10 Great Albums You Didn't Understand The First Time

You may need to play these on repeat and study the lyrics. 

linkin park waiting for the end
Warner Bros.

Over the years, there have been many perfect albums to come out of every genre of music. Most of the time, the genius behind these tracks are so immediate that the record is lauded with universal praise almost instantaneously. While most perfect records make you fall in love with them from the word go, others need more time to sit with you before you discover their beauty.

These are the types of albums that you might not have seen the greatness in the first time you sat down with them. Whether it be a shift in tone, a different sonic experiment, or just a lack of hooky material, these albums have been dismissed and even hated by some fans upon their first release.

However, hindsight is 20/20 when it comes to these kinds of things. The more you listen to these albums, the more sonic touches jump out at you as something fantastic. You find yourself spinning these albums more and more before you realize that what you thought was just a passable record is one of the greatest records you have ever heard. It may take a little bit to settle into their groove, but these albums are more than worth the breaking-in period.

10. Nimrod - Green Day

By the mid-90's, Green Day were known as the poster children for the pop punk genre. The band's meteoric rise with the release of their 1994 blockbuster Dookie brought the brighter side of punk rock to the mainstream world. With the band's followup Insomniac being even more angry than its predecessor, fans were ready for yet another punk juggernaut from these guys.

Once those fans popped in Nimrod, it was certainly a shock to hear the directions the group decided to take. The first single "Hitchin a Ride" had a much more subdued guitar riff and even a violin and jazzy guitar chord to both open and close the song. In fact, the entire album tended to take risks from more metallic cuts like "Take Back" to country tunes on "Walking Alone" and even a full-blown instrumental track on "Last Ride In." And let's not forget the biggest ballad of the era "Good Riddance."

While most fans tore into to the delectable tunes, many fans left this record feeling a bit cold. For many fans, Green Day were always at their best as a lean mean pop punk machine, which was not the MO of this record. Over time though, Nimrod has stood up as one of the more adventurous outings Green Day have ever attempted.


9. The 2nd Law - Muse

Muse was truly a band that dominated the 2000's rock scene. It seemed that every few years, the millennium's first decade was dominated by yet another stellar release from this English power trio. While many fans expected Muse to build on their epic momentum as they entered the 2010's, the revulsion brought to the band's 2011 album The 2nd Law seemed almost rapturous.

The band's choices for singles in "Madness" and "Panic Station" left fans insanely worried, with the band embracing dubstep and funk styles to a contentious reaction. Once the album was released with a more electronic tinge, diehard fans were quick to label this as the band's weakest effort.

That analysis tends to sell the album short though. The electronic elements are certainly dominant throughout the track listing, but the actual use of them are truly exquisite most of the time like on "Follow Me" and "Animals." There is also plenty of signature Muse tracks like the James Bond sounding "Supremacy" and even some experimentation like on the Chris Wolstenholme-fronted tracks "Save Me" and "Liquid State." Regardless of the acclaim it did or didn't receive, The 2nd Law was another fine example of Muse playfully taking risks with their musical vision.


8. Lateralus - Tool

Tool are regarded as one of the premier acts to come out of the 90's metal scene, and rightfully so. At a time when mainstream metal was floundering, these guys took the fundamental elements of the genre and expanded them into places they had never been before.

While any metalhead could get down with the band's first records, Lateralus may be seen as a trickier listen for some folks. Don't get me wrong, the album is absolutely stellar with its multiple prog epics and exquisite use of cerebral topics, but the initial listen does take some getting used to for newcomers. From the more sardonic perspective, these heavy topics could easily be seen as pretentious if not listened to under the proper circumstances.

With every listen, the album's riffs seep into your brain until you become more and more accustomed to the off-kilter time signature changes and the warped view of reality that comes from Maynard James Keenan's lyrics. After a while, these songs become less and less about music and feel more a part of your DNA, almost as if you've tapped into some higher plain of existence. It's nearly impossible to pick a favorite Tool album, but every new detail that comes with spinning Lateralus proves that it's the album that keeps on giving.


7. Neighborhoods - Blink-182

Most Blink-182 fans were met with a pleasant surprise at the 2009 Grammy Awards when the band finally announced they were getting back together. It had been a long time coming, and most fans were eager to see what a more mature Blink would sound like going forward. Once Neighborhoods dropped though, fans were nearly disgusted by the direction the band went down.

The entire album was marred by production difficulties, with the end result sounding more like a Tom Delonge solo effort featuring members of Blink. From the spacey production to the less whiny vocals, fans were lukewarm on the album to say the least.

On the other hand, this album is actually better than most fans give it credit for. Sure, the more spacey vibes sound much more at home on Delonge's group Angels and Airwaves, but the way Mark Hoppus and Travis Barker put their spin on them is actually very engaging. While the album does have great punk tracks like "Heart's All Gone" and "Up All Night," the sound being created on here sounds like Blink turning into a more alt-rock band, which is insanely cool to think about. Even though Blink has been going strong for years with Matt Skiba, it's still interesting to speculate as to where the band could have gone with Delonge's more ethereal ambitions.


6. Era Vulgaris - Queens Of The Stone Age

Out of all the fantastic hard rock acts to come out of the 2000's, Queens of the Stone Age stands as one of the few groups that has yet to release a bad album. However, many fans point to 2007's Era Vulgaris as the band at one of their more uninspired points.

When listening to it initially, it's clear that the more artsy direction is not the Queens we got to know on Songs for the Deaf. With Josh Homme utilizing countless musicians, the album can seem like a hodgepodge at the outset. What most people forget in this scenario though is the off-kilter beauty with which Homme approaches his riffs. Given the album's more straightforward rock approach, Homme claims this album is the closest the band has come to creating his self-defined "robot rock" genre of music.

