10 Biggest Album Flops In Rock History
Swing and a miss.
Any artist wants to put their lifesblood into every record they make. No matter how hard it takes to actually produce your final record, you always want to make sure the music that what you left behind reaches an audience in a way that nothing else has. You can put your blood on the pages, but that doesn't really guarantee that the public is going to appreciate it.
Even with the best of intentions, these albums by some of rock's greatest artists have met a deaf ear on more than one occasion. Instead of finding a good groove to settle into for their respective projects, these songs end up sounding either lifeless, lethargic, or just confusing to the average listener.
Some of these albums may have even been good on the surface, but the execution got in the way, whether it be the label's fault for rush-releasing it or the band taking on a new direction that didn't make the best first impression.
It's important for bands to work outside of their wheelhouse from time to time, but these were the swings for the fences that no one end up caring about. There's still a few things salvageable in here, but it's not necessarily going to be the next classic or anything either.
10. Second Coming - The Stone Roses
The Stone Roses may very well be one of the most overlooked bands in alternative rock. With just one album, these lads from Manchester combined dance, pop, and classic rock sensibilities to build the foundation of what would become Britpop later down the line. Their debut was a shock to the system, but fans weren't as attentive when coming back for more.
In the case of the Stone Roses, it may have been a case where the debut was just so good that pretty much anything the band released afterwards was slated to fail. Though there wasn't a chance to rewrite songs like She Bangs the Drums or I Wanna Be Adored, they seemed to give it a fair shot on Second Coming, as some songs ended up taking on a bluesy feel. It may have been good for what it was, but it was much too little too late.
By the time the band actually got back together to make their next record, the Britpop movement was already in full swing, leaving potential fans to pounce on Blur and Oasis before returning to the Stone Roses. The Roses would implode soon afterward, bringing one of the most influential bands in all of England to a stand still.
There probably wasn't a good chance of them topping their debut, but the good times didn't deserve to go out with this big a whimper.
9. Hot Space - Queen
At the start of the '80s, Queen had done something almost none of their peers could: change with the times.
As opposed to the other hard rock bands struggling to adapt to the age of MTV, these hard rock monarchs strutted onto the scene like seasoned veterans, with Freddie Mercury trying his hand at everything from funk rock to old time Elvis-style rock and roll. However, the one thing that put them back on top did end up coming back to bite them.
Seeing how the band's last single was the chart-dominating Another One Bites the Dust, their next record Hot Space seems like a deliberate attempt to cash in on that song's willpower. From one track to the next, this record just sounds like the band trying to make lightning strike twice, with songs like Back Chat using the same syncopated vocal approach that was already used on the previous albums.
Aside from the huge crossover smash with David Bowie on Under Pressure, the rest of Hot Space sounds like these guys had about half of a record finished but wanted to just settle with the leftover scraps from their disco episode. There's certainly nothing wrong with copying the formula, but you have to make sure that formula has staying power before you actually go through with it.
8. Don't Look Back - Boston
Most rock fans had never heard anything like the first Boston record when it first came across radio stations around the world. Done almost entirely in guitarist Tom Scholz's basement, this one record became the template for what modern rock would sound like, from the punchy guitars to the layers upon layers of harmony that gelled together perfectly.
For an album that was that huge, you might want to play it safe from the follow-up, but maybe not as safe as Don't Look Back.
From the opening song alone, I assume these rockers from Beantown want you to forget that there first record even happened, as most of the tracks on here sound the exact same. Whether it's the singles or the deep cuts, these songs don't really sound thought out so much as they are just copy and pasted onto a different piece of tape.
It stings even more when the band members themselves have fessed up to their lazy followup. According to the band, the entire reason they called the album Don't Look Back was a tongue-in-cheek joke to the fans to ignore the amazing record that had come before. These tracks may be solid for what they are, but when your new album just makes you want to listen to another album, you've got a big dud on your hands.
7. The Spaghetti Incident? - Guns N Roses
Guns N Roses had one hell of a start to the '90s. After stomping out what was left of the hair metal movement with their debut Appetite for Destruction, they had enough material lying around for a full-on double record, which sent them on one of the biggest tours in hard rock history. That kind of success is extremely rare in rock music, but when they eventually came off the road, everyone was fried beyond belief.
Thanks to the ongoing antics of Axl Rose and Slash and Duff McKagan sinking deeper and deeper into their alcohol addiction, the band decided to play it safe and come together for a handful of covers of their favorite punk tunes. What should have been a healthy way to reenergize these LA street urchins turned into the final gasps of the most dangerous band in history.
Are the songs played fine? Yeah...but the tone is way off. While there were some highlights in the track listing like Since I Don't Have You, the whole band sounds like they are at their wit's end and doing everything they can to provide the bare minimum for what would be considered a decent GNR cut. As Slash and Duff went their own way and Axl sunk deeper into his own ass, The Spaghetti Incident? was the last we'd see of the classic lineup for a long time.
6. One More Light - Linkin Park
It's never easy when a band decides to switch genres. Not only do you have to have 100% faith in what you're doing, but you also need to have the songwriting power to win over the rest of your fans so they'll follow you to the next phase of your career. If there was any nu metal band who could pull this off, it would be Linkin Park, but One More Light was snuffed out way quicker than anyone could have imagined.
After coming off of a return to roots record with the Hunting Party, these former metal titans took a leap of faith into the world of pop, where they sank like a stone. Once the debut single Heavy didn't register with the public, the nu metal faithful ended up abandoning the project pretty quickly after hearing songs that sound closer to something like Avicii than anything associated with metal.
