10 Classic Songs That Have Aged Terribly
One Year Older, Another Year Staler.
It's impossible to not get sucked into the moment when you hear your new favorite song. Instead of the usual fun track to throw on a playlist, music can sometimes can take ahold of you and lead you on a journey that you weren't fully prepared for in the beginning. However, things tend to take a bit of a different turn once time becomes a factor.
When looking back on these songs with a new lens, it's hard to see them as a bit too dated for their own good. While some artists have managed to use that kind of nostalgia to their advantage in recent years, the amount of cheesiness that we had to sift through even comes from some of the best acts in the business. As much fun as it is to mock the no names who never went anywhere, these artists have no excuse since they're still around to tell the tale.
Across years (if not decades), these songs have aged like milk compared to their counterparts, proving that not even the greatest bands of all time are safe from a little bit of corniness here and there. You might know the name...but just smile and wave when looking back on cuts like this.
10. Having a Blast - Green Day
Over half of Green Day's charm in the early days of their career came from that bratty attitude. Across songs like Longview and Basket Case, it felt like you were having just as much fun yucking it up with tales of masturbation and anxiety attacks as you were singing along to the melodies. There was some edginess hidden in there though, and Having a Blast marks the moment where things turn a corner.
Compared to the more sardonic humor on the other tracks on Dookie, this second song feels a lot more confrontational than everything else around it. Though a lot of songs tackle the lives of down on their luck nobodies, this is sung from the perspective of a man willing to kill himself and everyone around him in one go due to his anger alone. That kind of thing might have been a cheeky pun in its day, but it looks a lot more cringy in the age of terrorism.
Given that the world has dealt with actual suicide bombers in the years since this track, this kind of power fantasy looks a lot creepier for this '90s time capsule. Since Billie Joe Armstrong himself has even called out this kind of star struck violence in Bang Bang from a few years ago, it seems like even he has distanced himself from his angsty beginnings.
9. Miss You - Rolling Stones
The Rolling Stones don't really owe any of us a damn thing anymore. Being one of the few long lasting groups to come out of the '60s, these leaders of the British Invasion can easily rest on their laurels as one of the founding members of what we call rock and roll. You don't get to that spot without a few dips in the old career though.
Across each respective decade, the Stones had tried to fit themselves into whatever the hip new trend was for the time, oftentimes involving cringy outfits and course correcting back to their bluesy roots. Though the '80s weren't kind to them at all, it's time that we all come to terms with the fact that the Stones' disco era was a mistake, with Miss You being the prime suspect.
As much as this might have been a way to incorporate the fresh sound of the time into the Stones' trademark menacing sound, the entire song just feels like the Glimmer Twins being sterilized in the worst way, as Mick Jagger talks about pining for his lover with what sounds like indifference in his voice. While everything the Stones do has its own distinct swagger, this is the worst kind of disco that falls just a hair above Rod Stewart's Do Ya Think I'm Sexy in terms of quality.
8. Working Day and Night - Michael Jackson
Michael Jackson's run throughout the '80s is probably going to go down as one of the greatest streaks in pop history. Starting with Off the Wall up until Dangerous, Jacko's penchant for writing some of the most earwormy hooks of the modern age has served as both the blueprint for pop and R&B going forward and the benchmark for musical perfection from top to bottom. Things like that don't happen in a vacuum though. Case in point: Working Day and Night.
When put up against the rest of Jackson's catalog, it's not like there's too much wrong with this track either, being the subtle blends of disco and pop that populates the rest of Off the Wall. However, this is the one instance where Jackson's production goes a little too far into cheesy territory, making the whole track sound like something that's blaring in Studio 54 after a particularly uninspired night.
Sandwiched in between the more uptempo songs on the record like Rock With You, this feels more like a comedown when the real action of the record should be just getting started. Even Jackson's take on the sappy Paul McCartney ballad Girlfriend has aged a bit better compared to this on production value alone. While some artists tend to have good instincts, this is the one moment where that Jacko and Quincy Jones magic wasn't quite there yet.
7. Virtuality - Rush
A lot of rock's stalwarts were hit with a sea change in the music landscape once the '90s rolled around. As the age of flannel shirts and mountains of irony seeped into the public consciousness, the legends of rock's glory days had to undergo some real changes in their sound to look like they fit in with the times. U2 may have managed it okay, so did R.E.M....Rush not as much.
Being relatively dormant throughout most of the late '90s, the Canadian power trio's album Test For Echo does have a pretty audible clunker on it with Virtuality. Compared to the rest of the late Rush catalog, this song is actually fairly competent if it weren't for some of the worst lyrics Neil Peart would ever write. Considering it was the dawn of the Internet age, this song makes use of every tech reference Peart can muster, which almost looks cute these days.
While it might not be fair to judge Neil on what the Internet would become just a few years down the road, the references to "net boy, net girl" is hilarious, along with "put your message in a modem and throw it in the cyber sea." There's a good song in here about the dangerous of virtual existence, but this just comes off like your dad not really understanding how technology works.
6. One In a Million - Guns N Roses
It's always important to give bands the benefit of the doubt when it comes to the poorly aged parts of their catalog. As much as we may like to dunk on them nowadays, there's a good chance that songs like this fared a lot better at the time than what we have to look back on. Then again, a song like One in a Million by Guns N Roses probably had a few people turning their heads even back then.
