10 Essential Classic Fall Out Boy Songs

Light Em Up and Centuries are all well and good, but check out these Fall Out Boy classics.

Fall Out boy
Wikipedia

Since they returned after a three-and-a-bit-year hiatus in 2013, Fall Out Boy have been a different group from the cult kings they once were. After a number of years at the top of the pop punk mountain, the quartet felt disillusioned and decided to take a break, although always left the door open for a return at some point. Each band member went through his own personal evolution during the break – frontman Patrick Stump lost over 60 pounds and bassist Pete Wentz "grew up" in his own words, while Joe Trohman and Andy Hurley... had haircuts – which made their return all the more satisfying when it eventually happened.

Fall Out Boy's two post-hiatus albums – 2013's Save Rock and Roll and 2015's American Beauty/American Psycho – definitely mark a shift in style from the albums which made them famous, favouring high production values, heavy beats and repetitive pop lyrics over the previous formula of raw, guitar-driven storytelling. That's not to say that they aren't great, because they are, but most long-term fans will point to the group's older material as 'true Fall Out Boy'.

With that in mind, here are 10 essential 'classic' Fall Out Boy songs you must check out, if you haven't already. Note the exclusion of the band's most successful mainstream hits, because let's face it – everyone knows about Sugar, We're Goin' Down and This Ain't A Scene, It's An Arms Race already, don't they?

10. Headfirst Slide Into Cooperstown On A Bad Bet

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZnYpOuS4jA

Despite what many fans might tell you, Fall Out Boy’s 2008 album Folie À Deux is a great collection of songs, which were written with high levels of collaboration between Stump and Wentz. One of the highlights of the album is Headfirst Slide Into Cooperstown On A Bad Bet, a slightly haunting and often crushing story of what Stump describes as "infidelity and deception". Understandably originally titled Does Your Husband Know?, it is the only Folie track to be referenced amongst previous singles on later track What A Catch, Donnie (by Elvis Costello).

What makes this song so engaging is its constant shift in style. Starting on a funky swagger with deep vocals and a horn section, it crescendos on the pre-chorus with heavy guitars and the "husband" interrogative, before lifting into an almost peaceful chorus of promise. Headfirst concludes in epic fashion with a heavy chorus complete with emotional vocals and layered, harmonised guitar licks. It's an exhausting ride through a rollercoaster of feelings.


9. Dance, Dance

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C6MOKXm8x50

I'm breaking my own rule here, as From Under The Cork Tree second single Dance, Dance actually reached the top ten in both the US and the UK. But having been preceded by arguably the band's most famous track Sugar, We're Goin' Down, I feel this one is sometimes overlooked.

As the title suggests, Dance, Dance is pretty much just a great fun dance song. Built on a pulsating drum line and memorable bass line, the track feels urgent and collaborative, which makes it a fantastic live experience. Guitar kicks in on the pre-chorus following Patrick's vocal lines nicely, and the chorus is suitably hectic, but the real crescendo comes in the middle eight (or bridge), where the sound thickens and the attitude is laid on strong in one of the band's typically brilliant (and sexually suggestive) lyrical nuggets.

Dance, Dance is one of the group's most widely praised songs, as well as one of the most common live staples, having been a mainstay in the band's set lists since it was released.


8. Grand Theft Autumn/Where Is Your Boy

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GZb_mqH2zJY

An instant classic from the band's first full-length release Take This To Your Grave, Grand Theft Autumn almost didn't make it to the album, with both Stump and Wentz displaying an element of antipathy towards the track. Thankfully though, the song did make it to release, and when the band 'broke through' with their second album From Under The Cork Tree, the single saw a resurgence in popularity sending it onto the US pop charts.

The track starts with the now legendary a cappella chorus, usually taken over by the crowd at shows. Producer Sean O'Keefe came up with the idea of the intro, which Stump is said to have hated at the time. Guitars kick in straight after the opening to set a quicker pace than one might have expected, signalling a high energy carried throughout the tale of jealousy and unrequited love. With probably one of the band's most memorable choruses, Grand Theft Autumn/Where Is Your Boy is an archetypal early FOB song, both lyrically and musically. Fittingly, it opens the outro 'collage' of hits on What A Catch, Donnie.


7. Thriller

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Whh_lXiEDs

It likely came as a surprise to most fans that the first voice they heard on Fall Out Boy's third album Infinity on High was that of hip-hop legend Jay-Z, but it worked fantastically well and set the tone for a fun, rebellious album.

Thriller is probably the most well placed song in Fall Out Boy's library. After signing with Island Records and releasing major label debut From Under The Cork Tree in 2005, the band quickly found themselves at the forefront of the incredibly successful emo/pop punk movement spreading across the world. At an average age of just 23 years old, the four-piece toured extensively in promotion of the album and played to hundreds of thousands of energetic teenagers and young adults. At the same time though, they were receiving some pretty mediocre critical reviews and missing out on awards they believed they were due. Thriller was the response.

The song opens Infinity On High perfectly, with an extremely simple heavy riff bookending autobiographical verses detailing the band's early struggles with fame and recognition. If Grand Theft Autumn makes you cringe and Headfirst Slide is a bit too moody for you, Thriller might just be the perfect balance for you.


6. Alpha Dog

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AK_7TGhayuA

Originally recorded during sessions for Folie À Deux and included on the 2008 mixtape Welcome To The New Administration as a demo entitled ALPHAdog And OMEGAlomaniac, Alpha Dog is one of the most underrated tracks released before the band's hiatus. One of two previously unreleased (apart from said demo) tracks on the 2009 compilation Believers Never Die: Greatest Hits, it is suitably heavy, broody and angsty to sum up the group's incredible career.

