10 Hard Rock & Metal Bands With No Original Members Left

Their original lineups are gone, but Judas Priest and Lynyrd Skynyrd keep rolling.

Rob Halford Judas Priest
Aaron Rubin, CC BY-SA 4.0 , via Wikimedia Commons

Rock bands tend to be complicated beasts, to say the least.

Along with playing musical circles around their contemporaries, oftentimes you have to worry about clashing egos and infighting all while trying to create the most pure-hearted music that you can muster up. Though fans eventually get the amazing tunes, it does end up coming at a fairly heavy price.

While no band is really safe from the occasional blowup between band members, these acts have proved to have some of the most dysfunctional lineups in history. Whether because of the mortality rate of the band members or the age-old personality conflict, these acts have become virtually unrecognizable compared to how they started out. It's one thing to have one of the members take a leave of absence, but to have no original members at the helm is something much more interesting to deal with.

At this point, why would you even listen to these acts when they are a glorified tribute version of what came before? Well, there are many ways in which this could be an improvement though. Over the years, the "new blood" of these acts ended up turning into the shot in the arm that they needed, giving them a completely different lease on their musical life. While these acts look a lot different than before, don't let that fool you into thinking the quality has gone down either...

10. RIOT

RIOT tends to be one of the more overlooked acts of the golden age of rock and roll. Being birthed around the same time as other New York natives like KISS, the music coming from these guys was a lot more muscly than their contemporaries, with Fire Down Under and Narita being considered underground classics. However, maybe the reason they couldn't settle into a groove was their constantly shifting lineup.

In the first version of the band, Guy Sparanza was the main sonic force behind the mic, with a delivery that was greatly influenced by the bluesy acts of the time. After a few years of slogging it out though, Guy abruptly quit, leaving RIOT to move forward with Rhett Forester, who had the right amount of grit to compete with acts like AC/DC. As the years went on, you practically needed a scorecard to keep track of everyone leaving, with no less than 5 vocalists and 7 drummers coming and going throughout the years.

Though the sole original member Mark Reale had been the common thread among the group, things took a dark turn when Reale died in 2012 after a long battle with Crohn's Disease. As a new version of RIOT takes to the hard rock circuit, this is nowhere near the kind of band we started out with.


9. GWAR

It almost feels like cheating putting an act like GWAR on a list like this. When you're talking about some of the most amazing costumes and absolutely nuts live shows they have put on over the years, the music almost feels like an adornment at the best of times. However, there is still some clever things going on behind the scenes, just not with the same people.

Ever since forming in the late '80s (or on their home planet for those who follow), this was the perfect combination of grotesque and musical to get any metalhead acquainted with the sillier side of rock. Though there was a lot of dark themes and tasteless parts of GWAR's sound, you still could sense the tongue in cheek humor that was coming from these guys whenever they took to the stage. With an ever-evolving lineup, the GWAR train quickly turned into a tribute show as the 2010s began.

Being the main heart behind the group in the early days, original founding member Dave Brockie passed away in 2014 after OD'ing on heroin. As the unholy train of alien lifeforms ploughs forward though, the power of their live shows has not diminished in the slightest. No matter who is behind the masks now, it's clear that Brockie's original vision led to something truly unstoppable.


8. Quiet Riot

After being the face of sunshine rock in the '70s, the Sunset Strip started to get an attitude at the start of the '80s. With Van Halen laying the groundwork, acts like Motley Crue and Poison were rising to prominence on the scene, giving way to what would eventually become known as hair metal. Though Quiet Riot managed to be one of the first real success stories in the genre, the original sonic magic is nowhere to be seen these days.

Formed originally with guitar god Randy Rhoads, the crux of the lineup consisted of vocalist Kevin Federline upfront and Frankie Banali behind the kit, with journeymen like Carlos Cavazo and Rudy Sarzo having a brief stint in the group over the years. As things kept trucking along, Quiet Riot didn't really have a prayer in the '90s, with the grunge movement leaving their version of party rock in the dust.

