10 Mistakes That Made It Onto Famous Rock Songs
Even rock stars get it wrong from time to time.
Working in a top quality studio with some of the finest producers and technicians in the land is a sure-fire way to make the recording process go as smoothly as possible and to make sure there aren't any embarrassing errors left on the finished product... in theory.
In reality, this isn't always the case, as some of the biggest rock songs of all time were birthed during flawed studio sessions.
Production goofs, bum notes, fluffed lines, all of these mistakes and more have wound up making it onto the final versions of some massive songs.
In some cases, this was an oversight on behalf of the production team, who simply didn't spot the error until it was too late. On other occasions, those involved quite liked how the faux pas sounded, electing to bathe in the serendipity and leave it on the final version.
If you don't want to have some of your favourite songs ruined forever, then do yourself a favour and don't read on as, once you're made aware of these massive muck-ups, you'll never be able to unhear them.
10. Billie Joe’s Potty Mouth - Green Day's Good Riddance (Time Of Your Life)
If you go onto Green Day's Spotify page, you'll see that one of this no-nonsense, political punk band's most streamed songs is an acoustic ballad with a string section.
Good Riddance (Time of Your Life) from the band's Nimrod album was written by singer Billie Joe Armstrong to spite his girlfriend who had moved to Ecuador without him. Now, over 500 million people have streamed the frontman effectively telling his ex to go stick it.
This theme of bittersweet farewell can be found throughout the tune, as Armstrong sings about forks in the road and how unpredictable life can be.
Clearly, the emotional weight of Good Riddance got to Armstrong, as he messed up the intro not once, but twice. On the album version of the song, you can hear him attempt to start the song twice and blow it on both occasions, even muttering a curse word after the second failed effort.
The radio version and the one used for the song's music video omit both the flubbed start and the expletive, but you can still hear it in all it's glory if you get yourself a copy of Nimrod.
9. Kurt’s Early Arrival - Nirvana's Polly
Nevermind by Nirvana changed the musical landscape in a big way when it came out in 1991, prompting disenfranchised youths up and down America to pick up a guitar and make as much noise as possible.
Of all the many great songs on the record, Polly is often overlooked. It wasn't released as a single and is a largely acoustic number on an album full of hard rock bangers.
However, with its lyrics pertaining to feminism and women's rights (partially inspired by the real-life kidnapping and torture of a young girl), it's definitely worth a closer listen. If you choose to do this, you'll hear lead singer Kurt Cobain get it totally wrong.
About two minutes into the song, Cobain sings the words "Polly said", which are supposed to come at the start of the third verse. Only problem is he arrives at the line too early, during what was supposed to be an instrumental break.
The band clearly liked the way it sounded, as they left the blunder in the final take, and, to be honest, if you didn't know it wasn't supposed to be there, you wouldn't think anything of it.
8. Stick It To The Man - Pearl Jam's Rearviewmirror
Pearl Jam were clearly in need of a new typewriter when writing up the tracklist for their album Vs., as the space bar on their one obviously wasn't working.
That's an awful joke to introduce an excellent song, a deep cut from Vs. called Rearviewmirror.
Eddie Vedder said that the music to this song made him feel like he was in a car, so he composed a set of lyrics about looking back at something whilst driving away from it, only being able to see it in the rear view mirror. Though never a single, Rearviewmirror was popular enough to inspire the name of a Pearl Jam greatest hits album in 2004, even though a teensy mishap found its way onto the final product.
Towards the end of the epic playout solo, what sounds like drumsticks being fiddled with can be heard. This is actually said sticks being hurled against a wall by drummer Dave Abbruzzese, who was annoyed at producer Brendan O'Brien for being too harsh on his performance during the recording process.
O'Brien clearly didn't mind this take, as this was the one that saw the light of day.
7. Dammit, Hammett! - Metallica's Seek & Destroy
The phrase "guitar god" gets bandied around a lot, but one man who is truly worthy of that title is Metallica's head of shred, Kirk Hammett.
Originally brought in to replace Dave Mustaine right at the start of the group's recording career, Hammett quickly established himself as one of the best players in the game, creating almost all of Metallica's legendary riffs and solos.
But even gods are fallible sometimes.
The penultimate song on Metallica's very first studio album, Kill 'Em All, is called Seek & Destroy, and it is a banger-and-a-half. What begins as a fairly regimented song devolves into all-out chaos about halfway through, led into the madness by an epic Hammett solo.
During said solo, around the 3:47 mark, Hammett plays a note that sounds a little off compared to the rest of the sequence. Was he experimenting with some new scale that us mere mortals wouldn't understand?
Nope.
In the man's own words, this was him playing a "bum note". Hammett has apologised for this error time and time again, but when you've played as many perfect notes as the H-man has over the years, you're allowed one wrong one.
6. Canine Contributor - Jane’s Addiction's Been Caught Stealing
How many songs can you think of with dogs barking on them?
The Damned have a song called The Dog where a pooch makes an appearance, and the band Caninus' whole gimmick was that they were fronted by two pitbull terriers. Then, there's this from Jane Addiction.
Been Caught Stealing is actually the band's biggest hit, topping the US rock charts for four weeks upon its release. It will also be known to players of Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas as one of the songs on the Radio X station.
