10 Hated Songs Much Better Than Their Reputations
The songs you love to hate.
No matter how much we would like to admit it, no musician is perfect. Regardless of a band's previous pedigree, no one can keep the artistic fire burning for the rest of their days. Even amongst the greatest bands of all time, there are songs that lurk in the shadows as the most reviled pieces of music ever to infest the listener's ears.
Then again, are they all that bad though? Don't get me wrong, there have been many artists who have come out with outright crap throughout their tenure, but some of the mudslinging that these songs have had to endure is far from warranted.
Most of the time, these bands come under fire because the song doesn't sound like they "should," but there's nothing necessarily wrong with trying new things. On the other hand, some of these tracks have the opposite problem, with fans saying it sounds too much like the band's usual formula. Instead of looking at what the song isn't, more often than not these songs stand up as fine bits of music just the way they are. Even if it might not be what you are expecting, these songs deserve to be shown just a little more love.
10. Green Day - Nuclear Family
With the release of Green Day's trilogy of albums under Uno, Dos, and Tre, fans had high expectations only to be lured into a perpetual state of boredom by the end. Although there are some underwhelming moments at many points in the trilogy, the albums are not devoid of their bright spots.
For instance, the first album Uno kicks off pretty strong with "Nuclear Family," with its crunchy guitars and punchy interplay between the guitars and drums. Billie Joe Armstrong's lyrics are a bit dopey, but the chorus is pure Green Day tunefulness. The song even has an extended section where Mike Dirnt's plunky bass line takes center stage. The song's mock countdown also brings the song to a pretty satisfying conclusion.
Compared to the band's more operatic points on American Idiot, this song does admittedly feel a little bit stale, but it's not meant to be heard on a bombastic level. This is Green Day at their most power pop, where they were taking the best elements from bands like Cheap Trick and turning them into short bursts of delectable ear candy. Though the trilogy may have burned many Green Day fans pretty badly, this is one of the few gems hidden amongst the three-album set.
9. Muse - Madness
Muse have been known as a band that does whatever they want regardless of whether it falls under the umbrella of rock music. Over the years, the band have flirted with punk, prog, space rock, and even classical compositions, each of which have been given widespread acclaim. So, why is "Madness" the single that fans want to sweep under the rug?
Coming from the band's electronic release The 2nd Law, this song shows Muse fully embracing the sounds of dubstep, as the song is dominated by the fuzzy "wub" of Chris Wolstenholme's synth-bass. This is far from the riff-based rock of album's past, but that doesn't automatically make the track a stinker. Dominic Howard shows incredible taste as he fluctuates between synthetic percussion and the drum kit proper while Matt Bellamy builds layers upon layers of vocals to create a Queen-like sonic landscape.
Even though there is no discernible riff in the song, the climax is capped off by a brilliant guitar solo, with Bellamy descending down the scales like a cross between Brian May and Jimmy Page. While many Muse fans would sooner throw this record to the wolves, "Madness" is a bold new reinvention that showed that Muse were capable of so much more than just epic-sounding rock.
8. Blink-182 - No Future
When Tom Delonge was notoriously kicked out of Blink-182, a fair amount of the band's fanbase jumped ship with him. Though the band quickly found a replacement with Alkaline Trio's Matt Skiba, they still came under intense scrutiny over their 2016 return to pop punk, California.
A lot of the typical complaints that come with this record come from the fact that the band sounds like they're treading water, with songs that don't stray too far out of the pop-punk formula. While that criticism is certainly founded, the last few Blink albums were a hodgepodge of different styles, with Delonge trying to steer the band in different directions to mold Blink into something different. Fans needed something to show the adolescent spirit of the band hadn't died out.
With a single like "No Future," Blink finally got back to sounding like themselves again, with a fantastic chorus and a fabulous vocal performance between Mark Hoppus and Skiba. It may get a bit repetitive in places, but that doesn't diminish the power of this track's stellar hooks. An essential part of the Blink catalog that could hold its own against classics like "All the Small Things" any day of the week.
7. The Beatles - Ob La Di Ob La Da
The Beatles' White Album is known as one of the greatest double albums in music, but it does have a bit of musical incoherence. The common perception of this project is the Beatles were splintering off into their respective corners, creating solo tracks for the rest of the band to perform.
Out of all the members, Paul McCartney was the most meticulous with his tunes, making the band work diligently on this song for hours an end. The tension was so high that engineer Geoff Emerick eventually quit because he couldn't take the stress. All this, over what many consider the worst Beatles songs ever to be committed to tape.
Though the song is a bit too loopy to take seriously, that doesn't stop it from being a great tune, with a delightful story that turns into a tale of crossdressing by the song's conclusion. When recording, it's sometimes harder to capture a freewheeling vibe for a song, but McCartney found a way (albeit painstakingly) to make a perfect pop song sound like nothing more than a jam session. Carefully striking the balance between earworm and pop sing-along, "Ob La Di Ob La Da" showed that even when the Beatles were at their worst, they were still better than most other bands.
6. Weezer - Troublemaker
Weezer were in a bit of a conflicted position coming off their album Make Believe. Though the band had scored impressive hits with songs like "Beverly Hills," the more rudimentary playing style and poppy approach left many fans feeling jilted. It was time for Weezer to get back to basics.
After one listen, the band's self titled Red Album is certainly a return to a more classic Weezer sound, but most fans agree it starts with a thud on "Troublemaker." The whole song seems overly pretentious, with frontman Rivers Cuomo staking his claim as the next king of rock. No offense meant to Cuomo, but his presence is not what people immediately think of when you think of the macho rock frontman.
