10 Biggest 'Sellout' Albums In Rock
The ultimate insult to a band's integrity...
Being slapped with the label of 'sellout' is one of the more egregious accusations a band can receive. But artistic integrity isn't such an easy thing to maintain, particularly when presented with a wad of cash. It's a tough gig, slogging it out in a rundown van, with a bunch of stinking musicians; who can blame a group for cashing in when the opportunity presents itself?
It's another matter when a band is already established, though. Gathering a following is a fine accomplishment, it's often the result of a dedicated drive to creating authentic music with integrity. It can be jarring then, when a group suddenly adopts a new look and sound, seemingly out of nowhere. It's a risky business changing direction, either the gamble pays off, and bands are hailed as innovators, or they get called out. Fans and critics can smell when a change is influenced by cashing in on a new trend, from a mile away.
These groups have all released at least one record, that either marked a change in direction, that didn't sit well with folks, or was motivated by commercial and financial success. Whether you thought these albums were good or not, they've all been dubbed as sellout moments...
10. Silver Side Up - Nickelback (2001)
The dichotomy of Nickelback are that they've always been universally hated, while managing to sell an outrageous amount of records.
We must pay these Canadian rockers their due respect, though. Their appeal is not wholly unfounded. Their tracks have a certain raw energy, particularly during the early days. But there's no getting away from Chad Kroeger's smarmy frat boy face.
Their first two records, although filled with grinding guitars, were pretty uninspired takes on post-grunge rock. Leader Of Men, was the single that started garnering the group attention. It's derivative of a number of Pearl Jam tracks, with Kroeger doing his best to channel Eddie Vedder. But, it hinted at a degree of potential...
The simmering intrigue of Nickelback boiled over into full on excitement with their third album. But it was the kind of radio savvy rock that reeked of contrived marketability. The ploy worked, How You Remind me seeped its way onto every radio station and music channel. The band blew up, and we were forever torn between loathing their superfluous drivel, and resisting the urge to sing every chorus.
This marked the trajectory of the group. Forever more they would coast on cringe inducing lead singles, nestled within albums of post-grunge rock, that feigned authenticity.
9. Enema Of The State - Blink-182 (1992)
Pop punk is littered with once highly respected acts, who turned their backs on the underground. Blink-182 are a prime example. The buzz around the group's enthusiastic on stage charisma, brought them a degree of recognition and respect. Their early music was the kind of indie-punk that turned up on independent skate videos. It was the sort of music only the most tuned in kids would know about.
The move from an independent to a major label, signalled reputation suicide for the band, however. Enema Of The State, skyrocket Blink to international stardom, selling millions of copies worldwide. This kind of success reeked of selling out to members of the underground community. The music was punchy and easily digestible pop rock for the masses. Every other song made reference to some kind of ant-authority attitude, but in the most vague and surface level way - it was the kind of rebellious sentiment every misguided teenager feels.
We've all sang along to these tracks at one point or another, and who can blame us, it's harmless, inoffensive fun, but there isn't much substance to it.
8. Metallica - Metallica (1991)
The Black Album, might be the greatest example of a group 'selling out' while still creating an absolute masterpiece. Metallica had spent the '80s whipping fans into a frenzy of flailing hair. For thrash-heads, they were up there with the best; these guys played harder and faster than almost anyone.
But the pressure to maintain their status as the kings of thrash, left the band feeling discouraged and uninspired. After four albums of racing up and down the fretboard, James Hetfield in particular, felt as though they had thrashed the creative horse to death.
The group changed tack. They slowed everything down, opting for melody and power, over speed. The sound became heavier. The riffs were classic rock, fuelled by the power of metal. They also explored a more tender side of the genre. Once they wrote Nothing Else Matters, all bets were off. This was the moment, Metallica made a sharp right turn they could never go back from.
The Black Album transformed the group from heroes of a sub-genre to one of the biggest rock acts ever to flip the devil horns. There were grumblings from the hardcore thrash community, but they were drowned out by a sea of critical acclaim.
7. Only By The Night - Kings Of Leon (2008)
This was the turning point for Kings Of Leon. Once the moustachioed darlings of garage rock, this was the moment they became the pinup poster boys of arena rock. Set the two lead singles aside for a moment; this album is booked ended by two incredibly sincere numbers. Closer, was a haunting take on post-punk, with weeping guitars and poetically evocative lyrics. Cold Desert was equally as emotional, with Caleb Followill giving a soul bearing performance, as he exposed his struggles with alcohol and religion.
But the rest of the album was tasteless filler, devoid of all substance. It seems fate had a hand in writing, both Sex On Fire and Use Somebody. Calleb Followill was recovering from a dislocated shoulder. Deprived of a range in motion, the only part of his guitar he could reach was the bottom of the neck. This led him to write the two irritatingly catchy hooks to both tracks.
The lyrics were filled with derivative and uninspired musings about romance. Use Somebody was perhaps the most offensive. The second single reeked of over production, with swirling synth sounds, and surging pop choruses. This came from a group who had once written the song Soft: a number that humorously detailed Caleb's inability to get it up, while inebriated.
6. Hands All Over - Maroon 5 (2010)
Maroon 5 were never a particularly hip underground band. They weren't pioneers of a new exciting sound and they didn't strive for anything all that ground breaking. But, their first album was an engaging take on alt-rock, fused with funky pop. It was an album that hinted at depth even if it wasn't fully realised. There was a campness that screamed Scissor Sisters meets Elton John, and it was great.
Their second album presented two choices for the band. They could go down the rock route, exploring the edgier sound that had garnered them critical praise. Or they could double down on the radio-savvy pop. They chose the latter. By the third album they were firmly established as a pop group. They relied on their charismatic frontman, who was more keen on flaunting his tattoos and chiseled abs, than anything else.
