10 Least Festive Christmas Songs Ever

Never mind the jingle bells, here’s the weirder end on the Christmas hit parade.

East 17 Stay Another Day
London

In the 1970s, it seemed like everyone who was anyone in pop had to have their own Christmas hit. Slade, Wizzard, John Lennon, Elton John, the list goes on. This tradition carried on into the 1980s with the likes of Wham! and Shakin’ Stevens but by the 1990s things had trailed off quite drastically.

It seems like fewer acts now bother with Christmas songs, the closest modern day equivalent being the John Lewis Christmas Ad cover version.

What this means is that most of us have grown up with an established set of Christmas tunes that get dragged out every year.

We hear them on TV, on the radio and in shopping centres. They’re inextricably linked with turkey and tinsel and we know them back to front before we’re old enough to engage any critical faculties.

As we get older these same tunes wrap some of us in a warm nostalgic glow, while others are sick to death of them. Either way, we seldom stop to consider just how weird some of these tracks are. There’s a deluge of eccentricity in the pantheon of Christmas hits that goes overlooked.

Some of these songs are about as festive as Ebenezer Scrooge, before he had that breakdown and started seeing ghosts...

10. The Kinks - Father Christmas

The Kinks are a great and highly regarded band and their Christmas song, Father Christmas, is twice as catchy as the common cold but in a good way. Strange then, that The Kinks don’t enjoy the same Yuletide ubiquity as Slade and Wizzard.

Strange, that is, until you listen to the lyrics. The opening line is already enough to put off parents. “When I was small I believed in Santa Claus/though I knew it was my dad.” You don’t want this played at a kids’ Christmas party. Too many awkward questions on the way home.

Then singer Ray Davies goes on to tell us about the time he played a department store Santa. He gets mugged by a gang of kids who eschew presents in favour of cold hard cash. Actually, the gang’s ringleader does express an interest in one gift: “if you’ve got one I’ll take a machine gun/so I can scare all the kids in my street.”

By the end, the lyric tries to steer towards a, “think of those less fortunate at this time of year,” message. Too late. It’s the “Father Christmas, give us your money,” refrain that will be stuck in your head for days.


9. The Pogues Featuring Kirsty MacColl - Fairytale Of New York

Fairytale of New York has only been around since 1987 the but its timeless, folky tune sounds like it could have been around for centuries. Make no mistake, the song is an absolute classic and we’re glad it rolls around again every December. But is it really Christmassy?

Yes, that chorus about bells ringing out on Christmas Day leaves us all feeling just as warm and fuzzy as the drink presumably made the song’s protagonist before he wound up in the drunk tank. But in between that catchy refrain, everything is booze, drugs, gambling, rows and reproach.

Still, who amongst us hasn’t had a few pints at Christmas and launched full-lunged into the song's most scabrous lyrics?

“You’re a bum/you’re a punk/you’re an old sl*t on junk/lying there almost dead on a drip in that bed/you scumbag/you maggot/you cheap lousy f*ggot/Happy Christmas you arse/I pray God it’s our last.”

It’s enough to make Nat King Cole blush!


8. The Spice Girls - Christmas Wrapping

The original Christmas Wrapping by The Waitresses is a seasonal delight. It’s a festive romantic comedy wherein a cynic attempts to avoid the holiday festivities, only for fate to intervene and bring her together with the guy she likes. All wrapped up in a catchy tune, it’s a Yuletide gift for your ears.

You don’t get to hear the original so much anymore though. Not since The Spice Girls decided to cover it. Now theirs is all too often the version that winds up on Christmas playlists or pumping from the speakers in shopping centres. It’s a travesty.

Not only do the Spice Girls' vocals lack the verve of Waitresses’ singer Patty Donahue, they completely leave out the peerless bass line, one of the catchiest bass parts in all of pop.

The Spice Girls' version tramples all over Christmas Wrapping, like your big brother snatching your favourite new toy on Christmas morning and stomping on it.


7. Jona Lewie - Stop The Cavalry

Stop The Cavalry has a brass band arrangement that gives the track a suitably festive feel and lots of people can relate to that longing in the refrain, “wish I was at home for Christmas.” However, singer-songwriter Jona Lewie has repeatedly said in interviews that it was never intended as a Christmas song.

Listen a bit more closely to the words and you’ll spot that it’s no celebration of Yuletide but actually an anti-war protest song. It’s a pretty decent one too. Lewie’s protagonist sings of cavalries, Winston Churchill and nuclear war, because he represents all soldiers who have been pressed into service, “down throughout the centuries.” It’s a neat lyrical conceit but a confusing one for any youngsters with a limited grasp of world history listening.

Lewie’s dour vocals are a long way from Noddy Holder as well. The whole thing is about as festive as you’d expect a song that features nuclear war to be, i.e. not very.


6. Greg Lake - I Believe In Father Christmas

What more Christmassy sentiment can be expressed than, “I believe in Father Christmas”? Especially when paired with an orchestral interlude lifted from Prokofiev’s Troika.

This bonkers, bombastic epic from Emerson, Lake and Palmer’s Greg Lake isn’t quite as wide eyed with Christmas wonder as it first appears. Look a little closer and you’ll see it’s an odd fit alongside some of the season’s more innocent perennial hits.

