10 Disappointing Albums By Legendary Bands
More Than Just Mad.
Every band has to have at least one dud in them. No artist has a perfect track record for their entire career, and there’s always going to be those few records that never really hit the mark like they should have. Any album can be bad though…but disappointment is even worse when you’re expecting it to be good.
That being said, not all of these are terrible albums from front to back or anything. There are varying degrees of good spread across each of these albums. What makes them sting so much is the leadup that many fans had going into these albums, thinking they were going to get something amazing and then getting something mediocre instead. It’s not like something like St. Anger, since most Metallica fans knew well ahead of time that this was going to be a rough listen before the proper album came out.
No, these are the albums that we were rooting for this whole time but were not able to come through as the mammoth showstopping record that they were supposed to be. Even if these aren’t necessarily up to snuff though, their power just emphasizes the classics even more, making them more of a footnote in the band’s career or a fan favorite among some of the diehards. No one touches the sky every single time, but records giving us less than what we wanted is always a hard pill for fans to swallow.
10. Simulation Theory - Muse
From the minute that Matt Bellamy opened his mouth on the first Muse album, fans have always dogged on these prog rockers for being too influenced by Radiohead. Though there are some similarities in the way that both Matt and Thom Yorke sing from time to time, both bands seem to have their own identity, with Muse going for a much more dystopian bent to their lyrics and adopting classical influences that give a Queen-like epicness to their sound. The rock scene looked a lot different in the 2010's though, and Muse proceeded to just write an album that would make decent background music on Stranger Things.
That's not to say that Simulation Theory is all in one ear and out the other though. Throughout the entire record, you can tell that the band do have a genuine interest in the synth heavy side of their sound and wanted to explore that through the '80s aesthetic, but the end results come together with a bit of a clunk, with songs like Propaganda sounding a lot more haphazard than what you would expect from the guys who gave you songs like Uprising or Knights of Cydonia.
For all of the shockers on the album though, songs like Something Human and Get Up and Fight do reach the heights that they were originally setting up, having solid hooks and even toying with their sound in different ways by using acoustic guitar in some capacity. Muse have more than enough talent to make their way through whichever genre they want to, but this just sounds like their usual schtick being fed through an Atari sound system.
9. The Devil Put Dinosaurs Here - Alice in Chains
Most of the hardened grunge fans breathed a huge sigh of relief once Alice in Chains dropped Black Gives Way to Blue in 2009. As much as we were optimistic about the grunge titans coming back, replacing someone like Layne Staley wasn't going to be an easy task, and you could feel them making something that the Alice in Chains of old would have been proud to call their own. It was time to settle into something heavier though, and The Devil Put Dinosaurs Here became much more of a slog than what Alice was known for.
Although nothing about their sound has really changed on this record, the song lengths and droning riffs behind these cuts just make for a much more tiring an experience for the average listener. While the band had been known to have their brooding songs in the glory days like Sludge Factory and Rooster, these songs feel like you're working your way through a mud field in the wrong way, as one riff beats you over the head for what feels like hours.
It's no secret why this album sounds the way it does though, with Jerry Cantrell having to go through major surgery during production and even having to hum some of these riffs into existence to remember them before actually committing them to tape. If anything, having an album like this is a miracle under the circumstances, but you can tell that the band was aiming for something close to stoner rock and wound up in the boring middle ground.
8. Night in the Ruts - Aerosmith
Anyone who knew about Aerosmith's story in the '70s knew that whatever was going to come out after Draw the Line was going to be a bit of a rough listen. Even though their previous record stood out as a decent project, the band were really not taking care of themselves, getting strung out on drugs during the recording and some of the band barely even turning up at the first few sessions because of how screwed up they were. Something had to give, and Night in the Ruts was the band coaxing by on easy mode.
Since this was the last time that Joe Perry would play on an Aerosmith record for a while, you can definitely hear him slowly fading out of view, with songs like Mia being dominated by just Steven Tyler and a piano most of the time. Apart from the more ballad-esque moments though, a lot of the major Aerosmith cuts tend to sound like leftovers that weren't good enough for the last two albums, with No Surprize being just a rehashing of the story of how they got their record deal and Remember Walking in the Sand being a cover of an old teenage love song from the '60s.
