10 Messiest Band Splits In Rock Music History
Saying Goodbye With Middle Fingers.
Being in a rock band isn't that dissimilar from being in a marriage. Since you have to spend almost every waking hour on the road together, you're going to have to at least get along in some capacity if you even hope to stay together very long. Like all long term relationships though, sometimes friction can severely change things.
Whereas most bands like to bow out gracefully towards the end of their run, these acts were combustible from the moment they started. As opposed to the normal way that people talk out their problems, these are the kind of breakups that people still have the wounds from. After years of taking BS from one of the divas of the group or not splitting royalties evenly, most of these ended either in extremely hostility or (in the worst case) actually in the courts to fight over the use of the name.
Though some of them have been able to patch up their differences over the years, that doesn't change what the fans had to witness. Outside of the hectic touring, we were the ones that were robbed of the great music because business and hurt feelings got in the way of making the music. It might only be rock and roll, but that doesn't mean that everyone has to get along all the time.
10. The Pixies
There's no real right way to break up a band. If you're all having a good time and trying your best to create the best music you can, it's not always a walk in the park deciding to break everything apart. As for the Pixies though, they did have one of the more unique tactics by bringing a fax machine into the program.
Yeah, unlike most of the other massive blowups, Frank Black actually quit the band by sending the rest of the band a fax that he could no longer continue. You could say that it was passive aggression, but maybe he just wasn't sure that this version of the band was going to go the distance anymore. After making some of the best indie rock on Earth, it's only a matter of time before you decide to just call it a day.
The people that were really hurt in this scenario though were the fans. Since this was before the Internet was really a thing, the Pixies could have been broken up for months and none of their devotees would have been the wiser about it. No big press release...no gimmicks...just one little fax and the world's most interesting indie band was gone in an instant.
9. Blink-182
You can be a little bit forgiving of a band like the Pixies though. As much as they may have tried to make it work, Frank Black's decision felt more like he said all he wanted to say with his old band. But good Lord, the passive aggression with one of the saviors of pop punk is absolutely staggering.
It's not like fans weren't aware that the Blink 182 camp was in a little bit of trouble during the era of their self titled record. Even though the songs were absolutely brilliant, you could sense there was a bit of a rub between the band's tastes in styles, with Tom DeLonge going for more atmospheric tones than what we were used to on Enema of the State. Whereas most artists would just have a side project or sit down with their bandmates, Tom just sent an email and cut off ties with Blink altogether to form Angels and Airwaves.
Actually, there's a correction that needs to be there. Not only did Tom leave the band over an email...he actually made his manager do the dirty work and send the thing instead of actually being there for the band. Since Blink was always known for their larger than life sense of humor on stage, you would think that the frontman would have a little more confidence than this.
8. Oasis
The whole allure behind Oasis in the first place always came down to the animosity between the Gallagher brothers. At any moment during their run, you didn't know whether or not they would be comrades in arms onstage or wanting to kill each other at the drop of a hat. Even though most can accept that sibling rivalry, there was just that one gig that went a little too far.
During a stop in Paris, Liam Gallagher was particularly furious backstage before performing, going off on every journalist that would have him that night. By the time that Noel tried to soothe everything in the dressing room, Liam was absolutely volatile, swinging an acoustic guitar around and even throwing different fruit around the room. Looking to calm down, Noel went to the bus to chill out before eventually deciding that enough was enough.
After cancelling the gig, Noel held a press conference saying that Oasis was officially done, saying that he could no longer function with his brother anymore. Seeing how everything went down, it's almost bittersweet. If you were following Oasis' tour at that point, they only had two more gigs before being able to finish the tour and take months off from working. If things turned out differently, maybe the Mancunian legends could have hung on for a little while longer.
7. The Clash
When you lose a crucial member of the band, it sometimes feels like having to work with a different heart. Since these are the people that you've spent most of your creative life with, it's hard to get the rest of your fans onboard with some new random person sitting at the front of the stage. That didn't mean that the Clash didn't try though...and ended up falling flat on their face.
After the sessions for Combat Rock ended pretty harshly, tension had boiled over to the point where Mick Jones decided to leave the band. For most Clash fans, that would have been the end of it, but Joe Strummer tried to keep the dream alive with a new version of the group on Cut the Crap. What transpired next is one of the saddest endings in punk history, with songs that sounded like they were half finished and new members who could barely play their instruments.
Even the good songs from this era like This Is England don't even feel like proper Clash songs. They're more like a funeral dirge for the entire punk genre, as if Joe Strummer already knew this version of the group was never going to go the distance. Compared to the normal blowups that you get in between band members, you can't help but look at this kind of fallout and just end up feeling sad for everyone involved.
6. Van Halen
If you have to make a pecking order for every single member of a band, the frontman is typically the most important. Since this is the guy who operates like the mouthpiece of the entire group, you need to make sure you have someone that radiates charisma and the fun loving attitude that you're hoping for. Just don't make sure that he gets on your bad side any time soon.
Once Van Halen reached 1984, they were gods among men in the rock industry, having some of the biggest hits in the world that crossed genre boundaries. On the inside though, they were absolutely crumbling, with Eddie Van Halen putting his foot down about using keyboards and getting nothing but animosity from David Lee Roth. By the time that the tour wrapped up though, that's when the battle lines were drawn.
