10 Greatest Bands Who Mixed Music Genres
Making magic by branching out.
Most bands would tell you, if asked, that they hate being pigeonholed.
They’re artists, after all, and the last thing they want to do is stay in their lane, commit to one style. Commercially speaking, though, sticking resolutely to one genre is probably a good idea. It’s much easier to generate a fan base and to keep folks coming back for more if they know what they’re going to get.
For some bands, though, that wanderlust is too great. They might start off as a harcore act, or a rap group, or a zydeco band, but a few albums down the mine, those feet get a little itchy, and they start to experiment.
Switching genres can be a tricky proposition, and wandering into a format that doesn’t suit you can be embarrassing - witness Dee Dee Ramone make the brief journey from punk bassist to world’s worst rapper - but if you’ve got the musical chops, the genuine passion, and the songs to back it up, it can be the best decision your band ever makes.
It keeps things fresh, opens up all manner of creative avenues, and potentially brings in a new audience.
10. The Cure
These days Robert Smith’s gang of goths are better known for their bittersweet pop than their years dedicated to doom and gloom. The best known Cure tracks are in the main their soaring, sugary upbeat numbers, “Just Like Heaven”, “Friday I’m In Love” and the like. But in their lengthy career, they’ve played a little bit of everything.
They started off playing spiky new wave and post punk, and in their first two singles, “Killing An Arab” and “Boys Don’t Cry”, they ably illustrated the light and shade they had to offer. By the second album they were descending into darkness, with the shuffling, full goth “A Forest” a highlight.
Things got gloomier up until The Head On The Door, whose second single “Close To Me” embraced prettier sounds and alternate instrumentation - a plinky synth, a jazzy trumpet. Soon after, they were experimenting with every album - Kiss Me, Kiss Me, Kiss Me alone sees the band whip between genres from track to track.
Maybe their most outre offering is spooky jazz number “The Lovecats”. While it’s not a song for long-time Cure obsessives, it demonstrates how much more there is to the group than moping and bouffants.
9. Fleetwood Mac
The ever-changing Fleetwood Mac has shifted genres as much as they’ve swapped out members. The band is best known today for its soft rock ‘70s iteration, but the intercontinental superstars used to peddle a totally different type of music.
The Mac was formed in London in the late ‘60s, and for a while they were strictly blues. Led by longtime bluesmen Peter Green and Mick Fleetwood, their early releases featured rockers, ballads like the gorgeous “Need Your Love So Bad”, and the dreamy instrumental “Albatross”.
Things changed pretty quickly after Peter Green left. After a forgettable period, the Americans turned up, and Lindsay Buckingham and Stevie Nicks ushered in the most famous version of the band. Rumours was a colossus of a record, with west coast pop like “Second Hand News” nestling alongside churning rockers like “The Chain”.
Years into this phase, they continued to mix it up, following Rumours with the dark and tricky Tusk before reverting back to light and dark on Tango In The Night. It speaks to the quality of their golden material that so many big fans don’t feel the need to look beyond it - but they should.
8. Radiohead
Radiohead’s approach to experimentation isn’t just bold, it’s downright defiant: every time they gain critical adulation for their latest format, they scrap it and start anew with something totally different. Somehow, it always seems to work.
They started life as a grunge-lite act, and while Pablo Honey is no one’s favourite Radiohead LP, it spawned “Creep”, a solid hit. The band were immediately sick of the song, though, and refused to play it for years. They shifted to their glam rock phase with The Bends, big, open hearted songs, full of depth but with real singalong quality.
It was a hit, so they chucked it. OK Computer was far harder to classify, beautiful ballads complimented with operatic odysseys, electronic experiments, and everything in between. Everyone loved it, so they went another direction again. Kid A is icy cold and mostly bereft of guitars - again, a winner, yet another masterpiece.
Later albums tangled with protest music, danceable rhythms, and piano balladeering. Whatever they’re up to, they’re nigh impossible to categorise - they’re just Radiohead.
7. Paramore
They’re one of the last bands standing from the emo boom of the mid ‘00s, and for good reason: Paramore are one of the few bands of that era who refused to stand still and continued to mix things up rather than remaining trapped in the delayed adolescence of some of their contemporaries. Through a willingness to embrace different genres and - horror of horrors - slick, radio friendly pop, they’ve gone from strength to strength.
Their first album, when they were mere nippers, is straight ahead emo/pop punk of a ‘90s vintage. There are great tunes, like “Emergency”, but the album is of a piece.
They kicked on with Riot!, featuring hard rocking favourite “Misery Business”, contemporary indie in “Fences”, and U2-esque stadium rock on “When It Rains”. But their biggest reinvention was still to come - 2017’s After Laughter saw the band fully embrace modern pop.
For some bands this would seem like selling out, but Paramore’s music has always been current and youth-oriented; calculated or otherwise, this was a smart stylistic shift that fans old and new seem fully on board with.
6. Faith No More
The most mischievous band in metal has made a career of zagging when fans expected them to zig (or vice versa). Exploding in the ‘80s, they took the scene in a totally different direction, eschewing the lightning pace and self seriousness of thrash in favour of something sludgier, funkier, and more playful - basically year zero for nu metal a few decades later.
Helping to co-author a new style of music wasn’t enough for the band, though, particularly the enigmatic frontman Mike Patton, who joined for The Real Thing, the band’s third release. Patton and co brought in a diverse range of influences, upping the amount of rap and funk but adding lush strings to “Zombie Eaters” and recording the ridiculously anthemic and almost poppy “Epic”.