Instead of celebrating Christmas, the song rails against the commercialisation of the season, with lines like, “they sold me a dream of Christmas.” It also complains about the snow that never really comes. Instead, the relentless, rainy British weather provides, “a veil of tears for the virgin birth.”

Lyricist Peter Sinfield described the track as, “A picture postcard Christmas, with morbid edges.” Somebody needs to explain to Peter that you don’t send postcards for Christmas. He must have been thinking of Christmas Cards.


5. Joni Mitchell - River

The opening melody of Joni Mitchell’s River is Jingle Bells in a minor key and she opens by telling us, “It’s coming on Christmas, they’re cutting down trees/They’re putting up reindeer, singing songs of joy and peace.”

So far, so festive but things soon take a turn for the melancholy and never turn back...

River is an utterly miserable song of heartbreak and regret. There’s no redemption here, no lessons learned, festive forgiveness or romantic reunion in time for a kiss under the mistletoe.

Instead, Joni wants to escape down some imagined river because, “I’m selfish and I’m sad/now I’ve lost the best baby/that I’ve ever had.” This one still gets dragged out every Christmas for fear anyone might be getting too jolly.


4. Band Aid - Do They Know It’s Christmas?

This song stood as the UK’s best selling single ever for over a decade and it’s been re-recorded by new line-ups of pop stars three times. Do They Know It’s Christmas is so much a part of Christmas that it’s easy to forget how completely at odds it is with most other perennial Christmas hits.

Midge Ure does his best to squeeze some Christmas spirit into the melody. If we’re being generous, the sound of so many pop stars singing the chorus on mass is vaguely reminiscent of a choir singing carols. There’s no getting away however, from Geldof’s far from festive lyrics.

Of course, the song was for a good cause and it reminds us to think of others at this time of year, which makes it a welcome part of the Yuletide pantheon. It’s something of a departure from previous Christmas fare all the same.

If you go back to the UK in the seventies, the big Christmas songs were all about everybody having fun and snowmen bringing snow. The bleakest Christmas song they had was Mud’s Lonely This Christmas and even that was livened up by an Elvis impression. They wouldn’t believe you if you said that one day, no Christmas would be complete without a song that mentions “dread and fear,” or, “the clanging chimes of doom.”

We’re so used to it now that we can happily gorge ourselves on turkey and stuffing while a song about famine plays in the background.


3. East 17 - Stay Another Day

It’s almost become a festive tradition in its own right: the perennial argument as to whether Stay Another Day is even a Christmas song?

Those who think it is will say it was a hit at Christmas and cite the snow and fluffy jackets in the video. They’ll also bring up the song’s smattering of church bells.

Those who insist it isn’t will say that videos don’t count for anything, you can’t see them when the song isn’t on TV (see also: 2 become 1 by The Spice Girls. Some warm coats and CGI snow have had us singing a song about condoms, every December for years now).

Plus the lyrics have nothing to do with Christmas whatsoever. It’s just a break up song, with a guy begging his partner to stay. Maybe if they’d tweaked the words a bit? It could’ve been “Stay For Boxing Day”, a sorry tale of a Christmas Day bust up.

Plus those church bells sound tacked on, a cynical attempt to flog something to us at Christmas. There again, isn’t that the most Christmassy thing of all?


2. Chris De Burgh - A Spaceman Came Travelling

This track is a long way from Chris De Burgh’s other big hit, Lady In Red, and so much the better for it. It’s also a long way from anything you might usually associate with Christmas. Instead, this proggy number reframes the birth of Jesus as a sci-fi fantasy.

Turns out, the star guiding the three wise men to the virgin birth was a spaceship, hovering above Bethlehem. Its pilot? An angel faced alien from a distant planet who strikes fear into the heart of mother and child before filling the air with “the sweetest music.”

Later, before flying away, he promises his song will begin again, “when two thousand years of your time has gone by.” So maybe it was 1999 by Prince? That got played a lot for the new millennium.

It’s all good fun, especially when DeBurgh gets all impassioned towards the end, singing about thousands of people, “standing on the edge of the world,” but the song is about as festive as an episode of Star Trek.


1. Johnny Mathis - When A Child Is Born

Back in the eighties and early nineties, long before you could Bluetooth your Spotify playlist to your car stereo, you knew Christmas was finally coming when Dad dusted off the Christmas cassette and stuffed it into the car’s tape deck.

Last Christmas, Merry Christmas Everyone, Wonderful Christmastime; the Christmas hits just kept on coming and we loved them all. Genre didn’t matter, neither did quality, each one was indelibly linked with presents, food, decorations and a fortnight off school.

The exception that proved the rule was When A Child Is Born, a tedious dirge that doesn’t even mention Christmas. Yes, this 1976 Christmas Number One, talks portentously about a special child being born and sure, you can argue that this allusion to Jesus recognises the true meaning of Christmas, etc. but even then, it seems to be suggesting some future child, a second coming or resurrection, that might not even be born at Christmas!

Either way, this tune utterly fails to inspire any festive feeling.


In this post: 
Christmas
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Chris Chopping is a writer, YouTuber and stand up comedian. Check out his channel at YouTube.com/c/chrischopping. His dream job would be wrestling Manager and he’s long since stopped reading the comments section.... Follow him @MrChrisChopping on Twitter.