Hands All Over contained a track that to this day still haunts radio stations and dance playlists. Moves Like Jagger was not worthy of bearing the name of one of rock's pioneering frontman. The song, and the album it resides on, sealed Maroon 5's fate as a group lacking in artistic integrity.
5. Americana - The Offspring (1998)
The Offspring are another band who deserve to have their achievements acknowledged. The group's third studio album, Smash, is the best selling album ever to be realised on an independent label. Released by Epitaph Records, it was filled with plenty of thrashing guitars, punchy drums, and lyrics that touched on political and social issues; as well as themes of mental health.
Rather than continuing to push the indie label hype, the group jumped ship and capitalised on their success by signing with Columbia Records. The Offspring had been seen as the pioneers of alternative punk rock, but this move was a slap in the face to the punk scene. After a lukewarm reception to their follow up record, Ixnay on The Hombre - which saw the band move further away from their roots - they released Americana.
It had all the appeal of a bunch of guys in the mid 30s attempting to relive their salad days. It was filled with teen-bop, pop-rock tracks, which bore little resemblance to the group's punk origins. Pretty Fly (for a White Guy), The Kids Aren't Alright, and Why Don't You Get A Job, all sounded juvenile. Sure, these numbers kindle a degree of nostalgia, but compared to the groups earlier work, they were nothing short of commercial money grabs.
4. Tickets To My Downfall - Machine Gun Kelly (2020)
Up until this point, Machine Gun Kelly, was as known for his high profile bromance with Pete Davidson, and his relationship with Megan Fox, as he was for his music. Hi prominence as a mainstream hip hop artist, was largely due to his diss tracks aimed at Eminem. He's done a pretty decent job of turning himself into pop culture icon...
In the last few years '90s and 2000s nostalgia has washed over everything from fashion trends, to movies and music. Riding the wave, pop punk made a resurgence. Although acts like YUNGBLUD, have released some interesting takes on the genre, for the most part, it's been unimpressive.
It's no coincidence, that after Machine Gun Kelly struck up a friendship with YUNGBLUD, he announced he was trying his hand at the genre himself. It smelled like a desperate attempt to get in with the younger generation. When emo rap and face tattoos, were all the rage, Kelly jumped on the wagon. And this was no different. The album might be able to boast Travis Barker as a producer, but even the drummer for Blink 182 couldn't make this sh*t stick.
3. American Idiot - Green Day (2004)
Way back in 1994 Green Day angered underground punk fans, by ditching their indie label and signing with Reprise. But signing with a major label didn't necessarily signal a decline in artist integrity for the group. Dookie was wildly popular and critically acclaimed. It yielded classics like Basket Case and When I Come Around. The former demonstrated Billy Joe Armstrong's ability to write insightful lyrics about a mental breakdown. The latter was an ambling musing about a broken relationship.
Even though the group's next three albums didn't have the same impact as Dookie, they all had merit. Even Warning had some great moments. Armstrong proved he wasn't just a pop rocker, he had an ability to pull in a variety of musical styles, with an aptitude for blending sincerity and humour.
Then we got American Idiot... To many, this was the soundtrack of their youth. Holiday became an instant anthem. And, Boulevard of Broken was a ballad that spoke to any teenager going through that godawful, confusing phase of life. But the desperate attempt to reinvent themselves with checkerboard ties and guy liner, felt contrived. It was if they received a check list of 2000s emo-punk fashion and diligently ticked off every box.
2. Invisible Touch - Genesis (1986)
By this point Genesis had been progressively moving away from their art-rock past for some time. This album saw them close the door on prog once and for all. Collins was clearly the driving force, with Mike Rutherford and Tony Banks taking a backseat. Many critics of the time, panned the record for being an extension of Collins' solo work, regarding it as a collection of songs, clambering for radio play.
In many ways, they weren't wrong. This was a pop record, and Collins was most definitely at the helm. But when 'selling out' harbours pop music that sounds this good, who bloody cares? Prog rock had its heyday; it was time for cheesy '80s synth, and atmospheric soundtrack music.
Both the title track and Land of Confusion are timeless classics in the realm of '80s synth-pop. Anything She Does is absolute nonsense, but in the most enjoyable way. The jaunty synth lines are so over the top, you can't help but surrender to them. The lyrics are equally as absurd. They might sound like a yearning for lost love, but Tony Banks wrote the song about a guy who's obsessed with a porn star... This album served as the the stepping stone to the Genesis classic, We Can't Dance.
1. Permanent Vacation - Aerosmith (1987)
Aerosmith were swaggering rock royalty throughout the '70s. It was the classic set up: Steven Tyler was the snake hipped frontman, swanning around onstage; Joe Perry was the mysterious axe god, delivering killer riffs and wailing solos. As the decade drew to an end, however, the dynamic duo drifted apart with the years of debauchery taking their toll. The group were a spent force. Perry left in '79 and the rest limped on without him.
For the next few years the group released a string of moderately successful albums, including a greatest hits compilation - never a good sign for any act. Perry, eventually rejoined the band, and in 1987 they released Permanent Vacation. Among other fan favourites, it included Dude Looks Like A Lady and Rag Doll. It was undoubtedly a come back for the group but it all felt a little manufactured.
The group had a fresh new look. They leaned into the hair metal thing, adorned in leggings, bandanas and an an unholy amount of scarfs. But the group also brought in a number of ghostwriters. The authenticity was waining. Mainstream-savvy production techniques and a boy band style back up team, helped provide the material. If succumbing to ghostwriters isn't selling out what is?