10 Classic Rock Bands That Ripped Off Themselves

Same Song, Different Day.

Otherside Red Hot Chili Peppers
Warner Bros.

Rock and roll has never run short on people stealing from each other. The old adage goes that it takes a genius to steal, so it's only natural for some bands to wear a little bit too much of their influences on their sleeve from time to time. It's a bit of a different story when you end up stealing from yourself though.

If you've been in the rock world for a while, there comes a point when you're going to want to settle with a formula that works, and many artists have gone through the motions with songs that are a basic redo of what they had done before. From a pure song construction standpoint, these are the kind of songs that these people can write in their sleep, especially when all they had to do was copy and paste the same formula that they did before and putting different lyrics to it.

While there are also bands like AC/DC who seem to just write the same song over and over again, these are the people that are almost self aware of how derivative they're being and are trying to just get by regardless. The new listeners might not pick up on these kind of things, but for those of us dyed in the wool with these bands, this is starting to look a little bit lazy, guys.

10. Between High School and Old School - Alice Cooper

By the time Alice Cooper was reaching the early '00s, he didn't really have to prove anything to us anymore. He had already been the standout back in the '70s with his shock rock days and now became the eternal cool guy in Wayne's World, so just let him have his fun with the music that he wants to make. As it turns out though, Alice decided we needed a refresher course on his legacy. It was time to go back to school.

It doesn't take a rocket scientist for you to see that Alice is trying to do with this song what he had done with School's Out back in the day. In the case of this one though, it doesn't really work that well, considering that the guy is in his 60s at this point and sounds more like a scraggly old teacher that has been wasting his life away in school instead of the brooding rock star that sang the original.

Then again, it's nice to know that the man is at least in on the joke that he's trying to sell in this song. From the title alone, Alice knows that he's doesn't have the finger on the pulse of hard rock like he used to, but he's going to be on their side regardless. There might be some definite repeats showing up on here, but as long as the king of shock rock is having fun, is it really that bad of a problem to have?


9. Crazy - Aerosmith

For every dyed in the wool Aerosmith fan, it has not been fun looking in on the band for the past few decades. Ever since the '90s, it looked like the band were going pop and leaving all of the down and dirty blues side of their sound in the dust. That's fine as long as the music kicks ass though, and if you don't try to write the same song twice on the exact same record.

Being the moment that they started to work with outside songwriters for their material, Crazy was the main event of the Alicia Silverstone era of the band, showing them go for a much more lovesick tone than what we were used to. Just before we get to Crazy, we also have Cryin, which sounds nearly identical to this song, from the slower groove of the tune to the fact that both of them are in the exact same key.

And what makes it even worse is the fact that these were both released as singles with their own distinct video, almost like they were drawing attention to the similarities. The liner notes of the album say that Steven Tyler and Joe Perry worked with two distinct outside songwriters for this, but you can't say that they didn't look at Cryin, tweak a few things, and just passed this off as the unofficial sequel.


8. Girl From The North Country - Bob Dylan

If there's anyone in rock who should never be slacking off in the lyrical department, it's Bob Dylan. As much as he may have his ups and downs as a songwriter, the man behind classics like Ballad of a Thin Man and Tangled Up in Blue is always going to be held to a slightly different standard than your average sex, drugs, and rock and roll songs. And at the end of his glory decade of the '60s, he opened up his country album with...the same song again.

This isn't even a joke. Girl From the North Country was already a Bob Dylan song, being one of the standouts from the Freewheelin Bob Dylan just a few years earlier. On this record though, it's Dylan doing a completely different take on the song, using the same chord structure by sprucing it up as a bit of a country leaning tune than the folk original. Though we do get some lines from country legend Johnny Cash, this feels like it belongs more on his record than Dylan's.

There's nothing wrong with it other than the fact that you so rarely see a band covering themselves on a record, complete with the exact same vocal inflections that Dylan was known for back in the day. Then again, if he was transitioning into a different sound, maybe this was Dylan's way of trying to recontextualize one of his older songs for the next era of his career. Still, since the original wasn't even a decade old at this point, you have to at least give a cover of the song some breathing room, right?


7. When - Megadeth

When you talk about bands ripping themselves off, there's always a bit of grey area when it comes to Megadeth. Ever since Dave Mustaine was booted from Metallica, he has been recycling the riffs that he wrote during his time with the band, while also seeing his old bandmates make songs out of them as well. Though Hangar 18 is the biggest comparison when looking at both bands, a better case should be made for When off of the World Needs a Hero.

By this point, we've gotten used to the more intricate clean guitar sounds on a Megadeth album, and yet there's something about this riff that feels all too familiar. When you break down what Dave's actually doing here, this is just the basis of one of the main licks in the Call of Ktulu from Ride the Lightning, which was based on some of the sketches that Mustaine was using before he left the band.

In this case though, you can't really call it plagiarism. After all, this was his idea in the first place, and this might have been just a subtle way for him to get some payback on the guys from all the bad blood that went down back in the day. Either way you slice it though, we did end up getting two kickass songs out of the deal. So which band wins here? Neither. The fans do.


6. Times of Trouble - Temple of the Dog

In the early grunge scene of Seattle, band members were being traded left and right across town. It wouldn't be all that strange to see a drummer in one band one week, only to be finding himself in a complete different one a couple of weeks later. When those swapping band members start to get famous though, you start to notice a little bit of overlap in the riffs.

As Mother Love Bone fell apart, Stone Gossard started shopping demos around of his music, which eventually found its way into Eddie Vedder's hands in San Diego. Creating a coherent story across three songs, Vedder took this spare guitar lick that Stone made and turned it into Footsteps, which became one of the most popular B-sides of the band's early years.

