10 Biggest Drop-offs In Rock History

The Slow Trail Back Down.

Oasis Do You Know What I Mean
Creation

When musicians are on top of the world, you don't tend to think of the downward spiral. Compared to the usual highs that come with having your album in the charts, it's better to go with the flow and ride the wave of success for as long as it will take you. Then again, it might be going so well that you don't realize the brick wall you're about to run into.

As much as some of these artists made phenomenal records for their time, these are the tracks that brought them back down to Earth in the worst way possible. Going from some of the classics of the genre, these records ended up sinking like a stone when they were released, not having nearly the amount of personality of their earlier records. Hell, in the worst case scenario, you have some instances where bands almost lose their identity entirely, instead trying to wear the latest trends like a mask and coax off the goodwill of their new fanbase.

For as much as their early work might have been great, these albums are proof that goodwill can only take you so far in this industry. In this case, we're not mad...we're just disappointed, which is almost a thousand times worse.

10. The 1975

It really hurts to put one of the most defining artists of the modern age of pop rock on a list like this. Back in 2013, hearing the 1975's debut for the first time felt so fresh, albeit with their own sense of retro throwback and synth heavy sound on songs like Chocolate and Sex. Once they got that taste of fame, it seemed that they found more time to screw around than give us actual good songs.

Despite the obvious Radiohead pastiches going on on the album A Brief Inquiry Into Online Relationships, you could tell that the guys were really starting to expand upon their sound and capture moments of emotion on songs like Sincerity is Scary. As the rollout for Notes on a Conditional Form kept coming in though, the track list kept expanding...and expanding...and expanding so far it was nearly a mile before the record even came out.

Outside of some genuine highlights like Me and You Together Song and Guys, Notes on a Conditional Form is both everything right and wrong about the 1975 in one album, with great songs that have virtually no flow due to the massive amount of interlude tracks. It's possible for the lads to make a comeback of sorts, but given how many artists are beating them at their own game, they have got their work cut out for them.


9. Guns N Roses

When looking at the career trajectory of most rock and roll acts, Guns N Roses seemed to grow up at an alarming rate. After making one of the hungriest sounding debut albums ever on Appetite for Destruction, the group went for a pretty sizable chunk of the record industry with their double record Use Your Illusion. The ceiling had been reached...now it was time for Axl Rose to show his stuff.

For as many stadium tours came with the success of the Illusion records, Rose's erratic behavior came at the expense of the rest of the band, who ended up either quitting in protest or being fired halfway through the tour cycle. No matter...Axl will just make the thing himself, right? Well...yes....in about a decade and a half.

Once Chinese Democracy was finally released on the world back in 2008, the hype had gone down considerably since the mid '90s. Since Axl was slaving away with dozens upon dozens of musicians at his disposal, the record sounds like it's coming from two different sides of his brain, which it very well may be considering that these takes were probably from different decades entirely. Granted, this does sound like the record that Axl probably wanted to make...but the amount of anticipation that we went through just to get it was a burn we still haven't recovered from.


8. Pearl Jam

Even if you didn't like Pearl Jam's direction in the '90s, you couldn't say that it wasn't at least fun to watch. Ever since defining the grunge movement on their debut Ten, their extracurricular activities like taking on Ticketmaster led to some pretty rough patches in their discography. Though they managed to turn those hard times into solid gold on something like Vitalogy, what the hell happened here with No Code?

Coming off some of the greatest albums that any band would release that decade, No Code just sound like the band are tired of the entire creative process, all while dealing with the sudden rush of fame that keeps getting thrown their way. While it's understandable for some records to be a bit more understated because of the celebrity buzz, you'd think that Pearl Jam would have been over something like this since they were in the public eye for almost half a decade at this point.

Instead, what we are treated to here is a scenario in which the weirder moments of Vitalogy are the highlights, as most of these songs range between cool art rock and songs that are struggling to get out of first gear from the moment they start. Looking back, Eddie Vedder had made mention of getting impersonal with this album and distancing himself from his audience. Given how forgettable some of these tracks are, he very nearly succeeded.


7. Bad Religion

When looking at the genesis of hardcore punk, Bad Religion make for a nice crossroads for the more uninitiated fans of the genre. As much as their abrasive sound on How Could Hell Be Any Worse struck a nerve with the hardcore scene, the firm grasp on melodic structures gave them a bit of musical credibility among their peers. So...what do you do when you have one of the best debuts of the decade? Well...assume it's a fluke I guess.

Given how young they were, both Greg Graffin and Brett Gurewitz were convinced that they had captured lightning in a bottle and could never top what they already did. Looking to almost self sabotage their own sound, Into the Unknown is one of the most perplexing albums of the '80s, as Bad Religion trade in their chunky power chords and raw production for some of the squelchiest synth tones ever conceived by man.

Seriously, some of these progressive style production choices on here would even have acts like A Flock of Seagulls telling you to tone things down a little bit. It would seem Graffin and Gurewitz knew they had a dud on their hands, considering they nearly broke up and never even mention the album as part of their main discography anymore. Even though something like this is not Bad Religion by any stretch, it's still worth revisiting if not for the sheer weirdness factor alone.


6. U2

There aren't too many bands from the '80s who can say they survived the '90s relatively unscathed. No matter what kind of music you played in the era of neon colored everything, the grunge explosion was sure to send you to the bargain bins at one point or another. Even though U2 felt like prime candidates for having a drop-off, they actually managed to turn things around...for a couple of years.

After the massive success of their drastic change on Achtung Baby, Zooropa at least showed that they were willing to take chances, with songs like Babyface and Numb taking a greater pop influence than we had seen previously. There's a fine line between taking influence and just plain old selling out...and Pop pretty much marks the defining line of that argument.

