying piece to Swimming, with the idea being we’re all ‘swimming in circles’. It’s an emotionally calming record to listen to. Like other Mac releases, it defies genre, with him having the ability to entangle different styles of music into one. There’s rare joy you don’t usually find with Mac on Circles. It’s a tragic yet perfect swansong for Mac Miller who will live on forever with this record. He hums on Complicated: "Some people say they want to live forever, that's way too long, I'll just get through today."
Swimming In Circles is what he was chasing: his masterpiece.