Before the record was even finished though, the band had already turned to shambles, as Joe left the group after one too many arguments with Steven and the rest of the band moving on with Jimmy Crespo on guitar. The Aerosmith brand name may have existed for a little while, but the magic behind the Bad Boys From Boston felt like it was being snuffed out for good.
7. Some Time In New York City - John Lennon
After coming out of the Beatles' breakup, John Lennon seemed to have a lot more to say than your average peace and love sentiments. As the Vietnam War continued to rage on, the Intellectual Beatle was starting to make his voice heard a lot louder than his former Fabs, writing songs like Power to the People and Give Peace a Chance to promote the message of a better world without war. All of that sloganeering seemed to be paying off in spades, but Some Time in New York City is where everything started to hit a brick wall.
Although most Lennon fans blame this album's failure on Yoko Ono's involvement with the project, Yoko actually tends to have some of the best cuts on here, with songs like Sisters O Sisters having a fun '50s rock and roll feel to it. Compared to the cutting lines he had written before though, Lennon seems to come up short, either being too controversial by using a racial slur in the lyrics to one of his songs or sounding more like a pale imitation of Bob Dylan on songs like Luck of the Irish.
Though gems like New York City do pick up the energy a lot more, the second disc of this double album makes for one of the most grating listens of his solo career, being comprised of two live performances that he gave around this time which amounts to a pure cacophony of noise whenever listened to for more than a few minutes. Having new John Lennon songs out in the world is rarely ever a bad thing, but Some Time in New York City feels like a record that sounds much better in concept than it is in practice.
6. Other Voices - The Doors
For any hardcore fan of the Doors, the idea of the band continuing on without Jim Morrison just feels wrong to think about. Jim may not have played any instrument on their records, but his aura and poetry on every one of their records gave them the character and swagger that made them stand out among their contemporaries back in the day. The rest of the band still had to figure things out though, and Other Voices was their first try at soldiering on as a three piece.
While there are good ideas present on this record, a lot of these songs just feel like jam sessions that the band were working on around the time Jim had passed away, having the makings of potentially good Doors songs without any of the menace. With Ray Manzarak sing most of the songs, the swagger that the band has just feels neutered, sounding closer to a band like the Grateful Dead with a lot less energy in their delivery. It also doesn't help that the lyrics take a dip here as well, with songs like I'm Horny I'm Stoned not really having the impact as something like Riders on the Storm.
There may be some fans that still want to support this era of the band, but anyone who thinks of this as the classic stuff is missing out on one crucial detail. If this album had anyone else's name on it other than the Doors, chances are nobody would care.
5. Sonic Highways - Foo Fighters
Everyone in the rock community these days seems to be at least rooting for the Foo Fighters to do well in some capacity. Since Dave Grohl is one of the only musicians in the rock scene that actually gets legitimate screen time in the big leagues, hearing him branch outside of his comfort zone with the Foos should have been fantastic news, taking to the road to make an entire record in one classic music city after another. That makes for a neat idea on paper, but it also means that the record is going to be completely scattered whenever you listen to it.
Though most of the songs on Sonic Highways are fairly solid Foo Fighters jams, most of them seem to work as singular musical experiences rather than being taken in as a whole. If the accompanying documentary had taught us anything, it would be that every one of these cities tends to have their own unique identity, and hearing those bleed through in the music is a bit disorienting, going from the homegrown feel of a song like Congregation written in Nashville to the bombastic style of I Am the River from their time spent in New York.
While this definitely isn't Foo Fighters by numbers or anything like that, this feels less like a record and more like songs that were just thrown together to create something that looks like an album. The band is still in it for all the right reasons on here, but this was the first Foo Fighters record that seems to be just a little bit bloated even with a tight album runtime.
4. The King of Limbs - Radiohead
Every single Radiohead release that has come out since OK Computer always feels like a new risk for them to take. These guys aren't ones for doing just the same record over again for the hell of it, and each new project almost seems to have a mission statement regarding what they can do to tinker with their own sound. Since they had already conquered the world by going electronic on Kid A, then going in a more dance-y direction would work just as well...right?