The album also takes a few detours with the laid back Elvis stylings on "Make it Wit Chu" and the track "Sick Sick Sick," which stands as one of the harshest cuts the band have ever released. At a time when the Songs for the Deaf lineup was all but dissolved, Era Vulgaris was the exact moment where QOTSA became Homme's band, which he would take through the deepest depths of rock and beyond.


5. A Thousand Suns - Linkin Park

As far as Linkin Park fans go, there seem to be two categories: those who love A Thousand Suns and those who hate it. Coming at the dawn of the 2010's, this album was the band's biggest foray into electronic music, with tunes that were dominated by a more ambient approach.

Though the more broad soundscapes waeredefinitely a strange look for the band at the time, it was by no means cause for outrage. The band had been dabbling in soundscapes ever since their formation, with turntablist Joe Hahn providing interludes for all the best albums by the band. At this point, this was where the band took the leap of faith and turned themselves into something more than just an aggro-rock band. There are more synthetic moments like "Robot Boy," but still some awesome ragers like "When They Come For Me" to be had on this record. Even a song like "Waiting For the End" shows how the rock and electronic instrumentation can play off each other to glorious effect.

Though it was not expected to see Linkin Park change this quickly, A Thousand Suns still feels like the natural progression the band were going to take after their initial nu-metal period. By taking that risk, this album gave Linkin Park a second wind and impacted how rock music would be looked at as a whole in the 2010's.


4. White Light/White Heat - The Velvet Underground

The Velvet Underground holds the award for the Best Band That People Got After The Fact. From their ramshackle debut to their more introspective later works, the band's experimentation with the song format shaped rock and roll in a way that not many other bands could.

Out of all the records of the band's early period, White Light/ White Heat remains the most chaotic recording the group had ever put to tape. At first listen, one wouldn't think that this is from a premier rock band, with its subpar sounding production and its lack of potent melodies throughout. At the same time, the record's strengths lie in its more experimental moments. Tracks like "The Gift" show Lou Reed's dark humor when conveying a story while songs like "Lady Godiva's Operation" shows John Cale using avant-garde techniques to provide an insane collage of sound.

While most listeners would be turned off by the 17 minute finale "Sister Ray," the song's journey through Hellish soundscapes remains one of the most influential moments of the 60's rock movement. Even if it wasn't greeted with praise, the right people were listening, with artists like David Bowie, Iggy Pop, and Julian Casablancas showing it love for decades. It may not be the most pleasant listen at first, but without this album, rock's more ferocious subsects like punk and noise rock would look very different.


3. Ok Computer - Radiohead

For most alt rock fans, Ok Computer remains a watershed moment for the entire genre. In one tight album experience, Radiohead created luscious soundscapes that turned into some of the best rock music the 90's had ever produced. While it's still been steeped with praise to this day, the initial reaction to this record told a different story.

For a lot of the rock community, this record seemed to just be another effort from "the 'Creep' guys," a backhanded compliment that seems hilarious in retrospect. All of the experimental and electronic influences on the album also seemed too jarring at the time. In fact, the group's label EMI went so far as to lower the expected sales of the album after they heard the initial version of the album.

Over time, the apprehension that came with this record was unfounded, with most of the experimental songs becoming pristine production feats in the rock world. After the album's tour kicked in, the album went from being a standard effort to being heralded as not only the album of the year, but perhaps one of the greatest records the rock genre has ever produced. This positioned Radiohead as the prime voices of the rock genre, giving them the freedom to go even more experimental as they reached the 2000's.


2. Dark Side Of The Moon - Pink Floyd

Ask any Pink Floyd where to start with the band's discography, and you'll most likely get an answer of Dark Side of the Moon. The album is a masterful piece of art that has gone on to become almost synonymous with the rock genre itself. Then again, it's understandable if many people don't see the hype when combing through it the first go around.

For those uninitiated prog fans, this album does tend to be a bloated with some songs eclipsing the 6 minute mark and full of trading solos and standard rock vocals. Even if something like "The Great Gig in the Sky" boasts phenomenal vocals, the lack of lyrics can make it hard for most to grasp onto.

On the other hand, the way to look at this album is not from the standard pop rock prospective. This is one of the instances where the album almost needs to be taken in as a whole in order to be fully appreciated. While songs like "Breathe" are absolutely spellbinding, the melody gets even better when interpolated on other tracks like "Time." The band's attention to production detail also helps to keep the listener engaged from front to back. It may not have the Beatles' level of pop smarts, but this album is certainly one that must be heard on repeat in order to be truly comprehended.


1. Pinkerton - Weezer

Weezer's debut was one of the most infectious pop rock albums to come out of the 90's. Alongside other bands like Green Day and Foo Fighters, these nerd rockers were able to pull the rock world out of the grunge doldrums and into something much more upbeat.

Where did the band decide to go after this? Start writing tunes with the same angst as their forefathers of the grunge community. When Pinkerton was released, it was not so much met with contention as much as it was full-blown hatred. The band's entire fanbase seemed either perplexed or just betrayed at the change in tone between albums. Backlash from this record was so bad that the band eventually went on hiatus and didn't resurface until the early 2000's.

What the fans missed out on on first glance was some of the most intimate songs Rivers Cuomo would ever write. Instead of the tuneful hits of their first release, Pinkerton paints the picture of a man who has finally become a star and suddenly realizes what a mess his life really is. From songs about lost love to angsty youthful loneliness, this album is one of the band's highest triumphs that never got its just due when it was first released.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Linkin Park
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97