10 Love Songs That Are Actually Incredibly Dark
Thorns amid the roses.
For as long as the concept of song has been around, we still haven't really seemed to come to an agreement about love. The Beatles have told us that love was all that we needed way back in the day, and you also have someone like Pat Benatar saying that love is a battlefield. It would be better to just say that love is a complicated emotion, but it can get downright dark some of the time as well.
Even though you can call every song on this list a love song, they do not detail their emotions in the best way. Across every one of these tracks, the relationships in question are either on the rocks or heading on a downward spiral that isn't going to be getting better any time soon. Then can you call them breakup songs? Well, not exactly. Breakup songs give us a little bit of context of what went wrong, and each of these relationships are still playing out while you listen.
As the song unfolds, you get to hear a lot more details about what this person is going through, and who knows whether they'll actually end up happy by the end of the song. Still, it's better to have at least experienced love once than to have never had it at all, and this is the moment where love starts to get really messy.
10. Face Down - Red Jumpsuit Apparatus
Amid the '00s emo rock scene, bands definitely had their fair share of hearts on their sleeve. Even if all the song was trying to say was the inner pain they were feeling inside, you couldn't stop paying attention to songs from My Chemical Romance or Fall Out Boy if you had tried. There were some love songs sprinkled in the mix though, just not the kind that you'd find on a Valentine's Day card.
Although the Red Jumpsuit Apparatus have rebranded themselves more as a Christian band these days, their hearts were already in the right place with Face Down, talking about a woman who has fallen on hard times. This isn't the Livin on a Prayer style of poverty life either. This woman is going through a full on abusive relationship in these lyrics, with her face being put down in the dirt as this waste of space man treats her like trash in any way that he can.
For a genre that was always known to exhaust the same love songs out of their fans, this was a much stronger leap forward for the genre, choosing to stand by and take abusers to task for what they've done. There's even an optimistic twist towards the end, where they hope that this woman finds the strength to tell her abuser that she has had enough. That might seem a little easier said than done, but here's hoping that this story ends the way we hope: with this woman finding peace and this man being left on his ass.
9. Easy Target - Blink-182
Face Down was always meant to be a look into something more than just pop punk though. If you look at what the rest of the pop punk scene had to offer at the time, you had many songs that were either jaded, heartbroken, and in some cases not the most respectful to the opposite sex most of the time. Blink-182 definitely had their campy side as well, but the girl at the center of Easy Target gave them reason to be afraid.
Though most of the self titled Blink record revolves around some pretty morbid subjects, Easy Target is almost more straight up punk or alternative rock than pop punk, as Tom DeLonge talks about this screwed up fairy tale love he has, comparing her to the flower that's placed on his casket and almost preparing himself for the pain that he's bound to face at the hands of her. When Mark Hoppus finally comes in, things don't let up either, talking about this girl eventually slitting his throat and cautioning everyone in her path to run as far away as they can, all while Tom screeches to be set free in the background.
And it's at this point that you realize that these are the same guys that wrote songs like All the Small Things and Dysentery Gary back in the day. Fame can change a person, but it can also make for some pretty gnarly romantic situations as well.
8. One - U2
For most of their career, U2 have never really been known for their love songs. Though they do have their romantic side on songs like With or Without You, people tend to remember the more militant side of the band from the days of Sunday Bloody Sunday and New Year's Day. It was a new decade when we got to Achtung Baby though, and One is love with a cynical smile painted on it.
If you were to look at just the first few verses of this song, this almost feels like a breakup song, as Bono talks about disappointing his lover and wondering if his relationship is even going to get better any time soon. There are even some spots in here where Bono talks about hurting each other only to do it over again. So how does this even fit as a love song? These don't sound like compliments, but there's a more optimistic tone going through that chorus.
In this case, One is more about coming together as one people, being able to stand up for each other and carry each other through the most difficult times. There's almost a hippy style sentiment about the whole thing, as Bono compares the entire concept love to a temple that makes him feel so small based on the sheer size of it. This isn't about living together in peace for the rest of the world. It's about looking after each other and hopefully finding a way to soldier on even when things look dark.
7. Paris - The 1975
If the 1975 started off as just your average pop rock band, their second album is where they really leaned into the pop side of their sound. Gone were the days of some jagged guitar work on songs like Sex, going for something a bit more larger than life and evocative on songs like Love Me and Change of Heart. Matty Healy definitely tears his own heart to shreds through most of the project, but Paris is where things start to mellow out just a little bit.
So far in the project, we've already gotten bits and pieces of when Matty was at his weakest, like doubting himself on songs like If I Believe You or bringing himself to the edge of sanity on songs like Lostmyhead. As Paris starts playing though, you can hear him trying to look back on this old flame, with the idyllic city lights shining down on them. That was the past though, and the verses of this song tell a much different story, talking about how he's just a waste of space in women's clothes and how his lover has a nihilist boyfriend and romanticizes heroin on the side.
Even with all of the chaos that surrounds them, they still have that one subtle memory of the time in Paris, willing to give everything they can to experience that moment just one more time. Getting to Paris at this rate might not even be possible anymore, but it's always nice to dream of a better place, right?
6. Self Esteem - The Offspring
Punk rock is never really a genre that prides itself on its love songs all that often. Going through the back catalog of bands like the Ramones and the Clash, there are a lot more songs about nihilism and horror movies than the love-focused songs that make it to the top of the charts. Given how the Offspring wrote about love songs though, you can understand why they might not be writing for the ladies every time they enter the rehearsal room.
While most people remember Self Esteem from the now iconic 'ra ra' opening chorus, the guy at the center of this song is clearly going into a relationship that is toxic as hell. Going through every line of this song, this guy is being manipulated in whatever way he can, staying with his old flame for carnal reasons and then being shot down when he's looking for something more. There's no sugarcoating the issues here either, since Dexter Holland straight up tells us that he's being used and choosing to go along with it anyway.