Being thrown onto the back half of the acoustic EP GNR Lies, this entire song paints Axl Rose as one of the most unlikable frontmen in the history of rock and roll. Though it's always somewhat excusable to have singers put on a chauvinistic vibe, the sound of Rose browbeating people of different races and sexual orientations just looks ignorant in the rearview.
It gets especially awkward when he decides to throw out homophobic and racist slurs in the middle of his verses, despite his assurance that the use of those words was to "provoke." Even though it's every artist's right to get on a soapbox if they want to, this is the equivalent of an Alex Jones rant set to music.
5. China Girl - David Bowie
Expecting David Bowie to stay on one course of music for the rest of his life really is foolish on the listeners' part. Ever since starting the glam rock movement back in the '70s, Bowie was comfortable to take leaps and bounds with songs he made up until his final album with Blackstar. Bowie may have been unafraid to take risks with his music...but that doesn't mean all of them are necessarily great.
When looking back on Bowie's discography, people tend to look on Let's Dance with a bit of disdain, thinking that the Thin White Duke has sold out to fit with the times. As much as the pop sound of the title track or Modern Love are classics for what they are, they might be onto something with China Girl, which is a bit too weird to really take seriously. Written with punk aficionado Iggy Pop, this entire song is where the '80s production fails Bowie a little bit, sounding more like a product of its time rather than a genuine artistic endeavor.
It also doesn't help matters that the idea of using the term China Girl is the kind of slang that didn't really deserve to survive past the early '80s. For all that Bowie has given us throughout his long and storied career, this probably should have just remained an Iggy song at the end of the day.
4. Kid A - Radiohead
The idea of Radiohead making a bait and switch change in styles after coming off of Ok Computer probably felt like career suicide at the dawn of the '00s. After making one of the biggest landmark albums in rock history, their line in the sand division on Kid A gave way to songs that were cold, calculated, and dripping with dread from start to finish. Though the end result was bold and brash as Squidward Tentacles would say, the title track of the album doesn't have nearly the same amount of staying power.
Working with loops and electronic effects for the first time, most of this song's "lyrics" were piecemeal assembled from bits of dialogue that Thom Yorke had recorded in the studio and then fed through a device that would make it sound like he was singing on replay. While the effect itself was pretty cool for the time, it's not necessarily all that fun to listen to these days.
Compared to some of the other strange sounds that populate songs like Idioteque and Motion Picture Soundtrack, this feels reminiscent of the kind of noises you hear when you try to order on that crappy speaker at the McDonald's drive thru. Kudos for the innovation you guys, now can you please get on with some actual songs, please?
3. Across the Sea - Weezer
Not many artists were willing to lay their heart on their sleeves in the '90s quite like Rivers Cuomo. After coming off one of the greatest debuts of the decade with Weezer's Blue Album, their followup Pinkerton was a lot more of an emotional listen, as Cuomo grappled with his nervousness, his unlucky romantic affairs, and trying to hold onto his sanity in a world that thrives on insanity. While everyone knows what it's like to fall in and out of love, Across the Sea is the kind of love that you don't really need to put down in song.
Granted, the genesis of this track starts off fairly strong, with Cuomo detailing a letter that he got from a teenage fan in Japan. There's probably millions of fans who would love to have been immortalized in their favorite bands' song, until you actually get into the gory details.
As the second verse comes up, Cuomo takes it down a much creepier direction, as he starts fixating on this girl every day and wondering what her room looks like and if she touches herself while thinking about him. Yeah, we just took a hard left turn into creeper territory real quick. Cuomo may in fact have a knack for turning his emotions into gold, but this kind of scuzzy song is two bad lyrics away from getting a restraining order.
2. Ebony and Ivory - Paul McCartney and Stevie Wonder
The idea of taking the piss out of something meant to bring people together can come off a bit mean spirited at the best of times. I mean, no one wants to be the guy yelling at people just because they're trying to make the world a better place. It gets even worse though when those people are two of the greatest musical minds to ever live.
Just as Paul McCartney was reaching his first elderstatesmen phase, he hooked up with music legend Stevie Wonder to write Ebony and Ivory about racial harmony, equating everything to the white and black keys on a piano. As much as their hearts are in the right place on this track, the actual execution isn't interesting in the slightest, sounding like a leftover from one of the Wings sessions while having Stevie Wonder on it to make it sound finished.
Though the talent is certainly here, both of these men were not necessarily at their musical prime either, with Wonder's classic period being firmly in the rearview and McCartney settling into the dad territory that would lead him to travesties like Give My Regards to Broad Street. If this song were made in the '70s, we would probably still be talking about its impact to this day, but we just got the cheesy "fresh" sounding version too many years too late.
1. Crawling - Linkin Park
In the vast sea of gray that was nu metal in the '00s, Linkin Park actually were the one band that managed to be fairly solid in their time. While there were some exceptional acts making the rounds at the time like Deftones, Linkin Park's knack for tortured songs like In the End and One Step Closer made Hybrid Theory one of the best selling albums of the entire decade, bringing nu metal to a much broader audience. When talking about nu metal though, you can never truly escape from the angst.
As much as something like Crawling has a decent enough melody to it, there's a good contingency of people who probably recognize this track for the memes that it has wrought than the actual music. Compared the usual pain felt on something like In the End, the performance by Chester Bennington is one of the more whiny in the history of nu metal, as he spews his venom about the wounds that won't heal around him.
It wouldn't be that much of a problem had Linkin Park not done this better in literally every other song on the album, from Runaway to Points of Authority. Given that Chester's final performances of this song were more subdued on their final tour, it's safe to say that we can permanently retire this kind of angst for good.