Though any band of Linkin Park's caliber could have recovered from a bad album, things ended up going south way too quick, as Chester Bennington was found dead in California just a few months after the album was released. One More Light might be a misguided record from front to back, but no one would have wanted the posterchildren of nu metal to burn out like this.
5. Sonic Highways - Foo Fighters
The greatest records of all time often start out with a simple premise. Even if your fans only see your work as just another collection of songs, some of the most foundation rock music tends to have a concept tying everything together. Having a goal for a record certainly sets you up for success, but that's doesn't mean that everything will line up perfectly afterward.
On the surface, Foo Fighters' 8th record Sonic Highways sounded like a fantastic experiment, with the band going to different legendary studios across the US and soaking in the influences of the city.
However, the resulting songs make the Foos' traditional punchy sound feel a bit flabby. It's almost as if you can hear the influences from these different cities coming through in the music, but the emphasis is too much on the traditional Foos formula that they all kind of blend together into your generic arena rock.
Most of these things can be sidestepped with songs like Something From Nothing or Congregation, but considering that the very last record Wasting Light saw the band getting back into their raw form, this complete 180 caused a lot of fans to mentally check out after they were done binging the TV series on HBO.
The Foo Fighters certainly weren't suffering after this record, but this felt like a good idea on paper that made for a bad execution on repeated listens.
4. X - Def Leppard
Unlike most of the other hair metal bands of their ilk, Def Leppard managed to put themselves back together after the grunge wave came and went. While they weren't safe from the alternative-leaning embarrassment that was Slang?, Euphoria put them back in tune with the glamorous pop flavored rock that were known for in their prime, down to the album title ending in -ia like Hysteria and Pyromania. The alt-rock buzz may have worn off, but the need for pop-flavored material got a bit too much on X.
For any fan who comes to Leppard for the licks, this is not the album for you, with the band being on full pop-mode for the duration of the disc. There's nothing inherently wrong with going in this pop direction considering Leppard's hooky chops, but this sudden switch left the die hard rock fans really cold.
Granted, it's not like any of these songs are played poorly or anything, but this sounds more like a band that would have killed the competition if they started in the '00s rather than the hair metal titans from 2 decades ago. X is not really that bad of an album when broken down, but the only thing going against these songs was the fact that Def Leppard was the name on the tin.
3. Tre - Green Day
At the start of the 2010's, there was no reason not to think that the next album trilogy from Green Day was going to be anything but spectacular. The band had scored a massive career resurgence off of American Idiot and even managed to create another blockbuster rock opera with 21st Century Breakdown just a few years later. However, this stretch of albums turned into a chore for pop punk fans really quick.
By the time Uno came out, fans were already a little bit bored, but when Dos embarrassed itself right out of the gate, Tre didn't really have a prayer to be anything but mediocre. Despite trying to go in a more epic direction on their final installment, all of these brats' goodwill had been firmly drained from their soul, with songs that were supposed to sound sweeping and grandiose feeling like carbon copies of other Green Day songs or just tired in general.
It also didn't really help matters that Billie Joe Armstrong started to spiral at this stage, which ended up coming to a head at the massive iHeartRadio meltdown a months before the album's release. After four long months of anticipation for the new pop rock vision, Tre feels like the sad final chapter that was sent kicking and screaming out the door just for the band to say that they were done.
2. Cyberpunk - Billy Idol
The golden age of MTV was dominated by Billy Idol. At a time when people were just starting to get acquainted with the idea of the music video, the former leader of Generation X struck out on his own with some of the most infectious pop-flavored punk the masses had ever heard. But like all '80s superstars, the turn of the decade ended up being too cruel to punk's commercial ringleader.
Trying to reinvent his career from the ground up, Cyberpunk was one of the biggest bombs to ever come from a mainstream artist, as Idol took on a concept of a virtual reality universe within the span of one album of music. This kind of idea actually seems do-able on paper, but the actual idea of a technological interface sounds much more suited to a prog rock production than a punk rock lens.
Kudos to Idol for trying the more DIY approach of DJs, but considering that the industrial boom hadn't really kicked into high gear yet, the age of Nirvana left this album out in the cold. After a decade of dominating the charts, this was the one album that Idol wouldn't recover from, as he escaped into the shadows before eventually coming out with nostalgic music and Christmas albums at the turn of the century. The Idol that we know and love is in here somewhere, but the running concept seems much more suited to an online RPG than an actual album.
1. Songs of Innocence - U2
U2 have always had an heir of self-importance about themselves ever since they hit the top of the charts. For every great record like The Joshua Tree or Achtung Baby that these Irish rockers made, the more pretentious behavior that came with projects like Rattle and Hum turned some fans off just the same. This kind of thing normally faded away as long as the music kicked ass, but there is a way of promoting your album into oblivion.
When presenting their new album Songs of Innocence, Bono and co. were planning on releasing the album online, which would make sense considering the unorthodox ways that everyone from Radiohead to Bjork were releasing their material doing at the time. However, when the band paired with Apple to launch the album onto everybody's phones, the average music listener was absolutely ravenous.
It's one thing to just get the album for free from the band, but to have an album literally force fed into your music library was too much to bear, leading fans to request that the album be deleted from their library immediately. Songs of Innocence may be a good record on the surface, but U2 ended forgetting the biggest rule of music marketing...balance. The worst album bombs aren't the albums that no one knows about...it's the album that the record company won't stop telling you about.