At the beginning of the song, a dog can be heard barking over the top of the guitar intro. Rather than an artistic choice, this was a total accident caused by singer Perry Farrell's pet, Annie.
"I'm singing in the booth with the headphones on and Annie gets all excited and starts going, 'Ruff! Ruff! Ruff!'" he said. "The fact that she ended up on the track was just pure coincidence."
In their review of the song, Rolling Stone said that it contained "the best use of dog barks since [The Beach Boys'] Pet Sounds", so hopefully Annie got an extra treat for her hard work.
5. Less Cowbell - The Rolling Stones' Honky Tonk Woman
A cowbell is a percussion instrument played by striking a metal object with a stick. They're quite easy to play, unless your name is Jimmy Miller.
Miller was The Rolling Stones' producer for some of their biggest albums, including Goats Head Soup, Exile on Main St., and Sticky Fingers. He also produced work for the likes of Steve Winwood and Motörhead, but it was with the Stones that he made his biggest impact.
You can actually hear Miller's work firsthand on the song Honky Tonk Woman, a single released in 1969. Jimmy is responsible for playing cowbell on the track, a memorable part of this memorable song, which makes it even more of a shame that he got it completely wrong.
Drummer Charlie Watts said in the book The Rolling Stones: All the Songs that "either he [Milller] comes in wrong or I come in wrong… It’s actually a mistake, but from my point of view, it works.”
Watts doesn't outwardly admit that this was Miller's fault, but considering that he had a reputation for being one of the steadiest drummers to ever sit behind a kit, it's safe to assume he was just being modest.
4. Plane And Simple - Led Zeppelin's Black Country Woman
You know what's great about recording studios? They are specifically designed to keep out external noise, making them the perfect place to record a song.
You know where isn't designed for that purpose? Outside.
Wings recorded the bagpipes for Mull of Kintyre outside, but only because there simply wasn't a studio big enough to accommodate so many pipers. Led Zeppelin had no such excuse when it came time to lay down Black Country Woman from the album Physical Graffiti.
It was recorded during a period of time where the band were looking to explore unconventional spaces, so most of the track was captured in the gardens of the Stargroves country estate in Hampshire, England.
The session was going well and everyone was on fine form until the recording was disrupted by the sound of an aeroplane flying overhead. A plane flying over a field? Who saw that one coming?
Because they were completely insane, Led Zep kept playing in spite of the racket going on above them, and the version with the plane sounds in it was the one chosen for the album.
Only Led Zeppelin could have gotten away with something as monumentally mad as this.
3. Cough Up - Pink Floyd's Wish You Were Here
Of all the great songs Pink Floyd have put out in their time, few match up to the majesty of Wish You Were Here from the 1975 album of the same name.
A soft and sombre ballad, Wish You Were Here has many different interpretations, but the most popular theory is that it's a tribute to former Floyd member Syd Barrett, who left the group in 1968 due to mounting mental health problems.
Guitarist and one of the song's writers, Dave Gilmour has said that he never plays the song without thinking about Barrett, who died in 2006. He probably also can't play the song without thinking about coughing, as that's precisely what he does all over it.
In the introduction to the song, Gilmour, a ferocious smoker, can be heard spluttering away in the background. He can also be heard drinking something (probably not apple juice) and breathing heavily before the main guitar comes in.
The rumour is that Gilmour was so appalled by his inability to control his own lungs that he quit smoking altogether the next day.
So there you have it; a great song that also might have saved a man's life.
2. Desmond Does What? - The Beatles' Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da
For all their serious songs about love and peace on Earth, The Beatles' back catalogue is also filled with some utter nonsense.
One of their most divisive tracks is the ska-inspired Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da from The White Album, which was written by Paul McCartney and detested by John Lennon and George Harrison.
Ringo was probably just wishing everyone would stop arguing, like a child of divorce.
With a jaunty piano line and overly-saccharin vocal performance from Macca, Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da tells the story of a man and a woman who fall in love, have a couple of kids, and live happily ever after. The characters are Desmond, a market trader, and Molly, who performs in a band, although McCartney clearly forgot this towards the end of the song.
In the final verse, Paul sings that Molly lets the children lend a hand in the marketplace, whilst Desmond "stays at home and does his pretty face."
Whilst this could easily have been chalked up to Beatles whimsy, it was actually just a big fat error from the staunch perfectionist McCartney.
To be honest, it fits the corny vibe of the song quite nicely.
1. Take A Seat - The Police's Roxanne
Perhaps the most famous musical mistake to ever make it to record, one The Police's biggest ever songs features an unexpected contribution from Sting's backside.
Roxanne, which was written by the Stinger upon observing sex workers near the band's Paris hotel, served as the lead single to The Police's debut album, Outlandos d'Amour. Initially not a hit, it got re-released a year later in 1979, when it rocketed up to number 12 in the UK singles charts.
The song begins with its trademark short, sharp chords, as played by guitarist Andy Summers, but towards the beginning of the third bar, a strange collection of notes can be heard.
What happened was, whilst the song was being recorded, Sting went to sit down and accidentally planted his buttocks on a keyboard, creating the weird noise. Rather than abandon the take, the sound was left in, alongside Sting's laughter at his own gaffe.
A simple mistake in the studio has grown into a huge musical legend, with the Roxanne mystery piano taking on a life of its own. It's even got a place in the liner notes of the album, where Sting is credited as playing "butt piano" on the track.