Even though it would have been one thing for the band to just part ways with Roth, the tabloids had other plans, with DLR explaining that the title of his debut solo album Eat Em and Smile was about eating scum like Eddie and Alex for breakfast. They might have recovered with Sammy Hagar, but Dave was not yet done, saying that it must suck for Hagar to have to sing a song like Jump every single night of his life. Since this is the band that gave birth to the hair metal movement, this is the equivalent to seeing your parents fight when you're a kid.
5. Aerosmith
There's something to be said about bands that keep the same lineup throughout their entire career. With all of the industry BS that gets in the way of playing the music you love, these are the bands that never let any of the middle men come in between their brotherhood bond. While Aerosmith falls into that category, it was definitely on the rocks for a little bit.
Coming to the end of the '70s, Aerosmith were abusing cocaine left and right and getting more and more passive aggressive with each other. When going on tour to support their album Draw the Line, the band made the big mistake of trying to bring their wives into the equation, which made arguments between Steven Tyler and Joe Perry grow even nastier.
After playing one of the biggest gigs of the tour, a fight erupted backstage which ended with Joe's wife Elyssa throwing a gallon of milk across the room. As if to fulfill the cliche, that turned out to be the final straw, with Joe packing up his guitar and leaving the band for a few years. And you could feel it too, with most of the records released afterwards leaving Aerosmith as a shell of what they once were. Though they learned to patch things up at the dawn of the '80s, this was definitely a dark time for the Bad Boys from Boston.
4. Red Hot Chili Peppers
The everyday life of a rock star isn't something that you necessarily want to get into. Even though the thought of going around the world playing music for a living seems intriguing at first, having cameras and paparazzi on you 24/7 has got to weight on you at some point. Especially if you're someone who wasn't used to fame to begin with, you're going to snap eventually.
After the release of Blood Sugar Sex Magik, the Red Hot Chili Peppers had reached a level of fame that no one was prepared for, becoming one of the biggest names in music alongside the alternative revolution of Pearl Jam and Nirvana. Once the tour kicked into high gear though, John Frusciante was getting more and more uncomfortable, since he originally signed on thinking the Peppers would remain an underground band.
The last few shows Frusciante played ended up being agonizing to watch, from a disastrous performance on SNL to eventually deciding to leave the band right as they were about to go on stage in Japan. While they were able to get through that particular show, Frusciante was out the minute the last note sounded, leaving the Peppers without a guitar player yet again. Considering how amped the Chilis' live shows can be, it just feels disheartening knowing they had to play as a band divided.
3. Eagles
If there was ever a band that shouldn't have been as combustible for their genre, it should have been the Eagles. Considering that they built their career on mellow music, you'd think that the only thing that they would get angry about is whether or not they could have a day at the beach when they're off tour. When someone in the band isn't getting paid though, things can start to boil over pretty quickly.
During the tumultuous tour promoting their album The Long Run, guitarist Don Felder wasn't too jazzed about the fact that they were playing a benefit concert for Senator Alan Cranston. While the rest of the band remained professional about the whole ordeal, Glenn Frey took issue with Felder's behavior, especially when he replied to the senator's thank you by saying "You're Welcome...I guess."
By the time they took the stage, the band was seething, which got even more over the top when they started to fight onstage in between songs. Imagine that crowd too, listening through songs like Tequila Sunrise and then hearing the singer talk about beating the sh*t out of the guitar player. The minute they stepped offstage, Felder smashed a guitar and drove off in a limousine, never to return again. If you insist on breaking up in a big way though, you'd be hardpressed to find a bigger dramatic moment than this.
2. The Beatles
In the late '60s, it truly felt like the Beatles' legacy was going to go on forever. No matter what kind of stumbling block stood in their way, the Fab Four always found a way to persevere and managed to make some of the most incredible music that the world had ever seen. That didn't mean that the four moptops that we loved hadn't grown along the way though.
After launching their Apple business model, things really started to hit a brick wall during the recording for the White Album, with most of the tracks feeling like glorified solo songs from all four members. Even though they tried to put things back on course, their return to roots with the Get Back project was shelved and they decided to work on Abbey Road instead.
Though the studio albums left things on good terms, the same couldn't be said for the business side of things, with Paul McCartney getting more and more troubled by what manager Allen Klein was trying to do with the rest of the band. If you need any indication as to how far the friendships sunk, just listen to the solo tracks from each of the band members, from George Harrison lamenting the loss of friendship on Isn't It a Pity to John Lennon dissing McCartney outright on How Do You Sleep?. For a band that was always about coming back to the unifying feeling of love, it's a shame that they couldn't take their own advice.
1. Guns N Roses
Sometimes it's no one's fault as to why a band has to break up. Musicians can't be in the same creative space forever, and there just comes a point where you need to branch out and find new roads to express yourself. Then there's instances where people just fed up with the one fly in the ointment.
By the time that Guns N Roses made their double album Use Your Illusion, things had started to come off the rails for Axl Rose. Taking full creative control of the group, the entire experience of songs like November Rain made it look more like the Axl Rose and Friends show than an actual band project. What's even more embarrassing was the tour, where Axl would just not show up to shows at all, which sometimes ended with fans rioting in the stands.
Along the way, you could see every one of the band members starting to lose it, from Steven Adler being fired during the recording sessions to Izzy Stradlin quitting halfway through after getting fed up with Axl's antics. Though the band hung in there for the covers record The Spaghetti Incident?, it didn't take long for Slash and the gang to follow suit. Considering the fact that a band like Velvet Revolver exists, it's become abundantly clear that Guns N Roses broke up because King Axl wanted his way or the highway.