10 Fantastic Rock Albums That Never Got Made
Just Slightly Out Of Reach.
An artist can never truly give everything away. While hardcore fans are quick to call anything they do as gospel, there are always those missed opportunities that slip through the cracks even with the greatest musical minds. Although sometimes it's for the best, it's a crime that we never got to see these records come to fruition.
After spending years (if not decades) in the incubator, these records never managed to see the light of day when they were supposed to. As opposed to the usual scheduling conflict or industry snafu, these records managed to be kept in the vault by their creators, either because they don't want us to hear them or they still remain unfinished.
Judging from the snippets that we do have from these projects though, they sound like they would have been great.
That's not really our call though, with the artists themselves saying that these records either weren't right for the time or the artist in question passing away before the projects were fully realized. For all intents and purposes, there's a good chance that these songs will be kept on ice for the foreseeable or released in a completely different.
Sometimes things just fall through, but these are the albums that we never got to hear in full.
10. Jeff Buckley's 2nd Album
When looking back on the '90s rock scene, Jeff Buckley really feels like one of the artists that slipped through the cracks. With tons of potential at his disposal after his debut album Grace, hearing of his death in the late '90s due to an accidental drowning left the rest of the rock world feeling hollow. It's even more of a shame considering what he may have had coming down the pipeline.
At the time of his demise, Buckley was already well into the process of making his second record, which ended being folded once he passed. Though we do have the bare bones of what he was working on at the time on Sketches for My Sweetheart the Drunk, the songs on here hint at something even greater happening. While Buckley had been known to pull from the classic rock playbook, songs like Vancouver show a different side of him, almost going into a more ethereal mold than he was before.
Considering that these are out in the world already though, there's probably no chance of anyone actually going back and finishing these ideas any time soon. Still, when looking back on what Jeff had left us, it's probably better that we at least have what he gave us when he was still among the living.
9. Huey Lewis' Swan Song
For anyone who isn't a fan of Back to the Future, Huey Lewis actually kicked a lot of ass back in their day. Despite what the inherent lameness of Patrick Bateman might tell you, the work of Lewis and the News was a lot more than the disposable pop rock to be found all over '80s radio. Even though Lewis could have easily kept on going with one retro album after the next, it's a crime that he didn't get to end things on his terms.
On a whim this past year, we got a taste of what The News were working on with the album Weather. That is to say...half of an album. About midway through the recording of the record, Huey was diagnosed with chronic hearing loss and would most likely have to end things as soon as possible. Without even realizing it, Weather is the swan song for Huey Lewis, as the News are permanently retired from music at this point.
It stings that much more when this record actually holds up, showing Lewis settling into his older age with ease and reminiscing on what it was like playing music as a kid. Much like nostalgia though, this album is the all too grim reminder that you can never truly go back to where you started.
8. Bon In Black - AC/DC
Looking back on the early '80s, you can't really sculpt a better comeback story than Back in Black. After losing one of the greatest frontmen of all time in Bon Scott to alcoholism, AC/DC somehow never missed a beat and continued on with one of the most fitting tributes in rock and roll history. That's not how those riffs sounded like going into the project though.
In fact, most of the central riffs that are on this album were actually written well before Bon passed away, with most of them just having different lyrics and performances from Brian Johnson. As it stands, people have speculated what Bon would have done with these demos had he had the opportunity, with Back in Black being one of the main lines they were working with up until the last day Bon was alive.
Considering Bon's unique wordplay coming off of Highway to Hell, this might have been what sent AC/DC even further over the top, incorporating some of the more sinister passages he put into songs like Dirty Deeds Done Dirt Cheap and TNT a few years before. Since Back in Black has become one of the most essential albums in hard rock history, there's no doubt that Bon would at least be proud of his old mates coming through with the goods.
7. Toy - David Bowie
An artist of David Bowie's caliber often has more than a few things going at once. I mean, if you've managed to actually create characters around some of the music that you play, you're probably looking at the big picture more often than just the gory details behind your work. Then again, sometimes that causes your more celebrated stuff to go overlooked from time to time.
Looking to meld the old with the new, the initial idea for Toy was supposed to be Bowie making a new album of music all while incorporating some ideas that he had laying around since his work in the '60s. Operating somewhere after the album Hours, things started to take a turn when production halted midway through the record. Combined with the added sense of dread that came after the events of 9/11, Bowie decided to put Toy on hold as he worked on the album Heathen, after which he quickly folded the project.
While the eventual demos of some of the Toy odds and ends were released onto the Internet in 2011, chances are we probably won't be hearing any more after Bowie left things on glowing terms on Blackstar. Then again, considering the raw material we have to work with, maybe the time is right for someone to actually come in and properly mix these tracks into a coherent album.
6. Pearl Jam's Concept Album
Out of all the heavy hitting grunge bands to come out of Seattle, Pearl Jam always stood out as the most thoughtful of them all. Whereas you sometimes had to work out every nuance of what someone like Kurt Cobain was saying, Eddie Vedder's way with words painted grim pictures of internal pain as well as character portraits on songs like Daughter and Why Go. So...the fact that they never tackled a concept album almost seems like a missed opportunity.
The idea of the minds behind Jeremy making a story album should be a slam dunk, considering Vedder's admiration for the kings of the rock opera the Who. While we got the first germs of a storyline on their self-titled Avocado album, there was just none of the follow through to speak of. When talking about the record after the fact, Vedder had suggested that the original idea was to follow a man as he works his way through war and struggles to find himself in war-stricken America in the '00s.