Around the same time that Eddie was finding his groove though, Chris Cornell offered Stone to join Temple of the Dog as a tribute to Andy Wood, and that same guitar lick crept back up again. For the most part, Times of Trouble and Footsteps are practically the exact same song, only with Cornell delivering his searing wail over top of it instead of the brooding sounds of Eddie. Although Temple of the Dog's record came out long before Ten was released, the magic of Pearl Jam was already starting to bubble up just a few miles south of Seattle.


5. Otherside - Red Hot Chili Peppers

Most of the Peppers' album Californication sounds like a healing process for everyone involved. After bringing John Frusciante back from the brink of drug hell and Anthony Kiedis also being on the road to recovery, a lot of the songs reflect those scars, with topics that delve into the seedier side of life in California. When you're writing about your scar collection though, you just have to make sure that you don't end up repeating yourself too much.

Of all of the ballads that were released on this record, Otherside feels like another version of what we had already seen before leading up to this record. Since the standout song from this era is the title track, putting this song right before it just makes it look weak, especially when you start to pay attention and realize that they share some of the exact same chords.

'But wait'...I can hear some of you saying. The messages of the songs are different though, since Californication is about Hollywood and Otherside is about Anthony's addiction. Point taken, except for the fact that Anthony already played that kind of schtick brilliantly almost a decade earlier when he wrote Under the Bridge. While Otherside is a great song, you can definitely see the stitches where they brought in different parts of other Chili Peppers songs to flesh it out.


4. Sugar Youth - Green Day

Everything about Green Day's album Father of All felt like it was meant as a rush job. From the talks about Green Day being free from their label and the fact that the album is a little less than a half hour long, this feels more like an excuse to get out of a record deal than an actual artistic statement. Even when the song is less than a minute though, Green Day still found a way to steal from the past.

Out of all the lackluster tunes on other parts of the record, Sugar Youth is where we get to see that punk band that Green Day always knew how to be, with a little bit more edge in the guitars throughout most of the verses. When that chorus hits you though, you start to get some big flashbacks to the better times, and not necessarily in the best way.

As Billie Joe lets loose with his vocals and comes down with the line 'and it's dangerous,' the entire melody is lifted note for note from the song She's a Rebel off of American Idiot. The lyrics aren't really that different either, since all Billie had to do was replace 'she's' with 'it's' to make it slightly different. Given the fact that this entire album art work was about recontextualizing the American Idiot album cover, this is definitely the discount version of what we got during the rock opera years.


3. D'You Know What I Mean - Oasis

Ever since Oasis' '90s heyday, rock fans have done their due diligence wiping their hands of Be Here Now. As much as the songwriting may not have changed from the past few records, the overproduction of the entire record and the millions upon millions of guitar overdubs just made the entire thing feel a bit lackluster once you started listening to the songs. And we probably should have seen the burnout coming based on the first song that the Gallagher Brothers led off with.

Starting with the sounds of electronic noise and backwards vocals, this looks like Oasis are about to enter the next phase of their career, being much more bombastic than before. Once the guitars kick in though, the lightly strummed acoustic leads everything off with a chord progression that every open mic guitarist has engrained in our skull for years now.

For the most part, all of the chords for the verses are just the Wonderwall chords again, with Noel just putting different lyrics in place this time around and a melodic hook that isn't quite as hard hitting as what he did before. Compared to the melodic tendencies that he had at the time, D'You Know What I Mean just feels like the band were on autopilot through these sessions. We may have wanted a Wonderwall part two eventually, but this is the perfect case of being careful what you wish for.


2. King Nothing - Metallica

When you first taste success, there's always an inkling to want to do the same thing over again. Since the audience liked this song so well the first time, they'll like it even more when you give them another one, right? In theory, that should work, but you just have to make sure that you make the right changes so you don't come off like whatever Metallica did.

While people have been way too hard on Load and Reload for years now, King Nothing is still the best choice they could have made for a first single, with the same type of structure that made everyone love Enter Sandman. In fact, the whole thing seems to have too many things in common with Metallica's biggest hit, down to the fact that the entire song is practically a beat for beat copy of it.

From one section to the next, you can really pinpoint just how many parts of this song were copying the formula of the first one, like when the guitars build up to the title drop in the chorus to the beginning of the song with the guitars subtly creeping before things get going. As if it wasn't plagiarizing enough, we have James saying 'off to never never land' at the tail of the outro. Because this is not just a by the numbers Metallica track. This is Enter Sandman Jr. and don't you forget it.


1. Don't Stop - The Stone Roses

If a band ever decides to crib notes from one of their old songs, they do have a few options. Whether it's the construction of what they did before or just sprinkling in some of the same lyrics, you can always find different ways to morph your old sound into something that's slightly different. In the case of the Stone Roses though, their ripoff is actually one of the few that actually seems a lot more artistic.

Right after their peppy song Waterfall off of their debut, we're treated to Don't Stop, which has more than a few passing similarities with the song we just got done listening to. Compared to the last one, there's a lot more airy feel to this song, with the instruments almost sounding like they're being beamed in from the other side of the world. There's a catch to this whole setup though: it's backwards.

When the band were originally making this track in the studio, they took the basis of the song Waterfall and played it backwards, using completely different lyrics and crafting a new song out of that. They even tried to make it fit in with Waterfall as well, since the lyrics of the song were meant to mimic what the band members thought they were saying when they were hearing the vocals backwards. Rock and roll may have indulged itself with backwards music a lot of the time, but not many bands can claim that they have a song that they can play both backwards and forwards.


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97