Just when it seemed that they could make a comeback in the '00s, Federline was found dead of a heroin overdose, leaving Banali as the sole original member of the group. While Banali managed to keep everything going for a few more years, his tragic death this past year marked the final piece of the puzzle gone. Even though Quiet Riot may not have had the most functional of lineups in the old days, when it comes to the start of the hair metal movement, there was no one who could touch them.


7. YES

As the '70s started to open up, it was clear that rock was getting a taste for the more experimental sides of music. With Pink Floyd and Genesis quickly rising to prominence, the arrival of the prog rock genre gave way to some of rock's most ambitious moments, from long song lengths to full-blown conceptual pieces coming from acts like Emerson, Lake, and Palmer. Whereas YES fit comfortably in this scene, there's practically no way of keeping track of who is actually in the group anymore.

From day one, most of the magic from YES came from Jon Anderson, Chris Squire, and Bill Bruford, each of whom works magic when drafting in titans like Rick Wakeman and Steve Howe into the mix. As time went on though, the egos and personality conflicts led to the group basically fracturing in two, with Howe and Wakeman continuing on with members of the Buggles and whoever else they could fit into the fold.

Though Anderson has been in and out of the band every now and again, the death of bass legend Chris Squire in 2015 led to Howe as the only real recognizable member in YES at this point. For as much as Howe might be able to play like a madman nowadays, it's probably time that YES finally retire their name for good.


6. Lynyrd Skynyrd

As the new era of rock began, it became abundantly clear that the American South had something to say. With the arrival of the Allman Brothers on the scene and the Eagles taking on a country tinge to their sound, it was only a matter of time before we got a Southern act that was proud of their heritage. Once Lynyrd Skynyrd arrived, we finally got the Southern-fried goodness we were looking for.

Formed by Ronnie Van Zandt in the early '70s, most of the band's beginnings were formed with the help of guitarists Ed King, pianist Billy Powell, and drummer Artimus Pyle. As time went on though, the lineup kept getting bigger and bigger, with no less than 9 people working on stage whenever they took to the road to support albums like Second Helping and Street Survivors. However, the biggest casualty came when a devastating plane crash killed Van Zandt, guitarist Steve Gaines and backup singer Cassie Gaines.

Though the surviving lineup reassembled with Ronnie's little brother Johnny out front, it's clear that this is a much different outfit than the one we got to know earlier. Even as the years go by, much of the core lineup has faded away, with Powell passing away along with bassist Leon Wilkinson. As Ricky Medlocke from Blackfoot fills out the lineup on guitar, Gary Rossington may be the closest one from the early days that Skynyrd actually has left to a 'classic' member.


5. Heart

Looking back on it now, it's virtually impossible to imagine Heart without the Wilson sisters out front. Throughout the glory years of the '70s (and some embarrassing ones in the '80s), Ann and Nancy Wilson really brought the passion into Heart's sound, with Ann's bellowing voice and Nancy making some of the greatest guitar hooks of the day. However, the original version of this act was a far cry from what we had originally seen.

Long before the days of Dreamboat Annie and Crazy on You, the original incarnation of Heart back in the early '70s was a band known as Army, with Roger Fisher on guitar and Steve Fossen on the bass. Later changing their name to White Heart, the group didn't really have the fire until they drafted in Ann to actually sing their material. Bringing her amazing sister's songwriting skills with her, this made for the classic period of the group, with songs like Barracuda becoming mainstays on rock radio.

As time went on though, it was clear that the Wilson sisters became the real commanders of the show, with Fisher and Fossen fading away with time. Even as they took to the road in 2019, most of the new members of Heart are comprised of musicians who haven't contributed to any real Heart studio album as of yet. Though the Wilson Sisters deserve their place in rock history, this is nowhere near the version of Heart that formed back in the '70s.


4. Thin Lizzy

There's no getting around that Thin Lizzy was, by and large, an extension of vocalist Phil Lynott. From the first few albums onward, Lynott's delicate way of weaving in complex narratives and story structures into his songs was the main draw of Lizzy's sound, with Brian Downey and Eric Bell rounding out the original lineup as a trio. However, time can play tricks on these Irish lads.