While the basic idea of using different rhythmic textures to bring the Kings of Limbs to life sounds interesting, what we're left with is a just a bunch of fragments of songs that never feel fully fleshed out, like Morning Mr. Magpie sounding almost unfinished compared to the other classics tracks in Radiohead's discography. Although the spare ballads on here like Codex do strike a decent balance between the organic and artificial sides of their sound, most of the other tracks aren't nearly on the same level, often fumbling around trying to find some musical lane to stick with and never really settling into one.
Then again, it might have been the manner in which they recorded these songs as well, with the Live From the Basement sessions actually giving us much better versions of the tracks. The mindset behind this record was to make something that could put the audience into a trance while they listen to it, but somewhere during the mixing, the King of Limbs went from a trance-y experiment to just sounding tired.
3. In Through the Out Door - Led Zeppelin
From the beginning of the '70s onward, Led Zeppelin looked like they were on the verge of signaling a new regime of rock and roll. While Jimmy Page may have grown up in the same blues traditions that gave us bands like the Yardbirds, making riffs of his own turned into some of the biggest songs that hard rock would ever see, like the main line in Black Dog or the epic scope of something like Kashmir. As much as they may have defined the '70s, the decade they gave birth to isn't one they would survive intact either.
As the sessions for Presence came to a halt due to Robert Plant's recent car accident that ended with him in a wheelchair, In Through the Out Door sounds like the band playing catch up for the first time in their career, chasing after the new sound while not necessarily understanding what that new sound should be. For all of the people that like to heave insults at songs like Hot Dog off of this record, there are a fair share of highlights to be found here, from the lovely ballad All My Love to Bonzo laying down one of the best grooves of his career on Fool in the Rain.
Although this may have been looked at as a transitional record at the time, we'll never know what that new version of Zeppelin would look like, with John Bonham passing away before the tour for the album started, with the rest of the band breaking up around him. All we're left with is a few decent songs and a peek at what an '80s version of Led Zeppelin may have looked like.
2. Never Let Me Down - David Bowie
Throughout every era of David Bowie's career, you always knew you would never be getting the same thing twice. Bowie always played characters in his music, and his chameleon nature made for records that blended different genres together, from glam rock to soul to the kraut rock sounds of his Berlin period. We had reached a new guard during the '80s though, and Bowie may have gone a bit too far playing the pop star on Never Let Me Down.
Recorded in what Bowie would describe as his "Phil Collins years," a lot of the songs on here feel more generic coming out of Bowie, mining the same kind of dance-centric pop music that he was riding on after Let's Dance. While the songs off of his previous record like Tonight didn't really have the Bowie charm to them, Never Let Me Down was the first record where Bowie's zany nature seemed to work against him, as the production of this album goes for something abrasive and just ends up sounding like someone was playing with the levels in the studio, especially with the snare sound across the record.
Bowie may have been more than happy to follow the trends every now and again, but this wasn't the sound of a legend blending into a new genre. This was the sound of David fumbling around in the dark to see if something would stick, and what we got is more of a mess than some kind of abstract art.
1. Be Here Now - Oasis
After the massive success of What's the Story Morning Glory, Oasis had officially reached a level of success where they were too big to fail. While the press may have had their problems with the Gallagher brothers off the stage, songs like Wonderwall and Don't Look Back In Anger became anthems by themselves, putting them in the same league as other legendary British bands like The Jam and The Smiths. The next logical step was to go even bigger, but there was one problem...there was nowhere else to go.
Admittedly being stoned out of his mind during the making of this record, Noel Gallagher has made mention numerous times about how Be Here Now is far from the greatest Oasis record, with songs that go on for way too long and mountains of overdubs that seem to drown each other out half the time. For all the Beatles worship that's on a track like All Around the World, most fans weren't ready for the 9 minute version of the song, complete with key changes and a huge orchestral section at the end.
Then again, this isn't an album that's disappointing in the traditional sense. The songs on here are fairly decent and you can still hear the band that wrote Supersonic poking through the cracks here. This was just too much to take in all at once, and watching the band come off the tracks made for more than just a bad album. This was the sound of the Britpop movement finally coming to an end and cost the band their momentum.