Upon repeated listens though, this song actually grows on you exponentially. While the actual tune is dead simple, the whole thing seems to be meant as a tongue-in-cheek joke song. Instead of actually coming off as braggadocious, Rivers comes off as a regular Dad talking about what he aspired to back in his prime. Aside from its plain backing track, this song is probably one of the most endearing Weezer songs of the 2000's if you look past the initial lyric sheet.
5. R.E.M. - Shiny Happy People
"Shiny Happy People" has always garnered a bit of a reputation for being some of the most insipid alt-rock to come out of the genre's golden age. Interestingly enough, most of the initial rancor towards this song was delivered by the band members themselves rather than the fans.
R.E.M. frontman Michael Stipe has gone on record as hating the song and pointing out that it sounds like the band trying too hard to write a pop tune. However, that doesn't diminish the song's ability to get you out of a chipper mood. Right off the bat, this song has some of the stupidest lyrics the band have ever written, as they just talk about the idea of world peace amongst all people, who just happen to be shiny and happy.
While the song may not make you more intelligent after listening, the melody is still undeniably catchy, with fantastic guest vocals from Kate Pierson of the B-52's. It may not have been the band's most authentic tune, but the success it generated set the band up for more poignant material like "Everybody Hurts." The song is not the best example of R.E.M.'s real talent, but just try to get through one listen of this song and not nod your head with the rest of the band.
4. Guns N Roses - Shackler's Revenge
It's a modern miracle that Guns N Roses's Chinese Democracy was ever put out to the public. After years of speculation after its initial sessions in the mid-90's, the record seemed like a distant vision and an impossible dream for frontman Axl Rose. Once 2008 rolled around, the album that fans were met with didn't come close to capturing the band's initial swagger.
That's not to say the album is without its bright moments though. Coming right at the start, "Shackler's Revenge" is one of the most manic sonic bludgeonings the Guns have ever released upon their audience. The song almost has a horror movie vibe, with Axl Rose growling like a lunatic before exploding into a chorus that shows glimmers of the frontman's glory years.
The song also boasts several guitar solos, with everyone from Bumblefoot to Robin Finck to Buckethead trading licks across this epic track. It's no wonder that this was the track selected to be included on Rock Band 2, with its machine gun like riffs and blistering solos that could leave any player in a daze. Though Chinese Democracy is nowhere close to a Guns N Roses quality release, "Shackler's Revenge" has the slithering feel of a rattlesnake, which is more than enough to satisfy any fan of hard rock.
3. Metallica - The Unnamed Feeling
St. Anger has gone down in legend as the Metallica album that should be locked away forever. From the incessant snare bashing to the spotty production all around, this record clearly shows one of metal's biggest bands weathering one of the rougher patches in their career. On the upside, there are some great tunes that did come out of the whole debacle.
The album on the surface seems to be the band's attempt at nu metal, with "The Unnamed Feeling" being their moody introspective track. Given its abrasive sound and pitchy vocal performance from James Hetfield, the song certainly isn't in the same league as other ballads like "The Unforgiven," but the foundation is still incredibly solid.
The incredibly low-tuned fingerpicked guitars give the song a slightly devilish tone, as Hetfield cries like a broken man at the hands of his vices. Even if Hetfield's more strained vocals do sound a bit like he's popping a blood vessel, it's still incredibly powerful in terms of displaying raw emotion. At the time, OG Metallica fans probably saw St. Anger as yet another nail in the band's coffin, but "The Unnamed Feeling" is one glimmer of hope that the band we know and love is still in there somewhere.
2. Aerosmith - Jaded
Aerosmith's flirtation with the spotlight has come and gone periodically over the years. While the band's hard rock heyday gave them huge amounts of success with songs like "Walk This Way," they launched themselves into the 80's amid the glam rock movement as well as provided more ballad-centric material going into the 90's.
However, 2000's Aerosmith is when it starts to get a bit fuzzy. Riding high after appearing on the soundtrack to Armageddon, the Bad Boys from Boston got back into the studio with a sound that was much too polished for many rockers to stomach. While the band's foray into the new decade with Just Push Play was a mixed bag, "Jaded" isn't nearly as bad as you may have heard.
To meet the haters halfway, the polish on the song is incredibly sanitized, with nary a crunchy guitar to be seen within a 5 mile radius. If you look past the more sappy production choices, the song is actually a pretty decent pop song, with Steven Tyler putting his filthy lyrical content into a modern context. Though it may sound much closer to the pop diva sound of the day, "Jaded" showed Aerosmith settling into their latest sonic experiment with more ease than you might expect.
1. KISS - I Was Made For Lovin You
KISS were always known as the supreme rulers of the rock world all throughout the 70's. From their first smash with the live album Alive!, the band continued to serve up prime hard rock for masses of adolescent fans. Then disco started to rear its ugly head.
Every hard rock fan at one point or another has mocked "I Was Made For Lovin You" as the KISS sellout song where they stopped making rock music in exchange for just cynical cash grabs. With the benefit of hindsight, this song actually holds up much better than you might think. Sure, the falsetto vocals coming out of Gene Simmons's demonic mug does raise a few eyebrows, but the melody is absolutely captivating with Paul Stanley showcasing his high register with incredible ease.
Though people claim disco is a musical scourge on humanity, there was a ton of genuine talent to be found in that scene. Over the years, the song has become a live concert staple, where the band beefs up the original drum machine into a rock and roll stomper. While it may have weathered a beating upon release, this track has been written off by hard rock fans for far too long.