Musically, Alpha Dog is unlike almost anything else released by the band. Heavy pretty much from start to finish, with brief breathers in between verse and chorus (and a serene bridge section), the song is a full-on onslaught of distorted guitars and one of the most diverse Patrick Stump vocal performances ever. The lyrics hint at the band's then-impending break from music, whether intentionally or not, and the delivery jumps around from soaring to melancholic to aggravated. Understandably due to its complexity, Alpha Dog has never been played in full live, although the chorus has been included in a few medleys live here and there.


5. What A Catch, Donnie

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_lkJkwnXQZ8

It's been mentioned a couple of times already, so it should be no surprise that What A Catch, Donnie makes it onto this list. Both song and music video are intended as a throwback to the group's back catalogue, so it provides a fantastic introduction for the uninitiated.

Inspired by Elton John, What A Catch is a ballad built upon a simple piano chord progression with soaring vocals and horns. The verse descends into an evocative chorus, which later breaks out into a simple "na-na" chant. The real highlight, though, comes with the plethora of guest singers contributing to the aforementioned medley of Fall Out Boy hits. Elvis Costello starts it off with Headfirst Slide Into Cooperstown On A Bad Bet, before everyone from Travie McCoy of Gym Class Heroes to Panic! At The Disco's Brendon Urie perform hooks from hits such as Sugar, We're Goin' Down and Dance, Dance. It's an incredible finale to a beautiful song, and it blows your mind the first time you hear it.

The theme of nostalgia and revisiting past glory is mirrored in the music video, which features props from past videos including America's Suitehearts, Thnks Fr Th Mmrs and This Ain't A Scene, It's An Arms Race.


4. I Slept With Someone In Fall Out Boy...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T1OTsd9u0Wo

If you're into more hard rock and heavy metal, this will be the most accessible track for you. I Slept With Someone In Fall Out Boy And All I Got Was This Stupid Song Written About Me is probably the heaviest song released by the band to date. With alt-metal guitars, guttural vocal delivery and some classic Pete Wentz screamo thrown in (with featured vocalist Chad Gilbert of New Found Glory), it jumps out in the middle of From Under The Cork Tree as a harsh but welcome change in mood and attitude.

Beginning quietly with delicate, almost ominous vocals from Stump, the song quickly kicks in with hectic guitar riffs and amplified lyrical delivery addressing a groupie from the musician's point of view. The chorus is absolutely phenomenal, offering listeners a repeatable phrase to recite with a catchy melody. The breakdown of Stump and Gilbert screaming a repeated pair of phrases hasn't aged as well as the rest of the track, but it fits well with the tone of the song and is great fun live.

Harking back to the band's early hardcore sensibilities, I Slept With Someone In Fall Out Boy is sure to convert any naysayer to a fan in just three and a half minutes.


3. Thnks Fr Th Mmmrs

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=onzL0EM1pKY

In response to songs like I Slept With Someone In Fall Out Boy And All I Got Was This Stupid Song Written About Me were, Fall Out Boy's record label asked them to shorten future titles. Thus was born Thnks Fr Th Mmrs, an ironic disemvowelling of Thanks For The Memories. Another rule breaker, the second single from Infinity On High dominated rock and even mainstream radio in early 2007, but it marks a significant evolution for the group which can sometimes be overlooked.

Thnks Fr Th Mmrs starts dramatically with a prominent string section which is then joined by Stump's vocals, delivered in a theatrical fashion akin to a grand musical production. The song continues in classic Fall Out Boy fashion with emotional lyrics and one of the most catchy of any of the band's choruses, setting a new standard in the group's music from there on out. It marks a distinction from the raw 'rock band' sound of the band's first two albums and sets up the next, more pop-oriented phase of their career. A great introduction to the back catalogue.


2. I Don't Care

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Alh6iIvVN9o

Another heavy, moody number, I Don't Care was released as the first single from Folie À Deux and remains a fan favourite to this day. As the title and suitably anarchic video (which features former Guns N' Roses guitarist Gilby Clarke, plus a host of other guests) suggest, it is written generally about many people's negative reactions to the group, and in Stump's words is intended to "point out superficiality".

What's so great about I Don't Care is that it is simple and relatable: if someone is talking about you, even in a negative light, then they must care to some extent about you. This was really the main message of 'classic' Fall Out Boy and the pop punk movement in general – who cares if you don't 'fit in'? Another live staple, I Don't Care brings all listeners together in a repetitive chant of "I don't care what you think, as long as it's about me" with the support of overdriven guitars, gang-like backing vocals and deafening drums.


1. Saturday

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UEzhlFqtAJk

What else could really be the number one 'essential' classic Fall Out Boy song?

Released on their first album Take This To Your Grave, Saturday has every element that makes a great Fall Out Boy tune – high energy, awesome riffs, vocal harmonies, lyrical maxims, conflicting tones, and the most fitting Pete Wentz screaming of all. It's been played last at pretty much every Fall Out Boy concert and is the highlight of every show. When the band play the song live, Wentz throws his bass to his ever-present tech, takes centre stage and performs his screams in amongst his adoring crowd. It's enough to give you chills.

At the end of the day, you can take away all the string sections, studio production, bells and whistles, but you'll still be left with a group of guys who are among the best songwriters and performers of the modern era, as shown on Saturday. It’s not necessarily the best song the band have released, but if you had to go to a Fall Out Boy gig and only had time to listen to one track, it would have to be Saturday.


Contributor

Andre Pusey hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.