Instead of paving their own way for themselves, this entire record feels like U2 trying to put their trademark optimistic sound into the production of industrial music, which hits with an audible thud on nearly every track on here. Outside of some of the "so bad they're good" moments on something like Discotheque, a lot of these songs are reminiscent of what Trent Reznor might sound like if he never experienced a problem in his life. For as long as U2 managed to be on top of the world, there's no excuse for having songs that feel like the sonic equivalent of defecating into a MIDI synthesizer.


5. Oasis

No one was really expecting the drastic turn that rock music would take in the wake of the grunge implosion. After Kurt Cobain's tragic death, Oasis were one of the first to really blow up in England afterwards, making the old school flavors of rock and roll feel new and exciting again. Making one of the defining records of their generation with What's The Story Morning Glory, Oasis had hit the ceiling...only to find their way to the bottom of the barrel on Be Here Now.

Compared to the more spellbinding music on Morning Glory, these elongated songs feel half baked from the minute they start playing, as Noel Gallagher reuses some of the chord progressions from the band's older hits and tries to pass them off as something new. It's a wonder why they even bothered making this the proper followup, considering the amount of amazing B-sides they had at their disposal at the time.

Given that most of the final great Oasis songs would be released on the Masterplan a few years later, it stings that something like Half the World Away was relinquished to a B-side while something like D'you Know What I Mean was good enough to make it to the prime opening slot of this album. Just like grunge had done before it, Be Here Now might be the most glaring example of Britpop hitting a sudden brick wall.


4. Metallica

Any casual Metallica fan would know that the metal legends have gone through many career drop offs in their time. Though they always manage to at least learn from their mistakes, there's always been some questionable motives in the Metallica camp, from the decision to cut their hair and make alt-rock during the Load era to daring to even go mainstream with the Black Album. While many would point to St. Anger as the point of no return, there's probably a stronger case to be made for Lulu.

With the release of Death Magnetic, it was clear that Metallica were back to being the thrash legends we knew and loved, if All Nightmare Long and The Day That Never Comes were any indication. Instead of staying in that lane though, Lars Ulrich and James Hetfield thought it was now time to experiment, going into the studio to provide the backing track to one of Lou Reed's productions entitled Lulu.

As much credibility as Reed had as one of the founders of artful rock, there really is no reason for these two musical forces to come together, with most of the record sounding like two completely different genres that for some reason have to be placed next to each other. Even though Metallica fans have come to expect left turns like this, it stings that much more when they were doing something better literally one album ago.


3. Pink Floyd

There's probably a massive contingency of Pink Floyd fans who consider 1994's the Division Bell to have been the final statement the prog titans wanted to make. Since Roger Waters was firmly out of the picture at this point, it felt like Floyd wanted to put one last stamp on their career and leave their legacy where it was. After a while though, the temptation of reaping on your past glory ends up getting the better of you.

Compiled of mainly instrumentals, The Endless River is some of the most hollow sounding music to ever have the name Pink Floyd attached to it. Though The Division Bell was already a far cry from something like Wish You Were Here or the Wall, the fact that these tracks barely pass for background music make it all the more disappointing, as David Gilmour throws arrangements together for the hell of it.

As much as Gilmour hasn't lost his touch, the whole album really feels soulless when you don't have some unifying theme or even a handful of hooks behind it at any given time. Even though it's nice to remind your audience that you can still throw down when you want to, The Endless River is the ultimate case study of if you don't use it, you lose it.


2. Gorillaz

Ever since assembling Gorillaz back in the early '00s, Damon Albarn always had the idea of the cartoon band being an ever evolving entity. Throughout albums like Demon Days, you could feel the collaborative spirit throughout the record with Albarn as the mastermind, even taking a back seat to some of the more cartoony elements on records like Plastic Beach. However, taking a back seat does make you pick up some bad habits if Humanz is any indication.

Granted, it's not like Humanz is a gigantic failure in the grand scheme of Gorillaz' lore. From start to finish, it really feels like Albarn at least tried to fulfill his goal of making a dance party for the end of the world, albeit with a lot more scatterbrained production behind it. Considering the identity of Gorillaz comes back to Damon, it's disconcerting to only hear him pop up as 2-D every now and again, often letting the guest stars dominate the tracks with varying degrees of success.

While something like this definitely worked on Plastic Beach, the execution here just makes the album feel toothless, which doesn't really help when Albarn edited out any references to Donald Trump in the lyrical content. This may have been about partying, but the end result feels a lot more morbid than you would think.


1. Radiohead

Not many acts can claim to be releasing genre defining music after being in the game for over a decade. Usually when a band comes up with the best that they have to offer, it normally comes when they're either young and hungry or veterans of the genre that still have that youthful energy. With the release of In Rainbows though, Radiohead proved that they still had a handle of amazing music 10 years after Ok Computer...and then immediately forgot those ideas for the King of Limbs.

Recorded in a much different way than their previous albums, most of the King of Limbs was meant to be centered around the percussion aspect and incorporating different loops, which isn't all that different than what Thom Yorke was envisioning for Kid A back in the late '90s. While Kid A may have thrived off of the creepy atmosphere, this record just feels like it's struggling to reach the sonic peaks it's looking for, either getting too monotonous over time or just not having a good enough melodic leg to stand on.

Even the live shows for these songs seemed to be somewhat fractured, with another drummer being brought in to get every single sound heard on the record on the stage. Though A Moon Shaped Pool got us reacquainted with the sad atmosphere of Radiohead, the King of Limbs still reeks of a lot of good ideas that were just not given their moment to shine.


In this post: 
Oasis
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97