There isn't a clear resolution to this relationship either, as Dexter is hung out to dry and then wondering why this girl ends up sleeping with all of his friends whenever she's not with him. In his eyes, it's better to suffer than to actually find happiness at all. You can try to stand up for yourself if you want to, but do you really want to live the life of a dweeb?
5. True Love Waits - Radiohead
No one in their right mind is going to be listening to a band like Radiohead to have their spirits lifted or anything. Throughout every version of the band, Thom Yorke's lyrics combined with the melancholy music is enough to get some standard rock fans to burst into tears if they aren't careful. True Love Waits always fell into that category since it became a live staple, but the greatest gut punch was the circumstances under which we got the finished version.
For all of the cohesiveness of a Moon Shaped Pool, a lot of the songs were actually leftovers from earlier sessions, with songs like Burn the Witch dating all the way back to the days of Kid A. During the recording though, Thom had also split up from his wife, who also died a few months after their separation. If anything, the whole album feels more like an album of mourning than anything else, with True Love Waits serving as the final plea that Thom has to keep his relationship going.
Trading in the acoustic guitar for a echo-soaked piano, it almost feels like you're waking up from a dream when you hear it, as Thom talks about doing whatever he can for his partner so long as she doesn't leave his side. In the real world though, things are telling a different story. As much as this seems like one last love song, we all know that this story doesn't have a happy ending.
4. Every Breath You Take - The Police
To this day, The Police's Every Breath You Take has been one of the biggest songs in pop music history. Using a simple premise for a song, Sting took the few chords that everyone knows and loves from the past decades of rock music and turned them into this beautiful song about following your crush around everywhere they go. It may have been cute at the time, but you're actually listening to something a lot more sinister if you so much as look at the lyrics for a second.
Going through every line of the song, the word "love" is never mentioned once, with Sting just saying that he will be watching this girl with every breath and move she makes in life. He even talks about longing for her embrace and dreaming to see her even more in the future. We never hear about this nameless person's feelings, and that's when you start putting the pieces together. This isn't a love song... this is a stalker that is looking to feed on his prey to get what he wants.
The irony wasn't lost on Sting either, going so far as to admit that there's something quite wicked going on in this song and finding it strange how so many people connected with this really messed up story. If anything, this is actually a warning sign to listeners everywhere to pay attention to what they're singing along to. Because if you're not hanging on every word, there's a good chance that you're singing along to something just as sinister as you heard just now.
3. Pulling Teeth - Green Day
One of the biggest strengths that you have as a songwriter is putting your song in the right context. Even if there's a lot of strange stuff to talk about, it's up to you whether you're going to make your story into a comedy rather than a tragedy. And on Pulling Teeth, Billie Joe Armstrong managed to make the most out of a bad situation, even when that situation involves kidnapping.
Inspired by a real life fight that Mike Dirnt had with his girlfriend while making Dookie, Pulling Teeth is about a guy who takes it like a champ every time his girlfriend beats the life out of him. Though Mike's situation only had to do with him accidentally breaking his elbows during a pillow fight, Billie takes the situation a little bit further, with this guy being so tattered and torn than he can barely even stand up properly. Even though he's getting fed by this girl, he spends his days locked in a room and being forced to say 'I Love You' if he doesn't want to be hurt again.
For all of the drama surrounding it though, the tune itself is one of the most carefree sounds on Dookie, almost as if Green Day are trying their hand at a Motown style of song. If we're talking about it from the perspective in the story though, this is the kind of song that gives movies like Misery a run for their money.
2. You've Got Her In Your Pocket - The White Stripes
One of the mission statements when Jack White was creating the White Stripes was to bring things back down to basics. From the way that they play to the lyrics that they talk about, these are the kind of songs that brought it back to the stone age of rock and roll, almost having a child like spirit to the way that Jack and Meg worked off of each other. Even with puppy love though, there's a fine line between infatuation and something a lot more dangerous.
If you look at it just on the surface, Jack is really wearing his heart on his sleeve in this song, as he talks about anything that he will do for his lover to make sure that he doesn't leave his side. Throughout most of the verses, he practically sounds like he's on the verge of tears, almost scared of saying the wrong thing and watching her walk right out the door with all of her things. The fatal flaw comes in that title though, with Jack saying that he wants to keep her in his pocket where there's no way out.
When you see the girl's perspective, hearing him talk about how this little space in his pocket is home sweet home isn't really the ideal situation to be in. From the language here, Jack sounds more like he's keeping this woman as a hostage rather than a lover, and she should probably be doing everything she can to get as far away from him as she possibly can.
1. Hey Ya! - OutKast
Whenever any artist goes pop, you're going to have to dip your toes into writing love songs every now and again. Love is the most universal emotion that pop music can ask for, and even the most hardcore acts at the time have been known to indulge themselves with something a bit more light-hearted to get a whole new audience. OutKast always were straight shooters though, and Andre 3000 had a little something different in store when writing his pop masterpiece.
Going through every single verse of Hey Ya!, Andre is more confused about the concept of love than anything else, saying that he's thankful for Mom and Dad for sticking together since he doesn't even known how love works. As he gets the crowd going with different shoutouts though, it's clear that he knows that love isn't going to last, almost just having this girl around as a way to blend in while not really having anything else going on underneath the surface.
We're not listening to that though, and Andre knows that, saying that "y'all just wanna dance" in the lyrics. So when you're singing along about being ice cold, you're actually talking about keeping all your emotions in and not really wanting to be that intimate with anyone anymore. That's not what you're listening to a pop song for though. We're just here to shake it like a Polaroid picture. So why the hell not join in? Love is dead, so let's dance our troubles away.