Across the years, Lizzy always had a bit of a revolving door when it came time to guitar players before hitting a groove with the guitar duo of Scott Gorham and Brian Robertson. On the other hand, even that pair got a little tiresome, with blues legend Gary Moore replacing Robertson in his downtime before John Sykes was brought into the picture before being folded into Whitesnake. While everything seemed fine with Phil upfront, most of the magic was gone by the mid-'80s when Lynott died of pneumonia after a long battle with addiction.

Though the classic iteration of Lizzy pretty much ended that day, Gorham is still continuing on the musical legacy left by Lynott, bringing Scott Travis of Judas Priest behind the kit and Ricky Warwick being brought in to deliver the songs like Lynott could back in the day. Whereas other acts try to make new material and coax off of name recognition, this latest version of Lizzy feels more like a celebration of Lynott's contributions to rock than just royalty checks.


3. Opeth

When it comes to the proggier side of metal, Opeth pretty much has you covered with everything you need. From the word go, albums like Ghost Reveries and Blackwater Park are practical masterclasses on how to create some of the most morose sounding metal music ever conceived by man. Though the crux of the glory goes to Mikael Akerfeldt over the years, Opeth's original incarnation is like night and day compared to what we have nowadays.

Formed in Sweden in the late '80s, the original lineup had David Isberg as the real captain of the ship, with Dan Nilsson and Martin Persson rounding out the lineup. After 1990 though, Isberg was back at square one again with a whole new lineup, complete with Akerfeldt in tow along with Anders Nordin, who contributed to their debut Orchid as well as Morningrise. However, the creative differences between Isberg and the rest of the group began to reach a head as time went on, leaving Akerfeldt to take over as the group's new lead singer.

Compared to the other band reboots, this is one of the few times where the "new and improved" version is actually an improvement, as Akerfeldt became one of the most astonishing riff writers in recent memory. Even with the revolving cast of characters, here's hoping that there's still more dark glory looming just on the horizon.


2. The Misfits

At the end of the '70s, the rock world really needed something like punk to wake us all up. As most of the rockstars of old started to get a little too smug for their own good, acts like the Ramones and the Clash were delivering a crash course in getting to the point, with songs that hit with as much punch as a freight train within the span of a few minutes.

There was bound to be something even darker coming up behind it.

Formed in the late '70s, the Misfits were a much different animal than their contemporaries, with songs that incorporated horror themes into every single one of the lyrics. Though the original version of the band had Glenn Danzig out in front, time has proved to not be on these shock rockers' sides. With Glenn departing to form Samhain and eventually his namesake solo band, most of the cast has been a revolving door, with everyone from Marky Ramone to Slayer's Dave Lombardo serving time in the lineup.

While there are people like Doyle Wolfgang Von Frankenstein and Jerry Only who are still the faces of the band, they were not in the trenches with the group either, as Only was brought in with Glenn's insistence shortly after taking up the bass. Though there might not be too much of a tonal shift between Die Die My Darling and Dig Up Her Bones respectively, just remember that only the name has stayed the same.


1. Judas Priest

The origination of metal doesn't really have that clear of a timeline when you break it down. Even though many would like to cite acts like Black Sabbath or Deep Purple with starting the beginnings of heavy music, the metal side of things didn't really come into play until much later. While there might be a debate on where metal started, Judas Priest was the first band to really run with it.

Originally taking the name from a Bob Dylan song title, the original incarnation of Judas Priest was nowhere near the kind of band that we know and love today. Being comprised under the watchful eye of Al Atkins, most of the members that we know like Ian Hill and KK Downing weren't brought in until much later, as the Priest remained a blues outfit for a while. After Atkins left to care for his family though, things started to turn a corner when lead screamer Rob Halford entered the fold, bringing the metal aesthetic to the forefront.

With Glenn Tipton being brought in to form a guitar duo with Downing, this solidified what many would consider to be the actual classic lineup of Priest, which would go on to massive success with albums like British Steel and Screaming for Vengeance. For a band that was all about the bluesier side of rock and roll in the early days, no one could have predicted Judas Priest's rise to the top of the unholiest of rock genres.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97