After the hit and miss politics of Riot Act though, Pearl Jam managed to scale things back, taking out the narration they were considering and eventually giving up the concept altogether. While you can certainly make the case that this album has a concept, here's hoping that Vedder will hit upon the right idea later down the line.
5. Lifehouse - The Who
When talking about the genesis of the concept album, most rock fans point to Tommy as the place where everything got started. Though Quadrophenia isn't too far behind, the Who's first attempt at a full concept revolving around a deaf dumb and blind boy was one of the most ambitious undertakings of the late '60s, providing the blueprint for how a rock opera would later be structured. A lot of people forget though that Quadrophenia was actually Pete Townshend's 3rd idea for a concept.
Looking to make another dystopian vision, Townshend was already well into working on a project called Lifehouse during the last few shows to promote Tommy. Set in a futuristic society, this story would have followed Bobby as he tries to make sense of his life through music, eventually bringing together all of his followers to create a version of utopia no one had ever seen or heard before.
Once the actual sessions started, things started to stall when the rest of the band couldn't grasp the concept, leading to Townshend nearly suffering a mental breakdown and later folding the material for the album into Who's Next instead. Considering that these were supposed to be the centerpieces for what would have eventually been given the opera treatment, the world certainly needs to hear songs like Baba O Riley and Won't Get Fooled Again in the way they were originally intended.
4. Songs From the Black Hole - Weezer
Weezer's 2nd album Pinkerton will probably go down in history as one of the most misunderstood albums of its time. After getting lots of unwanted attention off the strength of their blue-colored debut, this is the raw and abrasive reflection of Rivers Cuomo's psyche after being forced into an extroverted world. If things had panned out though, we could have found the nerd rock calling in space instead.
During the making of Pinkerton, the initial vision that Cuomo had in mind was a concept album revolving around an astronaut going on a journey to find new lands, tentatively titled Songs from the Black Hole. While everyone seemed a bit reluctant to get on board at first, things started to actually turn around when disaster struck. In the interim period enrolling at Harvard University, Cuomo started to get more and more desensitized, all while trying to come off of painkillers from the surgery that he had on his legs during the tour.
After months and months of no real progress, Weezer eventually relented and just released the most emotionally resonant tracks they knew how, which became their final statement before going on hiatus shortly after the tour. While songs like Tired of Sex and Getchoo were originally envisioned for the space opera, this is the album that will almost solely exist in the minds of fans.
3. Get Back - The Beatles
The end of the '60s had started to turn really ugly in the Beatles' world. After the White Album left every member at each other's throats trying to guide them into the next phase of existence, it was definitely time to loosen up a little bit. While Paul McCartney had a novel idea to bring the band back to their roots, Get Back turned into the one album that didn't want to get made.
After coming off of respective vacations, the Fabs were still not on the closest of terms, with video footage of them devolving into petty arguments while trying to get things together. Almost on the verge of a breakup, everyone came together one last time to give their audience a true sendoff, which culminated in Abbey Road just a few months later. In the minds of record executives though, nothing really gets off that easily.
Needing one more album to fulfill their contract, Let It Be became the culmination of the older Get Back that was given the Phil Spector treatment to make them sound finished. Even though it's nice to have this fly on the wall energy to these sessions, songs like Don't Let Me Down showed a cool new direction for the band that we hadn't seen before. For as many classics as they pumped out in just a handful of years, the Get Back project was the one instance where time wasn't on the side of the Beatles.
2. Metallica's Symphonic Opus
Since the turn of the millennium, metaheads have gotten their fair share of the more lofty side of the genre. With acts like Epica and even the more melodramatic side of Evanescence rearing their heads around this time, the idea of symphonic metal finally started to make sense, with the dirty crunch of distortion mixing with the technical purity of classical instruments. While the newer faces on the scene managed to make some major steps forward with symphonic rock, one of the bands leading the charge could have been one of metal's biggest names.
As Metallica first started to reach legend status, S&M was the pure culmination of their powers, working with famed composer Michael Kamen to create some of the most lofty takes on their classic material. Then again, why the hell did we have to settle on just a handful of originals on the disc? Combined with S&M and its sequel, only a handful of originals have come from these sessions, when it could have been a fireworks show, with James Hetfield writing the perfect harmonies to go with the string accompaniment.
Doing something like this would not only be a testament to their abilities, but also a fitting tribute to Cliff Burton, whose knowledge of classical music informed Metallica's early days on albums like Master of Puppets. But who knows? Perhaps the purely concentrated kickass of orchestrated Metallica may be coming down the pipeline in the next few years.
1. Jimi Hendrix Jazz Fusion Album
There's no one really in the rock world disputing Jimi Hendrix's talents as a guitar player. Compared to his contemporaries both then and now, Hendrix's immaculate touch on the six-string was unparalleled, with an uncompromising sense of melody that we will probably never see again. For as much as Electric Ladyland may seem like a peak in retrospect, the door was open for one of the most legendary collaborations of all time.
At the time of his death, Hendrix was already putting the finishing touches on his Electric Lady studio as well as working on different projects of his own, as evidenced by the bootleg tapes that we see popping up every year. Although Hendrix had already crossed paths with the likes of Eric Clapton and Little Richard at that point, there was actually an idea for him to go into the studio with jazz legend Miles Davis for a session.
Remember, this was Davis during the height of his Bitches Brew period, which would have blended in perfectly with Hendrix's flair for the more cosmic side of rock and roll. Since neither men are around to tell the tale anymore, it would seem that Hendrix's almighty venture into the world of jazz fusion truly is the music of the gods at this point.