Things really go wild on “Angel Dust”. They get heavier than ever on “Midlife Crisis”, but then record a quasi-power ballad on “Everything’s Ruined”, and close the album off with two bizarre covers: a faithful if weighty rendition of the theme from Midnight Cowboy, and then a near-note perfect version of The Commodores’ “Easy”.
The latter became one of their signature songs. It’s wilfully confusing, tough to swallow for the pure metalheads, and generally brilliant.
5. Wire
There’s a strong argument to be made that Wire’s debut Pink Flag is the best punk album ever made. In true punk spirit, the group tears through 21 tracks in 35 minutes, taking shots at the government, the record business, poseurs, and more oblique matters. The immensely influential record proved their mettle, and they could have trotted out the same album again and again for years to come.
Instead, they immediately tore up the blueprint and started again. Sophomore effort Chairs Missing is every bit as good, but with a stretched, avant garde sound on the jittery “Heartbeat”, a space rock vibe on “I Am The Fly” and even a genuinely pretty pop track, “Outdoor Miner”.
Wire have reinvented themselves time and again in the interim. 1979’s 154 is more experimental still. Later they’d embrace electronic music, most notably on A Bell Is A Cup, the finest of their mid period albums.
As elder statesmen of punk and beyond, they remain in a state of flux, equally at home releasing restrained rock as bursts of noise. They’re unclassifiable, basically, which is probably just how they like it.
4. Talking Heads
Led by the worldly artistic tastes of David Byrne, Talking Heads’ musical shifts felt more like natural evolution than a series of abrupt turns. The band got their start as punk made way for new wave, and they were a big part of the New York scene of the late ‘70s, entertaining crowds at CBGBs and the Mudd Club with spiky and sparse tracks like “Psycho Killer”.
By their third record, Fear Of Music, the angular sound was already shifting. Along tracks like “Cities” were the gorgeous soft rock cut “Heaven” and the introduction of world music, particularly on the polyrhythmic opener “I Zimbra”.
This African influenced rock paved the way for their most influential record, Remain In Light. Gone were the short bursts of energy. Instead, Talking Heads were getting deep into Fela Kuti-influenced grooves. The whole first side of the record is one big dance party, the highlight being the kinetic “Crosseyed And Painless”.
The rest of their discography continued to branch outwards, with straightforward rockers like “Road To Nowhere”, breathtaking ballad "This Must Be the Place (Naive Melody)", and jazzy numbers like “Mr Jones”. Eight records, a consistent line up, but constant growth.
3. Ween
Ween are a band that just shouldn’t work. Comprised primarily of Gene and Dean Ween (not their real names, obviously), they’ve made a lengthy and prolific career out of not taking anything altogether too seriously. They’ll switch genres on a dime, come out with some of the most outrageous lyrics imaginable, and generally focus on entertaining themselves.
Somehow, though, it all comes together into something unique and often brilliant. One key to their success is the sheer musicianship of the band: they can turn their hand to prog (“Buckingham Green”) or blue eyed soul (“Freedom Of ‘76”), then switch to a chilled out latin groove or full on metal, such is their virtuoso talent.
They also don’t do half measures, committing fully to each new interest. The best example is 1996’s 12 Golden Country Greats. Aside from the incredibly fruity language, it’s a dedicated and serious country record, with bonafide Nashville players making up the band. Unsurprisingly, it bemused fans, but gave Ween an in on the country scene.
They’re a band that can’t and won’t sit still. So restless are Ween that they split up and got back together within the space of three years - there’s plenty more mucking about to do.
2. Beastie Boys
The social evolution of Beastie Boys is something to behold. From dumbass privileged kids who spat misogynistic and homophobic lyrics, they achieved enlightenment, preaching progressive politics while never becoming turgid and atoning for the sins of their youth.
Their musical style similarly broadened over time. Their Rick Rubin-produced debut LP License To Ill was all mid-80s boom bap rap, but by follow up (and masterpiece) Paul’s Boutique, they were taking in influences from glam rock to punk to metal, enlisting the Dust Brothers to create a varied soundscape of samples.
Next, they picked up instruments. The Boys themselves began life as hardcore kids, and on Check Your Head they got the band back together, injecting heavy rock, punk, and funk into their tracks, and jamming out with Elvis Costello on Saturday Night Live.
They’ve collaborated with the late Lee “Scratch” Perry on the dub-heavy Hello Nasty, and continued to evolve electronic sounds up to the untimely death of Adam “MCA” Yauch. The growth of this group is part of what makes them one of the best ever.
1. The Clash
Some purists like to say The Clash weren’t punk because they embraced so many other musical styles. Some would counter that this - rejecting the dogma - is about the most punk thing you can do, thereby demonstrating their credentials. Others still would surmise that it really doesn’t matter whether The Clash were or weren’t punk, because they were simply one of the greatest bands ever to come out of the UK.
The Clash’s self titled debut is primarily bonafide aggressive punk rock, but even here they’re experimenting with reggae on their cover of “Police And Thieves”, which is rockier than Junior Murvin’s original but still maintains the vibe.
On London Calling, they really let loose - there’s rockabilly (“Brand New Cadillac”), the swinging “Right Profile”, new wave (“Train In Vain”) and quasi-dub (“Guns Of Brixton”). Later they’d embrace their West Indian tastes further on the gloriously spacey “Bankrobber”.
They even turned their hand to early rap on “The Magnificent Seven”, and while it’s a bit embarrassing, a lot of contemporaneous white acts did it a lot worse. The Clash couldn’t care less what style of music you expected them to subscribe to - they did exactly what they wanted, and that’s why they were brilliant.